Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Air India Trial Update

Air India Trial Update

jagroop singh · 26 Apr 2004

TODAY'S PAPER 'It's as good a show as you can find' In the past year, moments of high drama sometimes overshadowed evidence at the Air-India trial By ROBERT MATAS Monday, April 26, 2004 - Page A4 VANCOUVER -- It was a rare flash of raw emotion from the witness box at the Air-India trial. A daycare worker told the courtroom she had lost her job, her home, her friends and contact with one of her sons since agreeing to testify against Ripudaman Singh Malik. "I'm so scared, so scared of running when there is nowhere left to run," she mumbled, wiping away tears. In the public gallery, Martine Donahue was pleased she'd been there for the woman's testimony. "Everyone was crying . . . I was really choked," she said later. Ms. Donahue, 77, testified almost a year ago in the sensational terrorism trial. She continues to attend out of interest -- and, she says, because on a rainy day in Vancouver "it's as good a show as you can find." The trial is a spectacle all right -- one in which moments of high drama have sometimes overshadowed evidence. But its outcome is still very much in doubt. The trial heads into its second year on Wednesday, and the prosecution is only now beginning the final portion of its case against the defendants. Mr. Malik and Ajaib Singh Bagri face murder charges for the killing of 329 people on June 23, 1985, in the mid-air explosion of an Air-India flight from Canada off the coast of Ireland, and in the death of two baggage handlers killed 54 minutes earlier in a bomb blast at Tokyo's Narita airport. The prosecution's theory is that the two Canadians were seeking revenge against the Indian government for attacks against Sikhs in India, and an invasion of the Golden Temple, the Sikhs' holiest shrine. Until the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks in New York and Washington, the disaster had been the deadliest terrorist attack in aviation history. Witnesses against Mr. Bagri and Mr. Malik have all been called. The primary evidence against Mr. Malik is an account of a conversation 12 years after the co-ordinated twin bombings, in which he is alleged to have confessed. The case against Mr. Bagri revolves around incriminating statements he made that do not spell out what he specifically did on the day of the disaster. In the final portion of the prosecution's case, beginning today, the trial will focus on the partly rebuilt aircraft that was blown out of the sky. The court is expected to hear conflicting evidence on whether the explosion occurred in a rear compartment of the plane, where baggage checked in at the Vancouver airport was stored. Defence witnesses are expected to be called beginning in June. Ms. Donahue, 77, is a spunky, retired airline employee who took the reservations used in 1985 to check baggage with bombs onto two aircraft. She has been in the public gallery frequently since she testified almost a year ago, a day after the trial began. She says she comes to court to see the accused, to hear the witnesses and to piece together what really happened. She measures each statement at the trial with the critical eye of a juror. Ms. Donahue also said she comes for entertainment. "That judge is so cool, he shows absolutely nothing. You can tell he is really attentive, but it's like he is made of stone, like a Buddha," she said of Mr. Justice Ian Bruce Josephson. She is bored by legal arguments, but is impressed with prosecutor Joe Bellows, who she feels presented the evidence against Mr. Malik meticulously. She thought lawyer Len Doust, who questioned Inderjit Singh Reyat for the prosecution, was outstanding. "His performance was so memorable." Lawyer Richard Peck, who cross-examined her, was "a real gentleman," but annoying. She wondered whether he tried to put words in her mouth. The mood at the trial has fluctuated dramatically, depending on who is in the witness box. Mr. Malik had a strong show of support from family and friends while witnesses testified against him. Many members of Mr. Bagri's family were there when the attention was on him. At times, the trial seems more like a substitute for the judicial commission of inquiry that never was. As the months pass, more and more pieces in the unfinished Air-India jigsaw puzzle fall into place. At other times, the plush $7-million courtroom, built for the Air-India trial, feels like a living shrine to the victims of the deadliest crime in Canadian history. With a respectful silence, members of the victims' families slip into their seats in the public gallery and peer through a thick, transparent, bullet-resistant wall at lawyers on the other side. About 110 family members have appeared in the public gallery since the trial began, a few different families coming to court almost every week. Most sit directly behind Mr. Malik and Mr. Bagri, a few metres away from the families of the accused. After so many years, the edge has been taken off any confrontation. Family members eye each other, but never speak. Mr. Bagri's and Mr. Malik's families have been reticent to comment to the media. Privately, they indicate they feel good about how the trial is unfolding. They believe the court will not find the witnesses credible. Across the aisle, the families of victims are persuaded by the evidence against Mr. Bagri and Mr. Malik. Nursing their sorrow for almost 20 years, they speak softly but with a firm belief that the court will convict. In the early months of the trial, families of the victims told reporters they came to confront the accused and remind them of those who were killed in cold blood. After waiting so many years for a trial to begin, they wanted someone to be punished for the crime. Many said they were taken aback by the glacial pace of justice. But now, family members are more realistic. They say they come just to bear witness. "It's important to be here," said Lata Pada, whose husband, Vishnu, and teenaged daughters Brinda and Arti were on the flight. "For a long time, it was as if the families [of the victims] were blotted out from public memory. People's lives were lost, people suffered, fathers and mothers and children were lost. But we are still here." Ms. Pada had trouble matching the image of terrorist bombers with the two middle-aged men in the prisoner's box, dressed in the traditional outfit of Sikh warriors. When they come into the courtroom, Mr. Malik and Mr. Bagri scan the public gallery, looking for familiar faces. They smile. They bow slightly, with their hands together, to those they know. Often Mr. Bagri waves with a big smile to his grandchildren. "When you look at the accused, they seem so innocent and religious," Ms. Pada said. She wonders what type of person could be capable of such heinous crimes. "They seem like two people who might have been active in their community, good neighbours, good parents in normal circumstances," she said. Neither Mr. Malik nor Mr. Bagri has indicated whether they will testify in their own defence. The court has heard from 87 witnesses over the past year. The prosecution's case stands almost entirely on the testimony of witnesses who have recounted private conversations with the accused. None of the witnesses had firsthand knowledge about the alleged involvement of the two men in the crime. The prosecution has not shown any physical evidence directly linking the two men to the explosions. Without direct evidence, the prosecution team of 18 lawyers has slowly built a circumstantial case. Any one piece of evidence may not be sufficient grounds for a conviction, they say, but all the pieces together point overwhelmingly to one conclusion. About 15 lawyers work on the two defence teams. Mr. Bagri's lawyers have been more aggressive in challenging evidence and raising legal issues about the process. Mr. Malik's team has relied on Mr. Bagri's team to take care of the legal challenges, appearing at times not to be as engaged in the courtroom battles as other defence lawyers. But with so much depending on whether a witness can be believed, both teams hammered away strenuously at inconsistencies in witness testimony, and unsavoury embarrassments in the witness's past. They also questioned the reliability of witnesses who received benefits for co-operating with the prosecution. The basic outline of the alleged conspiracy has remained the same since investigators pieced together their best clues in 1985. The prosecution's theory is that Mr. Bagri and Mr. Malik were part of a group of religious Sikh activists that included Talwinder Singh Parmar, Inderjit Singh Reyat, Hardial Singh Johal, Surjan Singh Gill and others. Mr. Reyat pleaded guilty to manslaughter, admitting he collected dynamite and other items for the Air-India bomb. He was previously convicted of manslaughter in the Narita explosion. Mr. Parmar, who was killed by police in India in 1992, and Mr. Johal, who died of natural causes in 2002, were never charged. The police have also not charged others who were named in court as part of the conspiracy. The most crucial evidence against the two defendants came from women with whom they had a close relationship. The court has prohibited the media from identifying either woman. Both were friends of the defendants before talking to authorities about the Air-India case. Both women testified they did not have a sexual relationship with either of the accused. Mr. Malik was betrayed by a daycare worker who repeatedly told the court about her love for him, while setting out in precise detail the most damning evidence against him. "He told me how special I was and gave me a big hug and told me he had a lot of feelings for me," she testified. "We grew very fond of each other and the fondness turned to love and the love to respect." Her love, though, was not blind. She told the court she balked when he wanted to involve her in a scheme to misuse government grants. She also came under pressure at the Sikh preschool to be more devout. Unwilling to comply, she went to the province's Human Rights Commission. She started talking to police about Mr. Malik's alleged involvement in an unemployment insurance scam, immigration smuggling and welfare fraud. The court heard she was repeatedly threatened, and eggs were thrown at her house in the middle of the night during the months she met with police. Six months after first approaching authorities, she told police about Mr. Malik and Air-India. She said Mr. Malik said: "We'd Air-India crashed." She said in a second conversation he told her that he had arranged the airline reservations and put up $3,000 for the tickets. He also identified others who took part in the plot, she said. She stuck by her account, although her credibility was vigorously attacked in court. The woman also held to her emotions. "I love him still," she said just before disappearing again into a witness-protection program. The woman linked to Mr. Bagri was a reluctant witness. She did not provide any incriminating evidence against Mr. Bagri when she was called to testify. Eight RCMP officers and a CSIS agent told a different story. The court was told she said Mr. Bagri came to her house on the evening before the disaster to borrow her car. Mr. Bagri told her the baggage was going on a trip but he was not. The prosecution alleges that Mr. Bagri was involved in getting the bags with explosives to Vancouver airport. The court spent two months considering whether to accept the testimony of the RCMP officers and CSIS agent. The judge decided the woman had feigned memory loss and was afraid for her life. He accepted as true the account of her comments provided by CSIS agent William Laurie, but rejected most of the police officers' work for failing to meet requirements of the court for evidence. Another witness to testify against Mr. Bagri was an FBI informant, who testified that Mr. Bagri had told him he was involved in the Air-India disaster. The informant, who received $300,000 (U.S.) to testify, recounted incriminating comments made during five conversations with Mr. Bagri. The trial has also heard from several witnesses about incidents that the prosecution says reveal motives for committing the crime, and provide insight into the defendants' thinking. The court spent several days considering a fiery speech by Mr. Bagri almost a year before the crash. Speaking before thousands of people at Madison Square Gardens in New York City, Mr. Bagri called for the death of 50,000 Sikhs, for first-born sons to be dedicated to the fight for a separatist Sikh country and for an aggressive fundraising campaign to support militant action in India. One of the most outstanding moments of the trial had little to do with either Mr. Malik or Mr. Bagri. Ms. Donahue recalled the days in September when Inderjit Singh Reyat was called to testify. "Reyat is a handsome man, but his testimony was totally dubious," she said. "But when he was on the stand, it was as good as anything you could think of."