Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

touching/serving meat

touching/serving meat

SadhSangat · 01 Feb 2007

Dear Tapoban.org, I am wanting to take Amrit this year but I am hestitating for one reason only. I am at university and part of my course is to work in a restaurant and serve meat to the customers. I know this is wrong and I shouldn't touch meat but could I still take Amrit depsite this, is it a big Kurehat or is it just something that I have to live with? I will have to work as a waiter as my first job and it is unlikely I can change this. If I was to take Amrit and carry on with this practice would it be classed as committing a Kurehat? What can I do? Please help, Could some GurSikhs please reply to this post as well with reference to Gurbani Lines. Thank You, Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vahegur Ji Kee Fateh! [%sig%]

Re: touching/serving meat

Tanu Kaur · 02 Feb 2007

Why would the Guru punish you for something that's not in your hands? Why would the Guru punish you at all?

Re: touching/serving meat

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 02 Feb 2007

How can you be a hypocrite and serve meat to others when you yourself do not eat it? If you truly beleive meat is wrong, you will give up anything that causes you to do this and allow guru sahib to find you a job where you don't have to do this.

Re: touching/serving meat

ssg · 12 Feb 2007

WJKK WJKF Sadhsangat, whether you eat meat or do not eat meat is not a bad thing at all..As long as your grateful for whatever vaheguru gives you. I heard many times that it is unhealthy to eat any food for its taste, rather you should eat for nutrition to supply the body and keep it strong so we can concentrate on naam simran and not concentrate on being hungry, after all that is the function of food, as long as you eat it with good intentions..Many brothers and sisters think its "safer" not to eat meat, since it is stated in SGGS that we shouldnt eat "halal" meat.. ..the almighty, responsible for everything you see, hear, smell, touch and taste...do you think "he" will forbid you to serve food to others? whether its meat or not makes no difference. Whats more important in consideration is whether you will be willing to fully commit yourself to the guru. I wonder what guru nanak dev ji ate when he was travelling in the mountins with rivers and streams full of fish? Something to think about maybe :)

Re: touching/serving meat

ms k · 12 Feb 2007

WJKK WJKF, I certainly agree that if, as an amritdhari, you don't eat meat, then you certainly should not touch it or encourage others to eat it. Defeats the whole teachings of Sikhi. WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: touching/serving meat

Roopkaur · 12 Feb 2007

>Many brothers and sisters think its "safer" not to eat meat, since it is stated in SGGS that we shouldnt eat "halal" meat..< Sri Guru Ji condemns all meat, not just halal meat. >I wonder what guru nanak dev ji ate when he was travelling in the mountins with rivers and streams full of fish? Something to think about maybe :)< I am sure Sri Guru Ji did not go against bani and eat those fish, as there were probably many plants and trees around as well. WHere there is water, there is growth. As for the initial question, it would be wrong for you to serve meat to others. It is like giving poison to others, would you do it, even if you yourself are not doing it. Just think, would it be appropriate for an Amritdharee SIkh to be a barber?, I think not, so how can a Guru fearing SIkh serve meat to others?

Re: touching/serving meat

Man Singh · 12 Feb 2007

Food have effect on mind as well as on your body. Yes many food items may have higher nutritional values but still may be stimulanting and hence not good fro spritual seeker. Any food that stimulates your mind and detracts it from naam and Simran, is advised not to be eaten by those who intend to rise on spritual path. Meat, wine, onion, garlic, brinjal etc are time tested dusturbing factors and hence to be avoided. We should keep in mind that these recommendations are only fro spritual seekers. It works two way. Those who abandon eating tamasic foods, can focus better on vahe Guru. Those who start naam and simran, slowly get away from tehse food items due to tehir arousen internal consciousness. Touching at work place doesn'nt matter as long you take it as your duty and do not get attached to it. There is no hypocircy in it. Spritual developemnt is purely personal matter. O

Re: touching/serving meat

PTE SINGH · 13 Feb 2007

Sadhsanghat, You have clearly answered your own question, if you feel that eating meat is SUCH a bad and sinful thing then you should already not be involved in its serving, cooking or in any other way. In your own eyes you are already a bigger 'sinner' then those (like me) who only substain from halal meat as prescribed. If you feel in your heart that killing and eating animals is wrong then why do you even need to pose this question, regardless of Amrit you should have the heart to sacrifice more for your personal belief let alone your religion. If you are unsure about the Sikh stance on meat then thats another question altogther... It seems that your convictions are flexible my friend and you should think long and hard about your current belief system and then worry about taking amrit. Kind Regards [%sig%]

Re: touching/serving meat

Roopkaur · 13 Feb 2007

>Spritual developemnt is purely personal matter.< If one tries to develop personally, i.e. making up rules as they go along according to what they deem is best, they will be lost in their own man's (minds) matt. That is why Bani tells us we need a Guru to guide us, and Sri Guru Ji says to earn an honest living, which can only be done when we earn it according to the principles of gurmat. According to your logic, anything is okay, if we realize it is in the line of duty. So prostituting would be okay as long as the woman realizes it is only to earn money. Umm, that does not seem to logically fit, for some reason. Guru Sahib never ate from the hands of Malik Bhago, which is a clear indicator that our earning has a direct effect on our whole jeevani. Let us not fall into the traps of >personal matters< when it comes to gurmat.

Re: touching/serving meat

Man Singh · 14 Feb 2007

Yes even if a prostitute who is not in that profession for lust but merely for livelyhood out of compulsion. `Ganika' 's story has been refered in Baani. Sadna kasai(Buture) is another example. Malik Bhago was sucking blood of innocent people.But these hardworking people earning their livelyhood in absense of other options. If we have an option, we should avoid the killing innocent creatures and be party in that. If we have no other skill or no other jobs in the market, like `ganika' and `sadna kasai' vahe guru knows better then all of us our circumestances and will decide about our fate.