< Portraying Our Passions >
Jagroop Singh · 08 May 2004
Portraying our Passions There was an excellent debate at my workplace just the other day. The people making-up the mix could be described in the following manner: someone from a Sikh background (me), someone from a Hindu background (colleague) and lastly, someone from a Roman Catholic background (other colleague). Independently of one another, we’d all watched The Passion of The Christ. For those who haven’t heard, this is Mel Gibson’s controversial movie which charts the last hours of Jesus Christ’s life and primarily focuses around the torture he endured just before being crucified upon the cross. It’s worth adding that many critics vehemently believe the film to be an anti-semetic diatribe, historically inaccurate and overly sadistic regarding its depiction of violence and torture. This has only encouraged Christians (and millions of non-believers the world over) to flock to cinema screens in order to experience what is being treated as a very important sermon; that is of the celluloid kind. Central to our colourful discussion was the following concern: what’s the point behind the film if we are to understand it as a Christian message? For the Roman Catholic colleague, it was a film far too consumed with the last stage of Jesus’ life and not with what he represented and why he ended-up in the predicament he did; all-in-all, a missed opportunity. Fair point. For the Hindu colleague, it was emotional to the extent that she could not imagine how a group of human-beings could put a fellow human-being through so much pain. Another fair point; after watching the marathon mutilation scenes, I’d have to agree. Although I share to an extent the thoughts of my colleagues, for me there was a drastically different interpretation of the film. Although I was confronted very graphically by a great human-being who underwent great suffering because of what he believed, I found the film emotional not necessarily because it was Jesus Christ who was being depicted but because what he was going through is something that our Guru Sahibs, and many of their Sikhs, have had to endure – penalty of painful death. Take Fifth Nanak Guru Arjun Sahib for instance. He went through untold tortures because ultimately what he believed and put forward was not to the liking of the powers which held worldy authority at the time. However, let’s go on to consider Ninth Nanak Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib. His martyrdom epitomises the very pinnacle of this most emotive of traditions – to give one’s life to protect the freedom and liberties of others; even when we do not necessarily agree with their beliefs and practices. This kind of Avastha (spiritual state) is not to my knowledge exemplified anywhere else by any other faith group. Whilst not trying to turn this into a competition, our Guru Sahibs have never gone down on record as even momentarily asking Vahiguru why He had forsaken them during their ordeal…something Jesus Christ apparently did. For Sikhs, it doesn’t just stop here. The whole concept of martyrdom is not something merely symbolised by the very originators of our faith. Gursikhs such as Shaheed Bhai Anokh Singh who had his eyes gouged, nails pulled out and was eventually ripped from limb to limb, prove that this tradition is a living and breathing reality for Sikhs – this took place at the hands of ‘the usual suspects’ less than 20 years ago; usual suspects being the Indian authorities. The ‘Guru Ka Bhag’ incident in 1922 is also a case in point. Hearing of the tortures that innocent Sikhs had to suffer, Father C.F. Andrews, a Christian missionary cried out; "I see hundreds of Christs being crucified every day". Put simply, if martyrdom is a competition, Sikhs win hands down. That’s why when I watched the film, the lump in my throat just kept getting bigger and bigger and bigger – those who have and will continue to give martyrdom for the Panth were represented in my eyes by Jesus Christ going through unspeakable tortures. I couldn’t help imagining this handsome long-haired figure as being Fifth Nanak Sahib or Shaheed Bhai Taru Singh; almost after the point where their Dastaar had been removed or fallen off during torture…and their tresses were flowing. I hope I haven’t offended anybody; this experience was something visceral and of course excessively personal. But a part of me is annoyed at itself with having to rely upon the unrelated accounts of others in order to experience my own specific feelings regarding our history and historic personages. When I hear Obi Wan Kenobi say in Star Wars (to Darth Vader); “If you strike me down, I will become greater than you ever imagine”, I get tired of having to imagine him as representing Fifth Nanak Guru Arjun Sahib. When the main character in Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon talks of how attachment to a worldly love stopped him from reaching enlightenment, I get fed-up of having to sculpt this into a message to myself regarding how Guru Sahib is teaching me about the perils of worldy attachment all the time. I want Sikhi to be projected to me without having to appear indirectly through other means…in its own right entirely. There’s a burning issue here in case you haven’t noticed. Do we Sikhs want to make films which depict our distant/recent history and experiences? What other kind of stories can Sikhi help us to realise? Will our endeavours simply be for our own consumption or will they be our attempt to engage the wider public? How about the ethics and conventions – would it be ok to for us to depict Guru Sahib via an actor? How can we ensure these narratives have a wider appeal and truly encompass archetypes and universal themes? These are all important questions. I was speaking to Simarjit Kaur, author of the well-received novel Saffron Salvation, and one of the things we spoke about was Sikh history-related films and novels. It becomes obvious even after an informal chit-chat concerning the current state of affairs that as Sikhs we need to create more; we need to utilise the written word and moving image – being the diasporic Sikhs that we are, we would enjoy an immense advantage in doing so. Unlike our brothers and Sisters who live in a country which claims to be a democracy, we do not have to bear the direct brunt of ‘forces’ who may wish to gag our mouths and limit our expressions. We are not restricted regarding the socio-political issues we may wish to allude to or directly tackle. One thing that Simarjit Kaur firmly impressed upon me was the following: anyone who can write, paint etc. should be doing so – we need to express our experiences. I for one was moved by her words and thought what the heck, I’m going to begin to write a novel or at the very least, a short play. I hope you also decide to get those creative juices flowing…eventually we’ll get around to looking for those rich Sikhs that we all know exist out there somewhere; will they help to fund things of such importance…well, we can only hope so. Otherwise, in ten years time, all we’ll have to show for ourselves are shoddy short stories and second-class movies destined only for Gurdvara Sahib video projectors. Although these part-time projects may be full of pyaar, they will certainly not be full of potential. So take this as a call to arms. Arm yourself with pens, brushes, cameras and above all, creativity and before you know it, we’ll have the skill and resources to really start showing people why Sikhi-inspired artistic expressions are such amazing things. After all, which spectator wouldn’t want to discover a treasure of evocative words and images created by people who’ve been spiritually inspired, socially empowered, continuously tortured, self-governed, ethnically cleansed, state-oppressed…and are still here to tell the story. (article originally appeared in The Sikh Times, a UK-based English/Punjabi Newspaper)