Effect of Prayers on Water Shown Scientifically
Wannabe Singh · 15 Apr 2004
Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Kee Fateh
Sangat Jee, a friend of mine sent me this link. It shows you how water crystals change with vibrations of music, good thoughts, prayer and bad thoughts.
Since our bodies are made of more than 70% of water, the study shows how we think and eat pollutes our body. I believe that this also proves how reading Bani will make the stuff we drink and eat better for us, How reading Bani and doing simran will purify our body as well.
Being in Sadh Sangat the vibrations are thousand times more powerful than one person reading Bani by himself or herself. Hence, the importance of Sangat in Sikhi.
Thank you Waheguruji for giving us the Sikhi Marg.
http://www.enews3.com/water/
Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Kee Fateh
Is it scientific?
singhsation · 17 Apr 2004
I think bani benefits us in all aspects of life but I don't know if this study proves anything. In fact, I couldn't locate the study at all - the link seemed to be a summary of this guy's beliefs and the subject of his research.
Has any of this research been published? If so, where?
Until this can be verified, I think we should stay away from pointing to this article as 'scientific' proof of why we should read Gurbani.
Why? The fact that our Guru ji commanded us to read Gurbani and highlights the benefits of Gurbani within Gurbani should be more than enough reason.
When someone points to so-called 'scientific' studies, they leave themselves open to rebuttal on scientific principles. I'm sure you've heard of the 'scientific' reasons for keeping long hair - those reasons are the easiest one to cut apart. Why do Sikhs keep long hair - our Guru ji commanded it - end of story. Same holds true for bani.
Now, if the above study is published and peer-reviewed and is valid - then we can point to this study as a supplemental reason but never, in my opinion, as the main reason why we do what we do. To reiterate, lets not make too much of this article until we see the study published in a reputable journal where the research can be challenged and tested.
- daas.
Re: Effect of Prayers on Water Shown Scientifically
singhsation · 18 Apr 2004
I make of it what it says - what does this have to do with what I wrote above?
Someone posted a link to a 'study' and the aim of my post is pretty clear - I hope Sikhs don't go pointing to this 'study' as some kind of proof for what they do until, at least, this 'study' has been published in a reputable and peer reviewed journal.
Until that time, we have no idea if the author of the 'study' is just making stuff up or if it is legitimate.
daas
Re: Effect of Prayers on Water Shown Scientifically
singhsation · 18 Apr 2004
*******
pure iron wrote:
> just because guru commanded something isn't a reason to blindly
> follow it.
*******
Of course it is! If your Guru tells you to get naked and dance like a chicken you do it - you do not ask for explanations, as if a Guru has to explain every command in order to get his followers to do what he says.
By your reasoning, the Panj Piare should never have become the Panj Piare. When Guru ji asked for a head, the Panj Piare should have demanded an explanation from Guru ji and then decided whether they wanted to obey or not.
There were thousands of Sikhs present that day in 1699 and when Guru ji gave his command, 5 Sikhs got up and 'blindly', as you put it, followed the command. The thousands who remained seated, failed the test. Only when they got an inkling of an idea as to what Guru ji was offering, only when they got a glimpse of Guru ji's motives did they all then line up to take amrit.
Going by your reasoning, the Panj Piare should have just stayed seated until they could make sense of Guru ji's command.
********
Yes, guru knows best but you should know why it is
> dear to YOU. And what makes it so special to its followers
> (gurbani, rehit). A simple reason that "guru sahib has
> commanded it" isn't good enough.
********
Perhaps not good enough for you, but it is good enough for me.
********
what if a non sikh asks why
> bani is read, are you honestly going to say "just because guru
> said so"? That's a blind practice then.
********
Of course I will say that Guru ji commands it. Then I will follow it up with what Guru ji says within the bani about the importance of simran and bani and what other respected Sikhs say about simran and bani and the benefits of simran and bani. First and foremost is the command - everything else is secondary.
Regarding blind practice - do you really believe that Sikhism doesn't involve blind faith? If you do, then you need to take a closer look at Sikhi. Let me give a few examples to highlight my point. (Dear Sangat - please forgive anything which sounds offensive in the examples - it's done for a purpose).
Guru ji says do simran. Why should you do it? Sure Guru ji explains the benefits of simran but so what? Why do you believe in what some guy wrote hundreds of years ago? What possible reason do you have to follow this command? Don't say your reason has to do with the positive benefits that simran is supposed to produce because you don't know that! All you have is the word of your Guru and your BLIND BELIEF that your Guru is true and his message is true.
In the end, you have to fall on blind faith in order to do what your Guru asks you to do. Once you've started, then, maybe, you can draw on your own personal experience and state the benefits of simran.
Every religion requires blind belief in one degree or another. Every religion requires FAITH. You do simran with the hope that the end result will be what Guru ji says it will be - but why do you believe him? Why do you believe the end result of simran will be what Guru ji says it will be? You have no reason other than faith.
*******
> ......to why we keep kesh and rehit, there is excellent reaasoning
> for every thing that sikhs practice. Gursikhi is the most
> practical religion, don't make it a ritual by blindly following
> something and not understanding its depth. Don't say that "we
> blindly follow guru cuz he's right" cuz its not enough in my
> opinion.
*******
Following Guru ji's commands and understanding its depth are two relatively distinct things.
Above everything else, a Sikh must follow his/her Guru's command regardless of whether he/she understands the depth or not.
(On a tangent: Sikhi is an ocean - you can study for a million lifetimes and not touch a tenth of its depth).
Understanding can, and usually does, come after one starts following the commands.
The most pathetic thing we can do is try to measure our Guru ji's hukums against the standard of our own feeble intellect.
- daas
[%sig%]
Re: Effect of Prayers on Water Shown Scientifically
Nobody important · 20 Apr 2004
If Guru Sahib has commanded you to do it, that is SUFFICIENT justification for follow that commandment....is that not what faith is? Faith implies believing with no verifiable, objective evidence...someone can ask you how do you know that God exists? FAITH..remember the stories of Guru Sahib, many of the Gursikhs followed the commandment, although to others it may not have seemed "logical"....