Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 29 Apr 2004
What's wrong with folding (method 3) ?
Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
singhsation · 29 Apr 2004
And pray tell, why is a dastaar, take for example the "UK dastaar", not proper? Where do you find these rules on what is "right" and who came up with these rules?
So a dastaar has to be five yards or more.............what if it's 4.89 yards? Is it now anti-gurmat? Is that Sikh any less a Sikh? Is that .11 yard difference the difference between gurmat and manmat?
And God forbid that the dastaar is folded. Wasn't it Guru Nanak Dev ji Maharaj who forbid Sikhs from folding their dastaars or was it Guru Arjan Dev ji Maharaj? Or maybe it was Dasmesh Pita ji?
It must have been someone very important, after all, whether a dastaar is folded or not folded makes all the difference in the world when it comes to Sikhi - it's the difference between gurmat and manmat, the difference between sachkhand and nark.
daas
Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
singhsation · 29 Apr 2004
sorry, but folding or not folding is not a matter of rehit. if it is please, point me to references regarding the so called "gurmat" method of tying a dastar and where it is mentioned that this is rehit.
as it stands right now, you have simply alleged something with absolutely no substance. if there is substance (ie. valid references: gurbani, rehitnamay etc.) I'd like to see it. Thank you.
daas
- wrote:
> yup, just like a sarbloh vs. steel karaa or kirpaan is
> difference between nark and sachkhand right? Or how about a
> blue vs. white kacherra? Right? No diff right? Why would god
> care?
>
> The answer is rehit: yes, rehit. Rehit says these things and
> must be followed.
>
> Folding a dastaar is not tying it "chin kay" or the gurmat
> method. The gurmat method is chin kay not folding over and
> over again.
Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
vaheguroo~vaheguroo · 29 Apr 2004
"2) The knot-keskee which is a regular keskee, but the last lar is tied with a knot at the back of the keskee. A dastaar shouldn't be knotted."
how is it knotted? you mean they tie a knot on the larh and then tuck it in? :S or do they tie it to teh keski somehow?
also, i dont think this is mandatory, but another thing keski wearers should do is tie your keski into your kes...
Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
i just have a · 29 Apr 2004
ya
um
but
What if your hair is short in length.....??????? some people dont have long hair....
Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
singhsation · 29 Apr 2004
Thanks for the reference - I'll definitely check it out, especially what "chunay kar" means and what it forbids.
When I tie a dumalla or round dastaar, it is via "crunching/pinching" (for lack of a better word) the two edges together and use a pooni on the occassions I tie a "boat" style dastaar. But if "chunay kar" carries the meaning that is being purported, I'll have to change up the "boat" style dastar - more info on that later.
With regards to asking for quotes too much, what other alternative do you propose when there are disagreements as to theology or the Sikh lifestyle?
We are nothing more than internet personalities on this forum, don't expect anyone to take the word of someone they've never met or who could have an agenda in what they are putting forth - references are an excellent way to put forward your argument and allow the reader to confirm what is said with valid sources. I don't see very many alternatives to this.
daas
- wrote:
> "kangha dono vakat kar, paag chunay kar bandhaee" is the exact
> quotation.
>
> What does chin-kay mean? It means not to fold over and over
> and make a thin bandage that you tie on your head. It means to
> open the dastar all the way, and then kind of pinch it together
> bit by bit. Hard to describe. But beyond rehitnamas this is
> the way puratan Singhs tied their dastaars and is just a
> tradition that has been passed down.
>
> We demand quotes way too much and refuse to acknowledge
> tradition as being a major source of our rehit as well. The
> way we think is pure example of orientalism.
Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
Why discuss this? · 30 Apr 2004
These discussions on detailed things that are "wrong" are brought up by people who want to feel better about themselves. They can look around at Singhs and Singhnia and say "I'm better than him, he folds his dastar, i'm doing what Bhai Nand Lal Jee said".
Instead of starting off a discussion with saying "so and so is wrong" discussions should take a positive spin, such as discussing "why chin kay is right".
These discussions do not have any value to them when they turn into attacks.
Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
simran_sewa_sacrifice · 30 Apr 2004
waheguru ji ka khala waheguru ji ki fateh!!
i would like to request that all singhnees please dont do pancake joora (joora that hair is just folded atop the head so as not to make the dastaar look big) daas has told many bibian not to do this and they complied but most of them from convicing of their fellow singhnees went back to their old style...only a few i know that have looked past opinion of fashion and keep a proper joora. i hope more ppl will follow proper rehat and encourage others to do the same
-bhulla chuka di maaf
[%sig%]
Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
Mohan Singh · 01 May 2004
I think that it is very good Singhnees are keeping Keski in the first place so first we should congratulate them on that.
I think personally that it is very easy to do a very neat dastar without folding it. It only takes a little practise. Yes I think it is very important to have a neat dastar - there is a Rehatnama saying tie your turban neatly and carefully - BUT we should not take it so far that we are infringing on what the Guru says. Personally some of the neatest Singhnees keskis Ive seen are those which are not folded, or with the pleat pattern.
I appreciate the dastar should ideally not be folded. However, I do not understand why pretty much all the Jatha singhs in the UK I know who do not do a Dumalla (ie they do a Gurmukhi dastar), they ALL fold their material first.
Also I do not understand why even Singhs who do Dumallas, now fold their material, usually just once.
Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
Deepinder Singh · 01 May 2004
There IS NO RIGHT OR WRONG WAY TO TIE A DASTAAR!!
KOOP TERI PAGRI MEETAE TERE BOLE!
Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
Kulbir Singh · 03 May 2004
There are many bibiyaan who wear dastaar with flat jooRa (knot of hair). They don’t tie a knot on their head but just place their hair on their head by folding them. Then they wear a keski on top of it. After dastaar, their head looks flat from top, as if there are no hair. They look more like Muslim Bibiyaan and daughters of Mohammad Prophet and not daughters of Guru Gobind Singh jee. Daughters of Guru Gobind Singh jee wear full sized dastaars.
It is a must to do a proper JooRa on Dasam Duaar.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Wrong Dastar-Styles for Girls
Khalsa Singh · 09 May 2004
i guess wearing these type of dastars is a paap. the type of dastar is a Dumalla.