Re: HOMOSEXUALITY IN SIKHISM YOUR HELP!!
kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 19 Apr 2004
VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA
VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!
in my humble opinion
there are a few things to consider
in guru gobind singh jee's akaal ustat (you will have to research it yourself) it says that God has created all creatures equally including transgendered people. Some people consider sexuality an aspect of gender. Therefore they think that gay people are also psychologically transgendered. In that regard they argue that Guru Gobind Singh jee has clearly said that gay people are equal to straight people. There is no argument there - the equality of human beings has been repeated throughout Guru Granth Sahib.
However, is homosexuality appropriate and right?
during the 240 years of the development of Sikhi from Guru Nanak Dev jee to Guru Granth Sahib jee's completion, there has been no janamsakhi or puraatan laykh about the arrangement of a gay marriage by Guru Sahib. The traditional "anand karaj" marriage rites have been consistent in Sikh society since Guru Gobind Singh jee's time - that the "laavaa(n)" shabad by Guru Ram Das Jee is read while the bride and groom sit together and (most of the time) do parkarma around Guru Sahib once for each "laav." This has always been the ceremony for a male and female. Guru Sahib emphasised grihastee jeevan and this included having children. The responsibility to raise children and also to overcome the ritualistic and hypocritical celibacy practices - Sikhs were told they can have sex within marriage for the purposes of reproduction. Their sexual activity was sanctioned by the ceremony of Anand Karaj.
Having said all that - I don't think homosexual activity is part of grihast, nor can that activity be sanctioned as the Anand Karaj has never been for two individuals of the same gender.
Guru Sahib has always created a dual system of preaching - where there is Miri there is Piri, where there is Degh there is Tegh, where there is Daya there is Dharam, where there is Sant there is Sipahi, and it only follows that where there is Singh there is Kaur - I don't mean that in a joking way, I mean that Guru Sahib even created the KHalsa equally, and he also understood that the differences in the genders compliment each other, as degh compliments tegh and as daya compliments dharam. Just as Dharam cannot sprout forward without Daya, there would be no Singhs if there was no Kaur to give birth to them. But that is not the only thing - Kaurs cannot remain only with Kaurs, because Singhs have psychological, emotional, physical, and sexual characteristics that compliment the characteristics of Kaurs - that is why a Kaur marries a Singh and a Singh marries a Kaur.
You will not find any passages in Guru Granth Sahib that directly denounce or support homosexuality. However, from the aforementioned details of Sikh psyche and history - it can be ascertained that generally gurmat does not approve of homosexual behaviour.
However, homosexuality in and of itself is not something that can be approved or disapproved - and the more open-minded Sikhs recognize this. It is similar to saying whether or not you approve or disapprove of somebody's gender or caste. They are just born that way, with those genes and that mental outlook - it cannot be changed. You cannot hate them for it, and nor can you treat them any differently. They are still your brother or sister, even if they are homosexual.
So what can homosexual people do if they would like to be a Sikh?
In my humble opinion the options are as follows:
One can and should still take khande-ke-pahul.
One can get married to a person of the opposite gender, but if it is forced and there is no real love, then this relationship is not appropriate. If there is love, but not lust, this relationship is still acceptable - because love is above lust, and even if the male and female do not procreate, or even if they do not have lust for each other - if they genuinely love each other and can share the same practice of rehit, then they are a good couple.
One cannot have homosexual activity in marriage or outside of marriage.
One should absorb oneself in Gurbani and Naam in order to overcome the thoughts and emotions of homosexuality.
One should never feel ashamed or guilty - as the way one is created is God's hukam. The practice of homosexuality may be unacceptable in SIkhi, but being a homosexual from the mind does not mean that the individual is lower or less of a human - nothing like that.
These are my views and these have been compiled through some vichar on this topic with fellow gursikhs.
Please forgive me for the errors and statements against gurmat.
bhul chuk maaf karnaa jee
VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA
VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!
Re: HOMOSEXUALITY IN SIKHISM YOUR HELP!!
kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 19 Apr 2004
just to add to the topic again
I think it is okay if a homosexual person decides to stay single because he/she wants to be a Sikh but he / she can't stand getting married to somebody from the opposite gender. However there are dangers of remaining single - marriage always sanctifies a relationship and makes it appropriate and it allows an individual to become more responsible and live within mainstream society while practicing Sikhi. It gives an individual the chance to do seva of kids and wife/husband. When you are single you might feel more homosexual emotions as you do not have any commitments. The only real reason to stay single is if you are a complete Gurmukh and have decided not to get married for personal reasons - but if you are a complete Gurmukh then your homosexual emotions and heterosexual emotions would both be under control anyway.
Another thing - it is a very sad reality that people who call themselves Sikhs these days call homosexual people bad names and insult them. They insult homosexual people more than they insult racists. When you insult somebody or hate somebody because of the way they are born - because of their "kudratee neeam" or their natural physical make-up, you are practicing cowardice, hypocricy and manmat. A person who practices this discrimination and hatred towards homosexuals or anybody cannot be a Sikh.
Lastly, When Sikh society says that homosexuality is not approved in Sikhi - this is not a matter of equality. You cannot pull out the equality card on this. A homosexual person can sit beside a heterosexual person in the langar and can do seva in many ways. There is no inequality.
A person who from within their mind feels lust towards others of the same gender, and does not feel lust towards others of the opposite gender - this person has a God-given, natural gene-makeup like everybody else. They are in a different psychological condition of perception from the average person. This is not something to be ashamed of, and it does not make anybody lower or higher. However, having a psychological make-up and practicing it are two seperate extremes. Sikhi promotes the anand karaj relationship between males and females but it does not promote lust or premarital sexual relationships. If homosexuality is not just lust, if it is about more than lust - the homosexual individual is more than welcome to spend time with many people of the same gender as his/her "siblings" as long as he/she does not look upon them in a lustful way. The only way to avoid this lustful feeling is to do more simran and read more gurbani. Lust is a vice that both homosexual and heterosexual people could have.
Anybody is welcome to comply with the rules of Sikhi and if they are genuinely interested - they will stop being sexually attracted to anybody at all because of the Guru's grace. Instead they will be spiritually attracted to everybody because they see God in all. They will only be genuinely, spiritually, deeply attracted to the Guru in the divine love of the One God - which is the most supreme religion and the essence of Sikhi.
VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA
VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!