Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

khalistan questions

khalistan questions

shere punjab · 17 Feb 2007

I was wondering why did so many khalistanis work with pakistanis isnt this some of the worst mistakes made in history by sikhs. Personally i think it was extremely dumb for some many khalistanis to trust and ask pakistan for help it just destroyed are reputation and humilated sikhs in front of the world.

Re: khalistan questions

sunny87 · 20 Feb 2007

after operation blue star .around 1986 87 onwards lots of sikh youth crossed into pakistan for training in camps run by the isi in lahore.i reckon the kharkoos of say the late 80s operation black thunder time upto the early 90s was more deadly than the blue star era.if you look at most of the top singhs in the khalistan movement all was trained in pakistan ie.lt general karaj singh thande btfk.surjit singh penta also of the btfk.lt general malkiat singh ajnala kcf.panthic commitee spokesmen jagir singh .and nirvair singh to name but a few. [%sig%]

Re: khalistan questions

Sitara · 20 Feb 2007

Agreed, Even to this day some Sikhs are gullable in thinking that Pakistanis have their best interests at heart (e.g World Muslim-Sikh Federation) while at the same time I have seen so many Pakistanis insult Sikhs behind their backs

Re: khalistan questions

sunny87 · 20 Feb 2007

yea they tried to make a divide between the sikhs.and hindus and other races.i was reading an article by a bloke who was platoon leader of the elite n.s.g commandos who was sent to punjab/this bloke also faced paki militants in jammu an kashmir.he said the sikh militants was the hardest toughest fighters he ever come across during his service .the muslims he said were cowards who broke easily during interegation.were as the sikhs fought like lions in the punjab. [%sig%]

Re: khalistan questions

Prabhjoyt Singh · 21 Feb 2007

although paki muslims are very untrustworthy i think many khalistani singhs see the friendship with pakistan as a case of "an enemy of the enemy s a friend" [%sig%]

Re: khalistan questions

Harinder Singh · 21 Feb 2007

Pakistan will help anyone who will fight new delhi. At the time of 84, singhs needed arms to fight new delhi and it was pretty logical of them to get it from pakistan. yes trusting pakistan was a big mistake if someone did it. Pakistan is nobodys friend. The main reason for failure of khalistan was that the people of punjab dint deserve it. Unless the sikh kaum starts to japp naam with complete jugti and starts keeping rehit, they wont get khalsa raaj. THere is a very special way of japping naam and without it, maya will keep on getting the better of sikhs and sikhs wont be able to become nirbhau sant sipahis.

Re: khalistan questions

CSJ · 21 Feb 2007

"THere is a very special way of japping naam and without it, maya will keep on getting the better of sikhs and sikhs wont be able to become nirbhau ant sipahis." PLease tell us that jugti [%sig%]

Re: khalistan questions

Man Singh · 21 Feb 2007

I feel friendship with pakis was OK. But they should have strated Khalistan from Nankana sahib. If Sikhs liberate nankana sahib, Indian side will never be the problem. Sikhs did the reverse. Moreover purpose of `sare jagat me khalasa panth raje' gets defeated the moment a narrow map of Khalistan is prepared. No map is needed. Whole world is our map and let's start from nankana sahib and not from Amritsar as Amritsar is 95% liberated and belongs to Sikhs. I am sure all anti terror countries will help Sikhs if they start efforts to occupy nankana sahib and Pakistan occuupied Sikh lands.

Re: khalistan questions

Harinder Singh · 21 Feb 2007

<> I hope its not a sarcastic comment. Only tyar bar tyar naam abhiyaasi charrdi kala Punj Pyare can tell this jugti. Get pesh at a charrdi kala amrit sanchar and you will know the gurmat way of japping the True Naam.

Re: khalistan questions

CSJ · 22 Feb 2007

please dont take it wrong way. I thought some people use some jugtis that is why i asked. i didnt mean what you thought [%sig%]

Re: khalistan questions

shere punjab · 22 Feb 2007

I know my comments are going to offend people but honestly. Khalistan strikes a nerve in me because it hurt sikhs more then it did good first by going over to pakistan so muslims can insult us saying we came bagging them and kissing their feets and if hindus want to they can say sikhs ran over to muslims begging the same muslims who raped their women killed inocent sikhs and spit on them and mock them.

Re: khalistan questions

shere punjab · 22 Feb 2007

I know my comments are going to offend people but honestly. Khalistan strikes a nerve in me because it hurt sikhs more then it did good first by going over to pakistan so muslims can insult us saying we came bagging them and kissing their feet. You have pakistanis insulting us. Sant jarnail bhindranwale wasn't it indira gandhi who found him.

Re: khalistan questions

singh1984 · 23 Feb 2007

Sikhs jus do not deserve something like khalistan. The sikhs are the most corrupt kaum in the universe right now. If i was from another religion i would have spit in a sikhs face everyday. OUR MOST SACRED PLACE "HARMANDIR SAHIB" WAS ATTACKED. OUR BROTHERS KILLED INSIDE THE PARKARMA , OUR SISTERS AND MOTHERS RAPED IN SIDE DARBAR SAHIb BY SOLDIERS, BUJANGIS KILLED. AND YET WHEN YOU MEET A SIKH ON THE ROAD AND TALK ABOUT 84 HE JUST WALKS AWAY SAYING HE DOESNT CARE AND IF YOU GO TO PUNJAB THEY JUST LAUGH AT YOU AND CALL YOU A TERRORIST. sometimes i imagine why the muslim religion is spreading so faster then a greater religion like sikhism. But then i realize because its the love the muslims have for their religion that is spreading this religion. IF SOMEONE WAS TO ATTACK THE MUSLIMES MECCA, IM SURE THAT THE MUSLIMS WOULD BURN THE WHOLE WORLD DOWN. BUT US SIKHS? it not even 20 years since the attack happened and sikh people are saying that it "strikes a nerve" when you talk about khalistan. DAMN!!!! WE PEOPLE OF PUNJAB DIDNT DESERVE TO GET THIS GREAT RELIGION. MAYBE DHAN GURU NANAK SAHIB SHOULD HAVE TAKEN AVTAR SOME WHERE ELSE. Maybe those people would have been more worthy of sikhism than the cowardly people of punjab.

Re: khalistan questions

Harinder Singh · 24 Feb 2007

Dear singh1984 I agree that the punjabis and indians never deserved to become sikhs as a whole but I dont agree with what you said about muslims. Sikhs are just 2% of indias population but still managed to give a befitting reply to new delhi. ON the other hand there are more than 20 crore muslims in India and get direct or indirect support from pakistan and entire arab world, but still could do nuthing much when their babri masjid was attacked. Whole of the arab world leaders have sold themselves to USA. Shias and sunnis keep on killing each other. I feel the muslims are in a mess. INfact without Satguru, the whole world is in a mess. Regarding the current halat of sikhs, well without rehit no one can be called a sikh, without Naam drirh, no one can discipline their minds. I dont consider the present "sikhs" as sikhs unless they keep rehit and japp naam according to Gurmat.

Re: khalistan questions

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 24 Feb 2007

singh1984...u hit it right on the head, brother remember when some newspaper drew some dispicable pictures of the Prophet Muhammed Sahib, Muslims lit the whole world on fire. If Punjabis are stupid enough to still want to stay a part of a country raped them, urinated on them, defecated on them, murdered them in cold blood ...then they definetley don't deserve to be called Sikhs, maybe these people are better off being called Hindus. Prof Darshan Singh said it best when he said u can't be a SIkh and not be a Khalistani. The two are one in the same. It's been 23 years since Operation Bluestar...and till this day we havent got so much as an apology, forget justice. Just remember for every action, there is always a similar re action of equal force. Singh1984, i promise you we will get satisfaction...either in this world or in the next. I promise you. As for India, I believe that wretched country is way beyond any hope of repair. Let it become so corrupt and full of koor that it rots, burns to hell (and takes Brahmanism with it) and everything in it dies....in hopes that it may one day be re born Khalas, pure, full of pyaar and respect. I firmly believe the further Sikhi stays away from India/Brahmanism/Hindusim etc...the more it will flourish.

Re: khalistan questions

DutchiSikh · 25 Feb 2007

There is something wrong with the Punjabis. Most so called Sikhs who are proud to be punjabi or jatt are really messed up, i see it happening with my own family and friends. A couple of weeks ago I had a heavy disscusion with a punjabi friend of mine. He was talking about the greatness of Punjab. But was is great about Punjab today? Half of it is turned into Pakistan, what was left in India has become Haryana etc. and what not. What is left is ruled by people who love to drink alcohol more then Amrit. Today Pagri is sign of the shaan of a punjabi! Sikhi doesn't matters at all. But back to my friend. According to him Punjab is great of its punjabi people. This is totally wrong! Punjab is not great because of the Punjabis, or bhangra or its nature, it great because Sikhi started their. It's great because the ground is filled with blood of Shaheeds of the Khalsa panth. Only Sikhi made Punjab a land to be. Otherwise it would be just as croocked as Afghanistan. The nature of Punjab is beautifal because Guru jee touched it with his hands. The air is filled with bani that's why it gives you a good feeling when you walk their.

Re: khalistan questions

Man Singh · 26 Feb 2007

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamnai Jee, are you preaching escapism? Esacapism is never a problem. India is the root of Sikhism. Sikhs were kicked out of Pakistan in 1947 along with all follwoers of religion of Indian origin. Yes a lady of no Imaan dharam Indira Gandhi did a nonsense, rajiv gandhi and his goondas butured Sikhs like a gang of dacoits burting innocent villagers. But should we blame poor innocent Hindus fro the sins of congress goondas? As landlords apointed by muslim invaders tortured dalits, Brahmins blamed the same way congres goondas committed crime and Hindus are being blamed. I feel Hindus are still slave of gangs of Mao, marx, macaueye and Mohamemd. Their temples are controleld by non Hindus including Muslims(AR Antule), Athiests(Communists in Kerala and bengal) and Christians (samuel rajshekhar RedDy in Tirupati). People thought after freedom 68 teeraths will be cleaned and taken care. But nothing happened. Hindus are taxed for their pilgrimage while Muslims are given haj subsidy out of money looted by secular government of India from all major Hindu temples. I feel condition of Hindus is worst then Sikhs. Aty least Sikhs have SGPC taking care of all Sikh properties while Hindus are looted even today by secular government. Sikhs have more rights as being minorities, Hindus have nothing. A Hindu can not start a Hindu school with government help though rest of rleigions can do that? I feel congress always befooled Hindus and even sikhs are getting trapped by secular propganda in which secular are smart enough to throuw their sins against Sikhs on the ehad of Hindus. Let's understand deeprooted truth behind teh strategy?

Re: khalistan questions

shere punjab · 27 Feb 2007

well bjp rss and congress all need to go to hell, a new party has to start in india.

Re: khalistan questions

singh1984 · 27 Feb 2007

shere punjab let me correct wat u said: "a new country has to me made in india" made by the pure, of the pure, and for the pure khalistan zindabad

Re: khalistan questions

Man Singh · 28 Feb 2007

why only in India why not in pakistan nankana sahib. If we capture nankana sahib, rest of India will definitely ours. Let's hit the root of problem and not branches

Re: khalistan questions

Seeker of the Truth · 28 Feb 2007

If you Sikhs are serious about Khalistan, then y'all should first get rid of your current leaders. They got to be most corrupted and ignorant leaders in the world. These leaders will do anything for money and power including selling out their own people. I also find that many young "sikhs" aren't educated about Sikhi. So I guess you Sikhs need to educate the youth about Sikhi so they can understand about their faith and reasons why Khalistan is a must for your community. Lastly, I get a feeling that the Sikh community is very divided right now. I hear a lot of silly conflicts going on within your community like the whole “chair and table in gurdwara” issue. Maybe you Sikhs should work on uniting your community first before asking for Khalistan.

Re: khalistan questions

shere punjab · 02 Mar 2007

dude we don't need khalistan when we can rule india, india is on the verge of being a super power in 30-40 years why not take this country over. Khalistan can't work face it most sikhs rather live in the west we have pakistan ready to take advantage their the once who started khalistan to get kashmire. Khalistan will turn into a bangeldesh look at the punjab right now. What is india doing to the sikhs in punjab that they need their own country punjab has the second highest per capita income and is considered the best state to live in all of india it was named the golden state. The man in charge of the indian army is sikh the army is made up of 10% sikhs and if they thought sikhs were getting discriminated against then why they in the army the prime minister is a sikh.What about the people in khalistan who were part of the punjab police were would they go. What type of laws would exsist in khalistan whats a real economic plan for khalistan military plan for khalistan. A real one.

Re: khalistan questions

Seeker of the Truth · 02 Mar 2007

Sikhs rule India? HA. Sorry, but I find that to be funny. If Sikhs can't get their religions rights (Sikhi is consider to be part of Hinduism in India) then how in the world do you expect Sikhs to rule India? Do you think the Hindu majority want Sikhs ruling their country?

Re: khalistan questions

Man Singh · 02 Mar 2007

"what are the religions rights of Sikhs that are denied in Hindu majority India' Kindly list them all. A Sikhs has been President A Sikh is Prime Minister A Sikh is Army Chief A Sijh has been CBI director Many Sikhs have been Supreme court Judges Many Sikhs are top Journalists In every arae of Indian social, political and economic life Sikhs represent more then their population. When Sikhs were considered part of Hinduism, every Hindus looked at them incarnation of Guru Teg Bahadur ie `Hind Ki Chadar' and revered them as defenders of Dharma. If separatist menatlity prevails, coming generation of Hindus will start considering sikhs as `just another minority' group without any emotional touch. I am afraid if we are ready to face such emotional isolation in our own country. I know we'll get hurt at their action and may call them ungrateful community. But do we feel that all blame should go to Hindus only? My understanding is that Sikhs represent the purest form of Indian civilisational values continuing tp prevail fro last 10000 year of known history. It is upto us to narrow down ourselves to merely few centiries of take broaden our view to brilliant civilisation that got temporarily degenrated and Sikhs resurrected the same and hence called `Khalasa panth'. I am pretty sure that if Khalasa is presented in such broad way, very easyly within 50 years half of India can be converted to Sikhism without any opposition from any source. But if we continue our narrow sectarian attitude we'll keep reducing further to minority.

Re: khalistan questions

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 02 Mar 2007

A Sikhs has been President ....Manmohan Singh A Sikh is Prime Minister.... Zail Singh A Sikh is Army Chief....JJ Singh Many Sikhs are top Journalists....Kushwant Singh Sikhs????? Don't make me laugh "When Sikhs were considered part of Hinduism" -Man Ji, pls read 'Hum Hindu Nahin' by Sardar Kahn Singh Nabha. Clear up some of those ignorant views you hold. If Sikhi=Hindusim, then Christianity (and Islam for that matter) = Judaism. The whole world has recognized Sikhi as a great Wolrd religion. In fact its the 5th largest world religion. When do u plan on catching up to the rest of us? Accept it at move on with your life. Hindus will not tell Sikhs (us) who we are and who we aren't. Sikhs will determine who Sikhs are. We will struggle and fight with everything we got to make this point crytsal clear. We will have our autonomy, you'll see. Good day! Raj Karega Khalsa!!

Re: khalistan questions

Seeker of the Truth · 03 Mar 2007

LOL I agree what "Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamnai " stated in his post. Man Singh, The Sikhs you have mention have done nothing positive for Sikhi. Where were these Sikhs at during 80's and early 90's? Manmohan Singh was even elected by the people of India to be the PM. Zail Singh isn't highly respected by the Sikh community. Kushwant Singh is nothing but a sell out. JJ Singh? I don't know too much about him, so I wouldn't comment on him. The point being that only way Sikhs will succeed in India is if they sell out their own people and/of beliefs.

Re: khalistan questions

Man Singh · 03 Mar 2007