Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

French law bans turbans

French law bans turbans

Rochak Malang · 18 May 2004

http://www.mlive.com/newsflash/lateststories/index.ssf?/base/international-6/1084835653165160.xml French law means Sikhs can't wear turbans By ELAINE GANLEY The Associated Press 5/17/2004, 7:08 p.m. ET PARIS (AP) — Sikh school boys must exchange their turbans for hair nets when a new law banning religious apparel in public schools takes effect in September, France's education minister said Monday, shocking representatives of the Sikh community. From Our Advertiser Education Minister Francois Fillon spoke after education officials adopted — with some misgivings — a set of guidelines to help school officials apply the law, which was enacted in March after a marathon parliament debate. The law forbids conspicuous religious symbols and attire in the classroom, such as the Jewish skull cap and large Christian crosses, but it is chiefly aimed at the Muslim head scarf. Under the guidelines, Muslim girls can only wear bandannas in schools that allow them, Fillon told a news conference Monday. Asked in an interview about the turbans worn by Sikhs, he said an "arrangement" had been made with Sikhs to replace the traditional head gear with hair nets. "We've come up with an arrangement," Fillon told The Associated Press. "They accept wearing a hair net. It's less aggressive, less showy." Representatives of the small Sikh community of 5,000-7,000 said they were unaware of any such arrangement. On the contrary, they said, Sikh representatives had received a letter from a counselor to Prime Minister Jean-Pierre Raffarin, dated May 10, that provided "conditional assurance" that Sikh boys could wear turbans in class. "We were told that we could wear turbans because we never posed a problem," said Karmvir Singh, a Paris member of United Sikhs. Sikhs cover their hair with a turban, compulsory in their religion which originated in northern India in the 15th century. "A hair net has no place and no meaning," said the director of United Sikhs, Hardyal Singh, based in New York. "It's appalling." A phone call to the prime minister's office was not returned. The school guidelines go beyond attire to forbid students from refusing certain courses — like physical education or biology — for religious reasons or rejecting professors based on their gender. The guidelines also forbid absences for religious reasons beyond major holidays. Fillon said it will be up to individual schools to decide whether bandannas — seen by many Muslims as a substitute for head scarves — can be worn. The new law is aimed at safeguarding the French principle of secularism, considered under threat by Muslims' growing militancy over their identity and the practice by some girls of wearing head scarves to school. "The most fundamentalist organizations considered that there was a weakness on the part of the French state and that this weakness could be exploited," Fillon told reporters. Teachers have reported that not only are head scarves increasingly prevalent in some schools, but students are refusing certain courses or contesting the right of a female professor to teach certain topics. Fillon said he expected legal challenges when young girls who defy the law are dismissed from school. "There will surely be organizations that try to test" the law, he told the AP. "But now we have a solid judicial basis."

Re: French law bans turbans

Gupt Singh · 18 May 2004

HAIRNETs pathetic really.. I hope the Prime Minister does something about this the suggestion fo hairnet is COMPLETLY PATHETIC bhull chukk maaf GurFateh

Re: French law bans turbans

Kulbir Singh · 18 May 2004

I am appalled at this very wrong decision by the French Government. They have betrayed the blood of thousands of Sikh soldiers who laid their lives for the independence of France in the first World War. My grandfather spent 3 years of his youth in France, fighting their enemy. Why did they not tell them to remove their turbans? Great gursikhs like Bayoo Mal Singh jee spent many years their and got infected with the terrible diseases like Tuberculosis. Is this how the French thank the people who helped them. French government has proved beyond doubt that they are a thankless nation. What a pity. I have full faith that this bad karma by France will take away Vaheguru jee's gaze of mercy and grace on them. I feel sorry for them. I pray that Vaheguru gives them wisdom to take back this very wrong decision to insult and humiliate the Sikhs who gave their blood for their independence. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: French law bans turbans

Guldeep Singh · 18 May 2004

"Hair nets" How insulting! For what its worth we should lead a boycott of all French Products. ie. cheeses, perfumes and most of all Air France. This directive should come from the Akal Takht to all Sikhs around the Globe.

Re: French law bans turbans

m · 18 May 2004

Air France, just about as good as Air India, and you know where that comes from - straight from the pind!!!!:) If you get my drift!!!

Re: French law bans turbans

The Singhpranos · 18 May 2004

the French come from a long line of cowards..... during WW2 they let the Nazi's march into Paris without even firing a shot..... the French have always been willing agents of the enemy. " did you see the ad which read FENCH RIFLES FOR SALE..... only DROPPED ONCE." Tony Singhprano

Re: French law bans turbans

singh 2 · 18 May 2004

Yesterday United Sikhs released a press notice stating they had been given a 'conditional assurance' from the French Prime Minister on 10 May that Sikh students would not have to remove their turbans under the new law. Today media outlets have run with the above story about an 'arrangement' between the French authorities and Sikh representatives over 'hair nets'. However in the same reports United Sikhs have been quoted as saying they have no knowledge of this 'arrangement'. So who has been making these representations to the French Education Minister? 'Hair nets' have I believe been mentioned in the past in the UK in human rights cases for covering beards when working in food processing plants etc. But how can these nets ever be considered as appropriate substitutes to the dastar? If wearing a helmet on a motor cycle or wearing a hard hat on a construction site is not a viable option for Sikhs, then how can a hair net on the head ever possibly be? [%sig%]

Re: French law bans turbans

Rashminder Singh Oz · 18 May 2004

its pathethic we all should get togeather and do something bout it................ may guru bless all waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: French law bans turbans

Daas · 19 May 2004

Seems as though the frenchies are using the old cover up tactic that we have come to an arrangement, but with who ???? its amazing the gorea at work commented on the stupidity of the french. Gorea normally don't talk about religion and neither do I, but I felt that they sympathised with the fact that what has wearing a turban got to do with being french, being a nationalist or citizen of a country means to live according to the laws of the country, pay your taxes and respect fellow coutrymen. As sikhs do all this where ever they go, it seems just another excuse to oppress minorities who died for the frenchies freedom. It is sad and I do feel for my french brother & sisters who will be faced with this great dilema/problem, I pray that Guru ji helps them to keep their sikhi intact and become stronger in their faith. Vaheguru ji ka khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki fateh..

Re: French law bans turbans

<><><><><> · 19 May 2004

What you need to realize is that this is part of a bigger trend in Europe. European governments are increasingly becoming more right wing...and I wouldnt be surprised to see this happen in a few other countries.