Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Khands

Khands

uk singh · 07 May 2007

In Jap Ji Sahib it states that Bhagats reside in Karam Khand. If this is the case and they were obviously all of high avastha can we take it that humans cannot attain a place in Sachkhand? Do Karam Khand and Sach Khand exist in such fashion as a house and varaandaah exist?

Re: Khands

Harcharan Singh · 07 May 2007

SikhSpectrum.com Quarterly Issue No.24, May 2006 The Five Khands (Realms) of Japji by Baldev Singh -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Introduction Guru Nanak’s Japji is the essence of Nanakian philosophy (Gurmat), but it is the most difficult section of Aad Guru Garnth Sahib (AGGS) to interpret and understand. There are numerous translations/interpretations of Japji in Punjabi, Hindi, Urdu, English and other languages.1 Unfortunately, they are marked by differences, especially in the interoperation of the five khands (realms). Moreover, they are deeply colored by the influence of Hindu mythology and doctrines. It is astonishing that even modern translators have followed the old ones with minor changes of words here and there. Besides, generally they are “line by line” and “literal” translations. To my knowledge none of the authors has attempted to explain the “substance” of the five khands in a logical and coherent way that is consistent with Nanakian philosophy (Gurmat). In The Teachings of Guru Nanak, McLeod has summarized earlier diverse and confusing expositions of the five khands under the title “The ascent”. He portrays the five khands as five different levels of spiritual development in ascending order. He designates Dharm Khand, as the first stage of spiritual development, which does not seem to be right because Dharm Khand (Realm of Righteousness) is the arena of practice of a gurmukh (God-centered being) who is in perfect union with God. Becoming a gurmukh is the ultimate state of human spiritual evolution according to Nanakian philosophy. I would suggest and argue that the five khands represent five different aspects of God-consciousness (Cosmic-consciousness), not five different stages of spiritual development in ascending order. Discussion I would suggest caution against the interpretation of the khands in isolation. Guru Nanak’s other statements on the subject of khands interspersed throughout his compositions must be taken into account. For example, Guru Nanak’s thoughts about the purpose of human life, gurmukh, Hukam (Cosmic Law/Divine Law) and human mind are of vital importance for the understanding of khands. 1. Guru Nanak makes it abundantly clear in the “Commencing Verse” of AGGS and throughout his bani (sacred hymns) that God is infinite and ineffable and is beyond human comprehension in totality. 2. God is understandable only in Its immanent or manifest form-the Cosmos. 3. In the beginning of Japji on the opening page of AGGS, Guru Nanak has described God as Sach, meaning Everlasting or Truth. Then in the first stanza of Japji on the same page he has enunciated the purpose of human life: “How could one become a sachiara (Godlike or gurmukh) and how could one get rid of ignorance and falsehood?” “By living in harmony with Hukam (Cosmic Law),” says Nanak. AGGS, Jap 1, p 1. 4. Then how could one get rid of ignorance and falsehood? Throughout the AGGS it is mentioned again and again that Sabad (Word, Truth) destroys ignorance, falsehood, superstition and doubt. When the yogis asked Guru Nanak, “Who is your Guru or whose disciple are you?” “ Sabad (Word, Divine knowledge) is the Guru and my mind, which is focused on the Word and comprehends it, is the disciple,” replied Guru Nanak (AGGS, M 1, pp 942-43). What is needed to understand Hukam? It is true knowledge. So a sachiara (gurmukh) is the one who understands the Hukam and conducts himself/herself accordingly. It is for the gurmukh that the True One has fashioned the Earth. AGGS, M 1, p 941. The Earth was created to practice righteousness. AGGS, M 1, p 1033. Dharm Khand (Realm of Righteousness/Moral Duties) In the environment of -- water, air, fire, space, seasons, nights, days and dates -- the Earth has been established as the place to practice righteousness. Creatures of innumerable kinds and names, who have different modes of living, inhabit it. The Creator is just and so is Its court.[a] The five are recognized as honorable in this court. Their deeds are monitored and evaluated and those who meet the approval are honored. One’s inferiority or superiority is determined there. Nanak, on going to the court the worth of each becomes known. AGGS, Jap 34, p 7. a. What is God’s court and where it is located? Guru Nanak gives the answer to these questions in Asa Di Var and other compositions. This world is the abode of the True One, Who resides in it. AGGS, M 1, p 463. This means that God resides in humanity. And it is the “collective human conscience” within Cosmic-consciousness, which is God’s court (dargah). b. Varna Ashrama Dharma/caste system excludes the working masses Sudras and Antyajas (untouchable) from the domain of religion. Furthermore, their work which is service to society is considered unclean and demeaning. Guru Nanak rejected the Varna Ashrama Dharma (caste system) and declared that the five – Brahman, Kshatriya, Vaisya, Sudra and Antyaja2 – have honorable place in God’s court. In the last line of the preceding stanza Guru Nanak says that people are not born superior or inferior. Here he makes it clear that in God’s court the five are equal and every honest work is honorable. Earlier in the sixteenth stanza Guru Nanak has elaborated on the equality and “oneness” of the people divided into five categories by the caste system. The five have Divine approval and leadership qualities. The five are honored in God’ s court. The five would bring honor to office of the King. The five have “One Source” of enlightenment. AGGS, Jap 16, p 3. Gian Khand (Realm of Knowledge) Such is the practice of the Realm of Righteousness (reference to the preceding stanza). Now let us discuss the nature of the Realm of Knowledge. How many are the winds, waters and fires and how many are Krishnas and Shivas? How many are Brahmas constructing structures of different kinds, forms and colors? How many are lands for creative work, and how many are mountains and wandering preachers? How many are Indras, moons and suns and how many are solar systems and countries? How many are Siddhas, Buddhas and Nathas and how many are followers of goddesses? How many are gods, demons and munis (silent-sages) and how many are precious products of the ocean? How many are species of life and their sounds and how many are emperors and kings? Nanak, countless are those who serve and contemplate on God; there is no end to creation. AGGS, Jap 35, p 7. There are four messages in this passage: 1. The limited human intellect in contrast to the infinite nature of the Cosmos. 2. Mythical Hindus deities - Krishna, Shiva, Brahma and Indra are presented as mere human beings. 3. Human intellect can comprehend only a little of the Cosmos-the immanent form of God. 4. One realizes one’s smallness when one contemplates on the vastness of the Cosmos. Saram Khand (Realm of Effort/ Transformation into a Gurmukh) In the Realm of Knowledge, knowledge is supreme. There one experiences the pleasure of music, plays and wonders. But the Realm of Effort is the formation of a beautiful structure (mind). There the mind is reshaped into unsurpassing beauty. This transformation can’t be described. One would regret if one attempted to do so. There the mind develops higher level of God-consciousness, intellect and discernment. There one acquires the genius of a divine hero.c AGGS, Jap 36 , p 7. [c] A divine hero is one who has subdued his/her mind to control Haumai and its progeny of five: Kam (lust, sexual drive), Kroadh (anger), Lobh (covetousness, economic drive), Moh (attachment) and Ahankar (pride with arrogance). Karam Khand (Realm of Grace) The Realm of Grace is the uniond of a gurmukh with God. There a gurmukh merges his/ her identity completely with God. There are powerful and brave warriorse who are saturated with Divine spirit. There they are fully absorbed in the glory of God and their personality is beyond description. Whose minds are filled with God-consciousness, do not die spiritual death or led astray. In the Realm of Grace dwell bhagats (saints) who enjoy the bliss of the presence of the True One in their mind. AGGS, Jap 37, p 8. [d] Here (AGGS, M 5, p 238) jor means union (milap),3 as Guru Arjan has used it in the following verse. O my mind! Fall in love with God. AGGS, M 5, p 238. [e] One who has subdued his/her mind to control Haumai and its progeny of five: Kam (lust, sexual drive), Kroadh (anger), Lobh (covetousness, economic drive), Moh (attachment) and Ahankar (pride with arrogance). Sach Khand (Cosmos) The Formless One pervades the Cosmos where It continuously creates and sustains and blesses the creation. The Cosmos contains continents, solar systems and galaxies, no one can describe it in totality as it contains countless bodies of different shapes and sizes, and it functions according to Cosmic Law. “I am happy to deliberate on what I have seen (what I understand about the Cosmos), but it is as hard as steel to describe it,” declares Nanak. AGGS, Jap 37, p 8. A careful study of the khands reveals as if Guru Nanak discussed the subject of khands with the congregation. For example, he makes reference to Dharam Khand at the start of Gian Khand and makes reference to Gian Khand at the start of Saram Khand. This is similar to what a teacher does during the teaching of course. At the start of a new lecture, the teacher briefly draws the attention of the students to what was discussed in the previous lecture. Conclusion The five khands represent five different aspects of God-consciousness (Cosmic-consciousness), not five different stages of spiritual development in ascending order as described in earlier interpretations. Similarly, panch in Dharam Khand means five categories of people divided by the caste system. The word bani in both Saram Khand and Karam Khand does not mean Word, it means description/explanation and jor in Karam Khand means union/ bringing together, not power. Saram Khand is the development of mind with higher level of God-consciousness, intellect and discernment. Becoming a gurmukh is the highest state of human spiritual evolution. Sach Khand means Cosmos. REFERENCES 1 Chahal, D. S. Jap (The Essence of Nankian Philosophy): A Scientific And Logical Interpretation, Institute For Understannding Sikhism, 2003, p vii: “Dr. Joginder Singh has enlisted over 150 such interpretations only in Punjabi and some in Hindi, Urdu and many in English about 25 years ago.” 2 India by Al-Biruni, Ed., Qeyamuddin Ahmad, third reprint, National Book Trust, India, 1995, p 45- 6: The Hindu society is divided into four castes: Brahman, Kshatriya, Vaisya and Sudra. “ After the Sudra follow the people called Antyaja, who render various kind of services, who are not reckoned among any caste, but only as members of a certain craft or profession. They are eight classes of them, who freely intermarry with each other, except the fuller, shoemaker, and weaver, for no others would condescend to have anything to do with them. These eight guilds are the fuller, shoemaker, juggler, the basket and shield maker, the sailor, fisherman, the hunter of wild animals and birds and the weaver.” 3 Nabha, K. S. Encyclopaedia of Sikh Literature (Mahan Kosh), National Book Shop, 1996, p 537. p. 98. [%sig%]

Re: Khands

Harcharan Singh · 07 May 2007

Periodicals April 1998 Articles By Tharam Singh Significance of The Khands in Japji Sahib Tharam Singh* The word Khand is used in 4 or 5 different senses in Gurbani and other literature. For example : 1. As the Khanda — ghU gkj[b yzvXko j[fJ iBw ;[j/bk ... r[odk; II "Drink the nectar prepared with the Khanda, ..." 2. Signifying small pieces — yzv yzv efo G'iB[ ehB' ... ;'ofm, oftdk; p. 658 "Broken into tiny pieces and consumed ..." 3. As a big area of a continent — rktfj yzv wzvb toGzvk efo efo oy/ Xko/ . ig[ih ;kl p. 6 "All the continents, the galaxies and the whole universe that have been set in position are singing Thy eulogies." 4. To mean a shortage — nfpBk;h Bkjh feS[ yzv . ;[ywBh ;kl p. 282 "The Indestructible "One" can feel no shortage." 5. To mean a class, or a stage of progress — Here, the quotation given by Bhai Kahn Singh is : frnkB yzv wfj frnkB[ gouzv[ . ig[ih ;kl p. 7 "In the sphere of enlightenment, spiritual illumination blazes forth." Hence, the conclusion that the four khands — Dharam, Gyan, Saram and Karam of Japji signify the four stages in the spiritual progress of the devotee in order to reach his goal of a perception of the Sach Khand, the fifth stage of the Brahm Gyani. If we say that the khands refer to the different sets or regions of God's creation, one containing the practitioners of virtue and justice (Dharam Khand), the next containing those that have knowledge and wisdom (Gyan Khand), encompassing Krishans, Shivas, and Brahmas, Sidhs, Buddhas and goddesses, then we are propagating the Brahmin's concept of class and caste. In any case, such a group of wise personalities would need no further guidance, no Guru, no God to guide them, just as in a school, a class of elite geniuses can never be taught the meaning of kindness, generosity and compassion, if they never come into contact with poor and backward pupils. Guru Nanak would come down heavily on any kind of segregation. He chided the Naaths of Sumer Parvat, for coming away from suffering humanity to live their life of solitary bliss. How could he contradict himself by allotting a special realm or region to these knowledgeable Sidhs, Buddhas and Naaths ? Guru Nanak would certainly not set about enumerating the so-called realms of God's creation, when he himself declared in pauri 22 of Japji : gkskbk gkskb b] nkrk;k nkrk; .. UVe UVe Gkfb Ee/ t/d ejfB fJe tks .. ;j; nmkoj ejfB es/pk n;[b{ fJe[ Xks[ .. b/yk j'fJ s fbyhn? b/y? j'fJ ftDk;[ .. BkBe tvk nkyhn? nkg/ ikD? nkg[ .. 22 .. Guru Granth Sahib, p. 5 "Of the nether worlds and heavens has He created millions. Men have given up the accompt in despair. The Vedas too declare unanimously their helplessness. Muslim scriptures declare the number of species eighteen thousand. Vain is such count : Nothing is real, but the One Essence. His Infinity no one may measure or state — Men's lives are swallowed up in the effort; Saith Nanak : Know that He is supreme, all-knowing." — Talib Let us now look at pauris 32 and 33 preceding the khands to see if they give us any indication of what is coming in pauris 34-37. Pauri 32 : "If I convert my tongue into a lakh tongues, and that one lakh should grow to twenty, and with each of these 20 lakhs, I should repeat God's Name a lakh of times, even then these steps to my Lord can be climbed only if I can forsake my ego. ... O Nanak, only by His Grace can anyone have a perception of Him." Pauri 33 : "Man has no power on his own to talk or remain silent; neither can he ask or give as he wills, he cannot live or die, or acquire riches and reign, all on his own strength; he has no capability by himself for spiritual knowledge or wisdom, or to a life of discipline or emancipation; only the Creator has these powers in His Hands. O Nanak, no one can be great or lowly by his own efforts." Both these pauris deal with one's effort to climb the Master's ladder-steps to reach Him, or to attain spiritual knowledge of Him. It is natural to conclude that pauris 34-37 continue with the same theme — of man's spiritual progress to attain a glimpse of the Sach Khand. And this view is further clarified by Prof. Sahib Singh (Nitnem Satik) and by the Shabdarth, the standard exegesis of the Gurbani. To conclude this short commentary, I wish to submit a free rendering of the five pauris as follows : 34. Night, the seasons, the periods of the moon, the days of the week, wind water and fire, and the nether regions; in the midst of all these has been stationed the earth, the testing-ground of man's character. In this setting, live creatures of diverse colours and practices, with names beyond count; according to their deeds they receive justice, because in His Court there is always Truth; there the true devotees appear radiant, as they have received acceptance by His Grace; approval or rejection is awarded at this Court; O Nanak, one knows about it only when one gets there. 35. This awareness of righteous conduct on this earth, is the first step (in his spiritual progress); let us now look at the stage of knowledge and its signs. (The devotee now looks beyond himself and his family); he notices the countless stretches of water, air and fire, and numerous Krishans, Shivajis, Brahmas, that have been created in various colours, shapes and raiment; limitless are the worlds created and their mountains, countless are the Dhruva Bhagats and their preachings, countless the Indra deities, the moons, the suns and solar systems and countless the Sidhs, Buddhas and Naaths, and goddesses; countless are the saints and their devilish counterparts, the munis, the precious stones, and the oceans; countless are the species of creation, their languages, the rulers and their chieftains; countless the meditating souls and their attendants, and O Nanak, there can be no end to this count. 36. In the (second) stage of knowledge (Gyan Khand), the devotee's wisdom or vision is enlarged and strengthened; and here he experiences the bliss of music, drama and frolic; in the stage of endeavour (Saram Khand), his inner self (his mðn) turns beautiful. With regular effort his mðn is fashioned into extraordinary brilliance; it is impossible to describe the pleasure experienced at this stage; if anyone says he can do so, then he will live to regret it; in this stage are fashioned the inner awakening of the mind and the soul, here too is fashioned the wisdom of the angels and of the accomplished yogis. 37. The make-up of the stage of His Grace (Karam Khand), is power; nothing else resides in such a mðn besides His Name; such men are warriors of unparalleled valour, because the Lord resides in every pore of their system; the mðn is steeped in the praise of God; their bodies are exceedingly beautiful; they never wither spiritually, nor are they ever beguiled by maya; in such a state, live the bhagats of many planets, always in a state of bliss, since the Almighty is in their hearts. 38. In the stage of the Sach Khand, the Lord resides in the heart of the devotee, that Lord, Who is creating and caring for all with His Grace; in this stage, a man perceives many planets, solar systems and the universe, an account of which cannot be completed by him; he sees people of many types and forms engaged in activity as ordered by God; He is planning, watching and enjoying His Creation, and O Nanak, it is difficult indeed to describe this last stage of a man's perception. Beautiful are the feet, When they move towards Thee, O Lord, And beautiful is the head That falls at Thine feet. Beauteous is the mouth, When it hymns Thy praise, O Lord, And beauteous is the soul, Which seeks Thine protection. Guru Granth Sahib, p. 964 I know not a contrivance, nor dexterity, I know and utter but Thy One Name ever, O God. I am without merit, O Lord, I have no virtue, And I know Thee to be the only Doer and the Cause. Ignorant, doltish, unwise, and thoughtless am I : Now, Thy Name is my mind's only hope. I have practised not meditation, nor austerity, nor self-control, nor righteous deeds, But I have cherished in the mind Thy One Name, O Lord. I know not a thing, for little is my wisdom, Nanak prays Thee : O God, save me, for I lean on Thee. Guru Granth Sahib, p. 388 [%sig%]

Re: Khands

singh5 · 07 May 2007

Author: Kulbir Singh Date: 08-18-03 07:53 Someone mentioned that Khands are merely spiritual states and not actual realms where Bhagats reside. According to Gurbani (Siri Jap jee Sahib) there are 5 khands above our place of dwelling i.e. this world including solar system and other stars we see. DHARAM KHAND Pauri 34 of Siri Jap jee Sahib explains Dharam Khand. This is the khand where our soul goes to after death. This is where Dharam Rai is stationed. Almost every religion explains this khand in some form or the other. This Khand is huge and this is where heavens and hells are. Dharam Rai has an army of millions and millions jammdoots who control the whole Dharam Khand. Siri Jap jee Sahib summarizes this Khand as follows: There are countless seasons, waters, fires, fires and low-lands like Pataal. Amidst such wide variety of things is the land of Dharam Khand. There countless kind of creatures reside. These creatures are there suffering punishments or getting rewarded for their good deeds. Everybody is judged according to their deeds done on Karam Bhoomi (our Earth or likes of it). The darbar of Dharam Rai is based on truth. Panch Jan i.e. the accepted Gursikhs get recognition and respect there. Such Gursikhs are recognised by the nishaan (symbol, or mark) on their forehead that appears as we do bhagtee of True Naam. All this may seem like fiction here but once we get there, we will realize how true it is (Nanak, Gaiyaan jaapai jaaye). GYAAN KHAND No matter who one is, everyone has to come to Dharam Khand. Gursikhs go there as well as Manmukhs. The difference is that when the Gursikhs arrive there, no record of them is found there and because of the divine mark on their forehead, they are very well respected there. Manmukhs on the other hand get stiff punishments there and are sent to hell and thereafter back to earth to go through the 8.4 million forms, depending on their karma. Gursikhs and other good people who are above heaven move on to the next khand i.e. Gyaan Khand. This is a very huge Khand and references to this Khand too are found in various religious books. This is where most of the prophets and saints of other religions fall. The ones who worship Siri Krishna, Vishnu jee, Shiv jee, and Mohammadans etc. fall in this Khand. This is where Baikunth i.e. residing place of Siri Krishna and his devotees, Buddha, and other great religious leaders are. This place is very beautiful and there are countless Krishna, Shiv jees, Buddhas there. The bhagats like Dhru reside in this Khand. This Khand is very great Khand and only fortunate ones reach here. The only drawback is that the residents of this Khand are not eternal. When Vaheguru takes back his creation, this Khand gets destroyed. SHARAM KHAND, KARAM KHAND AND SACH KHAND This is the third Khand and hereon it is impossible to describe the Khands. Sharam Khand and the two Khands above this i.e. Karam Khand and Sach Khand are beyond description. One thing is for sure that the way we are today, we cannot comprehend anything there in Sharam Khand. For this reason when one reaches this Khand, one gets new senses, mind, intelligence and surti. The reason is that with old senses and mann, budh, we cannot comprehend anything there. Sharam Khand is essential for Bhagats before they can enter Karam Khand and Sach Khand. Sharam Khand is like prep Khand for entering Karam Khand and Sach Khand. This Khand is extremely beautiful. Everything there is just too beautiful to describe. Guru Sahib just says that no one should bother to describe anything there as it would be futile and such person who tries to say anything about this Khand have to regret. Karam Khand and Sach Khand exist in such fashion as a house and varaandaah exist. Varaandah is like the outskirts of a house but within the boundery of the property. Normally the top of the varandaah is ceiling. From Karam Khand one can view the inside of the house and know what is going on inside but can’t go inside. There is immense Anand (Bliss) in this Khand. Only real warriors who have subdued all bikaars can enter this Khand. This Khand – Karam Khand is accessible mostly to Gursikhs of Guru Nanak Dev jee but some rare ones who do kamaayee of Kirtam Naam (qualitative names like Raam, Gobind etc.) and give their best shot to it, but are not Gursikhs of Guru Nanak can reach Karam Khand. Both Karam Khand and Sach Khand are eternal Khands. Sachkhand is accessible only to Gursikhs. There Vaheguru resides in comprehensible form to Gursikhs. Gursikhs stay absorbed in the bliss of Darshan of Vaheguru. Sach Khand is huge and the whole creation including other 4 Khands are within Sach Khand. Sach Khand surrounds the whole creation and is inside the whole creation. In essence Sach Khand is Vaheguru himself. In Sach Khand, the bhagats don’t lose their identity. The Ten Gurus occupy the top position along with Vaheguru. It is futile to write anything about it. Guru Nanak Sahib has written that to describe Sach Khand is like chewing iron (Nanak, Kathna KaraRaa Saar). Dasam Duaar is a shortcut to Sach Khand. It is like a door to Sach Khand. Sitting here, one can have all the Anand of Sach Khand and know what is going on there. When I hear naive stories of some pro-Raagmala people, I only can do afsos at their meagre thinking and intelligence. One of the story has been spread by a so called sant and it narrates how when Bhai Sahib died and was being taken to Sach Khand, he was stopped by the doormen outside Sach Khand. They told Bhai Sahib that since he did not read Raagmala, he cannot enter Sach Khand. What can you say of such childish stories. People who spread such stories have no idea what Sach Khand is and what Dasam Duaar is. Bhai Sahib used to stay in Sach Khand even while he was in this Earth. For him death was no change at all. Who would have stopped him from going to Sach Khand? And there are doormen in Sach Khand? All this is totally abusrd and nonsense. What I have written is based on reading Gurbani, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee’s books, Bhai Sahib Vir Singh jee’s books and talking to Gursikhs. If I have written anything against Gurmat, Sangat Baksha lavay, Guru Sahib baksh layen. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Khands

Khalsaspirit · 07 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh, Khalsa jio, May be most of you know already there is a book [gurbani]gurbwxI Aqy sWieMs dI roSnI ivc AkwlpurK[/gurbani](Gurbani atay Science dee Roshnee wich AKALPURKH) by Bhai Dharm Singh jee Sujjon. This is excellent book for beginners and Intermediate level of avastha Sikhs. The only thing you should have is just basic level of understanding of Physics. Once you read (complete) this book you will really get the realm of Gursikhi jeevan. We know Bhai Sahib Dharm Singh ji personally and he is a high avastha Singh. In his book Bhai sahib also mentions what Bhai Kulbir Singh jee said above. These Khands are not just stages of a Gursikh life but they are really exist in the entire universe (consist all sub universes like the one we are living in). As of now book should also be available in English. We highly recommend this book and must say this is one's must read book. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Khands

Hargurmit Singh · 07 May 2007

Vahiguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Jee Kee Fateh Allow me to suggest readers listen to the audio of jupjee sahibs katha by giani thakur singh on www.sfsikhcenter.org for another insight. http://www.sfsikhcenter.org/multimedia/index.php?q=f&f=%2F01-Katha+at+El+Sobrante%2F13-Giani+Thakur+Singh+Ji+%28Patiala+Wale%29%2FKatha+Sri+Guru+Granth+Sahib+Jiuk singh wrote: [%sig%]

Re: Khands

singh13 · 08 May 2007

where can we get that book in english from khalsaspirit ji

Re: Khands

Khalsaspirit · 09 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Singh13 jio, Please check with the publisher if they already have the English version and get Panjabi version anyway. PANJAB TIMES 24 Cotton brook Road, Derby. DE238YJ (U.K.) Tel: 01332-372851 Fax: 01332-372833 Email: [address removed] Once we get further info we will post it here. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Khands

Khalsaspirit · 13 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh Singh13 jio, Just got the information that ENGLISH VERSION of the GOD in the light of Gurbani and Science is avialable. If you living in Canada/USA then you can get it from SACHA SAUDA GURMAT PARCHAR SOCIETY 2575 Steeles Ave., East Unit No. 18 BRAMPTON, ONT L6 P5 T1 Tel: (905) 459-8351 Fax:(905) 459-5986 We also got the information that the Punjabi Version is on back order in other words out of stock and under more printing. We guess this book is on high demand. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Khands

Atma Singh · 15 May 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Sadh Sangat Jeeo, i personally find Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh's writings re: 5 Khands more convincing. This is because Bhai Sahib, aside from other reasons, sticks to Gurbanee much more closely in explaining his views as opposed to much of the above and the other stuff i've read, where fanciful theories are stated, yet which ignore the very literal descriptions given by Maharaaj Jee. i would always prefer to listen to Singhs with major Gursikhee Jeevans such as Bhai Sahib as opposed to 'scholars' anyay...scholars theorise whilst Kamaai-Waley Gurmukhs only speak about what they have experienced first-hand; they have no need to theorise. Translations regarding 'SachKhand Darshan', perhaps Bhai Sahib's most relevant treatise re: 5 Khands, is currently being translated and posted here: http://www.sevatothemax.com/blog/ [%sig%]