Gurus in Human Body
Balbir Singh · 06 Nov 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all!
They often warn and preach Sikhs to reject dehdhaaree Gurus. Is this true only for the present time?
Our Gurus were dehdhaarees, lived in human body. Did Sikhs accept dehdhaaree Gurus in the past?
Is truth changing with the time? Please express your views.
Balbir Singh
Re: Gurus in Human Body
Manvir Singh Khalsa · 07 Nov 2006
Roop Kaur Bhenji has answered the question.
The "SHABAD" is the Guru. Always has been and is now. Guru Nanak Sahib jee and the Ten human personalities were "SHABAD-JYOT", they were embodiments of the Truth, the Divine Light and the Shabad - and hence they were called "GURU" and were the "AKAAL ROOP".
The HOUSE (body) changed, but the Guru ALWAYS remained the same.
The House or body of the SHABAD GURU is now the GRANTH (Scripture), which makes the Granth our Guru and hence we address Guru Sahib now as "Sri Guru Granth Sahib jee"
Re: Gurus in Human Body
Balbir Singh · 07 Nov 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all!
Quote >>>The "SHABAD" is the Guru. Always has been and is now. Guru Nanak Sahib jee and the Ten human personalities were "SHABAD-JYOT", they were embodiments of the Truth, the Divine Light and the Shabad - and hence they were called "GURU" and were the "AKAAL ROOP". <<<
Sikhs celebrate GurParb, the birthday of the Gurus. Is this the day when Shabad Guru's Jyot was born in Guru's body or is this the day when their body was born? Please elaborate.
Quote >>>The House or body of the SHABAD GURU is now the GRANTH (Scripture), which makes the Granth our Guru and hence we address Guru Sahib now as "Sri Guru Granth Sahib jee" <<<
May I ask why Sikhs celebrate Guru's birthday on different days when God and His Shabad Guru are the same?
I feel SHABAD is the live sound current when originates through a human body. Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji needs a human body to produce the sound of the Shabad these days though. Is the human body different from the body of the Gurus in the past?
Balbir Singh
Re: Gurus in Human Body
jagroop singh · 08 Nov 2006
VahiGurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahiGurooJeeKeeFateh!
Veer Balbir Singh Jee,
you wrote:
"I feel SHABAD is the live sound current when originates through a human body. Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji needs a human body to produce the sound of the Shabad these days though. Is the human body different from the body of the Gurus in the past?"
Pls explain, via Gurbani Shabads/Panktian, your opinion above...are you saying that by definition 'Guroo' must be human or is not Guroo because without human form, Shabad cannot be conveyed...?
Just slightly confused at your statement - please elaborate for the Sangat's benefit.
Thanvaad.
Re: Gurus in Human Body
Balbir Singh · 08 Nov 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all and Veer Jagroop Singh Ji!
Quote "Pls explain, via Gurbani Shabads/Panktian, your opinion above...are you saying that by definition 'Guroo' must be human or is not Guroo because without human form, Shabad cannot be conveyed...?"
Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is conveying this message from the Gurus often. For example:
[gurbani]sy vfBwgI ij quDu iDAwiedy ijn siqguru imlIAY ][/gurbani]
"say vadbhaagee je tuDh Dhi-aa-iday jin satgur milee-ai."
Those have big luck when meditate you who meet Satguru.
[gurbani]siqgur kI bwxI siq srUpu hY gurbwxI bxIAY ][/gurbani]
"satgur kee banee sat saroop hai gurbaanee banee-ai."
Speech of true Gur is the embodiment of truth. Speech of Gur is spoken.
[gurbani]siqgur kI rIsY hoir kcu ipcu boldy sy kUiVAwr kUVy JiV pVIAY ][/gurbani]
"satgur kee reesai hor kach pich bolday say koorhi-aar koorhay jharh parhee-ai." SGGS Ang 304-17
Who imitates the true Gur speaks differently false and wrong, those prevaricators lying fall apart.
**************
[gurbani]ibnu gur pUry iknY n BwKI ][/gurbani]
"bin gur pooray kinai na bhaakhee." SGGS Ang 1024-7
Without Gur completely no one has spoken.
[gurbani]mnmuiK kUVu vrqY vrqwrw ibnu siqgur Brmu n jweI hy ][/gurbani]
"manmukh koorh vartai vartaaraa bin satgur bharam na jaa-ee hay."
Mind's mouth engages in involvements, without Sat Guru the falsehood does not go.
I have never heard Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji speaking like a human being. Yes, I have heard many speaking and imitating like Gurdev.
**************
I will be grateful if someone provides a reference from Gurdev suggesting reading Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji to become enlightened.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Gurus in Human Body
jagroop singh · 09 Nov 2006
VahiGurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahiGurooJeeKeeFateh!
Veer Balbir Singh Jee,
I’ve taken the time to read through all of your posts re: this thread. It seems to be emerging that you do not believe in the Guroo-ship given to Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee. If this is the case please be clear about it…and also please tell us with whom the Guroo-Jyot currently resides. If you have certain beliefs please have the conviction to be clear about them. Notwithstanding this, here are my thoughts re: the ‘questions/half-questions’ you have put forth:
Siree Guroo Sahib, if He so wishes, can manifest Jyot within a human body; as was the case with Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee. If you think that Shabad can only be transmitted from a ‘Human Guroo’ then perhaps you think that Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee must have had a human Guroo, as Radhasoamis and other such similar groups believe. If this is the case why would Sacheh Patshah have told the Siddhs, when they asked Him who His Guroo was, that His Guroo is Shabad and His consciousness is the Cheyla/Sikh? Pls tell me if you think that Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee’s Guroo was not VahiGuroo. If you do think that His Guroo was VahiGuroo, then did VahiGuroo take the form of some other human in order to act as ‘Human Guroo through which Shabad must be transmitted’ to Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee, as per your concept?
You asked yourself a rhetorical question but please let me also answer it all the same - of course Truth does not change with time. However, to try and say ‘truth changed with time’ simply because Siree Guroo Sahib decided, in His 10th Mehl, to pass Guroo-Jyot to Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee would be an act of seriously limited or non-existent faith. If it was written in Gurbani that ‘Guroo must be human’ or that ‘without human body, Guroo cannot exist’ then you would have a point. However, as you know very well, this is written no-where within Gurbani. Do you think Siree Guroo Sahib would miss-out such an overarching concept? Those who have rejected Dehdharee ‘Guroos’ since 1708 are doing so because they are obeying the Hukam given by Siree Guroo Gobind Singh Jee. If you disagree that Sache Patshah gave this Hukam then be clear about this and then perhaps you and others can debate regarding this issue, upon a historical and theological basis.
You seem to be inferring that by celebrating Gurpurabs, Sikhs are somehow contradicting their belief regards Shabad-Guroo Concept. How have you reached this conclusion? As Gurbani teaches, the Guroo-Jyot has been in existence since before the ages, since the ages and will be forevermore because the Guroo-Jyot and Vahiguroo are indistinguishable. Gurbani states this in many places – the beginning of Sukhmani Sahib is proof enough. If you wish me to quote please let me know but again, I am sure you have come across such Shabads/Panktian yourself. Bhai Gurdaas Jee, in his Vaaran, states that the Sikhs celebrate the Gurpurabs, so it was obviously permitted by Siree Guroo Sahib when he was in Human Mehl otherwise this reference would not exist…or do you think that Siree Guroo Sahib told Sikhs not to celebrate Gurpurabs, in line with your argument? It is through love that Gursiksh remember those dates when Guroo Sahib took birth within a Human Mehl, passed the Guroo-Jyot onwards etc. Your theory that by celebrating Gurpurabs Sikhs are somehow showing that they do not believe in Eternal Shabad Guroo is a straw-man argument.
Furthermore, the Panktian you have quoted in no way prove your point – it seems you are focussing and trying to overly emphasise the words ‘bhakhee’ and ‘banee-ai’. So are we to take it that any words which mean: speak, speech, spoken, voice that are to be found within Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee are proof that the SatGuroo must ALWAYS have the means to create ‘human noises’ (i.e. throat, vocal chords, tongue, lips etc.) in order to qualify as the Satguroo? Again please refer to the 2nd paragraph above…VahiGuroo is referred to as SatGuroo many times with GurBani – did VahiGuroo speak to Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee via the vehicle of human flesh?
Please do not limit the concept of Guroo. The Radhasoamis etc. may believe that a finite human body is ALWAYS needed in order for SatGuroo to be Partakh/manifest but for Sikhs this just shows they have no real Sharda in the concept they try to write so extensively about…Shabad-Guroo.
Re: Gurus in Human Body
Balbir Singh · 09 Nov 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all and veer Jagroop Singh Ji!
Thanks for your post. Welcome. I request, please stay with Satsang.
Quote "It seems to be emerging that you do not believe in the Guroo-ship given to Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee."
I did not expect prejudicing.
Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is my Guru suggesting the same Truth my Guru transferred. I wish people do not mind if I ignore things my Guru is not suggesting.
While I hope and pray seekers do not practice things Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji never suggested.
**************
Quote " . . .perhaps you think that Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee must have had a human Guroo, as Radhasoamis and other such similar groups believe."
I do not feel the need to study extensively Radhasoamis and discuss their views. Please do not waste valuable time to find a box where I fit.
Quote "Pls tell me if you think that Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee’s Guroo was not VahiGuroo."
God is the Guroo of all. God was not once exclusively Guroo of Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee.
Quote "If you do think that His Guroo was VahiGuroo, then did VahiGuroo take the form of some other human in order to act as ‘Human Guroo through which Shabad must be transmitted’ to Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee, as per your concept?"
Sound or Naad is an attribute of Sargun God. God also in form of Naad dwells in all. God transmitted Shabad through Guru Nanak Dev Ji as well. Guru Nanak Dev Ji realized it too.
God is transmitting Shabad through all right now also. Blessed are those who are realizing it.
**************
Quote " . . . of course Truth does not change with time."
God is Truth. God in His Nirgun Saroop does not change. God in His Sargun Saroop is constantly changing. Gurdev is singing
[gurbani]scu prmysru inq nvw ][/gurbani]
"sach parmaysar nit navaa." SGGS Ang 1183-11
Truth Parmaysar is ever new.
Here is one more reference.
[gurbani]swihbu myrw nIq nvw sdw sdw dwqwru ]1] rhwau ][/gurbani]
"saahib mayraa neet navaa sadaa sadaa daataar." SGGS Ang 660-4
Truth is ever new and sadaa sadaa simultaneously. Realizing both at the same instance is the bliss.
Quote " . . .If it was written in Gurbani that ‘Guroo must be human’ or that ‘without human body, Guroo cannot exist’ then you would have a point. However, as you know very well, this is written no-where within Gurbani."
Guru Arjan Dev Ji is singing.
[gurbani]Aidstu Agocru pwrbRhmu imil swDU AkQu kQwieAw Qw ][/gurbani]
"adisat agochar paarbarahm mil saaDhoo akath kathaa-i-aa thaa." SGGS 1002-5
Invisible, unmoving and beyond Brahm by meeting Sadhoo, untold was explained.
I hope we agree that the Sadhoo, Gurdev is singing about, is a human being. I found many references in Gurbaanee suggesting the same.
Would someone please provide an example where Gurdev has suggested to reject the Guru in human body?
Quote "Those who have rejected Dehdharee ‘Guroos’ since 1708 are doing so because they are obeying the Hukam given by Siree Guroo Gobind Singh Jee."
Please provide a reference from Guru Gobind Singh Jee. I will be thankful.
**************
Quote "You seem to be inferring that by celebrating Gurpurabs, Sikhs are somehow contradicting their belief regards Shabad-Guroo Concept."
This should be clear also for missionaries. Shabad Guru and Gurus birthday in human body are two different celebrations.
Quote "As Gurbani teaches, the Guroo-Jyot has been in existence since before the ages, since the ages and will be forevermore because the Guroo-Jyot and Vahiguroo are indistinguishable."
Guru Jyot and God are not indistinguishable. Those are ONE and the same.
**************
Quote "So are we to take it that any words which mean: speak, speech, spoken, voice that are to be found within Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee are proof that the SatGuroo must ALWAYS have the means to create ‘human noises’ (i.e. throat, vocal chords, tongue, lips etc.) in order to qualify as the Satguroo?"
In your understanding those may be human noises. In my experience those are God's melodies.
Quote "Again please refer to the 2nd paragraph above…VahiGuroo is referred to as SatGuroo many times with GurBani – did VahiGuroo speak to Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee via the vehicle of human flesh?"
Yes. God speaks to all human beings in their language dwelling in their human flesh.
**************
Quote "Please do not limit the concept of Guroo. The Radhasoamis etc. may believe that a finite human body is ALWAYS needed in order for SatGuroo to be Partakh/manifest but for Sikhs this just shows they have no real Sharda in the concept they try to write so extensively about…Shabad-Guroo."
A blind never reaches light by competing another blind.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Gurus in Human Body
jagroop singh · 11 Nov 2006
VahiGurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahiGurooJeeJeeFateh!
Dear Veer Balbir Singh Jee,
i have 2 simple question, before we proceed any further:
1. In your opinion, where or with whom (i.e. a human-being) does the Guru-Jyot which was manifest within Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee reside?
(pls do not answer by saying we all have the Guroo Jyot within us...i want you to answer 'who' or 'what' is currently the Guroo of the Sikhs)
2. Are you trying to say that we need a human (i.e. a Sant, 'Human Guroo') in order to comprehend/understand/make manifest the teachings within Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee?
perhaps once you make your views clear regarding these simple questions we can at least discuss all the other issues you have raised since you began this thread. pls do your best to be direct and clear when you answer these questions.
Thanvaad.
Re: Gurus in Human Body
Balbir Singh · 11 Nov 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all and Veer Jagroop Singh Ji!
Quote "1. In your opinion, where or with whom (i.e. a human-being) does the Guru-Jyot which was manifest within Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee reside?"
I have not come across one up to now. In my observation they are lamps ready for Guru_Jyot to get lit.
Quote "pls do not answer by saying we all have the Guroo Jyot within us...i want you to answer 'who' or 'what' is currently the Guroo of the Sikhs"
They teach Sikhs to assert that they have a Guru, Sree Guru Granth Sahib Ji. I feel sorry for them because they are following everything else than what Sree Guru Granth Sahib Ji is suggesting.
Please name some daily activities from Sikhs and their preachers with a reference from Sree Guru Granth Sahib Ji. I will be thankful.
Quote "2. Are you trying to say that we need a human (i.e. a Sant, 'Human Guroo') in order to comprehend/understand/make manifest the teachings within Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee?"
It does not matter how one calls the help then all helps are Godly. This he can decide after he tastes the Truth explained in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. May I ask what kind of help Sikhs are trying to get through Keertaniaas,
Katha Vaachaks , translators, preachers etc.
Each Vaak in Sree Guru Granth Sahib Ji is an individual's experience who has come to know true Simran. No one can comprehend, understand or manifest the teachings within Sree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee. As smart, mind and ego never give a person one chance. Nevertheless, one can enliven Sree Guru Granth Sahib Ji within, with true Naam by God's Grace.
Gurdev's words are truth and simple. How can one understand Him till it has become one's own experience.
**************
No one has ever lost anything on a true path other than pseudo ego. The fear that one may loose what he is holding fast proves what he has earned up to now.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Gurus in Human Body
Khalsa Kaur · 14 Nov 2006
Respected Balbir Singh ji,
Satsriakal,
I have been going through your topic on various forums and it has mixed reaction as per their thoughts either in India and abroad and a lot of people also tried to raise a lot of queries. But you have replied in a very appropriate manner and I really appreciate your click of mind and most of it your knowledge or I can say intellect. Every time, no one else is able to give you response as per their own query and they retreated back. Though every sikh must be thinking to have a human guru (guru means teacher only) to teach them gurbani as our gurus also used to teach us, preach us or do vichar. How one can learn from SGGS himself. In school, we need a teacher to study and in life we do need a teacher (spiritual) who could help us to lead a good life. Though the guru should not be fake or money-making baba like.
Thanks to you and regards.
[%sig%]
Re: Gurus in Human Body
Balbir Singh · 15 Nov 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all and Khalsa Kaur Ji!
Thanks for your post. I have passed it on to forces that have worked behind it. I feel blessed being His tool in His hands. Please feel His Grace and advance your words directly to Him. That is a short cut.
Quote "Though the guru should not be fake or money-making baba like."
God is providing means to exist for all. Whom should we call, fake? Only ego is fake that makes one feel the giver or earner.
Quote "Sikhism teaches humanity only."
Sikhism is learning by receiving Naam and surrendering to its nursing. Humanity is never separated from a human, the true Sikh.
Balbir Singh
Re: Gurus in Human Body
jagroop singh · 20 Nov 2006
VahiGurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahiGurooJeeKeeFateh!
Veer Balbir Singh Jee,
You haven't answered the questions; in fact your 'clever answers' come across as attempts to evade very simple questions.
For instance when i asked you with whom/what do you believe the Guroo-Jyot currently resides, you wrote:
"I have not come across one up to now. In my observation they are lamps ready for Guru-Jyot to get lit"
So you have not come across any Satguroo...? And who are you referring to when you say 'they are lamps ready for Guroo-Jyot to get lit'? What's more you go on to talk about preachers who seem to be mis-preaching...your responses are irrelevant and abstract. Pls have some self-belief in your own beliefs!
Are you trying to say, as many Radhasoamis like to say, that the Guroo of the Sikhs is simply 'a book' and a 'human master' is needed to reach enlightenment? i asked you this before and you, which incidentally many Radh Soamis also do, decided (or at least seeemd) to insist that certain Panktian point towards the need for a human-body through which Shabad MUST act.
Furthermore, you still haven't told me about the 'human body' which must have acted as Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee's Guroo...perhaps because you have no answer. Perhaps you would like to explain why Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee has not declared his 'Human Guroo' throughout Gurbani. Sadly, i have a feeling you won't adress this and will again move onto other issues by making more abstract and irrelevant statements.
You finish by saying:
"No one has ever lost anything on a true path other than pseudo ego. The fear that one may loose what he is holding fast proves what he has earned up to now."
This statement sums up your contribution during this thread: statements which might sound nice but are actually irrelevant. i still have yet to read one statement of yours which actually makes clear what you are 'truly' trying to say.
To be absolutely blunt unless you respond by actually addressing the very simple and straight-forward honestly-put questions i have posed, i see no reason to carry on this thread.
Incidentally, 'Khalsa Kaur' wrote:
'How one can learn from SGGS himself'.
It is a shame that you call yourself Khalsa yet you do not have faith in Gurbani.
Re: Gurus in Human Body
Balbir Singh · 20 Nov 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all and veer Jagroop Singh Jee!
You wrote in the beginning of your post "in fact your 'clever answers' come across as attempts to evade very simple questions."
Then you wrote toward the end "To be absolutely blunt unless you respond by actually addressing the very simple and straight-forward honestly-put questions i have posed, i see no reason to carry on this thread."
May I ask who is evading the answers?
Anyway my posts are for those who feel they already know, consciously or unconsciously. Blessed are those who have earned the experience of Truth, not the borrowed answers.
Quote "So you have not come across any Satguroo...?"
Is this a wish or a problem?
Quote "And who are you referring to when you say 'they are lamps ready for Guroo-Jyot to get lit'?"
They are all true seekers.
Quote "What's more you go on to talk about preachers who seem to be mis-preaching..."
They, who have tasted mangoes, say all true about the mango. It does not matter, what they say and in which language.
They, who have not tasted mangoes, say all false about the mango. It does not matter, how expert they are of a anguage, and how many books they can recite, learnt by heart about mangoes.
Quote "Furthermore, you still haven't told me about the 'human body' which must have acted as Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee's Guroo...perhaps because you have no answer."
Please let it be the individual's answer and communication with Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee. I hope that you agree with me, accepting that nine of the ten Guroos at least had Guroo in human body. They do not allow that Sikhs had one in human body these days though. I could not find one instance when the Gurus have instructed so.
Quote "Perhaps you would like to explain why Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee has not declared his 'Human Guroo' throughout Gurbani."
Surprising you still want to know my experiences. Let us leave something for historians to search.
Quote "Sadly, i have a feeling you won't adress this and will again move onto other issues by making more abstract and irrelevant statements."
Please do not be sad. Taste it and come to know it.
Quote "i still have yet to read one statement of yours which actually makes clear what you are 'truly' trying to say."
I agree perhaps between us is a gap.
Quote referring the post from Khalsa Kaur Ji "It is a shame that you call yourself Khalsa yet you do not have faith in Gurbani."
Have the Gurus asked some to crown fellow Sikhs with such titles?
When sun is shining, no one asks a person to have faith in sun or believe that sun is shining. Truth is not faith nor belief. Truth is the experience.
**************
I am not waiting for your answers to give. Please find the answers and live with those in Aanand.
Balbir Singh