Bhangra at Gurdwara
Harcharan Singh · 01 Jan 2007
http://www.sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?p=77939&sid=89edfb8c7c2dfb60772dfb66b4be1236#77939
Wednesday 20th of december a meeting happened at the Gurdwara Nanaksar in southampton. The main committee suggested a bhangra bash this weekend in order to celebrate the shaheedi of the Sahibjadai. The youth committee was consulted and out of them only one bhenji opposed the idea. The committee main reason for this bhangra bash is to attract the kids. One of the Committee members Harjinder Singh Virdee (general sec) said lets move with the modern times.
Harjaap singh Lakhpuri ( stage sec) said bhangra has said our punjabi language and kids learn punjabi so they can understand the lyrics.
Gurdwara Nanaksar
3 Peterborough Road
Southampton
hampshire
02380 226464
[%sig%]
Re: Bhangra at Gurdwara
Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 01 Jan 2007
That is without a doubt the most ridiculous thing i have ever heard. I hope they arent planning to hold this at the Gurdwara itself!
Although i must say i have seen with my own eyes another Gurdwara in Southampton where they served meat in the langar, i was stunned to see this. It seems alot of people are very confused down there.
Truly saddening.
Re: Bhangra at Gurdwara
Manvir Singh Khalsa · 02 Jan 2007
News article from Panthic Weekly:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.panthic.org/news/124/ARTICLE/3006/2006-12-27.html
Beadbi Prevented at Gurdwara Nanaksar Southampton
Wednesday 27th of December 2006
Panthic Weekly News Bureau
[img]http://www.panthic.org/data/images/news/categories/cat_124/3006_Nanaksar_Southampton.jpg[/img]
[i]Gurdwara Nanaksar, Southampton (UK)[/i]
Southampton (KP) - A planned Beadbi at Gurdwara Nanaksar, 3 Peterborough Road, Southampton was avoided last weekend. On Wednesday 20th December the Gurdwara Nanaksar Management Committee held a meeting at the Gurdwara where they suggested holding a party that would include Bhangra music and dancing to celebrate 301st commemoration of the Shaheedi (martyrdom) of the four Sahibzaade (princes of Guru Gobind Singh Ji).
The main Gurdwara Management Committee consulted the Gurdwara Youth Committee about the proposal of a Bhangra party to mark the Shaheedi Diwas. It is claimed that only one person from the youth opposed the proposal, which is clearly a violation of Gur Maryada and insult to the memory of the Sahibzaade or any other Shaheeds.
It is said that the Gurdwara Committee main purpose of the Bhangra party was to attract the younger generation to the Gurdwara Sahib. The General Secretary of Gurdwara Nanaksar, Harjinder Singh Virdi, claimed to say that "let's move with the modern times." Further to this, sources have told us that the Stage Secretary, Harjap Singh Lakhpuri, said that Bhangra has saved our Panjabi language and that children are motivated to learn Panjabi to understand Bhangra song lyrics.
It is disturbing to know that those managing our Gurdwara Sahibs are willing to move with the times and adopt the youth culture of boozing, dancing and intoxication to bring money revenue, however blindly ignore the message, discipline and basic tenants of the Guru who's House they are alleging to serve. How has modern Bhangra music and culture inspired youngsters towards Gurmat? Semi-nude music videos; inappropriate lyrics that promote flirting, lust and physical intimacy; songs about liquor and getting drunk; are some of the many factors that are rotting away the traditional and proud culture of Panjab. If Bhangra music and dancing attracts children towards Gurmat, as in accordance to the bizarre logic of Mr. Virdi, Mr. Lakhpuri and the Nanaksar Committee, then the whole young generation of college boys and girls of Panjab would be Amritdhari Gursikhs. However, we all know the state of Panjab with the growth of drug addicts, alcoholism and sexually transmitted diseases.
With Waheguru's Grace, through the effort of some local youth and elders the plans of Shaheedi Diwas 'Bhangra Party' were avoided and stopped. However, this still raises the issue of how a Gurdwara Management Committee could even comprehend such an idea and associate Bhangra culture and music to Gurmat. Were the four Sahibzaadey inspired by Bhangra music and lyrics to give supreme sacrifices and die for Sikhi? Were our ancestors and elder generations drawn to Gurbani through Bhangra music and culture? Were the Shaheeds of 1978 and 1984 attracted to Gursikhi through Bhangra music and lyrics? The answer is 'No'.
One is attracted to Gurmat through Gurbaani, Naam, Vichaar, Keertan and Sangat. One is inspired towards Sikhi through Rehni (way of living), Kehni (way of speaking), Behni (way of sitting/socialising), and Sehni (way of character) of a Gursikh. One is drawn to the Gurdwara Sahib if there are role models, there is a warm and loving learning environment and that children are giving opportunity to participate, get involved and get opportunities to learn, reflect and appreciate Gurbani and their great history.
Copy of a "Bhangra PARTY" flyer created by the Gurdwara Committee:
[img]http://www.panthic.org/data/images/news/categories/cat_124/3006_flyer.gif[/img]
Editors can be reached at [u][address removed][/u]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Re: Bhangra at Gurdwara
Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 02 Jan 2007
I cant help but wonder how such committees get voted in. Who in their right mind votes in people who suggest a Bhangra gig to "Celebrate" a Shaheedi?
Could they find no other venue or time to throw their party? why attach the Sahibzaade to it and why oh why in the Gurdwara?
I'm sorry for ranting but i always try to see the other side of things. In this instance i cant make any sense of it whatsoever. If this had come to pass, what would have been next?
I hope the Sangat votes these failed comedians out before they manage any other kind of damage.
Re: Bhangra at Gurdwara
sikh and proud · 03 Jan 2007
sounds like the committee fancied a rave up.... muppets
Re: Bhangra at Gurdwara
balbir singh 2 · 03 Jan 2007
This is our fault ( I mean local sangat of that area ) who chose these people to run management and so on. My humble request is to open our eyes when choosing committe and all members have to participate in it and see well who need to be in there.
Oherwise we should'nt blame any one.
[%sig%]
Re: Bhangra at Gurdwara
Seeker of the Truth · 05 Jan 2007
Only in England. LOL
Re: Bhangra at Gurdwara
Rashminder Singh Oz · 05 Jan 2007
Yeh its always in United Kingdom
* Sharaab in gurudwara
* Bhangra in gurudwara
* Guru ji swaroop in mandir
* Meat in guru langar
* guru ji saroop taken to liquor shop
* Dance Party on shaheedi purab of 4 sahibzade
* Bollywood Shooting etc etc etc
Vaheguroooooooooooooooooooooo ;)
[%sig%]
Re: Bhangra at Gurdwara
Seeker of the Truth · 07 Jan 2007
How come all this kind of stuff happen ONLY in the UK? You don't hear stupid things like this happening in Canada and USA. Something is wrong in the UK Sikh community.
Re: Bhangra at Gurdwara
Super_Singh · 08 Jan 2007
I would like to proudly state that I go to this Gurdwara and help organised this event along with the youth commitee. In NO way was this ever stated to be a "BHANGRA BASH" as you have presumed it to be from a highly unreliable source. It was suggested from a younger naive member of the youth commitee that we could play some sort of bhangra, little does she know of lyrics. This music was for a game of pass-the-parcel! This celebration was aimed at getting the younger generation Under 12s to really understand the story and life lessons of the char sahibjadis. I'm am disgusted with the amount of hatred that has been posted up on here from such little information you all truly know. You are all so self-centred into how proper Sikhi you are that to try and avoid the fact that our faith is all about teachings, which was all the celebration was with a punjabi cartoon about the char sahibjadis and a brilliant demonstration of gatka. If the 'bhenji' was the only one with sense to oppose the bhangra bash then why did she even turn up to the event. Her form of opposition was "Yeah i agree that bhangra music isn't appropriate". Also when Harjinder Singh Virdi, claimed to say that "let's move with the modern times." this was completely taken out of context, with the use of technology such as projectors etc story telling and gurbani classes have become alot more popular. Yet you narrow minded people instantly assume he means taboos of our culture such as sexual intimacy, alcohol, drugs and other cultural differences. How stupid you can be is embarassing to me. And the worse thing is that I'm only 16 yet I have alot more courage and sense to understand anything that is happening. I learnt at the celebration, sorry I have to be careful about saying celebration in case any people may think I took some cannabis and put it into the samosa for an extra kick for the bhangra party (that may sound immature yet it is the same as other have been saying on here). Some are disgusted by what has happened at the Nanaksar Gurdwara but I am moreso disgusted by what has happened here. How do you propose to invite younger generations to the Gurdwara and keep them entertained for more than 5 minutes? Any suggestions please send them to [address removed] I am very eager to here of what we can do next year. Furthermore there is nothing wrong with the commitee, I absolutely love how you group together two quotes to a whole commitee, which my father is Treasurer of and one of the most respected men in Southampton amongst dozens more with the Gurdwara community. For those is the US and Canada your commitees are a joke! Most Gurdwaras are set up just for the financial glory which I know from family who live in Canada and the US who feel that the Gurdwaras have become commercialised so don't even think to say anything about how my local Gurdwara is run or any other Gurdwara in England either. The amount of frustration, embarassment and deceit that has been spread by one apparent true Sikhi surely cancels out by the amount of work we have put into this community to be crushed in a sentence which has been manipulated in the hands of liars and narrow minded "believers". Feel free to reply to this ([address removed]) as I shed a lot of truth in this to be heard!
Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa, Waheaguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Bhangra at Gurdwara
Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 09 Jan 2007
Super Singh Ji,
If i have said anything wrong then i am truly sorry, please accept my apologies. You are right, we should await confirmation of sources before jumping to conclusions.
I wish you had come here earlier and presented you version of events.
Re: Bhangra at Gurdwara
Super_Singh · 15 Jan 2007
Moorakh Mugad Eaan Ji thankyou for being understanding. However Man Singh Ji I do not understand why having a dhol is such a big problem, the dhol is part of our culture and is used at many Sikhi events such as Vaisakhi on the march and at Gatka demonstrations. The dhol was simply used for the gatka and not for anything else which you may believe to be.