Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

BBC Asian Network

BBC Asian Network

TRIGGER · 13 May 2004

Did any of you guys listen to the girl who direspected Guru Nanak Dev Ji, claiming that Islam is the true religion, on Sonia Deol's show on BBC Asian Network. I am surprised and saddened that nobody has put up thread about this and what we should be doing to make sure our religion isn`t being attacked like this. Maybe its not so surprising though that no one here cares- they`re too busy arguing about what`s the best dastar, what`s the holiest shape, best colour and what khanda to stick in it!!!! -lost the plot or what?? PEOPLE: WE NEED TO WAKE UP AND GET A GRIP!!!!!!!!! (just want to get this point across - no offence intended)

Re: BBC Asian Network

amrit · 13 May 2004

Sabh Tey Vadda Satgur Nanak Jin Kal Rakhee Meri Anyone that says anything bad about Satgur Nanak is confused and we should feel sorry for them. They are truly in a sad state if they perfer to wear burkas and be proud of it.

Re: BBC Asian Network

Mkhalsa · 13 May 2004

Most of the posters here are from north america.. I didnt even know there WAS a bbc asian network.. at any rate, she should get fired at least and groups like sikh federation in uk (or other applicable groups) should work at that.

Re: BBC Asian Network

sikh_in_uk · 14 May 2004

trigger is it possible to get a recording of the show?

Re: BBC Asian Network

Rashpal Singh · 14 May 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh Be compassionate and do ardaas for these moorakhs, that one day maybe they will be blessed with Guru Nanak Sahibs path of Truth, Humility, Selfless service and most of all naam.

Re: BBC Asian Network

Tigger...boing boing · 14 May 2004

wahegurujikakhalsa wahegurujikifateh! TERE BHAGAT NA SHODO BHAVAI LOG HASAI || thats all we hafta care about.....look how much people tried to say about our gurusahibs when it was gurusahibs day.......look how much people tried to attack sikhi........the main thing that matters is how strong we are ourselves too.......it's easy to go around and be ready to stamp down people on such matters, but what makes us stronger is how much faith we have......... people come and go..........but sometimes, MOORAKH NAAL NA LUGEYAI || esp people like the one on the radio..... don't get me wrong, things that can be damaging to the panth like kala afgana and RSS etc we should take a stand......but first we should be strong ourselves inside. wahegurujikakhasa wahegurujikifateh! [%sig%]

Re: BBC Asian Network

TRIGGER · 14 May 2004

wahegurujikakhasa wahegurujikifateh! <> exactly my point, Tigger (",) miaaaw miaaaw Are constant arguements about the best dastar, what`s the holiest shape, best colour and what khanda to stick in it going to make us stronger inside?? how much time is spent doing simran of waheguru and how much time is spent doing simran of how sainty 'my' jatha's bana is compared to 'your' jatha's unsaintly, anti-gurmat bana? To Mkhalsa ji, >>she should get fired at least and groups like sikh federation in uk (or other applicable groups) should work at that<< Should- ...perhaps you`re right but our community is way too apathetic on the whole. From my experience, if anything, we'll just sit at home and complain amongst ourselves about what an uproar the muslims would make if the situation was reversed and not do anything ourselves. To sikh_in_uk : >> is it possible to get a recording of the show? << It was on the bbc.co.uk website [click] asian network, but has now been removed. Luckily atleast a couple of recordings have been made by some Singhs who are working on having them up on the net. maybe by w/e wahegurujikakhasa wahegurujikifateh!

Re: BBC Asian Network

TRIGGER · 14 May 2004

- COME BROTHERS AND SISTERS - - NO EXCUSES - - LET'S ALL MAKE A DIFFERENCE FOR A COMMON CAUSE - (and remember) SAT SRI AKAL !

Re: BBC Asian Network

sikh_in_uk · 14 May 2004

qwerty sahib i dont think anything will be achieved in emailing sonia deol - she's a goree in a asain body..

Email from BBC

Jinder · 14 May 2004

This is what I got back Thank you for your correspondence, the following is an outline of the sequence of events broadcast on the Sonia Deol show on Tuesday 11th May 2004. The guest invited onto the programme who made the inflammatory remarks about the Sikh Guru, was a 22 year student. She was invited onto the show after she sent the Sonia Deol programme an email earlier in the week outlining her dilemma. In it she talked about her upbringing in a multi-faith household. Her mother being Muslim and her father Sikh, she said that after much soul searching she decided that she wanted to practice the Islamic faith. However, she recognised that this would upset her father because, since her parents divorced, his life was orientated around the Sikh faith and she was concerned her decision would cause conflict within the family. The Sonia Deol production team made the necessary checks on her story and invited her to take part in a live discussion/phone-in which would open up the debate and focus on the issues faced by a child brought up in a multi-faith household. The question posed to listeners was:" Inter-religious family life - does it really work?" The discussion started at 1000 when the student and a second studio guest, who had a fairly balanced upbringing in his multi faith household, both gave their experiences of living in a home that practiced two religions. For the first 40 minutes the debate looked at the various issues around growing up in a household where parents were of two different faiths. The second guest talked about how much it had enriched his life learning about Catholisism and Sikhism, but the first guest, the student, talked extensively of how difficult her experience was. At around 1045, a caller into the programme instigated a line of questioning which looked at where some of the differences in the two religions were and it was this that led to two offensive remarks. Firstly the first guest referred to Guru Nanak Dev Ji as Guru Nanak Singh, and secondly she claimed that Muslims believed that Guru Nanak Dev Ji was the devil (shaytaan), for having persuaded some Muslims to renounce their religion. The remarks were challenged by the second guest, the presenter Sonia, and by a number of callers. Sonia responded quickly by telling her that her remarks were offensive and unacceptable. The first guest apologised and said she was not directing her comments at Sikhs, and made it clear that the remarks were hers and not those of the other programme participants. The first guest was further challenged over her remarks by Sonia who asked her where she had got her knowledge from and when she responded by referring to unnamed literature, it became quite clear that she was not an authority on either Islam or Sikhism. (Note that she had not been invited onto the programme to talk about her knowledge of either faith, but about the problems of growing up in a multi-faith household). At this point Sonia steered the phone in/debate away from this issue and refocussed on the initial question. However, the topic was brought up again and Sonia made it clear that it was the first guest who made the comment. The first guest responded by saying she didn't want to offend anyone and then she apologised. A number of callers were put on air from both the Muslim and the Sikh faith who reprimanded her derogatory comments. The discussion continued after the 11 0'clock news, The first guest was not included in the subsequent debate. Sonia again made it clear that the opinions expressed were unacceptable and apologised for the comments that were made. The BBC Asian Network would like to re-iterate that the guests were invited on to the show to talk about the complexities of living and growing up in a multi-faith household, they were not asked to talk about religion exclusively. The guest in question will not appear again on the Network. I have also attached the retractment by Gurmukh Singh, the Admin Secretary of the British Sikh Consultative Forum, of his original complaint. Dear Amrat Singh Ji Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh You have most helpfully provided the actual recording of Sonia Deol's programme. I have listened to the relevant part (Part 2) from about 17.00 to 19.20 - about 2 minutes a number of times. I withdraw my complaint to the BBC because I thought Sonia deol managed that particular part extremely well. In fact the caller made a complete fool of herself. I regret that I was misled into believing otherwise in my capacity as Secretary of the British Sikh Consultative Forum. I am copying this e-mail to Sonia Deol, BBC Asianet and others who would have an interest. I shall be happy to field any questions. Next opportunity to question me directly will be at the open and accountable Btitish Sikh Consultative Forum meeting on Saturday 15th May at Guru Nanak Gurdwara, Smethwick at 1.00 pm. (The Secretary is replaceable by any meeting of the Forum) Gurmukh Singh Admin. Secretary British Sikh Consultative Forum Regards Rabiya S Parekh Senior Producer The Sonia Deol Show BBC Asian Network

Re: BBC Asian Network

Jagroop Singh · 14 May 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, Whereabouts are the comments in question: in part 1, 2 or 3? And at which point on the counter e.g. 2:13....? Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: BBC Asian Network

jd · 14 May 2004

i smell something fishy. This is the second time in two weeks with bbc midlands. 1 n a half weeks ago was a nagar kirtan in walsall a mainly muslim area. Muslim youths came out on da streets started smoking in sikhs faces, groping sikh women. Then somebody dabs one of them in the arm just a 2 inch scratch. The BBC the national media follow the police line saying it was a "racist attack on a muslim" and give the muslim most of the time exposure than the attacks occuring on the sikh community. The only thing they mentioned was "police are investigating claims by sikhs their religion was "disrespected". the muslim boy claims sikhs used sumarai weopons on his back, The BBC reported this. Does it take a 10 year old to work out if you get hit with a samarai on your back you dont walk away with a 2 inch scratch on your arm? The BBC then go onto say 2 sikh boys were hit elsehwere the following day and one had brain injuries the culprits were this time "people" but in the case of the muslim they were " sikhs". The headteacher of the sixth form where the attack took place was asked do you have security? he said the cctv was switched off. Sangat draw your own conclusions, the bbc reported an incident and more than once they have twisted information in favour of muslims whereas it was actually sikhs who were the victims. The police, the education authority and the national media joined the same chorus. Within barely a week on the same media Guru Nanak is called a devil. Sonia the presenter also believes one should be able to "express an opinion". The recording of the devil incident shows there were agendas within the programme they were claiming yes she is half sikh half muslim as though you have 2 religions, which even a 10 year 0old can work out your not a sikh unless you practice sikhi or muslim unless you practice islam.

Re: BBC Asian Network

TRIGGER · 16 May 2004

Mkhalsa: >> Most of the posters here are from north america.. I didnt even know there WAS a bbc asian network..<< To ALL NON - UK SIKHS: this is a fair point but the fact that you guys could have been listening, as it was live on the internet means you have every right to complain. So any of you with extra time on your hands go for it- its for the panth. To All - esp. UK readers Here is a email which can be circulated to all relevant people on your address book: Just Copy and Paste. 95% is done for you- come on guys! Sangat Ji, On the BBC's Asian Network during Sonia Deol's show 11th May between 9am - Midday a derogatory statement was made live on air about Baba Guru Nanak Dev Ji. The statement made by one of the guests referred to :- (a) 'Guru Nanak as a devil', (b) 'Sri Guru Granth Sahib as empty' and many other derogatory statements. This should NOT and will NOT be tolerated. http://www.bbc.co.uk/asiannetwork/ Asian Network is widely available on the following media. 1. Via a DAB digital radio 2. Via digital satellite television 3. Via a digital cable television 4. Via the internet 5. If you live in the Midlands on medium wave. 6. Via digital terrestrial television. Please forward to this email to ALL Sikhs you know and 'cc' [address removed] Please can you all officially complain in the strongest of terms using all the methods stated below. How to complain The following extract is from the BBC web-site, if you threaten them with legal action then the complaint is taken far more seriously. "The BBC's Programme Complaints Unit deals with serious complaints (see Chapter 42). Before referring a member of the public to the PCU, the Unit should be contacted to establish whether the complaint is within its remit. It is important to alert BBC lawyers, through Heads of Department or Commissioning Executives, to enquiries which threaten legal action." Also the statements may be 'inciting religious hatred' as it directly makes slanderous/ blasphemous comments about sikhism. This is against program guidelines. She did not use the 30 second cut-off facility available to all BBC show presenters. Please take time and fill in all details thoroughly and correctly. Show details:- Programme : BBC Asian Network Producer : Vijay Sharma Show : Sonia Deols show Date : 11th May Time : 9am - Midday Comments made by Guest ( Kerrie) at the studio. (a) 'Guru Nanak as a devil', (b) 'Sri Guru Granth Sahib as empty' and many other derogatory statements. 1. Lodge your complaint at - http://www.bbc.co.uk/feedback/ 2. Official BBC complaints procedure form http://www.bbc.co.uk/info/contactus/serious_form.shtml 3. Write and Ring to the following:- Head of Programme Complaints BBC Media Centre Media Village 201 Wood Lane London W12 7TQ and Ring BBC complaints on 08700 100222 giving full details. 4. Broadcasting Standards Commission , please lodge your complaint here. http://www.ofcom.org.uk/static/archive/bsc/plain/stanform.htm 5. Email Your MP full details. Link below. http://www.locata.co.uk/commons/ 6. Government Department of Culture Media and Sport (This department oversees the BBC) Email Tessa Jowell. Her email address is at the bottom of this page http://www.number-10.gov.uk/output/Page1576.asp#2 http://www.culture.gov.uk/broadcasting/default.htm 7. Write to BBC asian network producer Vijay Sharma :- Vijay Sharma BBC Asian Network BBC Eric House Charles Street Leicester Please forward to all sikhs you know and 'cc' [address removed] Waheguru Je Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Je Ke Fateh. Sikh Way Forward (http://www.sikhwayforward.com)

Re: BBC Asian Network

111 · 17 May 2004

awful

Re: BBC Asian Network

TRIGGER · 17 May 2004

True - what makes it worse is the BBC (*BRITISH* Broadcasting Corporation) thought that they could get away with it with out an official appology.(it's only the sikhs afterall - back in the days giving countless lives for the *BRITISH* army and now paying considerable taxes in *BRITAIN* by working hard here- 5, 6, 7 days a week leaving no time to go on demonstrations - no time to complain or issue fatwas. Well I'm glad to say that they have been surprised because of a few who took the time to complain - and with Waheguru's kirpa this will become 1 BIG LESSON for ALL that LIONS MAY SLEEP A LOT, BUT WHEN AWAKE THEY SHOW WHY THEY'RE CALLED "THE KINGS" and so: WAKE US AT YOUR OWN EXPENSE!! We need to wake up on this one sangat jee - if all you can manage is one call then complain here 08700100222. remember sikhs value MIRI aswell as piri. bhul chuk maaf Waheguru Je Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Je Ke Fateh.

Re: BBC Asian Network

s uppal · 18 May 2004

i think guru nanak is the only person who is keeping us going and helps us live the live we have he had said that all religions are the same and stick to that if u like it or not this had disgust me when a person got away with on tv if i was face 2 face i would explained to her what it is like to be sikhs [%sig%]

Re: BBC Asian Network

s uppal · 18 May 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh what was said had disgust me as a sikh and i would give the persona piece of my mindTRIGGER wrote: > Did any of you guys listen to the girl who direspected Guru > Nanak Dev Ji, claiming that Islam is the true religion, on > Sonia Deol's show on BBC Asian Network. I am surprised and > saddened that nobody has put up thread about this and what we > should be doing to make sure our religion isn`t being attacked > like this. Maybe its not so surprising though that no one > here cares- they`re too busy arguing about what`s the best > dastar, what`s the holiest shape, best colour and what khanda > to stick in it!!!! -lost the plot or what?? > > PEOPLE: WE NEED TO WAKE UP AND GET A GRIP!!!!!!!!! > > (just want to get this point across - no offence intended)

Re: BBC Asian Network

s uppal · 20 May 2004

hi i am a sikh and i was disgusted by the comment made by islam is the true religion because i don't agree and i am a lawyer if i was on the show i would of told her what had be right nanak is the person who will follow in our religion and truly we believe him as the only guru in the sikhism and that i don't regret what i say because sikh is a true religion as well and if i say it to islam and how will they feel about what i have said so no more rudeness about others and think about yourself as a btrue person.TRIGGER wrote: > Did any of you guys listen to the girl who direspected Guru > Nanak Dev Ji, claiming that Islam is the true religion, on > Sonia Deol's show on BBC Asian Network. I am surprised and > saddened that nobody has put up thread about this and what we > should be doing to make sure our religion isn`t being attacked > like this. Maybe its not so surprising though that no one > here cares- they`re too busy arguing about what`s the best > dastar, what`s the holiest shape, best colour and what khanda > to stick in it!!!! -lost the plot or what?? > > PEOPLE: WE NEED TO WAKE UP AND GET A GRIP!!!!!!!!! > > (just want to get this point across - no offence intended)

Re: BBC Asian Network

s uppal · 20 May 2004

hi i am a sikh and i was disgusted by the comment made by islam is the true religion because i don't agree and i am a lawyer if i was on the show i would of told her what had be right nanak is the person who will follow in our religion and truly we believe him as the only guru in the sikhism and that i don't regret what i say because sikh is a true religion as well and if i say it to islam and how will they feel about what i have said so no more rudeness about others and think about yourself as a btrue person.TRIGGER wrote:

Re: BBC Asian Network

manjit · 21 May 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. I heard the show. What the guest said was offensive but it was very well managed by the presenter, Sonia Deol. Here are some more facts that have come to light. 1. There is no 'time delay' on the BBC program. 2. The presented does not have a 'dump' button to end the call. The production crew controls the buttons 3. What the guest said was a complete surprise, and since the show is live and there is no time delay, there's nothing Sonia could do than to address the comment after it was on the air. 3. Sonia Deol told the presenter her comments were offensive and apologised. So, why are there some people asking for Sonia to be fired ????? Gurmukh Singh Admin. Secretary of the British Sikh Consultative Forum which launched a complaint before hearing a recording of the show withdrew the complaint after listening to a tape of the show. Sonia Deol is an excellent presenter and we sikhs should be proud that one of our own is doing so well. Trigger - It looks like you want to shoot first and ask questions later. Did you hear the show before jumping to conclusions. Are you being fair ? That is not what sikhism is about.

Re: BBC Asian Network

manjit · 21 May 2004

Mkhalsa. Let me get this right...you didn't know there was a BBC Asian Network... you didn't hear the show... you don't know that the presenter actually didnt say what some people falsely said she did...BUT YOU WANT HER FIRED AND THE SIKH FEDERATION TO JUMP ON THIS GIRL Right, you have learn't a lot about fairness, justice that our Gurus taught us and that differentiates us Sikhs from those tyrants that the Gurus were fighting. *****Admin Cut - No personal attacks please****** Think about what is means to be a sikh and then condemn others without evidence or when they have done nothing wrong

Re: BBC Asian Network

manjit · 21 May 2004

So why is she a goree ???? She is a Sikh, speaks fluent Punjabi, wears indian clothes, promotes asian culture in a predominantly white society, performs lots of community and charity work... Have you seen what other UK born kids are like... Do we want a 'paindoo' representing Asians at the BBC...is that what we want...how we want to promote ourselves... We'll be stuck in the 17th century forever with that kind of attitude... India has moved on...yet the brit/indians want time to stand still, they way they remember india when they came here 20, 30 or 40 years ago, fozen in time...

Re: BBC Asian Network

TRIGGER · 21 May 2004

to manjit: is that you Sonia? - changing your name! ... nice try ;-) yes i have heard your show, and more than once. Please tell me which conclusions I jumped to and what I have done which is against sikhism. I genuinely wish to learn about sikhism.

Re: BBC Asian Network

@@@ · 21 May 2004

How is she one of ours??? She's going out with a Paki (Pakistani- muslim)

Re: BBC Asian Network

..... · 21 May 2004

come on lets not attack each other torey izzat de naal ghal a baata karoh to make sure 1) we get justice 2) make sure this doesnt happen again doin each others besti will achieve nothing.

Re: BBC Asian Network

manjit · 21 May 2004

Did you hear the show in question, BEFORE YOU POSTED THE MESSAGE, supporting the view that Sonia should be fired ??? be truthful... There are many thousands like me that want shows that tackle tough topics, we don't want it muzzled because some idiot (not Sonia) said something offensive... the Taliban went around shooting people who didn't fall into line or said something they didn't like, is this the level we want Sikhs to get to...I don't, ...Sikhs are progressive, undestanding, compassionate and forgiving...thats what makes us different, if someone makes a mistake we correct them so they know better for next time, not shoot them And no, I am not Sonia, I am Manjit, so please try to be more respectful and lets have a mature discussion, if you like

Re: BBC Asian Network

back to basics · 21 May 2004

Manjit, you said that sonia is a sikh... please kindly describe what a sikh is..... please also back your ansa by gurbani........

Re: BBC Asian Network

tarunjeet singh · 21 May 2004

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh I've listened to the show and I have spoken with many Singhs regarding this issue, some say we should push for soina deol to be sacked, some say that we are over reacting and we shouldn't be so sensitive. Bhai manjit singh stated that <<<<<...Sikhs are progressive, undestanding, compassionate and forgiving...thats what makes us different, if someone makes a mistake we correct them so they know better for next time, not shoot them>>>>>>> Yes I agree we should be all of the above But we must can nto remain that we at all times if someone disrespects our Guru then it is our duty to stand up and complain and ask that they apoligise. The fact that people are saying Sonia should be sacked......well being the presenter of the show she holds responsibility for the broadcasts that go out , she should have vetted the guest speaker, there should have been a delay system in place so that it could have been edited. She also repremanded a caller by saying that it was the guest speakers opinion and that she was intitled to say what she feels. !!! We ain't yogi's who run in to mountains when it's tiem to stand up for yourselves. Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe

Re: BBC Asian Network

:-( · 21 May 2004

why are we concerned whether sonia is a sikh? why do important topics end up with "oh their not sikh anyway"? and what now? for cryin out loud we got a problem lets work to resolve that. manjit has his her point and trigger has his or hers. i can see where both r comin from. The shows aims on the topic are off the mark in terms of definitions and practically applieing however southall and brum theres too many cases of mixed marriages nowdays and that did need discussing. The question of sikhism shudnt have entered it u aint exactly gonna pracrtice 2 religions at once. manjit is right where he or she states that topic itself must not be muzzled. At the same point making bad remarks about gurus or prophets are inciting religious hatred breaking the law. Dont listen to this crap "shes a young naive 22 year old". thats a responsible adult attacking a religion on a time and place. manjit thank u for your points.

Re: BBC Asian Network

manjit · 21 May 2004

'back to basics', Could you please tell what is a Sikh to you...

Re: BBC Asian Network

TRIGGER · 21 May 2004

To manjit: Sorry to suggest that you are Sonia, i wasn't being serious so don't worry, but perhaps you can explain when i suggested anyone should be shot? ... and Sonia might be a good presenter, but on this ocassion she did muck up. She herself initiated the disastrous moment when these comments were made by asking an ignorant and biased girl what she DISLIKED about one religion over the other! ......and then after the girl's reply, she hypocritically contradicted herself by saying you can't knock one religon over another, precisely the thing which Sonia asked the girl to do in the first place!

Re: BBC Asian Network

preeti · 22 May 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Sonia DID NOT muck up. The problem was with the guest's answer NOT Sonia's question. I have just listened to the programme and heard clearly what happened...A caller asks the guest to study both Islam and Sikhism equally before making her final decision about which to follow...Sonia asks the guest if she has already? The guest replies yes. Sonia asks how? The guest says her friends have told her who are both Sikh and Muslim. So Sonia says points out to the guest her knowledge is just from friends and family? The guest says she has read books on Islam. Sonia asks her what about books on Sikhism? The guest says she has 'kind of' but she has made up her mind. So at this point Sonia asks her what she's based her decision on? What did she LIKE or dislike about one faith to the other. Now use your heads on this please. That's an OPEN question and one I have asked my mates of mixed families or converts often. The question was important cos the programme was all about the kids of mixed families and how they cope with the pressure and how they decide on what's best for them. The guest could have responded in a number of positive, non offensive ways. She could have said she doesn't believe in reincarnation..or she's just more comfortable...but she chose to be really offensive..bad move. Now how is that Sonia's fault?? Get a grip. I have heard they don't even have a delay system..so the guest could not have been cut out. And instead of thanking Sonia for correcting her and telling her off straightaway..what does everyone do? Have a go at Sonia. Am I going mad or have people who are attacking HER lost their common sense? I really feel for her and would hate to be in her shoes. Poor girl. She does so much in her community like charity work and stuff, and I wouldn't be suprised if she just stopped. And before you ask Trigger..NO I'm NOT Sonia. Just cos I support her after listening to the FACTS doesn't make my opinion less valid. bhul chuk maaf

Re: BBC Asian Network

silly · 22 May 2004

I agree with what manjit is saying. dont comment without getting the facts right first AND calling sonia a gori and who sonia deol is banging has nothing to do with this situation so refraim from personal attacks. if u belive she is deliberatly anti sikh find some evidence to support this as so far u hav non as she gave the anti sikh girl kiri a fist full of truth. as far as i can see the main outcome should be the following sonia and bbc should take steps to ensure sikhi is not misrepresented any further ie. talking about marriages in the context that was being dicussed on the show was misrepresentative of what marriage is in sikhi take steps to make sure nothing like this happenes ever again. i belive that the above 2 points are a pre-requiste before accepting any apology from the bbc as whats the point of saying sorry for a situation that you would allow to happen. its like sorry guroo sahib i broke my rehat today, and then do the same thing again tomorow lol therefore how can u be sorry.

Re: BBC Asian Network

jas_uk · 24 May 2004

I agree with Trigger, as far as religion was concerned it was obvious that kiri was biased and quite ignorant so the question should never have been asked what you dislike in one faith over other. and how much was the knowledge of the one who vetted her??

Re: BBC Asian Network

me4post · 24 May 2004

To Trigger: I accept you didn't mean to insult me by suggesting I was Sonia in disguise. My comment regarding "shooting first and asking questions later" was is response to your agreeing with mkhalsa that Sonia should be fired, heres what you said (mkhalsa's comment is first) "to Mkhalsa ji, >>she should get fired at least and groups like sikh federation in uk (or other applicable groups) should work at that<< Should- ...perhaps you`re right but our community is way too apathetic on the whole. From my experience, if anything, we'll just sit at home and complain amongst ourselves about what an uproar the muslims would make if the situation was reversed and not do anything ourselves. " Comments like the one from @@@ saying sonia is going out with a paki is totally inapropriate, has nothing to do advancing this discussion and total rubbish. I think thats someone who dislikes her personally and taking a cheap, below the belt, shot. COMMENT TO THE SITE ADMIN - WHY DID YOU ALLOW RUBBISH LIKE THAT TO GET POSTED TO THIS SITE. The BBC issued another apology today. I feel it didn't go far enough, because they didn't explain what they were doing to prevent it happening again. The BBC may feel they need to show they do not get intimidated and censored by any one group. That's also important to remember. To "silly" : I agree the BBC needs to go further, and take steps to make sure it doesnt happen again, have the 'producers' vet guests better, have a time-delay system put in. The BBC also need to admit there is a production team that also needs to share in any blame, Sonia is having to face all the heat on her own while the nameless, faceless 'production team' have it easy.

Re: BBC Asian Network

silly · 24 May 2004

me4post >The BBC issued another apology today. I feel it didn't go far enough, because they didn't explain what they were doing to prevent it happening again. this i think every1 can agree is central to the entire issue, apology can only be accepted if steps are taken to ensure something like this wont happen again, e.g. the example i highlighted earlier further, the misrepresentation of sikhi by bbc must also stop i.e associating the type of relationships beind discussed at the time of the show with the idea of a sikh marriage. they r incompatible, this is fact. therefore to sugest otherwise is misrepresentative and false and therefore wrong. so maybe somone should get back to the bbc with regards to rather than giving a nicly typed up apology, actually do something to back that apology up.

Re: BBC Asian Network

saira · 26 May 2004

why the hell should sonia be taken off? surely the girl should be names and shamed. sonia didnt do anything wrong.

Re: BBC Asian Network

Sana · 29 May 2004

hey, im just replying bcoz i feel that all this cant be condoned. But at the same time, i was brought up with my mother being sikh and my father muslim, and i see the beauty in both religions. Religious intolerance along with intolerance of any other kind should not be condoned, but please dont insult other religions because they insulted urs, an eye for an eye will get u nowhere (Author: amrit Date: 05-13-04 18:22 Sabh Tey Vadda Satgur Nanak Jin Kal Rakhee Meri Anyone that says anything bad about Satgur Nanak is confused and we should feel sorry for them. They are truly in a sad state if they perfer to wear burkas and be proud of it.) peace