Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

who is a REAL sikh?

who is a REAL sikh?

sandy · 18 Apr 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ke fateh hi, brothers and sisters. i was wondering if you could help me, im doing an essay at university on 'WHO IS A SIKH' but despite reading books and going on to numerous websites i just seem to be confusing myself evenmore. I was wondering if anyone knows 'how' people are judged as being sikhs, despite being an amritdhari and following sikhi does that necessarily mean that the rest of us are just fakes? if you are sehjdhari or keshdhari sikh,if you have been good all your life but have not taken amrit does that mean you still wont go back to another life form?. If you've got any suggestions it would really help me out Thank you sandy

Re: who is a REAL sikh?

Mkhalsa · 18 Apr 2004

Guru sahib tells us clearly, the only freedom from such pain is amrit. Without amrit one cannot be a sikh, this is pretty clear. But if one is amritdhari does that make them a sikh even if they are fake? not necessarily. After that first step, there is a long way to go.

Re: who is a REAL sikh?

kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 18 Apr 2004

this is what i think a KHALSA would say if you asked him about the role of a Sikh in Life this is not me and i do not live up to this lifestyle ... this is in the voice of a real khalsa: [i] i think of life as a game of love set on a battlefield i am the soul - a warrior my nation is sach khand i fight for the rights of the innocent and oppressed my commander-in-chief is akaal purakh i joined this army by taking khande-ke-pahul guru gobind singh is my general my allegiance to my general is a relationship of divine love my enemy is maya the enemy's battalions are kaam, krodh, lobh, moh, ahankaar the enemy soldiers include jealousy, slander, gossip, etc. my general blessed me with a uniform of the 5 k's everything else within reach is a possible shaster too ... my mind my body my wealth gurbani naam sangat physical shasters intelligence understanding humility faith devotion i can use these in any which way I please to beat out my opponents [/i] "sooraa so pehchaaneeai jo laray deen kay hayth" [u]"he alone is a warrior who fights in defence of true faith" [/u] the warrior who performs this to the best of his abilities is a real Sikh.

Re: who is a REAL sikh?

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 19 Apr 2004

A Sikh is one that follows these three principles that Guru Nanak lay out: 1) Lives a truthful life (does not steal, cheat, makes a honest living) 2) Remembers god 3) Shares his wealth

Re: who is a REAL sikh?

Mkhalsa · 19 Apr 2004

yes dorothy you are correct, that is one part of it, but the main step is taking amrit. One cannot take amrit without those 3 things but amrit is the most important rehat.

Re: who is a REAL sikh?

Singh · 20 Apr 2004

Good old Mkhalsa with his narrow minded thoughts again. You are right that Amrit is essential in becoming a Sikh, but don't think even for a moment that some one who has taken Amrit is a Sikh just because of that. People seem to think that anyone who has taken Amrit is automatically a Gurmuck (and are happy to eat from them) and people who have not are Manmukhs (who can never come near their food) . Im wish Sikhi was that simple but the fact is AMrit is only one requirment and an AMridhari can still be a non sikh by not following Gurmat ie someone who's gone through the Amrit ceremony but doesn't do Amritvela and commits sins etc. Taking Amrit doesn't make someone into a Sikh (learner) its only the start, and hence by just going through the procedure no one becomes a Khalsa. On the other hand someone can be a Sikh (learner) by doing Amritvela and living the principles of Sikhi but may not have taken Amrit but accepts that it has to be done and is working towards it. This person can not be regarded as a Manmuckh and the other as a Sikh or Gurmuckh just becaouse they spent five hours to shuck Amrit. If just taking Amrit makes someone a better person Bhadal is better than Mother Terraisa (I don't think so)

Re: who is a REAL sikh?

karmheen · 20 Apr 2004

I would just like to point out that mkhalsa in his first post did mention that ""But if one is amritdhari does that make them a sikh even if they are fake? not necessarily." Which is exaclty what the above post was saying, so I dont see how he is being narrow minded here. A person who is working towards getting amrit shack can call themselves sehajdaree sikhs, but like one of the above posts pointed out, they are not part of the khalsa fauj yet. They are getting prepared, but have not recieved admission yet.

Re: who is a REAL sikh?

MS · 20 Apr 2004

Singh >>but don't think even for a moment that some one who has taken Amrit is a Sikh just because of that He never said that you are, dont over exageragte and put words in ppls mouths. Amrit gives you the oppertunity i.e. is the mechanism to get to sachkhand. So for all those "its whats on the inside that counts" this is rubbish and plz find somthing in gurbani to suport that. Sikhi belives in balance i.e. combination of "being good on the inside" AND actions/outiside i.e. rehat. gusikh lifestyle etc.. So the simple fact stands you can know as much bani and be as good person as you like, without having Amrit you do not yet even have the oppertunity to break the cycle of birth! The very first Rehat is to take amrit, i.e. be recognised a sikh by guroo sahib, for all those who love guroo sahib, if you truly love him why have you not obeyed his first Rehat!? So a combination of taking Amrit and keeping a Gursikh lifestyle is what will be fruitful. ur quite right in saying somone who has taken amrit for the pretense of creating a false appearence or whatever is doomed to failure, thats simply obvious and logical and so plain in sight that didnt even need saying.

Re: who is a REAL sikh?

kaur · 20 Apr 2004

sikh means learner..so surely, if a learner makes mistakes and learns from them then they can stil b regarded as a sikh

Re: who is a REAL sikh?

Mkhalsa · 20 Apr 2004

Narrowminded?! Mee?!?! ive been called a lot of things, but narrowminded? I beleive in ufos and paranormal stuff, im a totally liberal tree hugging hippie kind of person, narrowminded?! HAHahah thats sooo weirddddd....

Re: who is a REAL sikh?

MS · 21 Apr 2004

Kaur, Your defintion or my defintion of what a sikh is does not matter, you can say it means learner which is true but as we both know your talking in the absolutly most liberal sense there is. Guroo Sahib will disagree with you and only even consider one a Sikh once they have taken Amrit. this is FACT, you dont have to agree or like it, just accept it.