Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is Gatka Not A Real Weapon?

Is Gatka Not A Real Weapon?

gupt · 08 Mar 2007

vjkk vjkf Came across this article today, can anyone please comment Is Gatka not a real weapon? (Amrit Pal Singh 'Amrit') On one of their websites, my 'Sanatan Sikh' brothers have displayed a picture and have given a description, which goes like this: - Unlike Gatka, Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya employs real weapons such as those depicted in the photograph above that are designed to kill with one blow ('Chatka'). One may think that they are trying to say Gatka is not a real weapon. What is a weapon? A weapon is an instrument of attack or defense in a combat. I would rather say that any thing, which is designed, or can be used for inflicting bodily harm, is a weapon. Is a wheel of chariot a weapon? One would say, "No, not at all". Krishn used a wheel of a chariot as his weapon in the battle of Mahabharat. It was the ability of a warrior (Krishn) that he used a wheel effectively as a weapon. If any self-styled warrior is sufficiently not expert, then even a sword or spear is but a toy, not weapon for him. Otherwise, a few self-styled Nihangs would not have sought Police protection in Punjab, though they keep so many weapons. There is no use of such exhibition of weapons, if one cannot use them to protect himself. As I have quoted above, my Sanatani brothers say: Unlike Gatka, Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya employs real weapons.... It gives impression as if Gatka (Kutka) is not a real weapon. Are they right? Let me permit quoting Sarbloh Granth, which is considered a sacred text by my Sanatan Sikh brothers. The word Kutka has been mentioned along with other weapons in this book: - Phari As Dhhaar Kutka Lohaangi Chhuri Saihathi. And, Barchhi Bhasudi Garheeya Bhairav Chakti Chaprha As Saang Sipar. Tomar Sail Chhuri Bichhuya Gun Baan Khatang Shamsher Tabar. Kaati KutKa Mungra Sota Taral Taal Bisaal Khanda Charam. Dhan Saayak Chaap Silimukh Ghoch Jamdaarh Sipar Bichhuya Balam. Not only Kutka, but Sota (club) too is mentioned in stanza given above. 'Kutka', 'Sota', 'Lashtika' and 'Laathhi' (stick) are mentioned with other weapons in Sarbloh Granth. Sarbloh Granth mentions mighty warriors using even Gulel (catapult), Brichh (tree), stones and mountains as their weapons in different battles: - Garha Bajr Gulel Chhauti Chhipri. Gada Grisht Chakr Naal Triselang Mandri. Sahithi Sool Kuthhaar Jambuya Bhangri. Moosal Brichh Pahaar Lashtika Mudagri. And, Kaheen Sota, Kaheen Laathi, Kaheen Chakti Chale Bheeham. And, Mer Mudgar Taal Paathar Vage Kotan Kot. Sail Prabat Guraj Gophan Gadaa Jamdhar Sot. 'Laathhi' We have a historic reference, when Kutka was used in a battle. It was battle of Bhangaani, the first battle fought by Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself. Kripal Das took part in this battle and used Kutka as his weapon. He hit Kutka on head of Hayat Khan and killed him on the spot. Description of this battle is given in Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Ji, where we find these lines: - Kripaal Kopeeang Kutko Sambhaaree. Hathhee Khaan Hyaat Ke See Jhaaree. Uthhee Chhichh Ichhang Kadhha Mejh zorang. Mano Maakhang Matkee Kahn Phorang.7. (Catching hold of Kutka, Kripal got full of wrath. He hit it {Kutka} on head of Hayat Khan. The brains of Hayat Khan erupted from his skull in such a way, as if Krishn breaking the pitcher have brought the butter out of it). (Chapter 8, 'Apuni Katha', Bachitra Natak, Sri Dasam Granth Sahib). It is clear from the quotes given above that 'Kutka', 'Sota', 'Lashtika' and 'Laathhi' (stick) and 'Gulel' (catapult) etc are real weapons, which had been used in various battles. Actually, my brother, Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya Gurdev, followed Mahan Kosh without considering other facts. When he saw that Mahan Kosh says that Gatka is used to teach the first limb of club fighting; he thought it is used only to teach. He accepted views given in Mahan Kosh that Gatka is used to teach, but he then went further and 'to teach the first part of club fighting' (as defined in Mahan Kosh) became 'training with sword and shield'. At last, he reached on conclusion that: - .... 'Gatka'/'Gatkabaji' (also known as 'Patabaji'), is but training with sword and shield. When he says, ".... 'Gatka'/'Gatkabaji' (also known as 'Patabaji')...., he accepts that Gatka is 'Pata' and Gatka-baazi is 'Pata-baazi'. It means that he believes that the word Gatka is synonymous with Pata. If Gatka is 'but training', then same would be with Pata, i.e. Pata is 'but training. Now, please allow me to quote Sarbloh Granth, in which Pata has been mentioned being used as a weapon in various battles. The word Pata has been used in this Granth many times. Here are only a few examples: - 1. Pata Phekant. Bichhuya Khedant. 2. Sela Daarat. Hreh Hakaarat. Pata Bhramaavat. Saang Pathhaavat. 3. Kaheen Bichhuya, Kaheen Naavak, Kaheen Pata, Gulel, Moosar. 4. Banaiti, Pata, Lastik, Bhind Darun Tamaal-r-Taal Sar Punjan. 5. Lakut, Saif, Pata, Banaiti, Sool Tichh Kripaan He. In Mahan Kosh, where the term Gatka is explained, Phari also is mentioned. In Sarbloh Granth, even Phari is mentioned among weapons used in battles: - Phari As Dhhaar Kutka Lohaangi Chhuri Saihathi. Thus, we should accept that Gatka is a real weapon. [%sig%]