Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Khalistan - Taliban

Khalistan - Taliban

tarunjeet singh · 21 May 2004

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe If we had Khalistan how would you enforce Gurmat living for all who live there?? For example how would you stop prostituation, alcholism, drugs, how would you break down punjabi culture??? Would we resort to the ways of the Taliban where by everyone is forced to comply? Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

10 · 21 May 2004

You couldn't compare it to the taliban. It would be a place where there is freedom of religion. I don't think it will be limitted to one country. It will be when the Pure Khalsa rule the earth and Punjab will be like Sach Khand. Raj Karega Khalsa!

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

Mohan Singh · 22 May 2004

There will never be a Khalistan but there may be a independant secular Punjab. I cannot see a Khalistan ever happening, realistically, unless it is at the time of Khalsa Raj. The time when such vice ends will be Khalsa Raj, not Khalistan in the middle of Kalyug. If we try to enforce things before our own Sikhs are all Khalsa, then we will end up just like the Taliban and become oppressive.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

avidya · 23 May 2004

Towards the end of the violence, some karkoo started to act like the taliban, including imposing a dress code for all Sikhs, which led to some teenage girls getting shot in the legs in jalandhar for not wearing salwaar kameez.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

Singhstah · 23 May 2004

Khalistan would never be taliban because 1) we will only get a Khalistan if the Sikhs are real khalsas and 2) I also think Non khalsas living in Khalistan would just becom khalsa anyway because in Khalistan there will be true and most pure Sikhi

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

Mkhalsa · 23 May 2004

Banning alcohol, prostitution and drugs isnt very talibanistic. prostitution and drugs are illegal in most western countries, hardcore porn is illegal in parts of europe.. alcohol was banned in the US at one time. We could ban all of these vices in the name of a society that cares for its people instead of in the name of religion.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

Singh · 24 May 2004

"imposing a dress code for all Sikhs" sounds like some posters on this site. Not to mention what you can and can't eat, what bowls you must use and not forgetting what style of dastar you are forbidden from tying. Some fanatics be they Taliban or what ever shaire the same fooloish narrow minded concepts and try to hide this under religion.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

avidya · 24 May 2004

It was more the way the codes were enforced that harks to Taliban MKhalsa

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

avidya · 24 May 2004

another example would be... would those who wished to create a Khalistan allow barbers? At the same time as the above incidents involving dress code occured, barber's shops were also destroyed. Imposing kesh on all was not something the Gurus did for their muslim and hindu followers, BUT it was something that the Taliban notoriously did for all residents in afghanistan.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

Mkhalsa · 24 May 2004

>>>>Author: Singh Date: 05-24-04 06:42 "imposing a dress code for all Sikhs" sounds like some posters on this site. Not to mention what you can and can't eat, what bowls you must use and not forgetting what style of dastar you are forbidden from tying. Some fanatics be they Taliban or what ever shaire the same fooloish narrow minded concepts and try to hide this under religion.<<<<< Your ignorance is amusing. I have never ONCE heard ANYONE on this site tell someone they need to keep a rehat or die, or keep a rehat or go to hell, or any other such nonsense. I have ONLY seen gursikhs posting on this site saying things very humbly and telling about rehat when asked. They never forced this rehat on anyone or coerced them. Gursikhs have explained rehat, history and guru sahibs bhana to those who have come seeking it and it is the seekers choice whether to follow such rehat or hukam etc. Anyone forcing another into sikhi is wrong. Sikhi must be approached with love. I have heard of children forced into amrit sanchars and later turn out to be really messed up. Such nonsense needs to be stopped. If we force people to become sikhs, we are no better than mughals and taliban people. I have yet to see any real gurmukhs forcing anyone to do anything against their will.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

g · 24 May 2004

Khalistan is wherever you can practice your sikhi freely not a state/country.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

avidya · 25 May 2004

so, you disagree with the above examples I stated MKhalsa?

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

@@@ · 25 May 2004

If it is to be called khalistan then the people who live there would be khalis - pure. Bhai rama singh wrote in his autobiography that we won't have Khalistan for another 10 generations

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

Mkhalsa · 25 May 2004

I dont see a problem with barbers for those religions that accept them. I dont know, I havent thought about this as barbers dont seem to be much of a vice.. in a place ruled by sikhs and dominated by a sikh majority, most people would keep hair anyway, as could be seen in the 80s when even hindus were keeping kesha.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

avidya · 25 May 2004

Another similarity was the intimidation of the media...akin to Nick Berg, Manchandra, who ran Patiala's all india radio was kidnapped in Patiala and later decapitated because their demands that media presenters have their heads covered while presenting the news wasn't met.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

singh · 25 May 2004

avidya, who exactly are you trying to blame for these things? There were probably at least a dozen different Kharkoo groups in operation, and each of these had their own splinter groups. Many of these groups were at each other as much as they were at the GOI and didn't follow the same set of rules, ideologies or rehit. Several of these groups weren't even led by real khalistanees. Zaffarawal and Dr. Sohan Singh being cases in point. Yet you try to paint the whole khalistan movement with the same brush.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

DaasanDaasanDaas · 25 May 2004

hes a nang what do u expecT?

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

khalistani · 25 May 2004

actually many would call india khalistan because of the sikh prime minister. but india is still india. on the other hand, we can not deserve khalistan. justhow many pure singhs/singhnees do you see? mostly wat it is that a person is hair-cut(manmukh), normal punjabi and they call them themselves sikhs. when they don't know a thing about sikhi. many of us are converting to other religions. we can't even handle a guruduara properly snd how r we going to handle sukh a big piece of land? and sikhs have no power. we'r not brave like puraten singhs. we've gotta fight to get khalistan and even if we do , it'll be just like a normal country! instead of being a heaven!

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

avidya · 26 May 2004

Friends, I am not a Nang, thank you very much, nor am I a Nihang! Read the title of the topic, read my posts. I am posting incidents that draw parralells between khalistan and taliban. Perhaps we should just pretend these events didn't happen? But that would be anti-sikh, if we are to be the seekers of truth. If you feel any of the above incidents are untrue, are lies I made up, please tell me otherwise, and I shall post the references.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

.. · 26 May 2004

according to a census released in conjunction with the last sgpc elections it was said that 80 somthing % of the sikh numbers were monai which many sikh institutes shyed from after one main body claimed they will make an amritdhari in every household in 1999. In my opinion yes its good to keep the khalistan torch burning but i think we shud first sort our community out, if thats not practical then make numbers somehow. If you got 20% kesdhari how many keep their tharei fully, then how many amritdhari out of that? how many pro khalistani out of that? how many anti meat of that? how how finally are you left with that will follow rehet? wake up amritvela?

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

jagroop singh · 26 May 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, i can never understand why most people cannot post on forums with their real names (unless for overarching reasons of Gupt - i.e. to prevent haumai when discussing deeply spiritual issues). It would certainly make clear who is saying what and delete the need for any of us to accuse one another of being Nangs/UK Nihangs etc. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

punjabi sikh · 26 May 2004

a lot of sikhs nowdays try to generalise punjabism as though its a sworn enemy of sikhi. caste - all kinds of people in the world follow one kind of caste class system or another. drink - are punjabis the only people in the world that drink like fish? most pakistanis i know drink heavy but not openly cos its taboo in islam, punjabis just open about it. meat- most of the world eats it not just punjabis bhangra - a traditional dance bought to the punjab by the folk tradition of the scythian massagatae culture. Now transformed with modern beats and vice ( compare todays bhangra to lal chand yamla jatt songs on legends which had a moral tale 50 years ago) so thres a time diff with a huge change of whats being sung. drugs etc these r problems endemic all around the world not just punjabi culture. all these things however wrong are not exclusively punjabi culture. Punjabi culture does have things contradictory to sikhi but you have to study it for a greater picture and its not all bad and we dont need to get rid of punjabiat totally for sikhi for then we wudnt have any identity. where do u think ur language comes from? our traditions? would u rather be like gorai sikh women and men freely mixing on their own? or a punjabi set family jitteh izzat di tohr tuk rendi? where i have seen sikhi survive is not where u throw everything about u away, but where u have a proper set family structure and support each other. over time many terms and traditions have eroded, to what we think is punjabi culture the caste system for one is false. caste in punjab today is corroded to proffssion, historically it meant a culture distinct with language, traditions, customs. it cannot be compard to a heirarchical structure with hindu caste system. Jatts happened to enter a vacant punjab became a majority thats all, most of the misals were dominated by jatts due to the geographical location and victories over land and transfer of power to jamindars went to the people who won it from a feudal moghul system that exploited jatts for cheap labour for hundreds of years. Rajputs are an offshoot of the giant jatt culture , most punjabis are from either, with successive migration waves from persia to parts of northern india, then of rajputs from other parts of india to punjab and making what is today punjabs set up. You cannot kill off something thats been there for thousands of years that creates the very punjabi phsyche. But the things that are contradicting sikhi shud go such as ooch neech. my words may appear castist but im not a jatt myself or justifieing what has become today as high low , im merely highlighting that we shudnt just generalise punjabiyat without research. and you cant kill off history thousands of years old or assume its hindu. We cant change people if they choose to change of their own accord thats fine, our job as sikhs in khalsa raj is to govern with pyar and dharm. Some people may have shot others during some so so in past, a true sikh would not take the life of another for just doing a dance, our job would be to be good sikh role models and fulfill our duties.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

punjabi sikh · 26 May 2004

also ramgaria is not a so called punjabi disease either but a confederation of groups of people from jatts lohars terkhans royal families who fought under the ramgharia banner. i for one stand for the goodness of punjabi culture but reject anything that is anti sikh. we already loosing sikhi, why loose everything else? we shud build upon our identity and nationhood. what makes nationhood?

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

punjabi sikh · 26 May 2004

i jus wanna say that many things have been corrupted and people just belittle this as " punjabi culture" dont take a cheap shot at the punjabi identity. instead of saying punjabi culture please be precise abouyt what is bugging and filter that against sikhi, if its manmutt then it clearly belongs in the rubbish bin. when i gave the ramgharia example look at what it was look at what its become, same with the jatt thing. theres a lot of corrosion dont blame ur background for that, hit the problem pinpoint it.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

avidya · 26 May 2004

WaheGuruji Ka Khalsa WaheGuruji Ki Fateh Jagroop ji, I remember you raising this issue before. I'd say the real issue is people shouldn't assume too much about other people they don' t know and prejudge others. You can have my word on the fact that I am not a Nihang. I have stated this from the beginning. And I'm slightly concerned that people feel anyone who is posting information contradictory to their own viewpoint is one! Furthermore the person who made the statement also failed to put their name to the post! Secondly your assumption perfectly elucidates the reason why many don't use their names on forums, because you seem more concerned about the person rather than the post! People often get very personal very quickly. Now the topic matter and my posts are in line with one another. Unforutnately others have now pushed it off topic and turned it into a personal issue, trying to discredit myself rather than objectively countering my points that I can only asusme they feel threatened by! Is this really how Sikhs are meant to discuss???? Now if you'd like to put a post stating 'punjab police - human rights violations' then I shall be happy to post on that topic as well. all the very best

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

punjabi sikh · 26 May 2004

i agree with avidya on the names. if my posts do not appear in line with the original i apologise but im sick of seeing punjabi heritage put down all the time as punjabi culture. maybe thats not ur intention but punjabi culture is always associated with something bad nowdays like a impediment to sikhi.

Re: Khalistan - Taliban

Mkhalsa · 26 May 2004

>>>punjabi culture is always associated with something bad nowdays like a impediment to sikhi.<<<< Thats because it is. Today's "punjabi culture" however genuine or not, is a definite impediment to sikhi. It seems that that is all punjabi culture is today, manmat! Anyone who says they are into "punjabi culture" 1) drinks, 2) shaves, 3) womanizes, 4) may do drugs, 5) is castist yes a VERY BIG over generalization, but just look around you!!! i dont have any love for western culture either, in fact i cant stand it! every culture in the world has degraded to manmat and forgotten all their great traditions! Lets NOT let sikhi fall prey to such corruption.

< a bit confused !? >

jagroop singh · 27 May 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Dear 'Avidya' Veer/Bhain Jee wrote: "I'd say the real issue is people shouldn't assume too much about other people they don' t know and prejudge others. You can have my word on the fact that I am not a Nihang...Furthermore the person who made the statement also failed to put their name to the post!" Veer/Bhain Jee, this comment wasn't a side-swipe aimed at yourself - i don't understand why you would think it was aimed at you in a personal manner. Could you elaborate. Veer/Bhain Jee wrote: "Secondly your assumption perfectly elucidates the reason why many don't use their names on forums, because you seem more concerned about the person rather than the post! People often get very personal very quickly. Now the topic matter and my posts are in line with one another. Unforutnately others have now pushed it off topic and turned it into a personal issue, trying to discredit myself rather than objectively countering my points that I can only asusme they feel threatened by! Is this really how Sikhs are meant to discuss????" Again, my point has always been that Guru Sahib has so kindly blessed us with a name - simple. As to how you refer to yoursef (e.g. nihang, akj etc.) means absolutely nothing to me. Again i feel you are, quite ironically in fact, assuming far too much. In fact we seem to agree on a basic level - points are more important than people...if we must disagree then as Sikhs we should disagree with Mut and not Tun; this is how i feel that 'Sikhs are meant to discuss'. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!