Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

shere punjab · 22 Feb 2007

I would like to know if sikhs are treated like second class citizens and how.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Dalbiri · 23 Feb 2007

I feel in the U.K. the Sikhs are generally not on the radar unless they are pushing a negative image of us i.e. gangs and stuff in the newspaper. I think Sikhs have become second class citizens through their own actions anyway. Lack of political acumen and backward practices being mainly responsible.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Seeker of the Truth · 23 Feb 2007

Huh? Are you talking about only Sikhs in India or Sikhs in general? In Canada, Sikhs generally have it good.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Dalbiri · 24 Feb 2007

I know SOT. I was mainly talking about U.K. But truthfully, if a bunch of Sikhs were going on like the so called Indo-Canadian "gangsters" do in Vancouver they would slaughter us in the media over here, so I guess you lot get light treatment by the Canadian media and authorities (apart from Bolan). Be aware of and appreciate that.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Bachitar Singh · 24 Feb 2007

Of course were second class citizens. In Canada Sikhs are a problem for the people. The majority of people regard sikhs the same way that america regards mexicans. Meaning there not happy with our presence.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Seeker of the Truth · 26 Feb 2007

I personally think the Canadian media and Canadian government don't care about the whole Indo-Canadian "gangsters" issue at all. I mean all these gangsters do is kill their own people. So why would your average Canadian care about minorities killing each other? If anything, they want us to kill each other.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Dalbiri · 26 Feb 2007

Ok SOT, but what you would probably get here is a subtle media campaign that would say "look at these bunch of animals" without ever directly saying it.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Seeker of the Truth · 27 Feb 2007

<<>> What are you talking about? Sikhs (or should I say Punjabis?) are one of the most successful people you can find in Canada. Punjabis are top of the food chain in the desi community. Punjabis are well represented in the Canadian parliament.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

A Singh · 28 Feb 2007

All over the world Sikhs are not very strong in influencing. for example using media effectively in highlighting their concerns. That why hats off to the Muslims, dispite the drawbacks they use the media effectively.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Bachitar Singh · 28 Feb 2007

Do some real research and instead watching whats on the telly. Wow in Canada sikhs have elected members in the parliment, so what we have elected sikhs in india, and we are still regarded as second rate citizens there. Everyday there is discrimination. Just by the looks people give Sikhs. It all depends in the population density in canada. In an area where there are a lot of sikhs there is no problem. In areas where sikhs aren't big in numbers they get discriminated. It's called a hate crime. Being stared at in a wrong way is discrimination.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Seeker of the Truth · 01 Mar 2007

Huh? So I can take someone to court for staring at me? lol I am sorry, but as a Canadian, I find that to be funny. Compare to other countries, Punjabis rarely get discriminated at all here in Canada. When was the last time you heard of a hate crime committed on a Punjabi in Canada? Unlike India, Sikhi is recognized as a religion in Canada. Unlike the U.K., Sikhs here in Canada don't face threats from Muslim extremists and/or white racist parties. Unlike the USA, most people here in Canada know what a Punjabi is and know the differences between a Sikh and Muslim. So don’t tell me that Punjabis are treated like crap and are not well respected in Canada. If you think you’re being treated like second-class citizen, then instead of whining about it, do something about it. I am sure that the Sikh gurus told y’all to defend yourself and fight for your freedom and basic human rights.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Man Singh · 01 Mar 2007

Media management if a money game Mr A Singh. Muslims have 66 countries using all political and economic might for islam. To built a mosque, they do not need any donation from public, one sheikh from Arab countries donates few millions and mosque is ready. Tere are no elections for management committee as membership doesn'nt mater for them. Sheik puts a man of his choice tere and that';s it. recently muslims pf south asian origin told me that they were being discriminated by Arab Muslims and hence planning to build their own mosque but lack funds. The day style of functioning of Mosque will be like grudwaras, you will see their real face. Therefore no need to remove your hat for those closeminded people who have not tasted freedom yet. Of course we should be more creative and put our resources of media managemnet as well along with routine focus of spritual developement. Focus of Muslims and christians is merely capturing the follwoers and not spritual developemnet. We, being spritual in nature, focus less on capturing power and more on sprituality. That is where we are lagging behind. The day on whcih we will understand the the power of media, it will be managed adequately. Thanks for highlighting the important issue and creating awareness among readers abt media importance.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Bachitar Singh · 01 Mar 2007

Seeker of the Truth I don't even live in Canada. Secondly I do stuff about. Third alright you say in Canada we are treated equal. Wow thats tough. So we ran away from our homeland because of discrimination and now your proud big man. Even though you admit sikhs are rarely discriminated in canada the point is they still are. Just because people in Canada do not act out there prejudices it doesn't mean that they don't have them. [%sig%]

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Seeker of the Truth · 02 Mar 2007

<<>> Bachitar Singh, I was born and raised in Canada. I didn't run away from anyone. I am a Canadian, not an Indian. You got to remember that everybody gets discriminated. Sadly, you cannot stop ignorance and prejudices in this world.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Sardar · 03 Mar 2007

first of all, for those who think India is such a bad place for Sikhs to live in, go there and see it for yousekf. You may find this funny or maybe even disturbing, but Sikhs are very well respected in India. Just because you will be wearing Kurta Pajam, Dastar, and Kirpan from the ourside, some cop isn't going to come up to you and start beating you up for following Sikhi. India is not what you think it is. Just because of 1984, it doesn't mean Sikhs are hated or discriminated in India. I mean where else in the world do you start hearing Path or maybe even Kirtan in AmritVela? It's only India. Hindus themselves respect Sikhs. So stop hating Hindus. Hindus do not laugh at a Sikh either. In case you maybe wnodering where I live, I live in Canada, [%sig%]

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Seeker of the Truth · 03 Mar 2007

Sardar, If Sikhs are so respected in India then how come Sikhs don't have any religious freedom? According to the Indian constitution, Sikhi is part of Hinduism. Also, how come Hindu laws like "Cow protection laws" are enforce in Punjab (non-Hindu state; majority Sikh state)? If Hindus (Indians in general) don't laugh at Sikhs, then how come Bollywood keeps making anti-Sikh movies and keep making fun of Sikhs in their films?

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Bachitar Singh · 04 Mar 2007

Sardar you have no idea what you are talking about. You like the rest of the idiots in punjab are getting screwed without you even knowing it. The brahams have changed there stratedgy against us. Now they flood us with drugs an alcohol. Just stating the obvious, but what they really doing that is bad is messing with our land. Have you notice how expensive land has gotten. Everybody is selling there land and making nifty profits for what? You buy a couple of cars this and that. Now what are you going to do when you run out of that money. Sikhs don't get accepted in services. We no longer have that land to grow food. Now you have a bunch of starving sikhs. Then again who cares were getting a big payoff today. Let our kids worry about that right. Yeah shame on you people that say nothing is happening in our punjab our homeland. Sardar you live in Canada so how can you say what India is like. Just because we have an uncle tom for a prime minister doesn't mean that sikh's are equal there. The common occurance I have seen is that unless **** has happen to you, people flat out say it doesn't happen. [%sig%]

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Man Singh · 05 Mar 2007

"Seeker of the Truth" Ji, can you enlist which freedon of religion Sikhs do not have in India? Is killing the cow is included in Sikhs religious rights and ban on it hurts freedom of religion of Sikhs? It is surprising me? I feel there should be a rational criteria how to evaluate if a community is being treated equal to another or not? I feel Sikhs in almost all araes of social life have representation well above their population. Politics, Administartion Police army sports bussiness and where not? So far as Bollywood is concerend it is controlled by and funded by mafia and smugglers like dawwob Ibrahim and ridiculing all religions of Indian origin is seen everu now and then there. Kindly enlist bollywood moves and let the readers know in how many moves Sikhism is moked and in how many Hinduism is moked. I am pretty sure ratio will be 1:1000 Yes even one instance should be stopped and it is possible when you have your own film makers and funding. Unless films are funded by Muslims dons, you can'nt stop it. Therefore India or people of India can not be blamed for that. Bachiter Singh ji, it is not only Prime Minister, Army Chief Ex-Airforce Chief ex-CBI dierctor ex-Chief justice ex-Home minister and many more. Bussiness leaders like Patwinder Singh and where not? Punjab is among btop two rishest states in India.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Bachitar Singh · 05 Mar 2007

Have you ever heard the term uncle tom. So what your gonna say that KPS Gill was a great man because he held a high post. Man Singh what is the capital of punjab, oh wait we don't even have our own capital. What is are main source of water, oh wait we can't control it because it is blocked by a damn. Two sikhs killed Indira Gandhi what happened many more sikhs had to die. Tamils assisnate Rajiv Gandhi nothing happens to them. You say bollywood is content with sikhs, do you have a recolation of what Amitab Bachan said about the sikhs. From the way you talk you have never been to punjab. It is because of people sikhi has gone to the pits. Where are all the sikhs in punjab. All I saw were a bunch of clean shaven people. People like you are worthless, what do you have to say about the claim I made a couple post before. Don't forget we have already declared Khalistan either your with us or against us.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Sardar · 05 Mar 2007

OK. Question: What is the Capital of Punjab? Answer: Chandigarh. What did Amitab Bachan say about the Sikhs? Tell me. Where is all the Sikhi in Punjab? What do you think of Punjab? What do you think of Sikhi? Are you one of those people who have the mentality that if its not AKJ, its not Sikhi? Those who follow Sikhi in Punjab, follow Sikhi, those who don't follow Sikhi in Punjab, don't follow in Sikhi in Punjab. UNDERSTAND????? GOOD!!!!!!!! Those who are clean shaven in Punjab, are clean shaven in Punjab. What's up with you people living in other countries? Why do you have such a bad image of Punjab and it's people? You see the exact same stuff here in Canada, maybe even worse. Then why do people say people follow Sikhi so much in different countries? Now if someone was to say something bad about AKJ in any part of India, then that would be seen wrong cuz AKJ is according to you is always good and theres nothing wrong with them doesn't matter what part of the world it's in. If the same thing was said about TAKSAL, then people would maybe agree . [%sig%]

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 05 Mar 2007

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh just because your born into a sikh household or have SIngh in your name doesnt make you a GurSikh eg KP"S" Gill, Manmohan "Singh", PK"S" Badal, and the list goes on and on. One who worships Nirankar, Akal Purakh Waheguru and only Waheguru (No ram, krishan, ganesh, Hanuman Laxmi Mooratian or whatever), Recognizes only Guru Granth sahib Ji as his one and only true living Guru, Recognizes and has love for all of humanity as his brother or sister regardless of whether he is Muslim/Pakistani or not, follows strict GURMAT/KHALSA Rehit can have the privaledge of calling himself or herself a Guru Ka Sikh. And just because your born in Hindustan, doesnt make you a hindu. Very nice post, Bachitar Singh Ji :-) Here is a translation in english Of Sant Ji's speech. Read carefully and enjoy Man Sahib. Best of wishes ! THE SIKH RELIGION IS DISTINCT They are not prepared to accept Sikhs as a distinct Nation. I had a conversation with Subramaniam and Ram Jethamalani. They consider themselves to be wise persons. They asked (me): "How are the Sikhs a separate Nation?" I said: "If I prove it will you agree? They answered: "In that case, perhaps". I told them: "The (Sikh) Nation has some attributes that set it apart. Sikh Scripture Is Different Our religious authority is different from that of other people. Khalsa Ji: Qura'n has thirty chapters, Geeta has eighteen. Geeta nowhere provides for a Muslim to attain heaven. Geeta does not provide for the deliverance of a Muslim. In the thirty chapters of the Qura'n nothing is written about the deliverance of a Hindu. But the place where we are sitting today, in the Guru (that it belongs to), in the Beloved Guru (Siri Guru Granth Sahib) whom we all revere; Kabir Ji, the weaver, is seated; out of Cobblers, Bhagat Ravidas Ji is seated; of Potters, Beni Ji is seated; of Jats, Dhanna Ji is seated; of Brahmins, Jaidev Ji is seated; of Washermen, Namdev Ji is seated; of Barbers, Sain Ji, the barber, is seated. Who did not get a place here? A Hindu can not touch the ground with his forehead in a mosque. In a Hindu temple, a Muslim cannot touch the ground with his forehead. But has anyone ever been turned away from this (the Guru's) door? This is our uniqueness. Only Sikhs Have Free Kitchens If you travel in this world - I too have had the opportunity to go out in Hindostan to a few places. I have been to Gaya. The Budh Temple in Gaya cost four crores of rupees to build, but if anyone wants a drink of water, he has to pay half a rupee for a glass of water. You will get it for a price, not free. The row of people getting free food will not be found in a mosque or in a Hindu temple. Nor will it be found in a church. The row of people getting free food is only found in the court of Guru Ram Das, Guru Nanak, Guru Gobind Singh Sahib. You will not find it elsewhere. Why The Opposition To Sikh Identity? Jethamalani said: "I consider the entire population of Hindostan to be a Nation". I said: "How many countries are there (in the world)?" He said: "117." I said: "There are 117 nations. If you accept the existence of Sikhs as the 118th nation, would some calamity strike?" He answered: "None". I asked him: "Section 25 of the Indian Constitution says Jains are Hindu, Budhs are Hindu, and Sikhs are Hindu. If the entire population of India is one nation, what was the need to specially name these three in the Constitution?" He said: "I have no answer". Here is a lawyer of the Supreme Court (of India). He charges twelve thousand rupees for each hour of debate and he says: "I have no answer". It is not in my control that there is no answer. "You tell me if we are a separate nation or not. Why don't you accept this? Is it because this is a Nation that wishes to live with a sense of honor, it is a Nation that wishes to live with self-respect?", I asked him. Sikhs Have Always Stood For Justice For All He (Ram Jethamalani) said: "Hindus are being unfairly treated, there is communalism in the minds of many Sikhs." I asked him: "When the agitation against the emergency (1975-1977) was going on, were handcuffs put on Longowal?" He said: "No". I asked: "How about Tohra (Jathedar Gurcharan Singh Tohra, President of Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee), Talwandi (Jathedar Jagdev Singh Talwandi), Badal (Sardar Parkash Singh Badal, former Chief Minister of Punjab), other Sikh leaders, Bhindranwale?" He said: "No one was handcuffed." I asked him who arrested you? He said: "Hindus". I asked him who were arrested (at that time)? He said: "Hindus". I said: "What then was the need for us (Sikhs) to launch a protest (against the declaration of national emergency and curtailment of civil liberties) from the (Akal) Takhat Sahib? (It was because) we believed in brotherhood of all, we had love for humanity. We had firm conviction in the teaching: Naanak Naam Charrdee Kalaa(n) ["Nanak says: God's Name is glorious"]. We followed (the teaching): Tere Bhaane Sarbat Daa(n) Bhallaa ["There is good for all in accepting Your will"]. That was the reason we started the agitation from here. Now you tell (us) how many out of your community of 660 million went to jail to protect your rights, and how many out of the community of 17.5 million courted arrest to get you released?" He said: "You had more". I told him: "Now we are struggling on behalf of all Punjabis. We are not making demands. We are asking for our rights, only our rights. And we have to get our rights, it is not that we are not to get them and all this is idle talk. We have to get them even if it means we are cut up bit by bit. We have to get them under all circumstances." Khalsa Ji: when I asked him: "Tell me this. Here the Akali Dal has assembled the entire Sikh Panth in this protest. Out of our 660 million Hindu brothers, how many have courted arrest? How many have gone with us to get us out of jails?" He (had no answer and) was quiet. Khalsa Ji: the Congregation should please pardon me but the weakness is in ourselves. When we sit on this stage and speak, why don't we talk about the Sikh Nation being distinct? The weakness is ours. We are sinners of the house of our Guru. Laws Discriminate Against Sikh Beliefs And Practices Sikhs are a distinct Nation. It is not (really) necessary to be so called but from the worldly point of view and other reasons it has become necessary. When you have to go to a foreign country, if you have been married here according to Anand Karaj (the Sikh marriage ceremony) in the presence of our Guru (Siri Guru Granth Sahib), you will have to certify in writing that you were married according to Hindu rites, not according to Sikh religion in the presence of the Guru. Else you will not be able to travel. Son of a Sikh cannot inherit his paternal property till he is 17. If Chhalli Ram (a Hindu) is born to Talli Ram (Hindu names contemptuously coined by Sant Bhindranwale), he is heir to his father's property at birth. For these reasons it is necessary to have us declared a separate religion in the Constitution. We cannot acquire more than 17 acres of land, we cannot own property (beyond this limit). But if Gulli Ram is born to Chhalli Ram, even if the property is worth four crore (forty million) rupees, he is the owner of that property. This is (the yoke of) slavery around our necks. Sikhs Not Allowed Free Travel In India The country is free, but a line is drawn. A person who has a turban on, whether he belongs to the Congress party or is an Akali or a Communist, cannot reach Delhi during the Asian Games. But a fellow who has cut his hair, is associated with a Hindu there, can go. Isn't this slavery?

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 05 Mar 2007

LOL Challi Ram, Talli Ram, and Gulli Ram ahahah. You gotta love Sant Jarnail Singh Ji's sense of humour :-)

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Seeker of the Truth · 07 Mar 2007

Man Singh, <<>> Example: When a Sikh couple gets married in India, they receive a Hindu marriage act certificate instead of a Sikh one. <<< So far as Bollywood is concerend it is controlled by and funded by mafia and smugglers like dawwob Ibrahim and ridiculing all religions of Indian origin is seen everu now and then there. Kindly enlist bollywood moves and let the readers know in how many moves Sikhism is moked and in how many Hinduism is moked. I am pretty sure ratio will be 1:1000>>> Does a movie “Jo Bole So Nihaal” ring a bell? As for your ratio, I disagree with it. It is more like 1:10 films. Sardar jokes and “12 o’clock” jokes are commonly used in these bollywood films. [%sig%]

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Man Singh · 07 Mar 2007

"Seeker of the Truth " Ji, These are just two reasons why you feel Sikhs are treated like second class citizens. Let me share my views on them: 1. When a Sikh couple gets married in India, they receive a Hindu marriage act certificate instead of a Sikh one. My views : Marraige certificate concept is a Britsh concept and we are carrying a burden of slavery by following British traditions. This act is neither Hindus nor anything else but British. My opinion is that this should be named as `Indian marriage act' applicable to all communities just like any otehr country. 2. “Jo Bole So Nihaal” ring a bell? As for your ratio, I disagree with it. It is more like 1:10 films. Sardar jokes and “12 o’clock” jokes are commonly used in these bollywood films. My Views : I am 100% with you on this issue. But almost all Hindi moves I have seen in my life make a mokery of Hinduism more then Sikhism. Almost in every Hindu move a Hindu temple is shown as place of vice in which Hindu priest is shown gazing at young women with malintentions. Sardarji jokes are creation of British Raj. Every marshal race of India they tried to ridicule. What we call freedome was nothing but change of signature from Mountbaten to Nehru and nothing more then that. Side by side I understand there are many jokes about almost all communities in India. Beharis, benagaulis, Avadh nawabs and many more. But I am pretty much with you that Sikhs definitely don'nt deserve that and practice should be stopped. Sikhs have to react for that. I understand for the rest of social life in India Sikhs are well respected especially by Hindus. Sports, defence, bussiness, education, government jobs, festival celebrations and where not? Sikhs are leading light of India in all areas. Of course seculars loyal to congress have done many mischiefs against Sikh and all blames of their mischief is put on Hindu heads.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Bachitar Singh · 07 Mar 2007

Hinduism is not a religion. There is no defination to it and it's holy books are only full of mischief. Hindu's don't like the sikhs because Siri Guru Granth Sahib shows us the kind of idiots they are. If our relationship was good with hindu's then why does the RSS keep messing with us. Why is it that they keep changing our history and baani. Who the hell are they to do that? Hey Mr. Man Singh. Have you seen the movie L.O.C. How come there is only one sardar in there, while the majority of people who died there were sardars.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

shere punjab · 09 Mar 2007

whats the movie L.O.C. All i got to say is sikhs need to take over india from the inside because are own country would turn into a bangledesh since most sikhs prefer living in the west. Sikhs have the potential and doors of oppurtunity to take india over from the inside. Make india count on the sikhs and we will control india.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

High Spirits · 09 Mar 2007

Apparently Government/Council wants to build a 'Mega Mosque' for the London Olympics. Are the Olympics not a mixture of all faiths? Shouldn't there be, for example an Interfaith Centre where any person of any religion can pray? It kind of highlights where Government chooses to spend money and how other faiths are treated differently maybe because of numbers. http://www.cbn.com/CBNnews/83805.aspx There is a link to vote in favour/against the proposal (don't know what good it will do though): http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/poll/poll-18791-details/ques-18669-id/%C2%A3100m+mosque:+Vote+now/poll.do What does the Sangat think?

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Man Singh · 09 Mar 2007

Bachitar Singh ji, did Guru Teg Bahadur sacrificed to protect `Idiot' Brahmins of Kashmir? If Yes, it was an foolish act unworthy of a great Guru if No then you are wrong somewhere?

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Bachitar Singh · 09 Mar 2007

LOC is a movie about kargal. If you haven't seen it you should. It's funny how these brahmans get all big and brave in the movies, but when s**t goes down there no where is sight. That being said. If punjab is such a great place then why did everyone leave in the first place. Once we get Khalistan tell me that you wouldn't want to be there. Think of how great of place it will be.

Re: Are sikhs treated like second class citizens

Admin · 10 Mar 2007

Topic Closed