Impact of Different Baanis?
Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 29 Sep 2006
Sangaj Jio, i have a question that i hope you may be able to answer:
Do Different Baanis impact our lives in different ways?
For example, we are perscribed 5 Baanis to do as our minimum nitnem, does each of them have a specific purpose to give and overall cumulative effect of the Nitnem?
if so, could anyone give a list of remedial effects of the baanis (for example, are there baanis for stress releif? Do certain Baanis fight one specific one of the Panj Chor? etc etc)? Japji Sahib, Jaap Sahib, Chaupee Sahib, Tav Prasad Swayyeh, Anand Sahib are, to my knowledge the perscribed Baanis for nitnem, if anyone could enlighten me to the individual focus of each Baani i would be very grateful.
I would also be interested to know if there is a specific target that Sukhmani Sahib helps you deal with. Akaal Ustat, Chandi Di Vaar, Rehraas Sahib, Kirtan Sohila... i would like to know about them all.
I understand that all Baani helps our spiritual development, but im asking if they help us with specific issues here in the temporal world. if they do, would there be a point doing more repetitions of one given Baani in order to deal with a specific issue in life?
Re: Impact of Different Baanis?
Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 29 Sep 2006
Gupt Jio i wish i could touch your feet and thank you in person. thank you so much for taking time to write so much and share your gyaan.
Do any other Gurmukhs have anything to add? Do you concur with Gupt Ji?
Please do respond if you would be kind enough to share your Gyaan in this matter, hopefully i will not be the only one to benefit from this knowledge.
Re: Impact of Different Baanis?
Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 01 Oct 2006
I am a little surprised that none of he other Vidvaan Gurmukhs that frequent this site have nothing to say on the subject.
I would humbly request that anybody else with Gyaan on the subject please share your knowledge. If you Concur with Gupt Ji then at least say that you do (or not and why).
Your input would be very much appreciated Jio.
Re: Impact of Different Baanis?
Balbir Singh · 10 Oct 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all!
You search impact of different Baanees.
Millions of imitators are the evidence.
Truth is the output. The input is Naam.
Gurbaanee is the result of true Simran.
Balbir Singh
Re: Impact of Different Baanis?
Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 10 Oct 2006
I'm sorry Balbir Singh Ji, i didnt understand the point you were making in your last post. Please excuse my ignorance and explain the following:
"You search impact of different Baanees.
Millions of imitators are the evidence."
Re: Impact of Different Baanis?
Balbir Singh · 10 Oct 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all!
Gurbaanee is the result of true Simran. Gurbaanee is the expression of experiencing truth.
For example, Gurdev's Vaak is "amrit naam parmaysar tayraa jo simrai so jeevai." SGGS Ang 616
This expression is the result of Simran.
Millions of people may repeat the above Vaak to get cured. It is not Simran nor it is medicine. In my view, such people are imitators following preachers. Gurus never suggested anybody to repeat a Hymn as Simran and get cured.
Balbir Singh
Re: Impact of Different Baanis?
Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 11 Oct 2006
Thank you for your clarification ji, but i think perhaps i wasnt clear enough in my original question...
My Question stems from the fact that we are perscribed 5 Baanis to read per day as our nitnem. So why 5? why not just one? why not just Simran?
If we are given 5 distinct Baanis as our Nitnem, i would assume each Baani has a specific purpose and the 5 together have a cumulative effect.
And if Baani is not a medicine and cannot "cure" us of the problems we face (Kaam Krodh Lobh Moh Hankaar), then what is its purpose?
In my humble and quite possibly totally wrong opinion, I would have to say that All Baani is beneficial. Whether you are doing Paath, Kirtan, or even just listening, there must be good that comes of it.
I was just asking a question that yes, can be considered as superfolous, but was asking if anyone could share further knowledge as i have hopefully now made clear.
With Gurus kirpa Gupt Ji has very kindly provided me with the answers i sought. Thank you all once again.
Re: Impact of Different Baanis?
Balbir Singh · 11 Oct 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all!
Quote "My Question stems from the fact that we are perscribed 5 Baanis to read per day as our nitnem. So why 5? why not just one? why not just Simran?"
Gurdev has prescribed Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji not only five Baanees. I could not find up to now where Gurdev prescribed only five Baanees to read as Nitnaym and why.
In my view, Gurdev suggested us above all one, Simran.
Quote "And if Baani is not a medicine and cannot "cure" us of the problems we face (Kaam Krodh Lobh Moh Hankaar), then what is its purpose?"
Gurus do not sing Baanee for a purpose as many think. Baanee is a natural and spontaneous flow of experiences from Simran.
This is Naam that cures.
What is the purpose of a suggestion to visit a doctor when we feel sick? Do we complain why the suggestion is not healing us?
Whole Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is singing about getting Naam Simran.
Quote "In my humble and quite possibly totally wrong opinion, I would have to say that All Baani is beneficial. Whether you are doing Paath, Kirtan, or even just listening, there must be good that comes of it."
Surely it is beneficial when one realizes that all Baanee is suggesting us to Japu Naam.
**************
Quote from Bazzer Ji "I would have to totally disagree with Balbirs sentiments that japing gurbani has no effect on the mind and body."
This is your understanding, not my explanation. The true impact of Gurbaanee on mind and body prepares one to seek true Simran.
We should not misinterpret the suggestion for a sick person to visit a doctor. Just by repeating this suggestion verbally one does not get cured.
Quote "This is simran and it is medicine."
Please do not let yourself hypnotized by the preachers. Gurus never said that reading and repeating a part of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is Simran and medicine.
Quote "Gurbani is so powerful repeating it will wash untold paap from the soul and these are the route causes of all our illnesses."
Many similar self suggestions from ego may help temporarily.
Thanks for the wonderful references from Gurdev.
[gurbani]dIiKAw dwrU Bojnu Kwie ][/gurbani]
"deekhi-aa daaroo bhojan khaa-i" SGGS Ang 877
Deekhi-aa is receiving the technique of true Simran. Daaroo is medicine. Bhojan means food. Khaa-i means is eating.
Gurdev is singing. Deekhi-aa is eating medicine as food.
Here again Gurdev is praising Simran not reading a sentence about Simran.
In my view the translation provided 'One who eats this food, this medicine of the Teachings' is not correct.
The fourth line of the next reference is from Ang 807
[gurbani]gun gwvhu inq rwm ky ieh AvKd jog ]1][/gurbani]
"gun gaavhu nit raam kay ih avkhad jog."
So chant continuously the Glorious Praises of the Lord; this is the only potent medicine.
Please ponder. How often, one should repeat the Guru's Vaak 'So chant continuously the Glorious Praises of the Lord; this is the only potent medicine' and it will start reacting as medicine?
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Impact of Different Baanis?
Balpreet Singh · 11 Oct 2006
Gurbani in of itself has a definite effect. Gurbani is updesh roop (a message/lesson) and it is mantar roop as well. I believe that reciting bani does have a spiritual effect.
Bani acts like a fuel for naam. Naam needs to be supplemented with a lot of bani as well. From the example of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh he says that before jot vigaas he was doing almost non-stop Sukhmani Sahibs. Gurbani has a vibration to it and it is by virtue of this vibration that amrit is created.
Even if someone has naam, Gursikhs have told me, that bani is still absolutely necessarily for spiritual progress and necessary to balance the jeevan. Without bani abhyaas it is hard to "jar" naam.
Re: Impact of Different Baanis?
Balpreet Singh · 11 Oct 2006
Doing Bani jaap to improve your health or other objectives doesn't seem wrong to me.
Jeevan Mukati is something you don't earn, it's bestowed through Gur Prsaad and Kirpa. If you aren't reading bani and therefore observing Guru Sahib's rehit of nitnem, etc. I don't think Guru Sahib will do kirpa.
Re: Impact of Different Baanis?
Balbir Singh · 12 Oct 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all!
Quote from Balpreet Singh Ji "Doing Bani jaap to improve your health or other objectives doesn't seem wrong to me."
Does it work really and with everybody? Could anyone ever cheat his soul?
True Simran works with everybody.
**************
Quote from Balpreet Singh Ji "I believe that reciting bani does have a spiritual effect."
May I ask when beliefs become true and our experience?
Please be sure. I am not asking to stop reading or listening Gurbani. Gurdev's singing about Naam Simran may incite anybody's hunger for Truth. Life changes its path after true Simran only. Reading or listening Gurdev singing remembers one his own experiences he had during and after Simran.
Balbir Singh