Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Tony Singhpranos · 20 May 2004

i know that you won't eat from a non-amritdhari's hand, but what is your position on pre-cooked foods. (french fries, chips, milk, flour) many a time i have seen a sarbloh using Sikh, munching on some pre-cooked french fries or enjoying a snack of chips or flavored peanuts. i know that french fries didn't come out of the gound that way.... someone or something had to pick the potato, cut it up, deep fry it, and then freeze and package it. Am i to believe that this process is allowable under your strict code. It seems to me that many non-amritdhari persons had a hand in this process. the same goes for the rotis you make... the actual wheat flour is ground from the wheat stock at a mill...... i'd bet a nickle that a non-amritdhari had a hand in your roti. Tony Singhprano [%sig%]

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz · 20 May 2004

If a Sarbloh using Sikh argues that he can't eat food prepared by non-amritdharis, then that Sarbloh using Sikh should eat nothing from a grocery store, because grocery store food, at some time or another, is handled by "manmukhs". I know of one Singh who would open a pack of chips, and swirl the chips around in a Sarbloh batta, and then proceed to eat the chips. Totally wrong becasue the food has already been prepared outside of Sarbloh. Swirling the chips in Sarbloh provides no value added. Also frozen juices would not be allowed as they were prepped by non-sarbloh/bibek/amritdhari people.

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Gaiani · 20 May 2004

Any RAW food is ok, how can u get fruits jootay? Then by following this logic water should be banned too, poeple who eat precooked meals arnt following bebik, but they can still follow sarbloh, just because u do one doesnt mean u do the other, although they should be done together.

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

<> · 20 May 2004

You're so smart tony. Flour isn't ground by amritdharees?? Ha, I bet all those sarblohees didn't know that. Good thing you pointed it out. Maybe you should actually find out exactly what sarbloh and bibek rehits entail before writing commentaries about them. Also, if someone likes to eat or cook in sarbloh once in a while, it doesn't mean that they follow sarbloh rehit. They just like eating in sarbloh. There's a big difference. "many a time i have seen a sarbloh using Sikh, munching on some pre-cooked french fries or enjoying a snack of chips or flavored peanuts." Many a time, huh? Is this just one sikh you're referring to, that you've seen many times, or are you saying you've seen many different sarblohees eating fries? If it's the former, than that doesn't really mean anything. If it's the latter, then please tell me what neighbourhood you live in, in which you see so many sarblohees. Usually, sarblohee singh's aren't very common.

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Tony Singhprano · 20 May 2004

i've seen the chips or flavored peanuts in the batta thing a couple of times....... its always amusing. i'm not taking about sarblohees in particular...but anyone who refuses langer or food at someones home due to it not being prepared by amritdarees. it seem like these people are more concered about the "naam vibe" while cooking, isn't it more important to pray during the sowing and reaping of veggies..... cause you don't know who actually planted the seeds and harvested the products. i want to hear from these people who eat these pre-cooked or pre-packed foods (check your pantry and freezer). Tony Singhprano [%sig%]

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Singh · 21 May 2004

<> i have seen it at Sikhi retreats... the sarblohees refuse to eat with the rest of us...and go eat in a separate room but do not mind putting their cups into the big pateelaa filled with juice...my wife and friends of hers saw this with their own eyes at a retreat a few years ago.

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

... · 21 May 2004

no singhpranos, it's more important about how hte food is cooked.. and how hte food is purchased.. what type of money (honest living or dishonest) these are the two main birbek points - whose money it was bought with and who cooked it. growing? anyone can chuck a seed int he dirt, god gives it life. Harvesting also doesnt matter. the final food preparation is what makes the differnce. after this step, dhe food goes intoo your mouth, so this is the step thaas important yah, some bibeekees drink juuice. Most that i know don't. the guys that do, they prollby follow lesser strict bibek. not like theres official bibek standards, everyone just trying to follow as best as they can, have their own standards.

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

jagroop singh · 21 May 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, ... wrote: "everyone just trying to follow as best as they can, have their own standards". That makes sense to me... :-) Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Singh · 21 May 2004

... are you saying that food goes through distinctive processes in its life and changes in spirituality along the supply chain?? i.e. from seed to the market/grocery store - the food is not affected by those who handle it from market/grocery store to our mouth - the food is affected by those who handle it i dont see food as changing spiritual qualities because of where it is along the supply chain... if you are going to argue that food being cooked by non-amritdharees is spiritually poor, then food grown/watered/picked/transported/stocked/sold by manmukhs is spiritually poor to be honest, I dont think that food really has any spiritual value, and how you cook it does not have value...it is what you do to get the food and what you are doing while you get the food that is important (if you lie cheat steal to get your food, then your food is poor... if you are honest, then you food is pure... if you do simran, while you earn, your food is pure)

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Some Singh · 21 May 2004

Then what is the point of keeping Sarbloh bibek? Didn't Guru Nanak Dev Ji eat at different people's homes? These people were not Amritdhari. Also, why not eat Guru Ka Langar at a Gurdwara? Everyone eats it, everyone is equal. But not eating because it was not made in Sarbloh or by Amritdharees in my mind is discrimination. I myself took Amrit from the Jatha, but I don't follow Sarbloh bibek. wjkk wjkf

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

... · 21 May 2004

singh, no, not from market to mouth. the cooking/preparation stage is the important one. a rehitvaan gursikh preparing food while doing paat and simran is the crucial step. this is where the difference occurs. Just as degh is prepared by a rehitvaan gursikh while doing paat, similarly the food eaten by a sikh should be. you don't see the spiritual benefits? look harder. food prepared and handled and served by rehitvaan gursikhs while doing paat will be like amrit pojaan. other stuff will be like poison. also like you said, it must be obtained through honest means. some singh, the point of sarbloh bibek... maybe when i get time i can write what it's done for me personally. maybe you should read the articles on this site for some points for keeping this rehit. Guru Nanak Dev Jee always ate from his sikhs. not just any old person. for example, bhai lalo and malik bhago. definitely, eating guru ka langar is good. but, it should be prepared by proper maryda. that's what makes it GURU ka langar. not because it's made inside the four walls of hte gurdvara and someone does an ardaas for it. for example, the recent decision at Sri Akaal Takht Saahib on meat in langar in malaysia. prepared in gurdvaras, probably ardaas done for it. should i eat it? No, because i don't think it's proper maryda. Langar in certain gurdvaras in BC. use of tables and chairs and often people bare headed, etc when they make it. should we say it's langar and eat there? no, direct hukam from Akal Takht Saahib against it. Similarly, if langar is prepared by rehitvaan gursikhs following proper marydaa, then it will be GURU KA langar and everyone will partake. nothing to do with equality. equality is in the pangat. sitting in rows to eat, regardless of race, caste, gender, etc. everyone gets served, sikh or not. but the sevaa for guru kaa langar is done by guru kaay sikh, just as guru kee degh is made by guru kaay sikh, following guru kee rehit. not eating might be discrimination in your mind, but preparing langar in such a way is a breach of rehit in my mind. nowadays you even have people getting stuff catered and calling it guru kaa langar.

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Mohan Singh · 22 May 2004

"Some Singh" Bhai Sahib, Firstly if you took Amrit from the Jatha then you probably believe the same Rehat Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji did. Incase you were wondering, Bhai Sahib kept EXTREMELY strict Sarbloh Bibek Rehat. Perhaps you should read his Autobiography if you have not done already. "Singh" if you believe that a God-centred Gurmukh doing Namsimran over your food whilst is is made, is no different to an angry, kaam-filled teenager giving you greasy chips at McDonalds on a spiritual level, then there is little I can say to persuade you otherwise. I am assuming that when you became Khalsa you were not drinking the Guru's ambrosial nectar but rather just water mixed with sugar? Is this correct? How could it have "any spiritual value" in your own words? Guru Nanak Dev Ji did eat at other peoples homes. But he rejected the rich food of Paapis such as Malik Bhago in favour of simple food from the simple and God-devoted such as Bhai Lalo. Let me remind you also that Guru Nanak Dev Ji did not wear a kirpan or a kara; should you remove these also? Because the Rehat was not around at that time it doesnt mean you can disregard it. I believe alot of this questioning of Bibek comes up from a jealousy, hatred or inflamed ego when one sees Bibeki Singhs and believes such Singhs think they are above everyone else. This could not be further from the truth in reality as the Bibeki Singhs I have met exhibit the utmost humility to all. Guru Ka Langar is only Guru Ka Langar if it is prepared according to Maryada. You can touch a kirpan on a beefburger, or prepare it in the Langar kitchen, and it will not become OK to eat. As a non Amritdhari myself I have no problem in not making the Langar, there is plenty of other seva to be done. Guru Ka Langar is to be done by Guru Ka Sikh - it is just common sense. I wouldnt want an adulterer or murderer making my Langar. Next non Amritdharis will be complaining, its unfair they are not allowed to do Panj Seva when Amritdharis are ;) Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

penj · 23 May 2004

bibek means discerning mind- being able to judje certain situations and being aware of right and wrong.this is tru bibek..is it not?

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Mkhalsa · 23 May 2004

>>>>>But not eating because it was not made in Sarbloh or by Amritdharees in my mind is discrimination.<<<<<<< thats what bibek means, discrimination. We are meant to have bibek, tan bibek, bibek of the body, and man bibek, bibek of the mind. Bibek of the mind would involve things such as not looking at disgusting images or thinking dirty thoughts, listening to dirty music. Some would go as far as not watching tv, movies etc. Bibek of the body would involve such things as not drinking alcohol, taking drugs, not eating meat, and some would go as far as keeping more food bibek like not eat from non amritdharis, not eating processed foods, only eating in sarbloh. Bibek is a must, we even say this in our ardas. Many of us make the mistake of having too much haumai to see gursikh rehat, seeing a hyprocrite in bana who makes you disillusioned, not seeing beyond food bibek, or not bothering to even ask the reasons behind it and just ridiculing it up front. I used to do this, and that was stupidity on my part. Even to this day I regret the comments I have made about bibeki singhs in the past, especially after having kept it for so many years.

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Tony Singhprano · 23 May 2004

hey Mohan, being a non amritdhari your lifestyle is worthless according to the bibek singhs...... but maybe they'll let you clean the toilets. lets not get off topic..... i still want to know about these bibek Singhs who chowdown on pre-cook or pre-packaged foods. Tony Singhprano [%sig%]

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Rashminder Singh Oz · 23 May 2004

well said bhai mohan singh ji i myself is not a strict bibeki so far but i agree 100% with u in malaysia gurudwara they do kirpaan bhet to meat langar IS IT LANGAR??? in hazur sahib and anandpur sahib (nihung dera) they do kirpan bhet to chatka of goat and call it mahaparshaad IS IT LANGAR??? in hazur sahib they do kirpan bhet to bhaang (mariuana) and call it sukh nidhaan IS IT LANGAR??? now onwards i have decided that i would never consume langar at gurudwara unless it is prepared by guru ke sikh. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

... · 24 May 2004

singhprano, don't you get it? Bibeki singhs don't eat precooked foods. If they do, than that's a weakness in their rehit, that they will hopefully overcome.

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Mohan Singh · 24 May 2004

"hey Mohan, being a non amritdhari your lifestyle is worthless according to the bibek singhs...... but maybe they'll let you clean the toilets." "Tony Singhprano" Bhai Sahib this is where we differ. What does Guru Sahib say? "Be the dust at the feet of the saints". If I have too much haumai to not accept, that I am the dust of the feet of the saints, then I am not yet ready for Amrit (well miles off really). I still have a huge amount of haumai, much more than you Singh, but I have managed to get my man around the fact that, as a non Khalsa, Nirgura wannabe-Sikh, I am not fit to provide nourishment for the Guru's Khalsa, or participate in Guru Ka Langar when I am not even Guru Ka Sikh. Having spoken to Gursikhs they have told me that as a non Amritdhari, Bibek will not have a huge effect on my spirituality at my level as other things like an early consistent amritvela so this is more important. But they did say that eating out from restaurants in particular was very bad for them. So to all non Khalsas like myself, you can start Bibek also, in the form of not eating out from restaurants (regardless of whether they are "vegetarian" restaurants or whatever) and maybe learning to cook (I still need to learn) Also Tony Bhai, I think your question has already been answered. I know people who do 1am Amritvela, but they still drink alcohol and eat meat! That does not mean Amritvela is bad or useless. It just means in some circumstances some people are not applying Gurmat correctly to their lives. In the same way, so what if a Singh doesnt do FULL Sarbloh Bibek yet? At least he is trying. Perhaps you should try being Sarblohi for 6 months, with an open mind, then you can tell us the results. Until then I do not think there is very much else that can be added to this discussion. Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Singh · 24 May 2004

mkhalsa...i thought bibek meant discipline

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

..... · 24 May 2004

awesome reply mohan singh... it makes my happy to see a non-amritdhari so open minded towards bibek... may guru sahib give you his blessing

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Mkhalsa · 24 May 2004

bibek means discriminating intellect or god-given consience, ie higher conscience, understanding, and discipline than an average person. bibek budhi (or bibek mindset) only comes with naam simran and grace.

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

star · 25 May 2004

perhaps a bibeki singh or singhnee could tell us exactly which food we are allowed to consume if we keep bibek. for example, can we consume dried fruits - e.g. raisins? Also, are we allowed to eat nuts, or do they have to be in their original shell - e.g. walnuts, pistachios?

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Mkhalsa · 25 May 2004

star, all mentioned are ok by me, but i am a kacha pilla so perhaps a real gursikh can answer...

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

A Kaur · 25 May 2004

<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< perhaps a bibeki singh or singhnee could tell us exactly which food we are allowed to consume if we keep bibek. for example, can we consume dried fruits - e.g. raisins? Also, are we allowed to eat nuts, or do they have to be in their original shell - e.g. walnuts, pistachios? <<<<<<<<<<<<<<< From what I know, one is allowed to eat dried fruit such as raisins, as long as they are washed beforehand. Everything that comes out of packaging is to be washed before it is consumed. Regarding nuts, I think a bibeki can only eat nuts that are in shells and don't have any thing added to them such as flavouring, salt, etc. Peanuts, pistachios, walnuts, and any other nuts that are in shells are pretty much acceptable as long as these too are washed before one eats them.

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Rashminder Singh Oz · 25 May 2004

good on u bhai mohan singh ji i feel ashamed on myself, being a amritdhari i from last 2 years i have started practise for bibek now but i can see u to be in chardikala rite from when u chak guru ka amrit.. DEG TEG FATEH waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

star · 26 May 2004

ok to be more specific, are which of the following foods are allowed/not allowed if bibeki? vegetable oil condensed milk evaporated milk baking powder bicarbonate of soda cheese yoghurt golden syrup cocoa powder coffee tea herbal tea chocolate dessicated coconut dried fruit nuts porridge oats yeast icing sugar pasta vinegar [%sig%]

Re: Pre-Cooked Foods....Is it Alright

Mkhalsa · 26 May 2004

it depends on how strict you are willing to be. For one person all of these may be acceptable. For another gursikh, none of this is and only dry parshada and dal are acceptable along with water. It depends on an individual's state.