Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Lords Grace

Lords Grace

hps · 15 May 2007

This concept is of an essence in entire SGGS. It looks that if one does not achieve something one can always say that we were not blessed with his Nadar. But it provides an ecape route. I wonder if other religions have this concept like hinduism concepts of karma and reincarnation are some of the borrowed from Hinduism , ma be this is also borrowed. Kindly enlighten. [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

Balbir Singh · 16 May 2007

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! Come to know true Simran. Come to know Lords Grace. ************** I am preparing for the journey for next few weeks. I may participate on Forums when God wants me. Balbir Singh

Re: Lords Grace

Roopkaur · 16 May 2007

Although we get everything according to Guru Sahib's kirpa, that does not excuse us from trying. Bani also says Aapn Hathi Aapnaa, Aapey Hee Kaaj Svaareeay. Guru Sahib gives us whatever we want, we just have to learn how to ask properly. Bani also tells us many times what pleases guru sahib, and how to accomplish what we want. Yes, everything in the end is Guru Sahib's meher, but that is not an excuse for dhills. Guru Sahib says, Charan Sharan Gur Ek Painda Jai Chaal, Satgur Kot Painda Aigai Hoe Lait Hai. So we have to take the first step. As for borrowing from Hinduism, although there are similiarities within all religions, nothing in Sikhi and Gurmat is borrowed. Sikhi is Sach, it has always been from the beginning, and always will be, so how can it borrow from any other religion? This concept that Guru Sahib "borrowed" what he liked from other religions is false, because just like bani, Sikhi and gurmat has come from "dhuro", and nothing is borrowed.

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 16 May 2007

I am sincerely grateful to you dear sister and really pray that you may kindly clear my doubts if it is possible. I am a beginnere in Gurbani. I am fairly old now and do not want to analyse the things but then I cannot stop myself, may be I am not cut for accepting things unless these are clear.I have already anoyed my friends ans now I am shy to ask questions that i need to. May you be blessed more .But please do help me like this.Without criticising my lack of appreciation of Gurbani. Regards. harpreet [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

Balbir Singh · 16 May 2007

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! Quote from Roop Kaur Jee "Guru Sahib says, Charan Sharan Gur Ek Painda Jai Chaal, Satgur Kot Painda Aigai Hoe Lait Hai." Would you please let all know which Guru has said so? I will be grateful. Quote "As for borrowing from Hinduism, although there are similiarities within all religions, nothing in Sikhi and Gurmat is borrowed." Please come to know the Truth of Naam Simran and realize that one cannot borrow it. Balbir Singh

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 16 May 2007

respected Balbir ji, I cannot answer so far as the 'shabad' part of your question i concerned. However, your answer like 'naam simran' are clearly notindependent as well. Hindus do believe in meditating on the supreme.HIndus phiolsphy of god and godesses is also believes in ' Ahm Brahmasmi'. I am the lord i.e the 'paramatman'.The concept of Soul,re-births theory, cause and effect and Karmic reactions are not concept wise but practically borrowed.I do no think that there is anything wrong in admitting it.Guru sahib has not thought of starting a new religion. ,atleast, Nanak Sahib did not do so.It was 10 th guru that thec oncept of khalsa was introduced. Almost all the guru's took something from the other religiions that were contemporary. Islam was also the one. however, not much could be taken from that as the rulers were Mughals. Hence to consoilidate his phiosphy , the Kabir and fraid;s banis were included in SGGS ji. There is hardly anything wrong in this. The dress code of a sikh and the five time prayer is also a concept taken from islam. God is one is also the basis philosphy that originated from 'Koran'. Every religion is the answer to the mischief's of the existing religions.Sikhism is the best form of alchemy of the hindu and islam. [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

Balbir Singh · 17 May 2007

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all and Hps Jee! I feel to ask. What is important? Is it analyzing worldly religions and their mishmash or experiencing Truth? I hope someone does not criticize a person one day because he eats and sleeps like a Hindu or Muslim. Only worldly interests keep one busy with such analysis. Human languages and activities are limited according to his developed conscious mind. Godly Truth does not fall in these limits. The expression of Truth may sound similar through human reflections. The Truth is the same though. This is why God is unique through all HIS expressions, each unit of existence. The Gurus did not invent Truth new. They realized Truth that is existing from the beginning, also before Hindus came in existence. Balbir Singh

Re: Lords Grace

jassmannn · 17 May 2007

The truth is the truth and Guru Nanak Dev Ji came to bring the truth to the people. It was not a pick and choose scenario, as there are certain tenants of Islam and Hibduism which Guru Nanak Dev Ji did not agree with. They did however promote a pluralist ideology . All are welcome and can believe what they want. Sikhism isn't a 'thou shalt not' religion. The Bani gives you the options and results and it is up to you to make your decision. It's not about Gurus taking anything from another, it is about highlighting what they believed the truth to, and giving that to the people who became Sikhs, whilst at the same time sending a message of tolerance and pluralism to the people.

Re: Lords Grace

Roopkaur · 17 May 2007

That pankiti is from Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaaran, thank you for clarifying that. However, I do not think that point makes this pankiti any less applicable. Although everything we get is because of Guru Ji's meher, it is our own karam that earn that meher. We are now bhoging the karms that we have comitted in the past, while making new karms for the future. As for admitting to borrowing, like I said before, Sikhi has existing before all other religions, it was just made available openly in kaljug, so the question of "borrowing" does not arise. As for your comment on how Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji did not want to make a seperate religion, I think you are gravely mistaken, and an excellent essay that prooves that is written by Balpreet SIngh Bhaji, which you can read here: http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=22853&t=22853#reply_22853

Re: Lords Grace

Balbir Singh · 18 May 2007

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! Quote from Roop Kaur Jee "However, I do not think that point makes this pankiti any less applicable." Ego convinces one that without taking its first step God and Guru do not take the second step. Just imagine. God has not given birth to ego. Quote "As for your comment on how Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji did not want to make a seperate religion, I think you are gravely mistaken." Guru Nanak Dev Jee recognized, His Dharma. People feel, He rejected Hindu religion with which He was born. When will we recognize our Dharma? Balbir Singh

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 20 May 2007

"Guru Nanak Dev Jee recognized, His Dharma. People feel, He rejected Hindu religion with which He was born. When will we recognize our Dharma? Balbir Singh" You will recognize your Dharma only when you are graced by HIm,........Ok [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 21 May 2007

"Guru Nanak Dev Jee recognized, His Dharma. People feel, He rejected Hindu religion with which He was born. When will we recognize our Dharma? Balbir Singh" We all will realize it when He wishes us to do the same. even thousand of preaching will not be beneficial. [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

Balbir Singh · 21 May 2007

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! Quote from Hps Jee "We all will realize it when He wishes us to do the same. even thousand of preaching will not be beneficial." God keeps one waiting for HIS Grace. Someone else feels the shower of HIS Grace. This is HIS Play. Balbir Singh

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 21 May 2007

Sardar ji, It is Good that someone has started jumping out of shoes, those who jump too high hit the floor with fury and forget thir sikhi if they have any. Enjoy the 'ping pong' state forever, [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 21 May 2007

wah sradar ji wah..I am happy with the answers that i have got and the thread is closed for me. Anyone with no value of time may keep on writing please. [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 21 May 2007

Be grateful to HIm if you are showered with some Grace. All the best. I pray that this shower continues. [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 22 May 2007

as per rehat maryada 'code Of conduct' sikhs are not to follow the 'vedas' and 'upnishadas'. Hence it is clear sir, that Guru Nanak rejected Vedas as authorities and sikhs do follow. Personally speaking , being an indian, we live here all as brothers .There is not a thing discussed with anyone. regards [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

Balbir Singh · 22 May 2007

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! Quote from Chandra Jee "May be he rejected Karmakanda of Hinduism but only an ignorant fool will say that he rejected the Parabrahma of Vedas." The true Gurus do not promote Karamakanda. Anyone may be doing it. Who will be interested in wasting time for rituals after knowing true Simran? One does not seek Paarbrahma to reject HIM. Also, Paarbrahma is beyond Vedas. Balbir Singh

Re: Lords Grace

SomeSingh · 22 May 2007

actually, Bani teaches to respect religious scriptures of other dharms, and even to contemplate on them. But the Guru in his Bani makes it clear that sikh dharm is separate and he doesn't worship Vedas etc.

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 23 May 2007

To somesingh ji, I am a sikh and have till date never met anyone calling him hindu that they woirship Vedas. Vedas is a source of wisdom for all of us. It has enriched the life of so many. It might be durig the times of Sri Guru Nanak devji that he found something that we cannot analyse. Reading Vedas is not considerd as a religion. Infact, I doubt if a copy of these scriptures would be available. Regarding scriptures and discarding them altogether is not possible. Everyone owes the concept of Soul to the main source that is Geeta. It does not seem to be logical to accept almost evrything of a nice book and then reject.Personally speaking I have read and am benefitted with this. Atleast one can make a concept. Similarly Gayatri mantra is like 'mool mantra' of Hindus. There is nothing wrong in this. Let them reach HIM thru this route if it takes them there. [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

Balbir Singh · 23 May 2007

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! Quote from Hps Jee "as per rehat maryada 'code Of conduct' sikhs are not to follow the 'vedas' and 'upnishadas'. Hence it is clear sir, that Guru Nanak rejected Vedas as authorities and sikhs do follow." Rehat Maryada has nothing to do with Guru NAnak Dev Jee's Message. Nor Gurdev's message depends on Rehat Maryada. Can someone please refer anything from Rehat Maryada that the Gurus also suggest? I will be grateful. Quote from SomeSingh Jee "actually, Bani teaches to respect religious scriptures of other dharms, and even to contemplate on them. But the Guru in his Bani makes it clear that sikh dharm is separate and he doesn't worship Vedas etc." Please provide one reference from Gurbaanee where the Gurus have stated that Sikh Dharam is separate and they do not worship Vedas etc. Thanks. Balbir Singh

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 23 May 2007

Dear balbir ji, Your questions are almost pointless and it appears tha you are asking for the sake of asking.Since you cannot change much of your thinking process you are advised to study the rehat maryada yourself and May He bless you as well. [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

Balbir Singh · 23 May 2007

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! One becomes holy by means of religious rites like JAP. God blesses him with HIS true NAM. This is the true Grace of Lord. Other remain busy in the mayic world with so-called Rehats. Balbir Singh

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 25 May 2007

Let it be ,if it is our fate....Sardar ji. [%sig%]

Re: Lords Grace

Balbir Singh · 26 May 2007

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! Quote from Hps Jee "Let it be ,if it is our fate....Sardar ji." I thought only a stone's ego behaves that way. Anyway. I enjoy knowing your reactions. The Godly songs are always a flow though, not aimed at someone in particular. Balbir Singh

Re: Lords Grace

hps · 26 May 2007

Wahe Guru Gurumantar hi Wahe Guru Guruimantar hi. He Is great and great are HIs creations. Satnaam Waheguru jeo.... [%sig%]