Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

300

300

nihang singh · 01 Apr 2007

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh..... a reccommendation 4 the sangat ji, 300 is a very inspirational film and though it is based on spartans it has many similarities with sikhs.... The young soldier who throws a spear at the big rhino .......kinda like bachiitar singh and two soldiers fighting bak to bak kinda like baba botha singh and baba garja singh. Big similarity was small army of three hundred take on hundres of thousands of persians....compared to small army of singhs fighting hundreds of thousands of moghuls etc I got excited when i watched the film so had to share my thoughts with the sangat. AKAAAAAALLL [%sig%]

Re: 300

talikhaak · 01 Apr 2007

Movies are Movies. I'm not disagreeing or debating anything I watch movies myself. But what makes you think is why watch movies like that when you can do sooo much naaam/bani and through his kirpa attain that avasthaa so you can revisit time and see the battles before you as they took place, sabh vadeaaeeaa har naam vich| Sikhi is FULL of it all, a movie can be made on every turn of the century, whether its love, devotion, holiness, war, forgiveness, or loyalty. In Sikhi we've had many 300's when the khalsa would be swarmed by mughal armies and how they fought off the mughals being outnumbered by so many. Bottom line... I wouldn't recommend any Singh or Singhni to watch 300 because it contains sexually explicit scenes, I went with a few singhs, and I just had to turn away seeing all that gundh, because when you watch that you're DOING IT with your mind even though its not with your body. My two cents, Bhul chuk muaf.

Re: 300

Roopkaur · 01 Apr 2007

>because when you watch that you're DOING IT with your mind even though its not with your body.< I have tried many ways of explaining why I refrain from watching tv/movies, and why I think if anyone wants to get seriously spiritual it is best to avoid the negative effects of media. However, I had never thought of this explanation and it is indeed one hundred percent true. I will use it next time!

Re: 300

confused · 01 Apr 2007

just to remind everyone that this movie has some certain inappropriate scenes even though the theme of this movie is soo great kinda inappropriate especially for children [%sig%]

Re: 300

PTE SINGH · 02 Apr 2007

The story depicted in 300 is based on heroism considered among one of the greatest feats of battle in History. As Sikhs, however, we do not have to look towards the Spartans for such inspiration, for the Battle of Sargarhi is also considered by history in the same vein. [%sig%]

Re: 300

nihang singh · 02 Apr 2007

thats the thing...the sexually explicit scenes shows how women were raped and also how women and wealth were used as a means to concert people.....however i understand now why i should not have posted this ....there are sexually explicit scenes and the spartans did kill there babies if there was things wrong with them.... sangat ji i apologise do not watch 300 it promotes kaljug just sit at home insted and do simran or alternatively go to the gurdwara. [%sig%]

Re: 300

Dalbiri · 02 Apr 2007

"and the spartans did kill there babies if there was things wrong with them...." Some "Sikhs" still do that if the baby is simply a girl! Look at our homeland for instance. I think Baba Gurbaksh's shaheedi outside the Akal Takhat (there were 30 of them) against 30,000 odd Afghans is the Sikh equivalent of 300. I saw the movie and thought it was great. I know some conservatives will point out the sexual scenes and whatnot but still. In this day and age, it is movies that are used to convey messages more than anything else. Sooner or later Sikhs will have to face up to this. But the ones that happily go along thinking "all is o.k. as long as I am o.k." will obviously not care a monkey about wider issues than themselves.

Re: 300

Dalbiri · 02 Apr 2007

Read more at :http://www.historyworld.net/wrldhis/PlainTextHistories.asp?historyid=ac44 The Spartan experience: from the 8th century BC The political institutions of Sparta, notorious for their lack of conventional humanity, are said by ancient Greek historians to have been introduced by Lycurgus. But he is probably a figure of legend. Sparta seems to have delevoped gradually as a practical response to unusual circumstances. The valley of the Eurotas river, unusually fertile for Greece, is a rich prize conquered in the 12th century BC by Dorians - few but fierce invaders compared to the settled people they overwhelm. A military society is one way of stabilizing such a situation, with an elite group of soldiers keeping the villagers hard at work. When Sparta emerges in history, in the 8th century, a system of this kind is firmly established. The peasants of Sparta, known as helots, are serfs owned by the state. They do all the manual work of the community, enabling the citizens - an exclusively military caste - to concentrate on warfare and politics. At the age of seven the sons of all Spartan citizens leave home to enter a state education system in which the emphasis is on courage and discipline. Corporal punishment is used not only to punish but also as a test of endurance. This schooling continues to the age of twenty, but there is no evidence that learning to read is part of the curriculum. Girls in Sparta are educated in the same austere virtues, training them to be good wives and mothers. Unlike the boys, they are allowed to live at home. On graduating from this regime, at the age of twenty, a Spartan becomes a member of a group of men, something like an officer's mess, with whom he will spend most of the rest of his life - leaving them only from time to time, after marriage, for the requirements of conjugal life. Gainful employment plays no part in this manly existence. Spartan citizens are forbidden by law to engage in any money-making activity. Instead each is provided by the state with a lifetime interest in a plot of land. This is farmed for him by the state's slaves. The warrior lives off the produce. Sparta is able to provide for its citizens in this way thanks to the conquest of Messenia, a rich plain to the west beyond Mount Taygetos. Messenia is annexed in the 8th century. In the 7th, after an uprising against Spartan rule, the Messenians are reduced to the status of helots - more than doubling the amount of land available to support the Spartan army. Sparta is both strengthened and weakened by this form of exploitation. The weakness derives from the permanent danger that the helots will rise in revolt against their military masters. On several occasions they do so. The constant threat prevents this rigid society from relaxing or developing.