Guru Nanak Religion??
singhnisister · 07 Feb 2007
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa
Waheguru ji ki Fateh
Someone from my school told me tht he read tht Guru Nanak ji was born as a Muslim but i read tht he was born as a Hindu, but i dont know. can you pls tell me that where was he born?
And yes, how did he die? I couldnt even find any story coz i looked up on internet but i couldnt find any.
Thank you
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa
Waheguru ji ki Fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Guru Nanak Religion??
singhnisister · 07 Feb 2007
Thank you, but i couldnt find anything about his joti jot :S
[%sig%]
Re: Guru Nanak Religion??
dalbir singh shergill · 08 Feb 2007
well ji guru nanak dev ji was born a hindu
below is from wikipedia.com
Guru Nanak was born on 5 November 1469 in a Bedi family of Hindu Khatri clan,[5] in the village of Rāi Bhōi dī Talvaṇḍī, now called Nankana Sahib, near Lahore (in present-day Pakistan).[6] His father, Mehta Kalu, was a Patwari—an accountant of land revenue in the government. He worked for the Muslim landlord of the village, Rai Bullar. Guru Nanak's mother was Tripta Devi and he had one older sister, Nanaki.
Joti Jot Samaye
Guru Nanak spent last fifteen years of his life in Kartarpur. The Guru would wake at dawn and recite his daily prayers. At daybreak, he would address his followers. He worked in the field and earned his livelihood. He worked in Langar; or community kitchen, where food would be partaken by Nanak's followers irrespective of their caste or creed.
On 22 September 1539, aged 70, Guru Nanak met with his demise, after he had requested his disciples to sing the Sohila (the praise of God).
[edit] Folklore
The legend says that upon the death of Guru Nanak Dev, his Hindu followers wanted to cremate the remains while the Muslim followers wanted to bury the body following Islamic tradition. However on raising the cloth under which the Guru's body lay, some fresh flowers were found which were shared between his followers. The Hindus cremated their flowers whereas the Muslims buried theirs.singhnisister wrote:
[%sig%]
Re: Guru Nanak Religion??
raj karega khalsa · 10 Feb 2007
exactly! this is something people need to get drilled into their heads. Not even just punjabees but people in general...they need to realize that religion is NOT a birthright.
i remember a couple years ago i was talking to one of my frends n he said to me, 'my mom says that we're all half hindu because Guroo Nanak was a hindu too.'
Re: Guru Nanak Religion??
Demonic Warrior · 15 Feb 2007
Who cares about other religions, or about who Guru Nanak Dev Ji was at his birth. They are not our concern. All we know is that Guru Nanak Dev Ji was higher then religion, and he gave us Sikhi, so worry about that; about being Guru's Sikh. Thats if you care?
Chandra can I ask you a question? And please don't add 'Singh' to your name. Anyway about the question. Here it is:
Do you know for how long you will be living?
Re: Guru Nanak Religion??
dalbir singh shergill · 15 Feb 2007
well chandra guru ji gave us a path to true guru he told us we didnt have to go in to jungles and live there to be free from the world
even if u live in the jungle
but still havent gotten rid of ur evil inside how are u free then
guru nanak dev ji rejected the hindu sacred thread and thus rejected all hindu WAYS
if guru wanted up to be just free
the freedom that u talk of from being subservient to some one or some religion
well ji that is not he freedom that sikhs look for
we look for the freedom from the worldly bonds
Freedom from kam and moh from family members and other things
guru ji gave us a path by giving us a bani
he gave us japji sahib he gave us other banis
just bc the words of some muslims saints are in the SGGS doesnt make it Abrahamic
how can we be abrahamic when we don’t recognize the muslims text nor the hindu one
“O God ! Since I have held your feet, none other has entered my vision; Ram, Rahim, Puranas, Quran and many others recite, but I don't believe in even one. The Simritis, Shastras and Vedas describe many mysteries, but I don't recognise even one of them; O Sword-wielder God! All this I write, with your blessings, is not what I know but what you have shown me.”
Dohraa.
sgl duAwr kau Cwif kY gihE quhwro duAwr ]
sagal duaar ka-o chhaad kai gahi-o tuhaaro du-aar
Having turned my back on all other doors, I have come to Your Door.
bWih ghy kI lwj As goibMd dws quhwr ]
ba(n)hi gahay kee laaj as gobind daas tuhaar
Please help me, and protect my honor. Gobind Singh is Your slave.
qumih Cwif koeI Avr n iDXwaUN ]
tumahi chhas ko-ee avar na dhiyaaoo(n)
May I never forsake You. May I meditate only on You.
jo br choN su qum qy pwaUN ]
jo bar chaho(n) tum tay paa-oo(n)
May I obtain from You the gifts I wish for.
how can u say nah hum hindu, na muslims
y use guru jis words now
ur hindu
sikhs are sikh the followers of guru nanak
and will never be hindu and will never follow those countless gods
guru gobind singh ji told us to have rehat
he said if u didn’t have rehat then ur not a sikh
guru ji has left us the shabad guru SGGS to guide us
to moksh
to freedom when we leave this body
that is true freedom when we achieve enlightment
if we didn’t have SGGS the preist would be taking advantage of the population and tell them hey u can achieve this if u give me so much money
that is wht guru ji was against
that is wht guru ji wanted to stop
that is y he left was SGGS so we wont be blind and left astray by blind fools
if we aren’t following a true guru then we are just blind and running around blindly
so tell me how are u supposed to get to that moksh
with outs any guidance
does a child automatically start to write or read
he needs a teacher and that teacher is SGGS
SGGS IS THE ONLY TEACHER WE NEED
Once u are one with shabad guru then are liberated
The yogis can only go take there swas to heaven and when they come back down they are still affected by the 5 evils
I know u hindus are like unorganized and don’t have one doctorin
Then y have any doctrines y have temples y have the word hindu
Y u wane just achieve moksh tell me how u achieve it
“"Hinduism is a religion with a strong sense of dharma. It cannot accept anything or everything that calls itself a religion as true. From its point of view religion should be a moksha-dharma and a yoga-pantha, a teaching that gives inner liberation and projects a path to achieve it. Its purpose is not to make one subservient to a particular God, prophet, guru, savior, holy book, church or institution but to free us from all external bondage e.g. "Na hum Hindu, Na Muslman" rejecting all superficial identities and accepting the true identity of "Self". Religions which do this are not true moksha-dharmas or spiritual paths but just additional forms of conditioning that keep us trapped in the worldly mind and its egoistic motives."”
U said teaching that inner liberation well y a teaching
Y have teaching
Doesn’t that make u bonded to one thing
So u are saying that one path isn’t that keeping u to one religion
Doesn’t that become one religion
Or are u saying there are many way to reach moksha or liberation in Hinduism
Tell us those different ways
Lets hear it
Wht u mean worldly minds and egoistic
Well u are saying that is one is a hindu then they are free from ego and worldly desire
Wht
So just automatically they become free from it
Haha
That is bs
Well in Sikhism we are taught to keep god on our mind and not money and to be truly free from the wordly u have to live in it and be free then not go in to jungles
Wht are the way that u hindus say are to moksh dharma to liberation
Hah I wanne hear
And y would guru ji want write gurubani when he wanted us to be free
Y
Well ji he wrote it so others couldn’t mislead us
Ppl like u
Let me guess it just gone a simple answer that u just be a good human and that is all
ya take off the singh from ur name
[%sig%]
Re: Guru Nanak Religion??
akjamritsar · 16 Feb 2007
what a draw back of sikhi ? , the childern of sikhs even don't know abt her Father.
bhai nisister singh ur mother father don't tell u abt guru.
u know even internet not provide u right information
sikh-history , wikipedia etc
[%sig%]