Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Comparison of Sikhism vs. Christianity

Comparison of Sikhism vs. Christianity

Singh · 18 Mar 2007

By Rawel Singh Anand The Gospels are full of Jesus' praises, miracles performed by him, his crucifixion and resurrection. It is was the basis of selection? Is this how scriptures come into being? The Christian missionaries say that Bible is the Word of God. This does not appear from the contents of the New Testament. In which the only notable words attributedsaid that the four gospels were chosen. out of about forty existing at the time of selection. Who cho them what to God are "This is my beloved son in whom I am well pleased. The reader may be aware of more gospels like the Gospel of Judas coming into news lately. There thus seems to be no authenticity of the New Testament. All religions have scriptures and life histories of their preceptors. Any doubts about the latter can be resolved in the light of the scriptures but in the case of the New Testament if the Gospels are in doubt, nothing is left. In the Gospels the only part of real spiritual value is the Sermon on the Mount. This does not find in two of the four gospels and in the other two the details and language are vastly different. Many parts are not common between the two. Also whereas throughout the Gospels the names of persons and places are mentioned both the latter gospels say 'a mountain'. This casts doubts whether the sermon was indeed delivered or it has been added in the two gospels later to show something spiritual. OF CHRISTIAN CONVERSION AGENDA MISSIONARIES Wide networks of Christian missionaries of their various denominations exist all over the globe. Missionary work is a legitimate activity of a faith to keep its followers and those of the other faiths informed about its faith. However Christian missionaries have an agenda of obtaining conversions from other faiths. They say things in such a manner that others get convinced. It needs to be stated at the outset that it is not the intention to criticize or denigrate Christianity as a religion but only to point out the types of things they say. For example they tell people that Jesus Christ was born to a virgin mother and is therefore the son of God; he gave his life for the sins of all and should therefore be accepted as a savior by all and that he rose from the grave walked the earth and was later carried by the clouds to heaven. No person with a reasoning power can accept these things as reasonable. Such things certainly make their presentation interesting but not convincing. That is why people including some Christians raise questions about these. That is why there are more atheists in Western countries having Christianity as he main religion than elsewhere. The purpose of this article is to find out the truth so that one is not misled by the tactics of the Christian missionaries. The Bible is the scripture of Christianity. It has two parts called the Old Testament and the New Testament. The Old Testament is accepted as the scripture by the Jews, Christians and Muslims. Torah which comprises of the first five books of the Old Testament finds frequent reference in the Muslim scripture the Quran as does the New Testament. The New Testament covers the period of Jesus Christ and thereafter. Christians believe that the prophecies made by the earlier prophets and contained in the Old Testament were to be fulfilled in the New Testament. Those of major interest say that a Messiah was to come who would be the savior of the Jews. The Christians believe that Jesus was the Messiah. It is well known that a prophecy is taken as fulfilled if that happens on its own. However the New Testament is at pains to see that these prophecies connected with the Messiah apply to Jesus. It is interesting to note that whereas the Quran accepts Jesus as a prophet it does not accept many things that the New Testament claims about him. The New Testament has three parts. The first part dealing with the birth, life and crucifixion of Jesus comprises of four Gospels. The second part contains the book of Acts describing the situation after Jesus' death and letters written to various destinations asking them to accept the new religion and is in the form of propaganda. The third part called Revelation shows the imagination of John about Jesus in heaven. The It 2:255). Sri Guru Granth Sahib the scripture of the Sikh religion says: God is everlasting; He is neither born nor He dies; He is indestructible and pervades all (Page 758). The Old Testament says: You shall fear the Lord thy God and serve Him and shall swear by His name (Deuteronomy 6:13) It is therefore surprisimg that Jesus is given status equal to God. But there seems to be a reason for this and that is to project Jesus as high as possible so that his stature is seen higher than the others and is easily accepted. In order to improve acceptability many stories have been made in connection with Jesus. They are like fairy tales as are told to children or to impress people. For example they say thmay come as a surprise to many that Jesus was not the founder of Christianity although it carries his name. He was born and died as a Jew. Establishment of Christianity was due to the efforts of Paul and Peter. Paul was opposed to Jesus during his lifetime and converted later. Jesus, referring to the laws made in the Old Testament had said "Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled" (Matthew 5:18). But Paul went against this and said "But before faith came we were kept under the law, shut up unto the faith which should afterwards be revealed" (Galatians 3:23). Jesus had condemned the practices of the Jews during his lifetime which was responsible for his crucifixion. Paul's utterances poisoned the relations further exacerbating the antipathy. Jesus had said that he had come to fulfill the earlier scriptures. Once Jesus asked his disciples "Whom do men say that I Son of man am" (Matt 16:13). To this they named earlier prophets. He asked them again "Whom say ye that I am"? Peter replied "Thou art the Christ, the son of the living God" (Matt 16:16). Jesus complimented him and said "Thou art Peter and upon this rock I shall build my church" (Matt 16:18). He did not say that a new religion would be founded. It later transpired that Peter did not believe Jesus and Jesus told him "Satan: thou art an offence unto me" (Matt 16:23). Later the same Peter thrice denied that he knew Jesus (Matt 26:70-74). Peter's conduct described above indicates that he satisfied Jesus' expectation of endorsement and sycophancy; he did not have faith in Jesus and his denial shows that he had no commitment to Jesus. But it was on him the Jesus had intended to build his church. Jesus had said beforehand that Peter would deny him thrice but did not revise his statement about Peter being the foundation of the church. Also Peter was the only disciple of Jesus who had gone to see the grave after it was reported that Jesus had risen and gone (Luke 24:12).This would show that the church that came into being after Jesus was based on seeking endorsement, sycophancy, lack of faith and denial. This may seem blasphemous but that is the only inference that can be drawn from the scriptural references given above. The way Christianity came into being it was natural that fissures should occur among its followers. This is what happened in course of time. At present there are numerous denominations of Christianity differing from one another in many ways. They also seek conversions from one another. A lot of blood was shed in the intercine So next time when a Christian missionary comes and asks you to convert ask him the number of Christian denominations and which denomination he wants you to join. He should also be advised to first establish unity within his faith and then ask others to join his faith. Who would like to go where such divisions exist? Please tell him we are happy where we are. Christian missionaries are professionals who have been trained in the art of convincing people. They are easily able to convince gullible people of other faiths. So one needs to be on guard when approached by them. They are very sweet to talk to but soon start showing their true colors. For example in the end of 2004, the Tsunami waves caused extensive damage particularly in Indonesia. Many organizations went for aid among which were Christian. While the others provided help it was heard on the television channels that while there were only some percentage of Christians there then but after some time they would all or mostly become Christians. What a pity that even at that time of suffering these people could think of converting people simply by providing aid. Those receiving aid beware! Christian missionaries choose those areas for their operations where the people are poor and need help. With considerable resources at their command they first establish facilities like schools and hospitals. They tell the people that they have come there to serve. Then slowly they try to attract people to their faith either by offering concessions or preference in employment to Christians. Because poverty is a fertile ground for their operations, Christian missionaries say that poverty is a gift of God. They literally try to buy the poor people's conscience with their resources. Is that service? All religions teach that tempting people is sin. Even their own Bible says "Man does not live by bread alone, but by every word that comes fro the mouth of God" (Matt 4:4). They should be asked why they are asking others to come to Christianity when they do not themselves follow it. They should be politely told "No thank you, we are happy with our own religion; at least we practice it". Christian missionaries talk of God once in a while but their main emphasis is not on God but on Jesus. They emphasize that the only way to salvation is by accepting Jesus Christ as the savior. They do not hesitate to equate him to God but also call him god. All those who believe in God can never accept this position. How can a man who is born qnd dies be given this status? For them the only one fit for worship is one God. All faiths are unanimous on this. The Hindu scripture Gita says: God is the goal, the sustainer, the master, the witness, the abode, the refuge and the dearest friend. He is the creation and the annihilation, the basis of everything; the resting place and the eternal seed (9:18). The Quran says: God, none else is fit for worship; He is everlasting, neither dozes off nor goes to sleep. Whatever is in the heavens or earth is all His (at Jesus was born to Virgin Mary through the Holy Ghost and therefore Jesus is the son of God. This is an attempt to project as truth something which in reality was different. The first story goes like this. God sent an angel to Mary to inform her that she would bear a child without the usual process of impregnation. This was done because it is forecast in the Old Testament that a virgin shall give birth to a child (Isaiah 7:14). the word used in the original Hebrew version of the scripture uses the word 'Almah' which means 'young woman'. Similarly the original version of the New Testament in Greek uses the word 'Parthenos' which again means young woman. It is only in the Christian versions of the Bible the word virgin has been used. It is a pity that such attempts should be made in respect of scriptures just to show that Jesus' birth was miraculous. The New Oxford Annotated Bible mentions young woman1. There are two widely different stories about Jesus' birth. The first story says that when Jesus was born, a star appeared in the East. Some people were sent by the king to go and search where he was born; they departed and the star went before them stopping where the young child was (Matt 2:9). An amusing story yes, but can it be true? Probably the author of the story wants people to believe that stars are so near the earth that a star can indicate the location of a house? Since the star appeared on Jesus' birth it should have been there during his life time but there is no mention of what happened to it after that. This type anomaly occurs when astory is made up. Here is the second story. Jesus' mother had been informed by God's angel "The holy thing which shall be born of thee shall be called the Son of God" (Luke 1:35). This was supposed to be a gift of God. The mother gave birth on due date and "Wrapped him in swaddling clothes, and laid him in a manger; because there was no room for them in the manger because there was no room for them in the inn" (Luke 2:7). It is obvious that parents of the unborn baby were staying in an inn at the time of his birth. It is worth pondering whether a gift of God would be thrown into a manger like this. Even if the child was not considered a gift of God, but a child born under normal circumstances would any parents be so cruel as to put their newly born child in a manger? The story of no room in the inn has been made just to explain why the child was put in the manger. The real reason is that like other things it is an effort to show that the prophecy in the Old Testament "Voice of him that cries in the wilderness" (Isaiah 40:3) was being fulfilled and prove that Jesus was the Messiah. Making comments on a preceptor is not a matter of happiness; in fact it is one of sadness because one does not know what to believe. Neither of the stories seems to be true. This casts doubts whether a personality with the name Jesus ever existed. The Gospels do not give further details of Jesus' life until he is about 30 years old. At this age he was baptized by John the Baptist according to the Jewish practice. Here is the next fairy tale like story. "And lo the heavens were opened unto him, and he saw the Spirit of God descending like a dove, and lighting upon him. And lo a voice from heaven saying, this is my beloved son in whom I am well pleased" (Matt 3:16-17). Jesus was then made available to the devil to be tempted. He was asked to turn stone into bread but he refused tshow a miracle saying "man shall not live by bread alone but by every word that proceeds out of the mouth of God" (Matt 4:4). When the devil promised him all the kingdoms of the world and glory if he worshipped the devil, Jesus told him "Get thee out of hence Satan for it is written, thou shall worship the Lord thy God, and Him only shall thou serve" (Matt 4:10). After this the devil left him and angels came and Jesus assumed ministry at the age of 30 which lasted for about three years. With this the process of Jesus performing miracles started during which period he also taught people including saying that no one could go to God, the Father except through him. He also said "And no man had ascended to heaven but he that came from heaven, even the Son of man which is in heaven" (John 3:13). If Christianity teaches that no one except Jesus shall go to heaven, and every one wants to go to heaven, then why should any one become a Christian? The highlight of the period from then on is performance of miracles by Jesus is one of pain for those who do not accept any one equal to God. Jesus is shown to say and do things agaist which he had himself taught. Given below are some examples of this. Bible (Matt 15:4) asks man to honor his father and mother, but when one of his disciples asks permission to go and bury his dead father, Jesus does not allow him saying "Follow me; let the dead bury their dead" (Matt 8:22). On another occasion when he was informed that his mother and brother wanted to meet him, Jesus said "Who is my mother? And who are my brethren"? Then pointing his hand towards his disciples said they were his mother and brethren. He further said "For whosoever shall do the will of my Father which is in heaven, the same is my brother, and sister and mother" (Matt 12:47-50). It is agreed that one should not have attachment to one's relatives but not letting bury one's father or refusing to meet his mother does not seem right from any standards. Or was he trying to convey that either his family did not believe in God or he could not get along with them? Jesus had said "Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth" (Matt 5:5), but when a man asked Jesus to cure his son of lunacy, he lost his temper and said "O' faithless and perverse generation, how long shall I be with you abd how long shall I suffer you? Bring hither to me" (Matt 17:17). There are three significant points in this. Firstly a divine person could not have used such contemptuous language and secondly this language was used for a whole generation, not just one man indicating everyone was bad. This is very antithesis of spirituality. Thirdly it cuts at the very concept that Jesus had eternal life since he himself asked how long he would be there. That means he was like any other mortal Similarly when some Jewish leaders asked him to show them a sign from heaven he used still more offensive language when he said " A wicked and adulterous generation seeks after a sign and there shall be no sign given unto it" (Matt 16:4). Again once when Jesus was hungry he went to a fig tree but found no fruit on it. He lost his temper and cursed the tree "Let no fruit grow on thee henceforth for ever" (Matt 21:19). Jesus made another strange statement. He was asked why his disciples did not wash their hands before eating. His reply was "Out of the heart proceed evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, fornications, thefts false witness, blasphemies; these are the things which defile a man but to eat with unwashed hands defiles not a man" (matt 15:19-20). It must be accepted that clean mind is essential, but surely that does not justify not washing the hands before eating which is necessary to prevent contamination. The Bible including the Ten Commandments teaches against adultery. On the other hand in the Western countries where Christianity is the predominant religion no body talks about it. Pre-marital and extra-marital sex is taken as a way of life. The institution of marriage is not respected. The only subject of discussion in this regard is whether abortion should be freely allowed or restricted. This virus is spreading fast. We need to practice the principle of sex-with-spouse only and protect our children against casual sex, by teaching and example. The Gospels are full of miracles performed by jesus. As mentioned above he had initially refused to perform the miracle of turning stones into bread. Later, after cleaning a man of his leprosy, told him "See you tell no man but go your way, show yourself to the priest and offer the gift that Moses commanded for a testimony unto them" (Matt 8:4). Afterwards however he started performing miracles frequently. These included curing of fever, restoring eye sight, cleaning of leprosy, removing lunacy, exorcising evil spirits, reviving the dead and feeding 5000 people with a small quantity of bread. There were so many and it appears that that is for what Jesus had assumed ministry. At least that is what the Bible indicates. John the Baptist e sent two men to Jesus ask he was the Messiah. Jesus replied "Go your way and tell John the things you have seen and heard: how the blind see, the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, to the poor the gospel is preached" (Luke 7:22). It seems very strange that a spiritual teacher instead of saying what he did to remove ignorance and lift the people spiritually talks only of miracles. This is confirmation of the fact which many religions teach, that one who performs miracles goes on a path that leads away from God. This is clear from the fact that initially he refused to perform a miracle and when he did, he did not advertise but asked the man to go and make an offering. Oce he got busy in miracles it was only praise of him that mattere.Men of God are in fact ashamed even to talk of miracles. According to them miracles are nothing but tricks of a magician: Performance of miracles is like a play, they are evil Men of God are ashamed even to talk of them. It appears that as Jesus performed more miracles he not only started thinking but calling himself God. For example he asked his disciples to go to the village and bring an ass and a colt which they would find there. He further told them that if any one questioned you say "The Lord has need of them" (Matt 21:3). On another occasion he told his disciples "you call me Master and Lord; and you say well; for so I am" (John 13:13). He not only equated himself to God but said that when he sits on the throne of glory, his twelve disciples would also sit on the throne and judge the twelve tribes of Israel (Matt 19:28). All this shows that he had started feeling proud. It is an accepted fact that God likes humility not pride. It appears that because of this pride Jesus drifted and was ultimately forsaken by God. As we have sen above he had started using intemperate language. This was the first sign of his losing sing sight of God's presence. After this, performance of miracles took him further away from God. This was felt by Jesus when a woman touched his garment. He said "Somebody has touched me for I perceive that virtue has gone out of me (Luke 8:46). Jesus' drifting away from God resulted in his spirit being weakened. For example at a meal which is called the last supper, he broke bread, gave it to his disciples saying "Take, eat: this is my body". He took the cup and after thanks gave to the disciples saying "Drink ye all of it; for this is my blood" (Matt 26:26-29). Then he said "My soul is exceedingly sorrowful, even unto death: tarry ye here, and watch with me" (Matt 26:38). After he was crucified at the cross some people mocked at him saying he saved others let him save himself and come down from the cross. Jesus felt helpless and cried "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me" (Mark 15:34). In spite of all this Christian missionaries do not tire of saying that Jesus alone can save. Who will believe that one who has been forsaken by God can save others? Another thing they say is that Jesus gave his life for many for remission of sins (Matt 26:28). Except for such statements there is nothing in the Bible to show that he died for others. Jesus was punished based on accusations by the Jewish priests. They had said "We have the law, and by our law he ought to die, because he called himself the son of God". So Jesus died because being a Jew he broke the law. Also those who die for a cause do not try to avoid death but he did not want to die. The Bible says "And he went forward a little and fell on the ground, and prayed that if possible the hour might pass from him", and he said "Abba, Father, all things are possible unto you; take away this cup from me; nevertheless not that I will, but what you will" (Mark 14:35-36). It is significant that he said all this even before he was arrested and tried. It appears that some people have taken this statement of Jesus dying for sins of all seriously because they are convinced that whatever they do, they will be saved by Jesus. This seems to be the reason for the minds being in turmoil and violations of scriptural teachings rampant. A little thought would tell that no one can die for the sins of others. The principle of you shall rep what you sow is universal. Whatever good or evil man does goes into his account and he is judged accordingly. That is the concept of judgment day in the Semitic religions and the account maintained by Chitra-Gupt in Eastern religions. The Christian missionaries also talk of Jesus' second coming i.e. he is to come again. They use this to attract people to their faith. In this connection they quote chapter 24 0f Matthew in the New Testament which talks of destruction of the temple, wars, famines and earthquakes ang then Jesus will come. They also say that situation in the world is now building up as given in the bible so Jesus is coming. Thy say this despite Jesus saying "Verily I say unto you, this generation shall not pass till all these things be fulfilled" (Matt 24:34). Jesus was referring to his resurrection and not a later period. Resurrection of Jesus when he is reported to have risen from the grave is considered the foundation of Christianity. The Bible says "If Christ be not risen, then is our preaching vain, and your faith is also vain" (1 Corinthians 15:14). That means Christianity is based on a dogma and not on teachings. If this dogma is in doubt what happens to the Christian religion? The details of resurrection given in the four Gospels significantly differ from one an other which indicates that the details are not based on personal knowledge but hearsay. For example they all differ on who went to see the grave, what or who was found in the grave, where did Jesus go after rising. One person who was there in all cases was Mary Magdalene. She is considered to have had close to Jesus and was present at his crucifixion. In one of the accounts she fids a man standing next to the grave but thinks he is the gardener, whereas actually it was Jesus. She realizes this when he calls her by her name. It may be said that if she did not recognize the man it was not Jesus. The Quran gives considerable details of Jesus' life. The whole of chapter 19 is devoted to Jesus' mother Mary, which the Bible had omitted. The Quran accepts Jesus as a prophet and acknowledges his miracles. On the subject of his his crucifixion however it says "and their saying surely we have killed the Messiah, Jesus son of Mary, the messenger of God, and they did not kill him nor did they crucify him, but it appeared to them so and most surely those who differ therein are only in doubt about it, they have no knowledge respecting it but only follow a conjecture, and they killed him not for sure" (Quran 4:157, translation by M.H. Shakir on web site The Koran). It appears a look alike of Jesus was crucified. If Jesus was not crucified the question of resurrection would not arise. All in all the story of resurrection cannot be true. Children going to Christian run schools need to be educated in their own religion and also told to be ware of attempts at conversion because they are slowly brain-washed and then motivated to become Christians. The author wishes to admit that writing this small pamphlet has not made him happy, in fact it has made him sad for criticizing someone. It is again emphasized that the purpose of writing was to suggest caution when confronted by Christian missionaries and not to find faults with their religion. Yes it is strongly felt that dogmas take one away from the essentials of religion and should not be its basis. 1 Michael D. Coogan, ed., The New Oxford Annotated Bible, 3rd Ed., New York: Oxford University Press, 2001, p. 988. See Isaiah 7:14 in the Hebrew Bible section.

Re: Comparison of Sikhism vs. Christianity

nitn3m · 24 Mar 2007

1. I studied at a Christian primary and secondary school and this article is nothing less than an attack on Christianity. I do agree that people need 2 be aware of missionaries who are trying to convert other religions into Christians, however saying that stories about Jesus are fabricated is truly wrong. You said: “On another occasion when he was informed that his mother and brother wanted to meet him, Jesus said "Who is my mother? And who are my brethren"? Then pointing his hand towards his disciples said they were his mother and brethren.” Does the Guru not say something similar to us i.e. “thoon maeraa pithaa thoonhai maeraa maathaa; thoon maeraa bundhup thoon maeraa bhraathaa.” Guru Ji has also stated that Sangat is vital to attain a good Sikhi life. 2. You also stated in the article that the stories of Jesus being born to a virgin mother and the whole idea about being born in an Inn was a ‘fairytale’; however we cannot say whether this was true or not. The story of Guru Nanak Dev Ji being born could also be stated to be a fairytale as when he was born the midwife stated that he was born smiling and not crying unlike every other baby which the midwife had delivered. So it is unfair to see that Jesus’ story is fabricated; even if the story is wrong it still preaches some essential facts which we could employ in our life; Jesus was the saviour who was born in an Inn and placed in a manger; this shows humility which we should have at all times as GurSikhs. 3. It has also been stated that Jesus performed miracles like the cleansing of leprosy; did Guru Harkrishan Sahib Ji not cleanse people of the mumps and similar illnesses? 4. The stories that are in the Bible may or may not be true, however there is always a moral of the story which should be taken from them and we should be practising them in our lives; humility, sharing, helping poor etc is something we should all do. I would just like to end by saying that while this post makes us aware of conversion tactics; I strongly disagree with accusing the Bible of being a book of ‘fairytale’ stories. In my opinion, the Bible is a book that contains stories that help us to live our lives in a better way. Bhula Chuka Dee Maaf Fateh!! [%sig%]