Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What is a right khanda for your dastaar

What is a right khanda for your dastaar

Novtej Singh · 13 May 2004

vaheguroo jee ka khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fateh I was just browsing thorugh ebay until i came across these very expensive khandas. There are 2 of them at the moment, both with 18k gold and one of them also having over 1k of emerald. I would just like to know whether these kind of khandas can be worn on your dastaar as a piece of honour although I undestand that they maybe classified as jewellery. Please give your comments openly. Regards Novtej Singh vaheguroo jee ka khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fateh

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

Rashpal Singh · 13 May 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh A Khalsa should not wear these, they are, like you have stated classed as jewellery. It's like wearing a gold khanda necklace...should not be. It should be made from Sarbloh or Steel, preferably Sarbloh Obviously Gurfateh

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

njsingh · 13 May 2004

I disagree with Rashpal Singh. The dastaar should be as much ornamented as possible. Its your CROWN. Look at historical depictions of Gurus, Maharajas, and other various Sikhs. It's a beatuful thing to put jewels on your dastaar, pearls, etc. It shows the Shaan of the Khalsa. Nihang/Warrior tradition shows weapons placed on thier dastaars, but that was during the times of battle. Things are different in times of peace.

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

Tarunjeet Singh · 13 May 2004

We are in times of battle!!!!

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

Balpreet Singh · 13 May 2004

The only metal worthy of a Singh's dastaar is Sarbloh. Gold is nothing to a Singh. What does a gold Khanda symbolise? That you're wealthy and can afford to throw around money on nonsense like gold khandas while the children of Shaheed Singhs languish in poverty? If a gold kaRa and gold Kirpaan are not ok, then why a gold khanda? I dont' get it. As for the paintings of Guru Sahib with the jewels on the dastaar etc. I was wondering, do you think Guru Sahib wore a red or pink chola with a green kummer-kussa? Those paintings are completely false and have no base in reality.

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

Rashpal Singh · 13 May 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh We should decorate our Dastaara with Sarbloh or Steel Aad Chands, Khandai, Chakkars, Shastar and toRa. Not gold. VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

njsingh · 13 May 2004

<> Not really, we live in times of peace and live in Nations of democracy. We can use the law, rational thinking, debate, reasoning, protest, petition, press, lectures, discussions, phorums, and so many more solutions as a means to fight back if we have to; which were unavailable or not so common in old times. We can avoid violence altogether now through democracy, rights, and freedom. These solutions are our first priority before we take out our swords in the event of differences. An intellectual of today's modern times, should need to keep a bare minimum of Kirpan as thier last resort of shastar to fight on any battlefield. This modern age relies on your skills as a speaker, a writer, a lawyer, but not so much as a warrior (relatively speaking); although we have a warrior tradition. 99.9% of Sikhs today, havent had to physically fight another person, but instead fight them verbally using thier mind to explain them about sikhi (this is considering if you are getting heat from someone for being a Sikh). If you ask me, these aren't times of battle.

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

njsingh · 13 May 2004

<<>> Those are not HISTORICAL depictions. Those kinds of paintings are moreso of what the artists believe Guru looks like. There are many accurate portaits of Gurus that are in unison with what British historians and other history has noted down. There was one museum with collections of artifacts, war armour, weaponry, paintings, photographs, and other priceless paraphernalia, that was being shown in Toronto for 1 month in 1999, maybe 98, that was on tour from UK. Pictures by british photographers, paintings, writings, journals, etc.. In that collection, there were paintings that date back to early 1800s, made by british artists who studied Sikh culture for a while and made historically accurate paintings of Gurus, Maharaja Ranjeet Singh, etc.. They had akali nihang dastaar bungas on display, which were amazing to see, and obviously didn't have any jewels due to the times of war. But the depictions of sikhs when there was not any war, showed sikhs as prosperous kings. pearls, feathers, rich silks, gold, etc... Especially the Gurus. Guru's were stated to be 'living like kings'. My point being, although simplicity is encouraged in gursikhi, you dont have to shy away when showing the shaan of khalsa; KHALSA Raj.. But i do agree that its a waste of money, when that $$ can be used elsewhere. :)

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

Mohan Singh · 13 May 2004

It is Manmat to put gold jewellery under the guise of religious symbols in your dastar. Sarbloh is very powerful and this should be a preference. If you are unable to get sarbloh then steel is acceptable. We are not talking about worldly ornaments in our dastar, we are talking about Khalsa ornaments. Khalsa ornaments are shastars, chakkars, toRRha, aad chands, khandas, etc. If you can put Gurus ornaments below fancy worldly ornaments, then you should be questioning why you have a dastar in the first place. Apologies if I have offended anyone but this is my opinion. Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

Balpreet Singh · 13 May 2004

njsingh, I recall that exhibition. None of those pictures were eye-witness drawings of the Gurus. To date, I have seen one picture purported to be of the times of the Gurus. It is a picture of either Guru Tegh Bahadur or Ram Rai (the captions on the painting differ depending on the book). At any rate, that painting shows a person dressed in orange from head to foot with no jewellery. I have never heard that Guru Sahib wore jewellery. If they did, then wouldn't they be preserved? Like we have shastar of the Gurus, then wouldn't we have "gold bracelet, pearl necklace of Guru Sahib" etc? In the time of Raja Ranjit Singh, it's true that Sikhs began wearing jewellery. They had pierced ears and wore pearls and rubies, etc. But at that time they were Sikhs only in name. They were not living Sikh lifestyles. Guru Sahib stresses the need for simplicity. BaaNee repeatdly explains that these jewels and ornaments will not last. A Sikh dresses in simple clothes and lives a simple lifestyle.

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

Mkhalsa · 13 May 2004

>>>We can avoid violence altogether now through democracy, rights, and freedom.<<<< HAHAHAHA what world are you living in?! We have rights and freedoms? SINCE WHEN?!

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

njsingh · 13 May 2004

<<>> What are you talking about? Are you being oppressed? i live in america Mkhalsa. I don't know about you, but I am happy to have my rights and freedoms. This is the best it gets, i can deal with the rest, and so can the Sikhs of America. The little things don't matter. Sikhs are very successful here. As well as UK and Canada. We've been good to our nations, they've been good to us. No complaints here.

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

har · 13 May 2004

I disagre with njsingh we should not were and agree with rashpal singh.we should not were gold khanda necklace

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

!!!!!!!! · 14 May 2004

which when guru ji gave us

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

<><><><><> · 14 May 2004

Tarunjeet Singh: You say, "We are in times of battle!!!!" Are you in battle? Are you in India, fighting for freedom of Punjab? I love when people over here in Canada act like they are in battle, but do absolutely nothing. Mkhalsa is partly right...in India, freedom is garbage.......but Sikhs outside of India do have freedoms... and sad to say...but the majority of Sikhs outside India are all talk...they learn Gatka, saying we are at war and say we will fight for Khalsa...but in their heart of hearts...they know they will never do anything...and live in comfort here in Canada/US/UK

'Khalsa soi jo kareh nit jang'

tarunjeet Singh · 14 May 2004

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fahte <<>> 'Khalsa soi jo kareh nit jang'...the Khalsa is the one who fights daily. Even at Guru Sahib's time it was impossible to have been fighting the Moghuls and Hill Rajas every single day. But our great heros and heroines who fought on the battle field then, and those who fight today are REAL Khalsa. There are other REAL Khalsa too, but they fight on different battlefields. Like the old Bibi ji who needs a zimmerframe to walk, needs thick lenses to see, needs false teeth to eat...for her the daily battle is to get to the Gurdwara and fall at SatGuru ji's feet. Another REAL Khalsa is the 30 year old woman dying with cancer, fighting it day in day out so that her 2 young sons can have their mother. She fights with Waheguru on her tongue and pain in every part of her body. Another REAL Khalsa is to grow up surrounded by a non-Sikh culture and to maintain Guru Gobind Singh ji's form, and to fight for the rights of other Sikh children against racism and abuse. Fighting with Waheguru on their tongue. The list of everday REAL Khalsa is endless, everyone doing the duty given to them by Guru Sahib. And if Waheguru ji wanted the old woman and the mother's souls to have been destined for a young warriors body in the killing fields then they would have fought with the same Khalsa spirit. Not everyone can go and die on a killing field. But wherever Guru Sahib has given us our duty we must do it as REAL Khalsa. And the first and foremost daily battle that Bhai Nand Lal ji talks about is with the 5 enemies inside us. VAHEGURU

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

Mkhalsa · 14 May 2004

>>>>What are you talking about? Are you being oppressed? i live in america Mkhalsa. I don't know about you, but I am happy to have my rights and freedoms. This is the best it gets, i can deal with the rest, and so can the Sikhs of America. The little things don't matter. Sikhs are very successful here. As well as UK and Canada. We've been good to our nations, they've been good to us. No complaints here<<<<< Really? we are free in america? We are stuck in a country that is in an unjust and unethical and immoral war. We sit here waving our american flags because if we DARED criticize, some racist punk would come up and put a bullet in our head thinking we are muslim terrorists. free to express our opinions? NO I was called for jury duty, but was refused entry into the court house building. Why? because i REFUSE to take off my kirpan for something the country is FORCING ME to do. Dont get me wrong, i would love to be on jury duty, i think its cool to perform civic duty, but if they arent going to let me in, why should i be penalized? again, injustice I am going to a samagam in vancouver, do you think the airlines will allow me to take my siri sahib with me? again, not free to practice my religion. Racism, intolerance, and injustice, right here in the US. I live in california, im relatively better off than most singhs outside of california, but we still have problems. Am I free to visit my homeland without being harrased for wearing a big orange damalla? Am I free to visit the places my guru sahib has set foot at without being afraid for my life? Are we free here in america to run our gurudwaras and other bodies in ways that dont match western ideas? Can we pass gurmattas and have panj pyare controlling gurudwaras? NO WAY!! our religious bodies are not even RECOGNIZED ANYWHERE!! Are we even free to protest idiots like kala afghana without having riot police surrounding us? Are we free to get any job we want? I know I have personally been refused a job for wearing dastar, they wont say it outright, but you know thats the reason. Are we free to walk around with our siri sahibs outside in full bana without being questioned? Where is our freedom of religion? Freedom of religion in western countries is freedom of THEIR religion, not of anyone elses. I hope I have made my point.... And another thing, are we even free to criticize (never mind fight against) terrorist governments, ie INDIA without being called a terrorist?

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

njsingh · 14 May 2004

Mkhalsa, yes, the immoral war we are in is the byproduct of our incompetant president. the things you have mentioned are difficult, but are still small things. We have our core freedom, we simply need the right for kirpan legally. Soon our dream will be reality, and america will be the ideal place to live. We haven't gone to court in all states yet for kirpan cases. But it will happen in the future. Other than that, there arent any other complaints. Protesting -- we can protest freely, but police have the right to moniter in case of a riot. It happens everyhwere, to all americans at concerts, big events, university protests... As for jobs and wearing bana on streets, we have to work on as a community for outsiders to see us as americans too. We need to gain thier respect. We can only do that by becoming professionals in the workplace and the way we carry ourselves. We've been pretty good at it so far, but if there are any flaws in it, we must blame ourselves, not them. We have a smaller community than most in US, so we must uphold better values than them to be noticed as good people. About bana, no one will criticize you for wearing it, but it will look odd in society since its not part of popular culture. They have every right to stare at you on the street and question your dress. If you tell them intelectually, they won't bother you. Hell, they will RESPECT IT! About wearing kirpan in airplanes and courtrooms, and federal buildings -- you have to understand that they aren't taking away your freedom of relgiion. They must look out for themselves that NO WEAPONS are allowed in the courtrooms and planes. We have to understand where they are coming from -- an armed man is entering thier federal building. Outside of fed buldings, we have freedom of religion, and the right to bear arms. No one can stop you if you are an american citizen. :) It helps to know your rights and freedoms. So what i'm saying is we have to work towards these things -- no job discrimination, bana, kirpan, etc

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

Mkhalsa · 14 May 2004

>>>They must look out for themselves that NO WEAPONS are allowed in the courtrooms and planes.<<< Thats one of the BIGGEST problems.. even our singhs are going around saying kirpan is a dagger, kirpan is a weapon.. if u keep saying that, sure it is. A Hocky stick, baseball bat, tire iron, and chainsaw are also weapons but if a gardner is carrying a chainsaw and a hockey player is carrying his stick, is it a weapon? When a gursikh carrys a kharad it becomes a kirpan. and this is much MUCH more than a simple weapon. I have explained it like this to westerners before and they seem to be a lot more accepting of it and some have even told me we should be allowed to take it into court rooms at the very least. In hindustan we at least have that right.

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

Mkhalsa · 14 May 2004

I would also like to add, I would really like to live in my mother land one day. The place my gurus walked. I am aware I do not speak punjabi well and am very western in my thinking. But to me, home is in anandpur sahib and amritsar and thats the only place worth living. But in its current state, I could not live there. And this is why myself and others like me feel opressed, we may be in the west, but our hearts are in punjab, khalistan.

Re: What is a right khanda for your dastaar

khalistani · 14 May 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh! im wit mkhalsa one day i wud also want to live on the earth of where guru je lived, punjab aka khalstan :D bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!