Re: tying a sharp dastaar
DipperFromSurrey · 24 Apr 2004
He/She DOES want to tie a round one...
read the post again..
Re: tying a sharp dastaar
gabroo khalistan dah · 26 Apr 2004
its called patiala shahi is'nt it?
and arguing over pugs dayumm.....what next the material used?
Re: tying a sharp dastaar
vaheguroo~vaheguroo · 26 Apr 2004
umm...i think a singh was being somewhat sarcastic when he said "samosa style.."
read the post again:
"more akin to the so-called samosa styles,"
"me", a singh did mention bhai sahib randhir singh jee in his post
Re: tying a sharp dastaar
Rashpal Singh · 29 Apr 2004
VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh
'A Singh',
There are two 'proper' ways. One is a Dumaala, which is like Bhai Fauja Singh, Nihang Singh style to make it easier.
The second style is Bhai Randhir Singh style, now this is called a Gurmukhi Dastaar, as it is the proper style in line with gurmat, it shouldn't have the laRR in the back, and should not be done with pooni. Also Keski should be worn underneath both styles.
VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh
Re: tying a sharp dastaar
Harmeet Singh · 29 Apr 2004
Veerji
Is a 'Kenya' style turban against gurmat?
Re: tying a sharp dastaar
singhsation · 29 Apr 2004
What an absurd topic. Now there are is a specific and definite dastaar style?
Moreover, a pooni is not allowed - good God. When did the pooni become anti-Sikh or anti-gurmat?
Where are these ridiculous rules coming from?
I wear a round dastar, a dumalla (for which there are proper tying techniques) and on occassion, a "boat" shaped dastaar. In the end, it is a dastaar, regardless of what style I wear.
If something is a gurmukhi dastaar then is something else an anti-gurmuki dastaar? When did this term gurmukhi dastaar first come about?
The type of dastaar worn by Bhai Randhir Singh ji was the type of dastaar worn by most Sikhs during those days and today as well. My great-grandfather and grandfather all wore similar style dastaars.
(I can't believe I'm having this discussion)
Should we now regiment strict rules for how a dastaar must be tied? I think we should - it will make us look really hardcore then and superior to the rest of the unwashed masses.
Yes indeed, what better way to show the superiority of who we are as opposed to these lesser Sikhs out there - they should come and learn the meaning of Sikhi from us.
I think once we've established what the specifically proper dastaar style is, we should turn our attention to how we tie the knots in our kachere. Yes sir, I think the knot should be no more than 1/3rd of an inch in diameter and the loop on the left side must be one inch longer than the loop on the right side - anything else is anti-gurmat.
daas
Re: tying a sharp dastaar
singhsation · 30 Apr 2004
Dear Trigga -
While I agree with the sentiment of what you've written, I would humbly request refraining from mentioning Sikh personalities like Bhai Randhir Singh ji in the fashion below. It's not that I think you were trying to be offensive but mentioning someone of Bhai Randhir Singh ji's stature in the context below is probably not appropriate. Thank you.
daas
TRIGGA wrote:
> "...we should turn our attention to how we tie the knots in our
> kachere. Yes sir, I think the knot should be no more than 1/3rd
> of an inch in diameter and the loop on the left side must be
> one inch longer than the loop on the right side - anything else
> is anti-gurmat."
>
> 'singhsation', sadly you are mistaken, as you`re an ignorant
> manmukh!
> Personally I feel it will be far more saintly if the knot was a
> bit smaller and the loops were the same length- I wonder if
> anyone has any pictures/proof of how Bhai Randhir Singh did his
> kachera, or should I say his Gurmukhi kachera!
Re: tying a sharp dastaar
Kulbir Singh · 30 Apr 2004
------------------
-Baba Puran Singh Karichowale (and for that matter many Gursikhs in the NishkamSevakJatha) are all heretical Manmukhs, since they have dastaars that fall outside of this definition (i.e. with poonee and back larh!)
-Also included within this category, by the definition of the foregoing BhenJi and Bhaji, would be General Shubej Singh (who incidently also had a tied beard!), many Shaheeds of 1984 including Bhais Sukha Singh and Jinda Singh.
------------------
It is wrong to pull in famous Sikh personalities in every debate. Coming back to this debate, the fact of the matter is that there are some rules to wearing the Sikh Dastaar. Every Dastaar in the world is not the Sikh Dastaar. The dastaar that Afghanis wear or the Iranians wear is not the Sikh Dastaar and nor should the Sikhs wear that kind of Dastaar.
By the means of tradition and some instructions from Rehitnamas, we know that the Gurmukhi Dastaar has the following characteristics:
1) Dastaar is always one of the four accepted colours of Khalsa, for clothing.
2) Dastaar is like a circle i.e. the beginning or the ending of the Dastaar should not be visible. This is the reason why a laR is not left in the back.
Dastaar goes one way only but if you keep out laR, then that part of the Dastaar goes against the flow or direction of Dastaar. This is not acceptable in Gurmat. Dastaar goes in one way only and not two ways.
3) Dastaar can be round or cross-wise from the forehead. It does not matter. What matters is that there should be no laR.
4) No pins, should be used to hold any laR.
5) When wearing the dastaar, it should not be folded nor should the pooni be done. Just open your dastaar and wear it “chin chin kay”.
6) Dastaar cannot be worn over bare head. There must be a keski or small dastaar underneath.
7) Dastaar should not be sewn in the middle to make it wider. Traditionally, sewing dastaar is considered wrong.
8) Dastaar should not be put in mouth when starting. Dastaar is a very sacred article of our faith and we should not put it in mouth, thereby desecrating it.
There could be many more points. If we are wearing a dastaar, we should might as well wear the right one. Just wrapping a cloth around the head cannot be classified as dastaar.
And NO, this debate is not stupid or trivial. We should not forsake the original form of Dastaar. This is an important issue and we must move to protect the original saroop of Dastaar, otherwise our dastaar will become a hat just like Yahudis (Jews). They started off with a dastaar but now even the most ultra-orthodox Yahudis wear hats and not dastaars. If we don't move to protect our traditions, our dastaar will disappear in the future.
Some one mentioned Sant Kareechowalay and mentioned that he used to wear the African Style. We respect Sant jee’s bhagtee and Naam kamaayee but this does not mean that we should accept a violation of rehit by him as well. Sant jee himself never propagated African style dastaar. It is just that he naturally used to wear it and did not notice that it was a violation of Gurmat Dastaar maryada. He cannot be held responsible for any wrongdoing as he did not know but the ones who know and then knowingly follow the wrong path would be held responsible.
General Subegh Singh Shahid used to wear a round dastaar in his last days. Sukha and Jinda too used to wear the Gurmukhi Dastaar in their last days.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: tying a sharp dastaar
singhsation · 30 Apr 2004
Accepting the principles laid out in the rehitnamas (given that their interpretation is correct), tradition is probably not the best thing to fall back on regarding dastaars.
The dastaars worn by Sikhs have changed a number of times - there was a time when the Akali Bunga dastaar was the popular choice but sometime in the last century or two, that dastaar fell out of favor, even amongst the Nihangs.
Regarding wearing a small dastaar or keski underneath a dastaar, that is a contentious point, stemming mostly from the AKJ belief that keski is a kakaar. For those that don't believe keski is a kakaar, the conclusion maybe different.
Traditions vary and change, as is evidenced by the different types of dastaar styles which have come and gone. I don't think the Sikh dastaar will disappear as it did amongst the Jews because it does not carry the religious weight for them as it does for the Sikhs. The turban is not merely a cultural phenomenon for Sikhs but an integral part of the faith - the proper means of covering the head.
Again, I'm not a big fan of the term "gurmukhi dastaar" - it seems like a recent term applied to a particular style of dastaar. In itself, there is nothing wrong with applying the term but the insinuation is that this style of dastaar is somehow special, being a "gurmukhi dastaar" - it's a style of dastaar that was/is popular now - most likely, there were no Sikhs during Guru Gobind Singh ji's time who wore dastaars in that style.
The term seems to denote the style of dastaar as something unique when, in fact, it is not - it was/is a very common form of tying a dastaar and I don't think it was ever called a "gurmukhi dastaar" until more recent times. Forgive me, but the distinction of calling a dastaar "gurmukhi" strikes me as somewhat artificial.
daas
Re: tying a sharp dastaar
singhsation · 30 Apr 2004
mkhalsa, if you take a look at the mention of "gurmukhi dastaar" in previous posts, individuals are using the term to denote a style of tying the turban. If "gurmukhi dastaar" means dastaar as per rehit, then that is fine but that is not how the term was being used.
Regarding the rehitname, I'll defer to your knowledge of them as I have not read them myself - it's one of the things, with Guru ji's kirpa, that I hope to do this summer.
My mention of keski in the previous post and my reason for not wanting to get into a discussion on it was due to the fact keski is considered a kakaar by AKJ while it is not considered a kakaar by the majority of the Khalsa panth. No point getting into this old argument as I doubt either side is going to give an inch.
Regards,
daas
Re: tying a sharp dastaar
singhsation · 01 May 2004
If the above mention of keski was with reference to it being required by rehit as opposed to it being a kakaar, then I stand corrected. Thank you.
daas
ps. I'm hoping to read Sikh rehitname this summer - could you please point me to the one which says two dastaars must be worn? Thank you.
Mkhalsa wrote:
> Bhai sahib, this has NOTHING to do with keski as a kakkar
> discussion. The fact that keski must be tied under dastar has
> always been a rehat and I personally learned of this from a
> taksali! (who posts frequently on many forums)
>
> We are to wear at least two dastars, of whatever style, as long
> as our top one is not hte same one touching our head to start.
> its more secure this way and more comfortable, and it looks
> better, some of the many reasons for such a rehat.