Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

raj academy-prof surinder singh

raj academy-prof surinder singh

vaheguru1 · 27 Sep 2006

Vahegurujikakhalsa Vahegurujikifateh firstly sangat ji may i apologise for the particularly negative tone of this topic but i would not have started it unless i thought it was truly necesary. as many people may be aware, the raj academy have been doing kirtan at the past two akj/akji rhensbais in the uk.firstly at milton keynes and then at bedford. although this maybe perhaps a positive step towards introducing variety into akj rhenbsais and promoting rag, i dont knwo what the snagats views are, but i believe this cannot be done at the expense of allowing those who do not follow the BASIC sikh rehat doing kirtan( im not even talking about "akj" rehat, im talking about the basic panthic maryada). the main "leader" of this group, firstly eats meat(which some may argue is not against "maryada") BUT ALSO does not wear all of his panj kakar all the time. there are also other things that have been doen and said by this person in the past, but i will not disclose, as i dont want to rubbish this person, i merley want to ask the stage secretaries or who ever..of akj or anywhere else who regards kirtan very highly..not to allow just anyone to do kirtan..especialy if they dont follow the basic panth maryada...which requires all panj kakkars to be worn at all times. the jatha has often said that non amritdharis cannot do kirtan on stage..and if they say this, then they must surely folow up those who quite obviously go against the rehat maryada... sorry about the negative nature of this topic.i was jsut wonderign if the views of the snagat on this issue are similar to mine, and whetehr everyone agrees raj academy should be boycotted at "akj" programes..at the very least.

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

cSingh · 27 Sep 2006

you should speak to Satnam singh Southall direct. He is stage secretary. His number is 07956 519256

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

ummm · 27 Sep 2006

Have to agree with the sentiments expressed, on one hand this guy has always dished akj style of kirtan, dished every kirtani, dis respected gurbani by allowing it to be put in the feet of his students, has a very dodgy past and yet akj uk/akji let him come and do kirtan at their smagams, do not understand why he was invited, don't think he wouuld have come free either... or is it case he wishes to demonstrate to the akj sangat the proper marayada of kirtan now that he has made his money out of his academy...

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

vaheguru1 · 28 Sep 2006

can sum1 ring satnam singh and explain situation please? my punjabi isnt thaat fluent

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

maha_moorakh · 28 Sep 2006

he speaks english [%sig%]

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

kharkoo · 02 Oct 2006

Is the Prof a namdhari? He does kirtan in the diwans in the presence of their guru Jagjit singh.

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

vaheguru1 · 03 Oct 2006

um no he's not naamdhari as such, i dont think, but loads of naam dharis teach with him..and do kirtan with him.woah i didnt know he does kirtan infront of their "guru".

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

ns · 04 Oct 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Very cool points put forward by vahbeguru1 and by no means negative, heck there are a millions of things that are negative in the panth today. Why isn't any one of the organisers of AKJ UK/AKJI replying? Sant Singh Maskeen Jee said once the amount of kirtan programmes we have nowadays around the globe is uncountable compared to kirtan smagams in the puraatan times. Some Sikhs used to hang on to one line og Gurbani and live practically according to it in puraatan times. Nowadays we have kirtans smagams all over the show but nothing going in, just goes in and comes out, I am included here and this doesn't of course go for everyone there are some real gem gursikhs out there but verelee...

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

cSingh · 05 Oct 2006

To ns and others who have a problem with understanding the response. The AKJ UK is now run mainly by elders rather than youth as it was before. Many of these elders are not on internet. If you have a specific question about what happens at the rainsbhai, then speak to Bhai Satnam singh, who is the stage secretary. His mobile number is clearly written above. The Singhs have an open door policy and you can speak to them at anytime. They welcome discussion. Do you not think when Surinder Singh asked for time at the rainsbhai, that Bhai Satnam Singh did not speak to him about things? So lets have some faith in the elders who the sangat has given seva. I spoke to him yesterday and no one has rang him. This leaves me to think people are intentionally just stirring issues on here, but do not have the guts as proper sikhs to speak to the elders face to face. If they did, and had real concern about an issue, then they would just ring him.

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

ns · 05 Oct 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh cSingh jeeo , it 's not about stirring things , its about respect. If you know Satnam Singh and his response then why don't you have the guts to write it out fully here.Or are we saying here that most of the youth don't keep in touch with the elders. As you mention the elders , why does the AKJ not have a bunch of youth who express to the elders as they are not on the net. This youth comittee or call it whatever you want should report on threads such as these on questions and queries.The points raised are valid and we don't want stir anything but when there are stains on one past they can't be just wiped off in a second. So has the Khalsa behind the scenes done the "dekh ke anditha " on the professor, has he apologized or chaned his ways? Come on as sikhs we have guts to tell the truth dont' we?

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

cSingh · 05 Oct 2006

What are u talking about? This is so stupid ! The guys number is above. Ring him and you put it on the net if u want to yourself. I have no intention of putting what he said to me on the net, in case some idiot twists it, and makes it out to be something else. This is what often happens in these internet messageboards trails on people sikhi. Then Bhai sahib will have other people questioning him needlessly. If Mr ns, you have evidence that surinder singh has done wrong then put them facts in front of Singhs. I think it is very sad you are on your high horse talking about truth and high ideals, but you cannot just ring an elder and discuss the issue with him, face to face.

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

vaheguru1 · 06 Oct 2006

aaah please dont fight,that wasnt the aim of this post. Csingh, i assure you that i didnt start the post to stir things.also, its very hard to come by "hard" evidence that surinder singh has done soemthing wrong, i dont think anyones recorded what he says or anything, but i hope that just becuase there is no evidence, as such, that this will be overlooked, as a lot of people have been in sangat and know what he's like.i understand your point of view totally ji, and so im going to ring him by tomorow and i'l let the sangat know what he says i sincerely apologise if i aggravated anyone by starting this post. Vaheguru.

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

cSingh · 06 Oct 2006

Thats cool, Vaheguru1. Bhai Satnam Singh is a nice guy who has done alot of seva. Like most elders, he does not really understand the nature of anonymous messages in messageboards. He was a bit upset, that people who had objections did not just speak to him rather than putting it messageboards to which he has no access. But if you just ring him and explain your concerns and opinions on Surinder singh, then I am sure he will consider it. He will then be aware the next time Surinder singh or anyone else approaches him. Most Singhs do not know about A-Z about what people get up to. They just do their seva. But if you are helpful and just notify them, then those in charge can address the situation in the appropriate manner.

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

santkhalsa · 06 Oct 2006

Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khaalsa Wahe Guru Ki Fateh, Dear Bhai Singho, NINDA BHALI kisi ki Nahi, Sikhism does not encourage Galyaanta or Criticism of anyone. Trust me I am not a fan of Surinder Singh JI, but if you look at someones GOOD points, at least he is spreading the OLD Ancient art of doing kirtan with old and ancient instruments. Let WaheGuru Be the Judge, for if you judge anyone, are you in a position to be Judged. If not, lets get on with improving our lives. SantKhalsa, http://www.neeldhari.com

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

ns · 08 Oct 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Vaheguru1 that's indeed a cool response, and we look forward to the answer. cSingh , Glad you're cool at present, I don't mean to offend and haven't had the time to ring Satnam Singh, I only write on these boards when I get a moment or two as I work nights.The query was decent and response from Vaheguru1 is also decent enough , so the truth will come out as it always does at some pojnt.

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

kaurageous · 08 Oct 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh i totally agree with santkhalsa, if his karam are bad, he will be judged in the court of waheguru...we don't hold any right to judge anyone, why punish him?? we can not even judge ourselves..this is all written by waheguru to c how we react..to this..do we get our josh and start judging people or we stay calm and let waheguru handle it..it's his duty not ours..bhul chuk maaf waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

cSingh · 16 Oct 2006

I bumped into Bhai Satnam singh today. I asked him if anyone had rang him, he said no. He said if anyone has any concerns, or information that he should know, then they are free to ring him. I wish people would not bring up things on a public noticeboard, when they cannot even speak to the responsible people face to face. If the responsible people, have done something wrong, they you can write on messageboards, but first you should speak to them and try to resolve it in a proper manner.

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

gupt · 16 Oct 2006

bunch of cowards we all to read gurbani and jaap naam thats how will get himmat (courage)

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

vaheguru1 · 19 Oct 2006

vaheguroo ji, sorry for delay.jus to let the sangat know i spoke to satnam singh a few days ago and will post what he has said later on in the day when i have time. csingh paaji and others, you are right,the proper way to tackle this would have been to contact satnam singh directly, to be honest i did write the post as a spur of the moment thing and i was a little krodhi.i did not even consider ringing satnam singh up, but in future the direct approach is more effective and causes less bother.. thankyou Vaheguroo

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

Premabhagti · 27 Oct 2006

"Dhur Ki Baani Aaee, Tin Saglee Chint Mitaayee" My dear Gur-bhais, Is it really important if the person doing Kirtan follows rehat? I say so long as he sounds good, allow him to do so. It is the "BAANI" and its message that we are after, not the individual. Remember that "BAANI" is the Guru (BAANI GURU,GURU HAI BAANI). Having said that, if BAANI is uttered by a person not following the rehat code, versus BAANI uttered by the most perfect Gursikh, does that make the former BAANI less of a Guru than the latter BAANI?Is the former BAANI less pure than the latter? Bhul Chuk Maaf WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

maha_moorakh · 12 Nov 2006

i guess u better ring satnaam singh again [%sig%]

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

maha_moorakh · 13 Nov 2006

penji, did u speaK 2 satnaam singh before? what did he say? As the same thing happened on saturday, this issue should really be sorted out :( Gurfateh jee. T Kaur [%sig%]

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

vaheguru1 · 13 Nov 2006

i forgot to right what satnam singh said to me on the phone basically he said- he cannot reject people from doing kirtan, he says he has no right. he said what many of the youth dont realise is that most of the prominent kirtanee in the jatha now have doen very bad things in their not so distant past and whose to know whether they are still doing things.the point he was making was that he has no kind of scale or test that he can measure soemones jeevan by to allow them to do kirtan. i totally understand his points. if we were to take the pointas i made about allowing surinder singh to do kirtan, then we would have to stop most kirtanees from doing kirtan at jatha programs and since theres a whol lot of fanism going on i doubt anyone woudl be too happy with that. i also now agree with santkhalsa's post and the ssecond part of prembhagti's post. satnam singh also reminded me about these tuks- tho dhaevaanaa jaaneeai jaa saahib dhharae piaar || He alone is known to be insane, when he falls in love with his Lord and Master. ma(n)dhaa jaanai aap ko avar bhalaa sa(n)saar ||4||7|| He sees himself as bad, and all the rest of the world as good. ||4||7|| i totally understand bhai sahibs point of view now. and yesterday at the rhensbai when they did kirtan, it doesnt matter who was doing kirtan to be honest, what was importan was the sangats focus on the shabad i guess also all those shaabds about nimrata, neechee hoo at neech should make us realise i didnt realise it at the time, but i guess i made that original post out of total haumai. vaheguru maaf karo Vahegurujikakhalsa Vahegurujikifateh ps. he also said if theres anyone whose willing to take his place he would hand it over in a second lol.

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

maha_moorakh · 13 Nov 2006

hmmm i agree no one has the right to prevent anyone from doing keertan, as we shouldnt judge others and pick out their faults HOWEVER hmmmmmmmmmmm i dunno, i still think that if your claims are true and he does eat meat, then maybe .................aww i dunno. what can we do, i suppose we cant prevent him from doing keertan seva, but maybe some of the older jatha singhs should speak to him. I was told that some of the older singhs were not happy that he was doing keertan. hmmm. i dunno. Mahraj please guide us lost fools! vahigurooo vahiguroooo vahiguru Vahigurujikakhalsa vahigurujikifateh!!! p.s) the rainsbai keertan was wikedd ((((((((((:-) T.Kaur [%sig%]

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

Panthic Singh · 14 Nov 2006

Dont keertanis at rainsbai need to follow keski rehit? Also people who bash gurmukhs such as bhai Randhir Singh, Giani Amolak Singh are allowed to do kirtan?

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

Harcharan Singh · 14 Nov 2006

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh, Could I humbly request that people stop speculating, judging and wasting time. If anyone has any questions to ask, then ask Professor Surinder Singh Ji himself, why gossip on an internet forum? It is not only Professor Ji doing kirtan, it is a very large number of growing Gursikh youth, who follow Guru Ji's maryada. They and their super effort (i.e. learning GuruJi's kirtan maryada, Guru Ji's saaj, whilst, studying full time, working full time, teaching time and doing kirtan seva most days) never seems to get a mention. Maybe you should take a leaf out of their book, and focus on Sikhi and Kirtan rather than Nindiya. Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharajs 40th hukum says: Chugali kar kisae da kam nahi vigaarnaa - Do not ruin someone's work by gossip. The seva that these "Gursikh" (plural) are doing is amazing, especially when you see some of the really young kirtani who have devoted their life to singing Gurbani and have even changed the lives of their household. No one is brainwashed in Raj Academy, active debate and questioning the status quo is completely encouraged, as Puratan Kirtan Maryada is still being researched and revived. THE ONLY SINGLE THING THAT IS NOT QUESTIONED ARE THE 10 SATGURU'S AND THEIR JAGDI JYOT, SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI MAHARAJ. In fact quite the opposite is true - in Kirtan terms - their words, actions and example are set in concrete and not compromised at any cost. No one has insulted anyone, the question of whether or not some famous Gursikh did or didn't do kirtan in Nirdaareth raag is certainly discussed at times, but that is all. It is discussed within an historical context i.e. establishing where, why and how Guru ji's kirtan maryada disappeared. No one questions the jeevan of any famous Gursikh, only circumstances and facts. Many students have role models in Baba Puran singh Ji, Baba Isher Singh Ji and Bhai Randhir singh Ji, but this does not mean that they are blind to the fact that due to various economic, political and social circumstances, these Gursikh may not have done Kirtan in Nirdaareth raag. When you yourself do research you will find that the decline of Gurmat sangeet was due to a large number of differeing reasons rather than blame on any person i.e. British intervention, the rise of media, radio, cinema, concerts, change in Indian Classical, Western Influence, Sangat pressure, popularity of certain types of kirtan amongst sangats, growth of non-amritdhari kan ras Gurdwara commitees appointing filmi singing jathaas etc... Try and emrace good work rather than find holes, if anyone has doubts, then ask the person directly who you have doubts about, and not Nindaks. For those of you really interested in Guru Ji's kirtan, please note that Professor Ji's new Kirtan album "Anhad" will be released in December. It is amazing and has been complied purely by Professor Ji assisted by his Gursikh students, and using only Guru Ji's kirtan marydada and all of Guru Ji's beautiful saaj. It also features the first ever recording of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji's 60th raag "Asa Asavari". It continues the educational and devotinal recordings of Kirtan in Guru Ji's maryada folling "Mere Mun", where kirtan was done using the first 59 raags of Guru Ji. Vaheguru [%sig%]

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

gupt · 14 Nov 2006

the raaj acamdey did keertan seva again at the rainsbhai in west bromwich

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

Panthic Singh · 14 Nov 2006

Oh please Harcharan Singh lets not go down the route where you tell me and others to take a leaf out of there book as I rather not. I know the youth look closer they are not all that you think. I wouldnt call them role models for youth to look up to. On other hand i would look up to naam abhiyaasi Gurmukhs who have puka amrit vela, work go university everything. There are loads of youth who work, school and also do abhiyaas puka Amrit vela and learn keertan you need to go Coventry. Also please provide historic Reference of 59 raags you mention. VAAAHEEEGGUUUURROOOOOOOOOOO

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

Pwalla! · 14 Nov 2006

who are we to judge??

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

ummm · 14 Nov 2006

Veer Hachran singh, you seem very obessed with Surinder singh, I won't call him professor, because I can't profess to konw where he got the title from, in regards to doing kirtan at rainsbhais, the first thin I will say is those who mock AKJ kirtanis and kirtan to the point they use that to enhance their own reputation and then come and do kirtan at AKJ rainsbhais is the most hypocritical act I have ever seen, this person during the past has said many nindak things about AKJ kirtanis style of kirtan, if he dislikes its that much why the sudden need to come back and do kirtan at AKJ rainsbhais, secondly I have seen him sit on stage with namdharis etc to do his so called performances ??? do they believe in the 10 gurus full stop, or is their's 16 now ??? AKJ needs to wake up to the fact and not be used as a promotion for this person, also he brings out alubms ??? what's the verdict on those who sell gurbani to make profit, like the other 1000 ragis out there ??? sorry I have been blunt but I am really surprised AKJ UK are promoting this man, have all that has been said and done, yes he may have a knowledge of raag etc, but as you have said many a time AKJ hasn't really incorporated that in there style of kirtan to the lever at which you believe is should be, AKJ kirtan is a sangatee kirtan, not hey look at me, with all these istruments etc, please take a look at what is really going on, its more of a case of PROMOTION for my UPCOMING ALBUMN, and veer jagjit singh isn't it true the reason you like to voice a support for surinder singh is that he taught down in the south, and those who attended those classes know how much ninda went on about AKJ kirtanis.....

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

Harcharan Singh · 15 Nov 2006

Veer Panthic Singh, Reference : Guru arjun Dev Ji Maharaj/Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. You can find posts on the structure and basis of compilation on posts here or other Sikh websites. Also, look at the work of other Gursikh who have dedicated their life to Guru's kirtan i.e. Dr Gurnaam Singh Ji, Bhai Balbir Singh Ji etc. Lastly please do not hide under a fake name and judge Gursikh you know nothing about, you know nothing of their amritvela and saadhana, so stop belittling Guru's children. Veer Ummm ji, I am not obssesed with anyone except Guru Sahiban and Vaheguru. I am not going to get into a childish debate with you. If you have personal issues or problems with anyone in particular be man enough to first of all use your real name and secondly take your issue up with the people in question directly, rather than speculating and speading rumours. But, just to clarify, the Gurmat Sangeet albums fund research and the cost of producing the album. If spare money goes to assisting anyones gristi jeevan (raising a family etc), which is taken up 7 days a week performing and teaching kirtan, then it is neither your nor my concern or business to judge. They provide the single most comprehensive reference into Guru Ji's kirtan maryada, and are an educational treasure for many people across the globe who want to learn Kirtan our Guru's way. Kirtan is performed now only with Gursikh who have complete faith in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, it had been performed in the past on a few occassions with Namdhari due to their expertise in Guru Ji's created saaj, and the promotion of Guru Ji's saaj initially. Again this is an historic issue and you are no one to judge, if someone has given their life to retrieving, reviving and sharing Guru Ji's perfect kirtan using whatever means they thought necessary, let Vaheguru be the judge. No one has asked you to compromise your faith. If you wish to learn Guru ji's kirtan and Guru Ji's saaj (which you refer to disrespectfully "with all these instuments etc", then you are more than welcome to do so, if not, at least let those that have devoted their life to teaching kirtan, do so in peace. Vaheguru [%sig%]

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

ummm · 15 Nov 2006

"who are we to judge??" good comment but then why don't we allow non amritdaharis, nirankaris, namdharis to do kirtan as well ???? to judge someone is to condemned them, to make sangat aware of what a person is about is sach bolnaa, let's hope those in charge have the decency to ask him about his activities and his functions in halls where many sit on chairs whilst he demonstrated his raag knowledge through GURBANI !!!, satkaar of gurbani is a must........ don't care how many raags you know or PROFESS to know...

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

Jagjit Singh · 15 Nov 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I was sent a link to this today about this thread. I am sorry to say there is alot of nonsense and over active imaginations involved in this. AKJ UK has never invited Prof Surinder Singh, and neither has an agenda to promote him. AKJ UK promotes Shabad Guru only, and there is more than an abundance of Gursikh keertanis in UK. I have spoken to Bhai Satnam Singh briefly. He was unaware of the allegation that Prof Surinder singh eats meat. I have known Surinder singh for some years, and I was completely unaware of this. I even doubt this, as I think he has more sense that to eat meat, especially as he has far more sangat than me. The policy of the jatha is clear, any sevadaar should be wearing the 5 kakkaars and not not be a bujjar kurehti, which includes eating of meat. In an ideal world, we want every keertani to have an immaculately high jeevans, and we live in the hope that more people concentrate on abyass and build their jeevans, whether keertanis or not. Prof Surinder Singh has turned up to the two rainsbhais. He asked for time at one, and this time some sangat members approached Bhai Tarlochan Singh Birmingham who is Assistant Stage Secretary and Bhai Satnam Singh who is Stage secretary, and they gave him 30 mins. Bhai Satnam singh has asked Prof Surinder singh before about allegations about him doing speaking agianst Bhai Sahib, or disrespecting Guru sahib and Prof Surinder Singh has denied such. Now I am sure the two Singhs who do stage seva can ask him about the meat issue, or discuss it in the 5 Singhs with him. Bhai Satnam singh has aksed if anyone has any issues with his seva to ring him direct, as he does not use the internet. He has asked that he will only listen to people who give their names and address, and he is not interested in listening to invisable people. If you have a point then stand by it as a Gursikh. Then the Singhs can deal with it. AKJ UK is not going to make its decisions because of invisable people in internet messageboards. It aims to make its decisions based on truth and Gurmat. If it turns out that Prof Surinder Singh does not eat meat, and has not done such a kurehit, then people here are very guilty of ninda. Personally I have no wish to scan internet forums, and answer these silly discussions. If Gursikhs have issues that sevadaars may have overlooked, then I they should speak to them directly, ideally face to face or on the phone. Making allegations on messageboards where none of sevadaars, even myself, do not read, or have time to read, is helping nobody and completely counter-productive. Doing seva is not easy, and every sevadaar faces many challenges. All sevadaars try to do the best they can. If the sangat assists them, much can be achieved. However if people are not going to communicate with the sevadaars about these issues, then just plaster them on the internet, it is not helpful. How can you expect sevadaars to make judgements on what should be done, when they are unaware of the issues? Judgements can only be made on facts and not rumours. Hence Bhai Satnam Singh has asked that if there is any valid evidence of wrongdoing against Prof Surinder singh, then the people making the allegations should ring him on 07956 519256 or send it to him in writing. Then he can speak to Prof Surinder Singh if he feels that is appropriate, or speak to the 5 Singhs. My benti to the sangat, please stop these internet messageboard witch hunts via hidden ID`s. They are not doing anybodies jeevans any good. There is far too much specualtion and falsehoods. If you have valid points, then help people by speaking to them direct as Gursikhs. That is the honorable thing to do. waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh [%sig%]

Re: raj academy-prof surinder singh

Admin · 15 Nov 2006

Topic closed. Admin.