Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

fresno sikh · 12 Nov 2006

Most of the world religions are not written by their prophets. But the hold very dearly anything they find of their prophets like a scrap of paper with gospel written on it of 1 AD, cup of christ(nobody really know that its his) . Why its only the stuipd so called sikh experts argue about the wealth of original info of Dasam Granth. Wake up fools and respect the Dasam Granth as Guru Gobind Singh's gift to mankind than be petty manmukhs. Sikhism is the only religion with the original texts but is fighting among themselves to destroy it. Dasam granth compiled by Bahi mani Singh Saheed end of story read it as Guru Bani and be blessed.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Sikh Enkilaab · 13 Nov 2006

Wjkk Wjkk, I do not understand how anyone dares to question the Akhand Jaap of Ad Sri Dasam Granth. It is Bani of Dasmesh Pitta. Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji is undeniably and without question our Guru, the Guru of Righteousness. However just as Bhai Gurdaas Dian Varaan is Bani, so is every Ang and shabad of Ad Sri Dasam Granth. At Takht Sri Hazoor Sahib, they have been continous Akhand Jaap of Ad Sri Dasam Granth going on for the past few hundred years. This anti campaign against the bani of the Dasmesh Pitta Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj, who completed the foundations laid by Dhan Guru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj, and gave us brotherhood of the Pure and Righteousness, is one huge anti Sikh Campaign, that has been led by so called Sikh Leaders. Remember, the SGPC was a body setup by the Imperialest Rule, to undermine Sikhi and the Gurus' Maryada. They SGPC are nothing but 'Massa Rangars' in disguise of Sikhs. They have never done anything to help the Panth, apart from use their position to achieve party political (controlled by Badal and Indian Government) and individual gains. We respect all bani of the Guru's with upmost respect, we as Sikhs (learners) have no right to question the authority of the Guru's sacred bani. Wjkk Wjkf [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Man Singh · 13 Nov 2006

Criteria should be if `pooran jyoti jage Ghat me tab khalasa tahi nikhalas janai' and not if garnth sahib is supreme or dasam Granth is supreme. I feel both are almost equally great and contain same almost teachings. two possible ways to looking at the situation is : 1. Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj told us to treat Sri Granth Saheb as Guru and hence being a true Sikh we should follow advise of the Guru. 2. It was the greatness of dasam Guru Sahib that he scarificed his father, 4 sons, mother and everything. He was never after fame and as a true karam Yogi and Braham Gyani he even advised not to use his own writings so that respect to earlier Gurus may be kept intact. But as a true sikh should we be so ungrateful to greatest of the Gurus and stop giving adoring his writings. Both are true and both are right. Let's stop fighting on petty issues and focus on `pooran jyoti'. Problem strats when we strat focussing more on external symbols the very thing rev Gurus opposed always.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Prabhjoyt Singh · 14 Nov 2006

this was a big mistake of Harnaam Singh Dhumma he knew it would cause trouble so what was the point of doing it? are there not already enough divisions? do we need more? shame on Harnaam Singh Dhumma & co.!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

k Singh · 14 Nov 2006

the link does not work.... The Guru Guranth sahib is supreme. AKJ and other Panthic bodies need to speak out against this. Well done to Dal Khalsa for highlighting the issue.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Man Singh · 14 Nov 2006

Is there anything in Sri Dasam Granth which is not compatible to Sri Guru Granth ? Why there is so much fuss about it? Guru Gobing Singh told to consider Guru granth saheb as supreme. Guru Gobind Singh also wrote whole dasam Granth. A true Sikh should follow both as both give the same end result. Let's be scientific in our approach and not dogmatic.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

H Singh · 15 Nov 2006

No-one is saying Guroo Granth Sahib is not supreme. But Dasam Bani is still Bani, and there's no harm in doing Akhand Paath of it, just as there's no harm in doing Paath of Bhai Gurdas Jee's Vaars.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Bazzer · 15 Nov 2006

Guys, why are you creating controversy where there is none? Nobody, I repeat nobody has questioned the authority of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. All that has happened is that an akand paath of Dasam Granth has been undertaken. Very auspicious, and good luck to those who undertook this difficult task (as the bani is quite difficult to recite), and great laaha to all those who sat and listened to Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s pavitaar bani. To those bozoes who have nothing better to do but to complain, do you not recite Dasam Granth bani every single day? Where do you think Jaap Sahib comes from, or Amrit swayaia or Benti chaupai? What about Akaal Ustat or Bachittar Natak? Did you know in the olden days Dasam Granth Ji’s parkash used to be next to Guru Granth sahib Ji? They never felt insecure about it. Guru Granth Sahib Ji is our Guru and Dasam Granth Ji is the bani of our father Guru Gobind Singh Ji, where is the controversy? What harm (infact quite the opposite) can come from such an undertaking of akand paath of Dasam Granth Ji. Just because it is rare these days does not mean that it is illegal. Just because you have not heard of this before does not make it anti-panthic.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Sikh Enkilaab · 15 Nov 2006

What people who call themselves of the Panth don't realise is that, Akhand Jaap of the Ad Sri Dasam Granth continually happens at Takht Sri Hazoor Sahib for the past few hundred years. At the beginning of the home page of the Tapoban site, it says it observes the Tat Khalsa Maryada, and we all say we need to keep the Gurus' Maryada and the Puratan Maryada. The heads of the Tat Khalsa were the Great Mahapurukh Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh and Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji, they observed all the Maryada and kept in tact. Along with the bani of Bhai Nand Lal Ji, to whom Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj has given the status of bani, just Guru Arjun Dev Ji Maharaj gave t he status of Bani to Bhai Gurdaas Dian Vaaran. Our so called educated Sikh Scholars have got their knowledge of Gurbani from reading odinary text books such as Kahn Siongh and his Mahan Kosh, the type of people who question even the bani that is in the Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib. But we all know, you can only gain Gyan of Gurbani by meditating on Waheguru's name, and mediataing on Gurbani, with prem and sharda. People who do this will never question what true Dharam is. [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Bachitar Singh · 15 Nov 2006

Sant Prabhjoyt Singh I am a sinner you are a Sant. You are all knowing when you have probably never read the Dasam Baani like most who critise it. There are two types of people in the world my friend. One who does and the other who watches one that does. You my friend are only a watcher. Not good for anything. Harnam Singh is a very great guy. After Takhar Singh Lied to the panth; Harnam Singh has set things straight. I am going to ask you what you have done for the panth. You are so keen on Bad mouthing others what have you done. As for the Dasam Granth. Everyone who has been a sikh has always said Dasam Baani is Guru Gobind Singh's Bani. Baba Deep Singh to Bhai Vir Singh to Sant Jarnail Singh. Sant Vijaydeep Singh I didn't know you are a bigger gursikh then all of us. I am sorry for having to call out your names Masters. [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Prabhjoyt Singh · 16 Nov 2006

Nothing is equal to Guru Granth Sahib Jee!! everyday we say in the ardass "agia bhayee akaal ki tabee chalaeo panth sab Sikhan ko hukam hai Guru manyo GRANTH" NOT guru Manyo Granthaan Nu!! and if something doesnt go in line with Gurbani it can not be considerd bani!! (tria charitar) and Bazzer your claims are false Dasam Granth was parkash in 1850s. before that it was just Guru Granth Sahib jee. and Sikh Rehat maryada says "no book/granth or anything else is to be parkaash next to Guru Granth Sahib! its just sant samaj lot and Harnaam singh Dhumma causing trouble!! [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Prabhjoyt Singh · 16 Nov 2006

Bachitar Singh Yes Harnaam Singh set things straight after Baba Thakur SInghs lies, but wat was the need for this fateh divas? why cause more controversey? and also whats your take on Harnaam Singh taking a siropa fram Capt. Amrinder? [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Bazzer · 16 Nov 2006

As Bachittar Singh has said some are only watchers. Prabhjoyt Singh, I am sorry you are incorrect about parkash of Guru Granth sahib Ji and Dasam Granth Ji. From 1750's onwards parkash of both granths took place and akand paths of both were common. Sikhs had the utmost respect and adhav of Dasam Granth Ji. <<< Nothing is equal to Guru Granth Sahib Jee!! everyday we say in the ardass "agia bhayee akaal ki tabee chalaeo panth sab Sikhan ko hukam hai Guru manyo GRANTH" >>> You seem to repeat this over and over again yet fail to listen what is said. Nobody is questioning the supereme authority of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, nobody is advocating the parkash of Dasam Granth Ji, all that has happened is that an akahnd path has taken place and all of a sudden all manner of accusations start flying that have no basis at all.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

gupt · 16 Nov 2006

then y have nihangs b doin prakash of dasam and sarbloh granth nxt to siri guru granth sahib ji for all these years????? wot dal khalsa jus realised

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Prabhjoyt Singh · 17 Nov 2006

1750? guru Sahib did Jyoti jyot Samaan in 1708 so thats enough to say its not authentic. if you believe its by Guru Sahib do arth of TC. Its an insult to Guru sahib to associate TC with Guru Sahib! also Bani (Guru Granth Sahib Jee) is Signed off with the word Nanak so why is 24 avatars signed of by Kavi Shyaam? that wasnt Guru Sahibs name was it? so whos this Shyaam fella? [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Bazzer · 17 Nov 2006

Prabhjoyte Ji you should really do some research before mouthing off. <<< 1750? guru Sahib did Jyoti jyot Samaan in 1708 so thats enough to say its not authentic. >>> It is common knowledge that Mata Sundri Ji asked Bhai Mani singh Ji to collect the works of Guru Sahib Ji and compile the Granth. The bani is Guru Ji’s it dose not matter whether it was collected together after Guru Ji ascended the heavens. <<< if you believe its by Guru Sahib do arth of TC. Its an insult to Guru sahib to associate TC with Guru Sahib! >>> It is because our minds are so filthy that we cannot get past the first hurdle of this composition. <<< also Bani (Guru Granth Sahib Jee) is Signed off with the word Nanak so why is 24 avatars signed of by Kavi Shyaam? that wasnt Guru Sahibs name was it? so whos this Shyaam fella? >>> Tell me, is Jap Sahib signed off with the word Nanak? It Chaupai Sahib or Swayai signed off bby the work Nanak? Is akal Ustat signed off by the word Nanak? Are you going to cast doubt over these compositions also? Guru Ji has varyingly used the pen-names of ‘Shyam’, ‘Ram’ , ‘Shah Gobind’ and ‘Gobind Das’ in his compositions according to the meter in which they fitted. Other poets like Nand Lal have also adopted multiple pen-names, this should not therefore create any confusion . ‘Shyam’ and ‘Ram’ were the nick names with which Mata Gujri Ji used to call Guru Gobind Singh Ji as a child. If you want to call Guru Sahib Ji a "fella" that is up to you.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

gupt · 17 Nov 2006

we all read jaap sahib, tva prasaad swayie and chaupai sahib in our daily nitnem so, if we don't believe in dasam granth y do we recite these bania??? the whole of dasam granth is written by the tenth master Siri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Ji Sanbhat satrah sahas bhanijai|| Aradh sahas phun teen kahijai|| Bhaadrav sudi ashtami ravi vaaraa|| Teer satuddrav granth sudhaaraa||29|| It was Bikrami Samvat 1753; This book was competed on the banks of Sutlej on Sunday, the eighth Sudi of the month of Bhadon. (29) Dasam Granth is still part of Guru Roop, because it's gurbani it's our lack of knowledge about gurbani that we don't believe it's actually gurbani, listen u fools (ppl with no faith in gurbani) who question my beloved guru's bani go to hell, do ardas and take a hukamnama from Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Guru Sahib will give you the answer that's it Gurbani Plz visit this link to getter a better overview on dasam granth and woth each bani is saying http://searchgurbani.com/main.php?book=dasam_granth&action=chapterindex Sri Akal Takht and the five high priests have barred debate on the matter of Dasam Granth authenticity and content. Anyone who has proof otherwise and wishing to do so should take up the matter on a Panthic level with them instead. [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Prabhjoyt Singh · 18 Nov 2006

If any one thinks none of Dasam granth is bani then he is a fool!! and Vijaydeep Singh the DG debate has been going on long before narkdharis even entered this earth! and dont say im influenced by kala becasue i think hes a just as a big of an idiot as you do! Anyway as i stated before make Guru Granth Sahibs Bani your touchstone and if something doesnt go in accordance to that e.g. praise of hindu gods then that cant be considered gurmat. According to TC (Piara singh padhams translations) note: Padham is a very pro dasam granth scholar. The story of a prositute named anoop kuar and a yogi is about Guru Sahib so according to TC Guru Sahib sttabed his own principles in the back and commited adultry! wha! what great bani is this! also according to dasam granth in krishanavatar meditating on krishnas name you will never be born again. this is the samme kaami krishna who had all those gopis and the same guy who killed low caste man who was doing bhagti! wheres the gurmat in that. reading durga paath and you wont be born agin either! whats all that about? and im guessing you all believe 9th Guru went on tiraths to the east to pray for a son? Guru Nanak Sahib was from Luv n kish linaege? (this what shiv sen and rss say) apologies if i have offended anyone. [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Bachitar Singh · 19 Nov 2006

I am sick and tired of people who know nothing of the bani and have just read an article about it, therefore making them all knowing. 1. Guru Sahib Is not a fool Why do people play the Guru's out to be a fools. Do you guys know the story of Massa Rangar. The Singh's had decided to hold a meeting to discuss Sri Dasam Granth. They were thinking about changing it, but Sukha Singh and Mehtab Singh said that if they brought Massa Rangars head the baani should remain as it is. That would indeed be a hard task. If the baani wasn't Guru Gobind Singh's it all would of ended there. With Sukha Singh and Mehtab Singhs Shaheedi's. With Guru sahib's kirpa they succeeded in there task. Second the Guru is not an idiot. If that wasn't his baani he wouldn't allow it to be refered that. 2. What do people care if we read it or not? If i am going to hell so be it. What's it to you. It is us who read it that will go to hell so what do you care. Again Guru Sahib is not an idiot. It all depends on the intentions you have. If you read that baani and want to be one with god, then Guru Sahib will make sure that your on the right path. If you actually read the Dasam Baani Guru Sahib shows the arrogance of the Hindu Faith not glorify it. 3. Sant Prabjoyt Singh Chandhi Di Vaar is a Vaar. Maybe you should do some research before you open that mouth of yours. Before I go any further I am not here to insult you or put you down in anyway, I just want you to stop mouthing off about Guru Sahibs baani. This Vaar was sung by the Singhs when they would go to battle. This Vaar gives you an extreme addreniline rush. With this Vaar you get courage to go in the battle field and get shaheed. That is how you never get born again. Shaheedhi is the highest honor any singh can attain. Please people stop arguing. Let us have our peace. Or stop mouthing and actually do something. Time after time people have the courage to talk a lot behind a computer screen, but when the time to do comes they remain speechless. If I have offended anyone I am deeply regretfull.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Bazzer · 20 Nov 2006

<<< According to TC (Piara singh padhams translations) note: Padham is a very pro dasam granth scholar. The story of a prositute named anoop kuar and a yogi is about Guru Sahib so according to TC Guru Sahib sttabed his own principles in the back and commited adultry! wha! what great bani is this! >>> Baiya you have obviously not read this story. Anoop Kuar came to Guru Sahib Ji’s tent with evil in her mind, Guru Ji could have panicked finding a women in his tent BUT Guru Ji was resolute in his stance and steadfast in his principles, Guru Ji made her look within herself and she realised her mistakes and she left a sevak of Guru Sahib Ji. <<< also according to dasam granth in krishanavatar meditating on krishnas name you will never be born again.>>> Again, you need to read the bani first. The ending goes like this : “Joe ihe kuthaa sunnai aur gavai, dhook paap nikat naa avay.” Whoever listens or sings this katha (bani) will be saved from pain and sin. And why is this such a surprise??? This is Guru Sahib Ji’s bani and reading and listening to it will remove pain and sin. Even if Guru Ji wrote about a flower or a bird or an elephant, it would still be Guru Ji’s bani and such will have power to help those who read/listen to it. <<< this is the samme kaami krishna who had all those gopis and the same guy who killed low caste man who was doing bhagti! wheres the gurmat in that. >>> I say this for your own good, be careful what you say, Bhagwan Krishan Ji was not just anyone, Guru Gobind Singh Ji writes in ShastarNaam Mala “Tuuhi Raam, Sri Krishan tuu, Tuuhi Bishn koe roop…..” “You were Ram, Siri Krishan was You also………” Here is just one question , please answer it : Do you believe in Benti Chaupai? One of the five proscribed banies, do you believe in it? Do you know where it is from? Is comes at the very end of TC !!!!!!! How do you explain that? Either you do not believe in the command of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, hence you are not a sikh or you are going to go down the “I believe in this part of it and not that part if it” route which just does not wash. [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

gupt · 20 Nov 2006

without dasam granth bani there is no amrit

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Prabhjoyt Singh · 20 Nov 2006

Benti Chaupi isnt part of TC!! Panth belives in Chaupi as a mani bani but in 73 Akaal Takhat declared TC inidan folk stories which have nothing to do with the Guru or Sikhi!!! Do you know more than Akaal Takhat? Wats all this "bhagwan sri Krishan ji" nonsense just accept we are part of hindus why not whilst your at it! i asked some questions and i didnt mean to insult anyone ore anything but you guys come out with statements like "if you dont belive in Dasam Granth go to hell" (mr. gupt) why is it that anti DG guys just debate but pro DG guys always, swear curse, say "your not sikh, your a dhokhee etc" why? and "jo eh katha suay" comes after "raam katha jug jug atal" (reference to ramyan in Ram avtar) and cany you provide sources for shyaam being guru Sahibs Child hood name please? anyway if disscusion is barred so be it i wont say no more. and Bachiter singh dont disrgace the title of sant by giving it to me. Thanx. and no-one has yer answered any of the asked questions but just insults. why? apologies for offence. [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Harinder Singh · 20 Nov 2006

I have serious doubt over whole of Dasam Granth being Guru Gobind Singh Ji's rachna. Though banis like Sri Jaap Sahib, Sri Akaal Ustat, Sri Chaupai Sahib and Sri Chandi ki vaar are gurbani. Taksal tries to explain banis like charitropakhayan in accordance with gurmat, but then the same taksal also explains 35 meanings of a single pankiti and denies Gurbani Viakaran. If one can use phurrans of mind to do 35 arths of a single tukk, I guess one can also explain charitropakhayan as gurbani. In short, its really wrong to do Sri Akand Path of Dasam Granth.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Bazzer · 20 Nov 2006

<< Benti Chaupi isnt part of TC!! >> actually it is. There is a chapai right at the end of Benti Chaupai that goes "Subadh suttra sehas pharrigai......" and it says that here the Trayah Charutta is becoming "samapatt, mast sabh mast, affzoo." So it is absolutely part of it. You are not being cursed as such, it is just that if anyone does beadbi of Guru - ki - bani then they will be cursed automatically, you are just being warned by your Sikh bhai's that you should not do this, that is all. <<< Wats all this "bhagwan sri Krishan ji" nonsense just accept we are part of hindus why not whilst your at it >>> We can see what level of Sikhi you are on. I regard myself humbly as a Sikh of Guru gobind Singh Ji, although I am not worthy even of the dust of His charan, but I have the Utmost respect and adhave for Bhagwan Krishan Ji and Sri Ram Chandar Ji and Bhavan Ji, who were avatars in the Satjug, traitra Yug and dwapra yug, disrespect them at your own peril yaar!!!!!!! All your q's have been answered, see all the <<< >>> that I have used. It seems to be that you do not answer properly. Tell me where does it say the word 'Nanak' in Jaap Sahib, Swayai, Chaupai Sahib????? Anyway, lets chill, we can argue all day, there is far more that unites us then divides us.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Prabhjoyt Singh · 21 Nov 2006

http://searchgurbani.com/main.php?book=dasam_granth&action=pagebypage&page=1469 where does it say "it sri charitropakhyano"?? that is from a different place and added into the DDT and Bhuddha dal rehraas. and yes Akaal ustat, Chaupai, jaap sahib, shabad hazare, zafarnamma gian parbodh are not signed off by Nanak but they ere not signed of AT ALL. But 24 Avatars ARE signed of as SHYAAM. could you please provide a source which says Shyaam was guru sahibs childhood name? do you beleive Guru Tehgh Bahadur ji went to triveni to pray for a son? do you belevie Guru Nanak Sahib is from Luv n Kush's lineage? [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Prabhjoyt Singh · 21 Nov 2006

yeh true lets just end this debate [%sig%]

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Bazzer · 21 Nov 2006

If Jaap Sahib /Swayai / Chaupai are not signed off at all then are you casting doubt on them ??? You cannot accept one part of it and not another, its either all or nothing. It seems to me like being a part-time Sikh. One is with your Guru as long as it fits in with one’s narrow limited intelligence, as soon as it goes against ones thinking then you are against the bani. This is wrong, submit to your Guru completely, if you do not understand something then submit to the greater intelligence of your Guru and accept that you cannot understand the wonders of your Guru. I have no problem with Guru Nanak Dev Ji descending from Luv and Kush. If this is what it states in Bachittar Natak, and it does, then I have no problem with it, I am with my Guru all the way. I do not care what RSS say or BJP say or anybody, if Guru Ji has spoken then I follow. Surely Guru Nanak Dev Ji will have descended from some lineage? For arguments sake that someone could have been a muslim lineage, then the musllay would say Guru Ji is theirs. If Guru Ji was descended from Russian Aryans then the Russians could claim him as theirs, what does that matter? If Guru Ji is descended from a Hindu lineage then so what? Guru Ji rejected the Hindu janiu and tilak from the outset, where is your problem? Jesus was born a Jew. Just because some RSS say that it is the lineage of Luv and Kush you run scared with your arms waving in the air. The Akhand Paath of Dasam Granth is just that, an Akand Paath, a continuous reading of Guru ji’s bani and as such is a very pavittar undertaking. The pen names of Guru Ji are explained in either The History of the Sikhs appendix or its from Safarnama by Giani Ishar Singh I forget which.

Re: Dasham Granth 300 years

Admin · 21 Nov 2006

This is a Panthic issue that won't be resolved on this messageboard. Topic is closed.