Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Modern Music

Modern Music

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 20 Mar 2007

WJKK WJKF I would just like to get the Sangat's view on listening to non SIkhi related music. I know a lot of hip hop and R&B, rock stuff that comes out these days is obviously manmat (talking about alcohol, drugs, women, material things etc...) but to be honest I still enjoy listening to some of the oldies but goodies. I've always loved Frank Sinatra, Dean Martin (Dinooooo lol) Frankie Vallie, Bob Marley. Another artist that I find quite good is Norah Jones (she sings very calm, laid back songs who also, by the way, happens to be the daughter of Ravi Shankar) Like I said I've always enjoyed listening to their music, but since I've began to get more into SIkhi with GuruJi's Kirpa, keeping Kes and planning on taking Amrit in the near future...I find myself feeling quite guilty listening to this other music. I know we shouldnt listen or watch anything that aggrivates any of the 5 theives, but I dont really feel an increase in Kaam, Krodh, Lob, Moh, ahankar when i listen to it but for some reason I still feel I shouldnt be listening to it... altough i still enjoy it. I would really appreciate the advice and views from the Sangat. WJKK WJKF

Re: Modern Music

Balpreet Singh · 20 Mar 2007

Music is an interesting thing. It has an effect on us. It also has a tendency to stay in our minds. If you listen to something, it will stick in your mind. If you listen to shabads, you will notice they will go through your mind automatically. Same goes with manmukh songs. They too will stick in your head. People can call me a fanatic or extremist, but it is my personal opinion that a Sikh who is serious about their jeevan should avoid listening to songs by manmukhs. These clearly can't have a good effect on us I think. I think as someone grows spiritually they themselves will avoid such things and not like them. Please reflect on the following Shabad: [gurbani]<> siqgur pRswid ] rwgu iblwvlu mhlw 5 caupdy dupdy Gru 6 myry mohn sRvnI ieh n sunwey ] swkq gIq nwd Duin gwvq bolq bol Ajwey ]1] rhwau ] syvq syiv syiv swD syvau sdw krau ikrqwey ] ABY dwnu pwvau purK dwqy imil sMgiq hir gux gwey ]1] rsnw Agh Agh gun rwqI nYn drs rMgu lwey ] hohu ik®pwl dIn duK BMjn moih crx irdY vswey ]2] sBhU qlY qlY sB aUpir eyh idRsit idRstwey ] AiBmwnu Koie Koie Koie KoeI hau mo kau siqgur mMqRü idRVwey ]3] Aqulu Aqulu Aqulu nh qulIAY Bgiq vClu ikrpwey ] jo jo srix pirE gur nwnk ABY dwnu suK pwey ]4]1]81]

Re: Modern Music

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 20 Mar 2007

Thanks for Yours and Guruji's reply Veer Balpreet Singh;-) and no, I wouldn't classify you as a fanatic. Thanks again for the advice

Re: Modern Music

harveen_singh_manchester · 22 Mar 2007

just another thing. as veer balpreet singh already said, it has an effect on you. just like sarbhloh bibek, the person who makes your food should be a amritdharee because it has an effect on you. but this doesnt mean if there is an amritdharee singh singing some hip hop crap it will be pavitr, same with food, if there is a amritdharee making your food who has no jeevan at all your food is not gonna be langar or it won't be pavitr.

Re: Modern Music

jassmannn · 23 Mar 2007

I have another Dilemma for you guys. I have many friends who are not sikhs let alone Amrit dhari, who have done a lot for me over the years. Is it a problem if I east at their houses, or the food that they have cooked for me, which is vegetarian, but made by them? Also on my international travels, why I stay at a hotel, or fly on a plane, is that still ok or not? All of this does not seem to have had an effect on me, what is your opinion on the matter?

Re: Modern Music

Balpreet Singh · 23 Mar 2007

In my opinion it is a fundamental Sikh rehit to keep dietary bibek. This means to only eat food prepared by other amritdharis. If these are your friends, then I'd expect they'd understand. As for flying and hotels: use your judgment. I don't like using hotel beds or other beds that have been used by who knows who. I usually prefer to take my own sheets, etc. In the end, we have to use our own judgment and do what we feel is right.

Re: Modern Music

Harjas Kaur · 24 Mar 2007

[quote]Is it a problem if I east at their houses, or the food that they have cooked for me, which is vegetarian, but made by them?[/quote] One thing about the world, we don't see it clearly. That's because our eyes only see a fraction of the light spectrum. Someone's hands may be washed and clean. They may be very nice people. But there lives will tell us something. Maybe they are a drinker, a smoker. Maybe they eat meat. If we are only thinking, this person is nice, they are clean and we eat that food, we also eat that person's vibration. If the person is non-amritdhari, they have no obligation to live up to the standards of a Sikh. [img]http://www.babaji.net/catalog/photo%20section/Pages/gunanak2th.jpg[/img] Guru Nanak Dev Ji refused to eat at the rich man's table. He explained why he always ate with the poor man. The rich man's roti was dripping blood. And the poor man's roti dripped sweet milk. [img]http://www.auteursdunord.com/IMG/jpg/luminol.jpg[/img] Even if an area looks clean, police detectives using luminol can highlight areas of invisible blood that had been removed years earlier. Just because you don't see something doesn't mean it has no energetic reality. [img]http://members.chello.nl/~j.vastert/kirlian.gif[/img] Kirlian photo showing energy fields of the hand. When you touch something, you leave an energetic imprint of yourself on the thing you touch. Now I'm not saying just because someone is amritdhari they're a great person with automatically high jeevan. But a true amritdhari at least is not committing acts that weaken or break amrit. You cannot guarantee this with a non-amritdhari. Please forgive my mistakes. [%sig%]

Re: Modern Music

Seeker of the Truth · 24 Mar 2007

LOL You got to be kidding me, Harjas Kaur? What makes you think that every amritdhari is pure and good? What makes you think every non-amritdhari isn't pure and good? Besides, what is wrong with eating meat? You sound like one of those Brahmins who don’t eat food unless it is prepared by their own caste. Guru Nanak Ji ate food from those who were pure and good regardless of religion, wealth, gender or caste.

Re: Modern Music

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 24 Mar 2007

"Besides, what is wrong with eating meat? " -Pleassse....this can of worms is better left unopened

Re: Modern Music

Harjas Kaur · 24 Mar 2007

[quote]What makes you think that every amritdhari is pure and good? What makes you think every non-amritdhari isn't pure and good? Besides, what is wrong with eating meat? You sound like one of those Brahmins who don’t eat food unless it is prepared by their own caste. Guru Nanak Ji ate food from those who were pure and good regardless of religion, wealth, gender or caste.[/quote] You don't have to agree. I didn't say every amritdhari was pure and good. I said every true amritdhari has to uphold certain standards of eating and living. For example, if you have a good and nice friend who is not amritdhari, you do not know does he eat meat in the same pot he is cooking your vegetables in. Regardless what you think of this, it's still the case. If someone is trying to keep bibek, they don't want to take the risk. Maybe the person fixing your food is a wonderful person that you can see, but they drink sharab on weekends or maybe is a smoker. Whatever you personally might think about it, someone trying to keep bibek will not want that vibration in his food. Moreover, the point with food prepared by amritdhari vs non-amritdhari isn't about whether they are nice or not, but whether they are committing bujjar kurehits and influencing the food they mix, or whether they are doing paat or Naam simran and making your food into langar. If you don't agree with bibek thats your right. But the reality is most people don't even believe in vibrations. I was showing the vibrational reality of hidden things exists, and for this reason, those who choose to try and live principles of bibek won't want that hidden influence to affect what they eat. Guru Nanak Dev Ji was Guruji. He is beyond corruption and influence. We are not. I never said it is okay to discriminate based on wealth, race, caste, or male/female. I said discriminate the influence that comes in contact with your food, because some energy fields are not something you want to affect your jeevan. By all means, if you want to eat meat, no one is stopping you or even criticizing. If you want to call it brahmin, thats fine too. Personally, I believe subtle energies influence this reality from a level unseen. Fields of energy make an impression. As for the caste comment, I don't even have a caste. It isn't about born into a caste that distinguishes your jeevan. It's how you live your life and what influences you choose to expose yourself to, both seen and unseen. Those unseen factors definitely will affect your spiritual progression. If amritdharis are upholding the rehat maryada and their commitment to Guruji, then their food shouldn't be influenced by some vibration you don't want. When I took amrit, the panj piaras told me not to eat meat. So for me at least, it would be wrong to eat meat or come in contact with a vibration of meat. Bhul chuk maff karni [%sig%]

Re: Modern Music

_lowest_ · 25 Mar 2007

[quote] He [Guru Sahib] is beyond corruption and influence. We are not. [/quote] well said. [%sig%]