Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

2 Questions:

2 Questions:

Seeker of the Truth · 27 Nov 2006

1) How come Guru Gobind Singh Ji wanted Sikh males to change their last name (so these people wouldn’t be recognized based on caste) to Singh even though Singh is originally a Hindu rajput (caste) last name? 2) How come all the Sikh gurus married women that belonged to the same caste as them even though all the Sikh gurus preach about how people shouldn’t marry someone based on caste? Doesn’t that make them a bunch of hypocrites?

Re: 2 Questions:

singh5 · 27 Nov 2006

1) Singh wasn't THE last name for Rajputs, it was *A* last name. What were Guru Sahib's options? It wouldn't make sense to come up with a new word to serve as a last name. Singh is a powerful sign of what Guru Sahib wanted his Sikhs to be and so he chose it. Singh wasn't used by just Rajputs but warriors of the Gurkhas, Marathas, etc. It was a warrior's last name and Guru Sahib chose it for all Sikhs. 2) There is no doubt that Guru Sahib didn't believe in caste. Bani is clear on it and practices like langar and common initiation ceremony for all castes (which includes drinking from the same bata which shatters caste distinction) make it obvious that caste was rejected in Sikhi. Looking at Guru Sahibs: Guru Nanak, Guru Angad, Guru Amar Das all did not chose their wives and it was done according to family custom. The rest of the Guru Sahibs were approached by the families of girls to marry. They did not pick who approached them. At any rate it's clear in my mind that Guru Sahib didn't harbour any caste prejudice. Afterall, Guru Gobind Singh received amrit from the hands of so-called "low-castes" as well and any semblance of caste was destroyed for him at that point.

Re: 2 Questions:

Seeker of the Truth · 27 Nov 2006

History of Singh: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singh The bottom line is that Singh is a caste name. Guru Gobind Singh Ji should've chosen a different last name which wasn't associated with any caste. <<>> So in other words, they were too cowardly to stand up against their parents and family members? <<< The rest of the Guru Sahibs were approached by the families of girls to marry. They did not pick who approached them>>> Interesting.....

Re: 2 Questions:

singh5 · 27 Nov 2006

The link you said says the following (bold is mine): "Singh, is a [b]common surname in India[/b] used by Hindu [b]martial classes[/b] and Sikhs. For instance, the Rajputs, Dogras, Gurkhas, Gujjars, Jats and Marathas use Singh. Singh is also used by Bhumihars, Yadavs and Kurmis in Bihar and Uttar Pradesh. Singh was first used by Hindu Rajput and was later adopted by the Sikh religion. Amongst Hindus, it is now [b]borne by all four Varnas.[/b] Did you bother reading this article before posting? It says itself that Singh isn't associated with any caste (see the last bolded statement). Then you said, >>>>>>>>>> So in other words, they were too cowardly to stand up against their parents and family members? <<< The rest of the Guru Sahibs were approached by the families of girls to marry. They did not pick who approached them>>> Interesting..... >>>>>>>>>> Wrong. Guru Nanak's wife was chosen by his parents before Guru Nanak had spread the message of Sikhism. It was done according to the the usual process. At any rate Guru Nanak would have had no reason to reject the "rishta" with Mata Sulakhani except if he said, (as you seem to want) that she was the same caste and he would not marry her. There was nothing else "wrong" with her. So by doing what you seem to be suggesting, he would have in fact showed he bought into the caste system as opposed to opposing it. Guru Angad and Guru Amardas were married before the became Sikhs. The following Gurus were all APPROACHED by families. They would have had no reason to reject those rishtas except to say that the families were of the "wrong caste" and they wanted to prove a point by marrying out of caste. Once again, that would be self-defeating because it would show that they accepted the concept of caste even after these families had become Sikhs and their daughters were not acceptable for no other reason but for the fact that they were of Khatri background. Totally against the principles of Sikhism. [%sig%]

Re: 2 Questions:

niyarakhalsa -a complete idiot · 27 Nov 2006

dear seaker of the truth singh" was" a "caste" both male and female rajputs used it . while the concept of singh & kaur is completely diffrent , here the stupid castes are thrown out of the window as even husband and wife will have diffrent last nemes i.e. singh & kaur. now comming down to marriage of guru sahibs : Gurus married the girls who were ready to walk the path of gurmat ( barring Guru Angad & Guru Amar Das who married befor comming to know about gurmat) . That they were of the same caste was irrelevent , why would guru sahib marry someone totally disinterested in gurmat just because they are from a diffrent caste . Moreover , if someone lives a life of gurmat caste etc becomes very irrelevant for him/her ... he/she onle sees the gunas... their respected wifes were full of those gunas hence they married them. It is the sloth ridden minds of present day people who want to pull abd categorioze gurus in castes . If we have a little shame and sense we would would not use such disgraceful allegations of caste selectiveness on those great gurus , who were the prime movers in creating a unified humainty from a caste divided hindustan. the cancer of cste in the minds of us hindustanis is such that even today ( despite guru sahibs untiring efforts ) people are there who rather than learning from the guru are trying to put him under brackets of caste and porove god knows what ? Dear seaker of truth I have only one more thing to say to you : oh thou that buttest the high mountain , seeking to dislodge it with thy horns, take pity , not on the mountain but on thy head . - Sheikh Ahmed Al-Aawi || Al-Balagh [%sig%]

Re: 2 Questions:

Seeker of the Truth · 27 Nov 2006

"Singh was first used by Hindu Rajput and was later adopted by the Sikh religion." I guess you didn’t read that part.... Anyway, so you are telling me that Sikh gurus accepted the first family whom approached them for marriage?

Re: 2 Questions:

Seeker of the Truth · 28 Nov 2006

niyarakhalsa -a complete idiot, I am asking those 2 questions because couple Hindus ask me about this and I didn't have an answer for those 2 questions.

Re: 2 Questions:

Singhstah · 28 Nov 2006

QUOTE:"Guru Gobind Singh Ji should've chosen a different last name which wasn't associated with any caste. " END OF QUOTE. WHATTT??? AND WHO EXACTLY ARE YOU TO SAY WHAT PITA JI SHOULD AND SHOULDNT DO, DONT YOU FEEL ANY SHAME? HAVE YOU LOST ALL RESPECT? [%sig%]

Re: 2 Questions:

Seeker of the Truth · 28 Nov 2006

<<< WHATTT??? AND WHO EXACTLY ARE YOU TO SAY WHAT PITA JI SHOULD AND SHOULDNT DO, DONT YOU FEEL ANY SHAME? HAVE YOU LOST ALL RESPECT?>>> LOL Clam down! I am sorry if you found my post to be offensive. I never knew Sikhs could be so sensitive. [%sig%]

Re: 2 Questions:

niyarakhalsa -a complete idiot · 28 Nov 2006

seaker of truth ji tell ur hindu friends the same carbon is there in coal and diamonds ...but when when u treat coal via the right process it converts into a diamond . Guru sahib made changes to this decayed society and made singh surmey out of those bogas namesake singhs(&others) whose sisters and daughters were picked away by enemies. but yes the names existed before also , is of no problem to sikhi , even name of ram , allah , hari existed before but we still use them but in a diffrent context. THeir ram is the son of dashrat while ours is the ghat ghat vasi ram. about marriage well ithingh singh 5 has answered properly : caste was not in the minds of the guru gurmat and gunas were . so selection or desection ion the basis of caste would not arrise. [%sig%]

Re: 2 Questions:

guru_guru_jap · 29 Nov 2006

ofcourse your posts are offensive. to learn about sikhi first you must have shardha and some respect. your posts show no respect towards guru sahibs. sikhs are not sensitive but we cannot tolerate someone calling our guru pita a hypocrite and coward.

Re: 2 Questions:

Esher Singh · 29 Nov 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa,Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh, Veerji "Seeker of the Truth" i do agree with singh5 views on the usage of "singh" title. When taken the literal meaning of "Singh" is lion. As we all know that lion has always been honored by man, crediting the regal beast with attributes he prizes most; nobility, courage, loyalty and combative skills. These qualities, our Guruji wanted to embed in the psyche of people at the time of creation of Khalsa(I think i don't need to explain what were the state of Indian people at the time of Khalsa creation) because of this we got the title"Singh". And we also know what was the outcome of this(The sikhs created their own Kingdom by annexing lands from muslim rulers and they ruled till Afghanisthan) When "Singh" title was conferred on us we all became equal , whether the Sikh was from warrior class or from business class he became singh after partaking "Amrit" ,there was no monopoly of warrior class to use "singh" as a title. Thus erasing caste system among sikhs(though it is our own folly that we have started praticing caste system ) I hope I am able to answer your question.

Re: 2 Questions:

confused · 29 Nov 2006

you were way too offensive putting hypocrites, cowards and all in the same sentence as my Guru Jee insulting them as anyone should know the khalsa does not has ZERO toleration of insulting their Guru Sahib

Re: 2 Questions:

Seeker of the Truth · 29 Nov 2006

<<>> <<>> And what exactly are you two going to do about, eh? Besides, didn't Guru Nanak Ji use terms like fool? Anyway, thanks for the answers for guys. (singh5, niyarakhalsa -a complete idiot and Esher Singh)

Re: 2 Questions:

Man Singh · 30 Nov 2006

Mr Seeker of truth, I feel cast is deep seated in your brain therefore you seen cast even in the marraige of great Gurus. If you expect Gurus to marry a low cast women only to proove their castlessness, you are asking them to od a castist act. Todays fools in India are following your policy. Thye feel marriage as the only proof of somebody's castlessness. Reservation on cast base is the proof of castlessness today. A man who has married a dalit womne is real castless fellow? Don'nt you feel all such cast based acts are real castsist acts and you are expecting great gurus also to commit castist acts. Ig Gurus identify the cast first and then marry as per your advise that might have sown the permananet seed of castism. Todays Indian polticians are real fools of fool who are trying to build a castless society by providing cast based reservation on jobs. It is elf contradictory alotogather. And people with a conditioned mind in that system can never see beyong marriage and reservation. Gurus did it without all such nonsense and built up a castless religion. Of course certain difefernces remain in a society infected by castism for last 5000 years. It will time. But I am assuring you that hypocritic way of Indian system of building `castless society' using `cast' based reservation will never eliminate castism. Even Muslims and Christians who claim to be totally castless are also practising castism due to mistake of Dr Ambedkar for allowing cast based reservation. I am sorry to say that Ambedkar will be prooved the worst enemies of dalits oneday who have made castism a permananet agenda of Indian politics and nobody can eliminate it. Ambedkar wa having many other good qualities and he served the motherland with his very mature and deep experinece. But the mistake of reservation will kill his all talents. Example of Gurus is shining even today so far as elimination of castims is concerned. Today Singh has become synonym with Sikh all around the world and people have forgot its origin of rajpoots or any body else. Even in South India balsingham, veerasinghe etc are quite common name. Therefore it is not true that only Rajpoot uppercast used it. Bottom line is that if Guru Gobind Singh promoted ever human being to upper cast Khsatriya then castims is naturally eliminated. can you small mind understand this plain truth. If Guru Gobind Singh made everybody a Upper cast rajpoot, then what's wrong in it? Naturally it was a revolutionery step and only a person with divine powers can have such a great courage. Guru Gobind Singh Ji maharaj acted like a paras stome that was capable to change iron in to Gol;d just by a touch. His touch gave a respectable clan name, respectable status to all his followers. What's wrong in it? Let's not act like `gutter inspoectors' seeing filth everywhere in the name of seeking truth.