Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Atma Singh · 23 May 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Sadh Sangat Jeeo, At a time when Sikhs worldwide are offended by a man who has attempted to project himself as Dasmesh Pita Jee, i thought it worth sharing with the Sangat my personal thoughts regarding a case of Maha Beadbee which has been carried out by 'Sikhs' themselves and never gets the attention it deserves. Arguably, is a much more severe, faithless and distasteful act than that recently carried out by 'the pakhandee in pink'. If someone truly thinks about it, they will come to understand that the act of pad-ched regarding Maharaaj Jee’s Saroop, which is about the human-inspired breaking-up and reconstruction of Maharaaj Jee's Akalee Banee, is a completely faithless act which intends to make assumptions regarding Siree Guroo Sahib Jee's unfathomable and infinite intentions. A Gursikh accepts that Maharaaj Jee is unfathomable and so would never tamper with His Saroop. We all agree that it was the Lareevaar Saroop, not the 'modified' pad-ched Saroop, which was blessed and placed in the care of the Khalsa, by none other than Dasmesh Pita Jee, who passed the Gurgaddi to This Bir in 1708. Please note that there are no historic occurrences of pad-ched ever being applied to Maharaaj Jee’s Saroop pre-20th Century. What to talk of Maharaaj’s Pavittar Saroop, there were even no such things as pad-ched Gutkaa Sahibs pre-20th century, such was the level of respect accorded to Maharaaj Jee’s Roop by Gursikhs. Therefore, Sikh Ithiaas (history) attests to the fact that pad-ched Saroop is a ‘modern innovation’ and has never been Guroo-ordained. According to what I have learnt so far about the issue, it seems that it was Teja ‘Singh’ Bhasauria (the ex-Sajjan of Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Jee, who was ex-communicated for removing Bhagat Banee) who has the 'distinction' of being the first person to attempt pad-ched of Maharaaj Jee's Saroop, although this was in the form of Sencheeyaan. Apparently the actual printing press he had hired for the purpose was forcefully stopped by Gursikhs during the first print-run, before the first Senchee could be completed. Once again the issue came to the attention of Chief Khalsa Diwan and SGPC when a group of printers and their cronies attempted to push forward the pad-ched printing of Maharaaj Jee’s Saroop. Chief Khalsa Diwan stated the following about the matter in 1945, after a meeting where both sides of the argument were put across by both lobbies i.e. pro and anti pad-ched proponents: “The matter of doing Akhand Paatth from Birs with separated-words was presented together with the opinions of advisors, it was directed that neither is it proper to do the Parkaash of Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Ji from such Birs nor is it proper to do Akhand Paatth from such Birs and it is not appropriate and it is harmful to the Panth to publish and bind separated words form (of Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee) in one cover. A copy of this decision should be sent to the Shromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee and it should also be published in common (public) newspapers.” (Resolution No. 2682; 21/1/1945 - Working Committee - Chief Khalsa Diwan). This resolution was sent to the SGPC. Here’s what they had to say about the matter in 1950, after having given the issue and the above resolution due consideration for over 5 years: “Gurmatta Number 1637 dated 28th May, 1950, of the Executive Committee of the Shromani Committee about the publication or the Parkaash of the separated words form of Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee, about which the advice of the Dharmic Salahkaar (Religious Advisory) Committee was asked, was presented and passed to the effect that until such time as the matter is decided by the Panth, any one individual or organisation should not publish separated words form Beerhs nor should such a Birs be placed in Parkaash state (for holy sight and paying respects to i.e. for darshan, and for reading). (Gurmatta No. 7; 1/1/1950 - Dharmik Committee of Shromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee) It was during the 1960’s, when the SGPC, despite their previous resolution, allowed certain printers to carry-out pad-ched. Pad-ched has never become Panth-Parvaan (accepted by Panth). Sangat Jeeo, the sad fact is that printing was done through the back-door, with the SGPC who published the original Gurmatta against pad-ched, literally co-ordinating the process, without any due consideration for anyone’s opinions or feelings, let alone the wider Panth’s. Sangat Jeeo, these are the disgusting facts behind pad-ched of Maharaaj Jee’s Saroop. The key question is: How did that which was harmful to the Panth in 1945/1950, according to these Gurmattas, become desirable and acceptable during the 1960’s? It is this question, originally posed by Jathedar Bhai Raam Singh Jee of the Akhand Keertanee Jatha, which remains un-answerable. Shame on those who carried-out this unfaithful and egotistical act. There was money to be made because there were very lax Gurdwara ‘Sevadaars’ and ‘Parchaaraks’ the world over and the ‘Sangat’ were williing to take the ‘easier road’ of reading from pad-ched the moment it was offered. Like all good monopolists, the SGPC knew they were placed to make lots of money; especially since they were the ‘installed custodians of the Panth’. The harsh truth is that Maharaaj Jee’s One and Only True Saroop is rare today because of these ‘custodians’ who wanted to make money and pander to the un-informed masses. Our so-called ‘leaders’ were blind…but why should we follow their blind lead? At least we should respect the binding nature of a ‘Gurmatta’ or do we, like them, really not have faith in Him whose Mat we claim to base our decisions upon? Sometimes, people do not view pad-ched as a problem because so and so Sants/elders have told them it is ‘not a big deal’. Despite what these elders may think, it is up to us all as individuals to use our Guroo-given Bibek Budhi (discriminatory wisdom) to arrive at final conclusions. We are not to treat any one individual as the voice of Siree Guroo Sahib Jee. That would do us, them and Maharaaj Jee a seriously big disservice. The elders’/Sants’ valuable and experience-based thoughts should assist us in our personal Gurmat decision-making process, especially when those elders/Sants’ have a strong Gursikhee Jeevan. However, the elders/Sants should not completely determine our conclusions, even by virtue of their experience or indeed Gursikhee Jeevan. With that firmly in mind, let us consider some opinions whioch would go against those elders/Sants who believe pad-ched is an acceptable act. Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Jee, when discussing mistakes made by Gursikhs when doing pad-ched of words whilst reading Gurbanee, has written in his book Gurbani Dee Laagan Maataran Da Vilakhantia: "…[therefore] to print or have printed pad-ched birs of Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee is Mahaa-Manmat (Supreme Manmat). This is because they [the people who are reading], according to their own wisdom/knowledge, separate the words. Therefore, printing pad-ched Siree Guroo Granth Sahib is the work of shallow/ignorant knowledge. There are also many other reasons that the boat of Gurbaanee (to ferry across the worldly ocean), Siree Guroo Granth Sahib, should not have pad-ched birs printed. Even writers, printers and scholars who are aware of the grammar rules of Gurbaanee make mistakes when doing pad-chhed…" Let’s take another example. Bhai Raam Singh Jee, former Jathedaar Sahib of the Akhand Keertanee Jatha, has written the following in his amazing tract, ‘Lareevaar Saroop’, regarding pad-ched: “Kalgidhar Paatshah before merging with the Divine Light, commanded the Sikhs, “This is my command, that you must place (total) faith in the Granth (Sahib Jee) as your Guroo”. Having said this, Kalgidhar Paatshah bowed before the Lareevaar Saroop of Satguroo, Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee, in the traditional way. It was the Darshan (holy sight) of the Lareevaar Saroop which was ordained by Siree Guroo Gobind Singh Jee. However, we have used our headstrong cleverness to convert this approved form to the form with separated words so that Paath can be done easily and quickly. The suggested single sheet Paath by the Kookay (Naamdharis) and pad-ched, both arise from egoistic cleverness and are both condemnable. The Kookay intended to split-up Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee into single sheets but the Panth regarded this as sacreligious and protested massively; the Kookay were stopped from doing this misdeed. We were so hurt when we heard about the move to split Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee into single sheets, regarding it to be an irreligious act. The Panth united and protested strongly to stop it. However, seeing the words of the Lareevaar Saroop of Sireee Guroo Granth Sahib Jee being split failed to rouse us. Why do we regard one type of Manmat which is harmful to the Panth’s Chardee Kalaa as not tolerable and the other as desirable? In both situations, disrespect is shown to Gurbanee. If the form of the invincible Khalsa has been prescribed as distinct by the Kalgidhar Paatshah, then consider it as set in stone that the Saroop of the Guroo is also special. And that special Saroop is the Lareevaar Saroop, not the pad-ched form”. Despite what others may think, I find the above arguments put forward by these particular elders convincing. However, that is not my primary point - do you now see why I say that we should never COMPLETELY rely on elders/Sants for our final conclusions? Which elders/Sants sha’ll we rely upon when we are presented with conflicting views? Master Jaswant Singh Jee, the well-known Akhand Keertanee Jatha elder, laments the fact that at the time pad-ched took momentum, neither the Akhand Keertanee Jatha nor Damdami Taksaal took any kind of stand to prevent what was happening. Historically, these two Jathebandeean have had a firm stand regarding Lareevaar Saroop whereas now, especially outside of Panjaab, they do not take such a firm stand. Incidentally, Baba Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwalae Jee would not even allow his students to use pad-ched Senchiyan or Gutka Sahibs. I also believe it was either him or his successor, Baba Kartaar Singh Bhindranwalae, who also stated that pad-ched is 'maha-manmat’. What amazing examples of Bibek Budhi. It is shame that both Jathebandees have become so lax in recent times; their shared influence upon the worldwide Sangat could have prevented such a situation. Let us move onto one of the core issues in more detail. The Panth, even if it met today via Sarbat Khalsa tradition, would not be in unanimous agreement about whether within pad-ched Saroop, even from the 3rd Word onwards, as to what is mistaken and what is not. Should we read 'SatNaam' as two words or one? How would this affect meaning? Master Jaswant Singh Jee has made the above argument in his short tract, ‘The True Guroo is Lost’, and gives the following example: “A true Sikh comes to his senses right here. He repents and returns from the thought of doing pad-chhed. He asks the stubborn bemukhs, 'will you keep Sat and Naam apart or together?" How will you solve this issue? You have kept Sat apart, but hundreds of times, when the briefest form of the Mool Mantar comes, "Ek oankar Satgurparsaad", there you join “Sat” with “Gurparsaad.” Why is this?” Does the above point not show how badly the pad-ched producers are governed by Manmat, Dubidya and faithlessness, that they can allow such a situation to even occur, where they contradict their own pad-ched decisions? Even though the Panth is in such implicit disagreement, we have felt free to place our Dubidya into Maharaaj Jee’s Perfect Roop. As Maharaaj Jee says: ‘aap aapnee budh hai jethee , barnat bhin bhin tuhae tethee’. It is the Guroo-given understanding, through Gurprasaad, that allows us to read and to attempt to comprehend Maharaaj Jee. This comes down to, in the final analysis, a deeply personal and spiritual journey. Who is that person who dares stand between your Guroo Sahib and you, who decides the Budh that you must undeniably receive…that Budh which they, in there clever-mindedness have decided, through doing pad-ched of Maharaaj Jee’s Saroop, and placing themselves as Siree Guroo Sahib Jee’s executors as a result! They knowingly place their 'opinions' within Akalee Banee knowing that there are many differences of opinion! Should another human-being get to have the final say as to exactly what Maharaaj Jee is telling us; pad-ched places us in this situation. Sangat jee, please don’t dismiss these arguments. How are we better than the Namdhaarees? We are worse because we should know better. We have physically ripped Maharaj Jee’s Shabad Roop to pieces and we have happily introduced Bholaan (mistakes) into That which we claim to regard as Abhol (without mistakes). This is a major Dhil (lapse); there is no way to deny it. If these points are not convincing enough, let us move onto just one of the many Pankteean which have been identified as examples of why pad-ched Saroop simply doesn't work. Bear in mind that according to knowledgeable Gursikhs, there are over 500 different examples of controversial pad-ched occurrences for which there is currently no unanimous agreement! That is over one latent mistake that have been introduced into Maharaaj Jee’s Saroop per 3 Angs! Also bear in mind that technically speaking, there are different pad-ched Saroops saying different things. The mind boggles at the mistakes and inconsistencies we have created. Here is just one example which should suffice. Please tell me: which pad-ched attempt is right and which is wrong: [gurbani]hmmskInKudweIbMdyqum rwjsuminBwvY ][/gurbani] ham masakeen khudhaaee ba(n)dhae thum raajas man bhaavai || I am Your humble servant, Vahiguroo; Your Praises are pleasing to my mind. (Shabdarath; Teeka Faridkot) [gurbani]hmmskInKudweIbMdyqumrw jsuminBwvY ] [/gurbani] ham masakeen khudhaaee ba(n)dhae thumraa jas man bhaavai || I am a humble slave of Vahiguroo, (but) egoistic power (of administration) pleases you. (Bhai Veer Singh Jee; Prof. Sahib Singh Jee) (Ang 480) Which possible 'pad-ched created Arth' is correct, which is incorrect? One addresses Maharaaj Jee whilst the other addresses Munmukhs! Please consider such a distasteful situation! Also is it right to be intentionally reading something which has been decided by us, but not clearly sanctioned by Maharaaj Jee? Sangat Jee, the Dubidya will only increase unless we come to our senses. Only Maharaaj Jee has the Vahiguroo-ordained Right to Decide...He did...in His wonderous un-breakable, un-fathomable Lareevaar Form and we are now working against Him by printing, publishing, promoting and using pad-ched Saroop. Let us go back to Maharaaj Jee for guidance. Maharaaj Jee is the One and Only Kaswati/Paras Kalaa Who will take away all of our doubts in this world, as we walk upon the path of Gurmat. Maharaaj Jee's Shabad-Roop is the greatest Hukam; all other Hukams are contained within It and flow from It. A Gursikh can never even contemplate tampering with and therefore challenging Maharaaj Jee's Saroop - to do so is Maha Manmat of the highest order, going completely against against His Hukam: [gurbani]AmruvyprvwhuhYiqsunwilisAwxpncleInhujiqkrxIjwie ] [/gurbani] amar vaeparavaahu hai this naal siaanap n chalee n hujath karanee jaae || The Order of the Lord is beyond challenge. Clever tricks and arguments will not work against it. [gurbani]AwpuCoifsrxwiepvYmMinleyrjwie ] [/gurbani] aap shhodd saranaae pavai ma(n)n leae razaae || So abandon your self-conceit, and take to His Sanctuary; accept the Order of His Will. (Ang 1251) That Will has eternally manifested Itself within Maharaaj Jee’s Saroop, The Pothi of Parmeshar. Who are we to decide whether Maharaaj Jee can be improved; whether we should change a little here or there? Has Siree Guroo Sahib Jee been demoted to One who must change to suit our needs? The Gursikh should always know that their Guroo is Perfect and unquestionable in every sense; they should never even dream of such an act as advocating pad-ched of His Saroop. [gurbani]pUrykwkIAwsBikCupUrwGitviDikCunwhI ] [/gurbani] poorae kaa keeaa sabh kishh pooraa ghatt vadhh kishh naahee || All that the Perfect Lord does is perfect; there is not too little, or too much. [gurbani]nwnkgurmuiKAYswjwxYpUrymWihsmWhI ]33] [/gurbani] naanak guramukh aisaa jaanai poorae maa(n)hi samaa(n)hee ||33|| O Nanak, knowing this as Gurmukh, the mortal merges into the Perfect Lord God. ||33|| (Ang 1412) Has Satguroo Jee asked us to carry out or tolerate pad-ched of His Partakh Roop? Do we feel that we are worthy of making decisions on His behalf? Or maybe we should have been consulted: [gurbani]hirjoikCukrysuAwpyAwpyEhupUiCniksYkrybIcwir ] [/gurbani] har jo kishh karae s aapae aapae ouhu pooshh n kisai karae beechaar || Whatever the Lord does, He does by Himself. He does not ask or consult anyone else. (Ang 1135) We are un-caring about the fact that Maharaaj Jee's Saroop has physically been cut into pieces. In fact by condoning it and going along with it, we are party to it. [gurbani]kkwkwrnkrqwsoaU ] [/gurbani] kakaa kaaran karathaa sooo || KAKKA: He is the Creator, the Cause of causes. [gurbani]iliKElyKunmytqkoaU ] [/gurbani] likhiou laekh n maettath kooo || No one can erase His pre-ordained plan. [gurbani]nhIhoqkCudoaUbwrw ] [/gurbani] nehee hoth kashh dhooo baaraa || Nothing can be done a second time. [gurbani]krnYhwrunBUlnhwrw ] [/gurbani] karanaihaar n bhoolanehaaraa || The Creator Lord does not make mistakes. [gurbani]kwhUpMQuidKwrYAwpY ] [/gurbani] kaahoo pa(n)thh dhikhaarai aapai || To some, He Himself shows the Way. [gurbani]kwhUauidAwnBRmqpCuqwpY ] [/gurbani] kaahoo oudhiaan bhramath pashhuthaapai || While He causes others to wander miserably in the wilderness. [gurbani]AwpnKyluAwphIkIno ] [/gurbani] aapan khael aap hee keeno || He Himself has set His own play in motion. [gurbani]jojodInosunwnklIno ]17] [/gurbani] jo jo dheeno s naanak leeno ||17|| Whatever He gives, O Nanak, that is what we receive. ||17|| (Ang 253) Let us all accept these Panktees completely, in both Word and Spirit. Vaheguroo makes Perfect Plans which are Perfect. The job of a Daas is to receive the Perfection which is given to them by their Guroo Sahib without questioning or challenging anything. Those who initiated pad-ched Saroop interfered with The SatGuroo...those of us who promote it or do not speak against it have accepted that interfering with SatGuroo Jee is acceptable. What is the difference between them and us? Sadh-Sangat Jeeo, there are many other Shabads which could be used to make the point that is being made. We are all simply so used to pad-ched Saroop, the respected elders are so used to pad-ched Saroop, that we find it difficult to accept the reality of the situation. Bibekh-Budhi walae Singhs always say that one Dhil (lapse/slackness) leads to many others and creates Dubidya regarding that Gursikh's Gurmat-walee Sochnee. Those who do not believe that pad-ched Saroop is a major Dhil and believe it is instead Parvaan should consider the following scenarios...do these scenarios not force Dubidya into your mind: > Would we be happy if the Anmrit Sanchaar we were about to attend as an Abhilakee had Parkaash of pad-ched Senchiyan (or for that matter Larevaar Senchiyan) instead of the traditional single Saroop? > Why would we be unhappy…what is more important…the binding or the contents…yet it seems we are happy with the Gurshabad being forcefully cut-apart…over, and over, and over again...yet we worry more about the binding...Is it not the actual Gurbanee that carries the power? Should we not focus upon that? > If the seperation of the binding still troubles us, then lets's ask ourselves: why are we more interested in the singularity of the binding of Maharaaj Jee’s Bir, rather than the integrity of the Guroo-ordained Binding of His actual Shabad-Roop i.e. Lareevaar Roop? > If we have modified Maharaaj Jee's Perfect One and Only Original Form into pad-ched form, does that mean that Lareevaar Saroop was in need of 'more Perfection'. ..for we only 'modify' something if we wish to 'improve' it...we only 'fix' something if it is 'broken'. So can that which we claim to accept as the very epitome of Perfection Incarnate, Maharaj Jee's Saroop, be 'perfected more'? Is this not a contradiction in terms? > If Maharaaj Jee's Partakh Darshan is Shabad-Roop, are we really having His Partakh Darshan even though the pad-ched Saroop is not that same Blessed Roop that the Gurgaddi was passed onto in 1708? > If pad-ched and Lareevaar Saroop are equal and there is no difference, then let's be happy that Maharaaj Jee's Original Saroop is becoming rare; certainly, it is easier to read from, and generate money, from pad-ched Saroop...so why spend all that time on 'the other equal form' which takes longer to read? They're both equal right? Let's instead 'do Maharaaj Jee's Seva' by ensuring that nobody has to 'suffer the difficulty and indignity' of reading from Maharaaj Jee's Original Saroop...because both Saroops are equal right? I will stop now. Do you see what I mean? We have created this situation by accepting, using and promoting pad-ched Saroop. One Dhil, perhaps the Dhil of Dhils, has lead to all this. Let us genuinely accept that we all make mistakes, and let's look towards a solution. Surely, Siree Guroo Sahib Jee will be happy with our intentions. We his children (the youth, elders, everyone) have made mistakes and will continue to do so, Sacheh Patshaah, who is Abholan-haar and never makes mistakes, will surely forgive us. Only that person truly accepts their mistake, whom corrects it upon such realisation. I have not intended to offend anyone with my comments. I simply and sincerely believe that we should, wherever possible, speak against the practice, promotion and use of pad-ched Saroop, and find pleasure only in Maharaaj's Hukamee Lareevaar Saroop, which unlike the man-made pad-ched Saroop, can never be mistaken. Please remember that whenever we read, write or print Gurbanee, we are liable to make mistakes. Maharaaj Jee is not: [gurbani]hmBUlhqumsdwABUlwhmpiqqqumpiqqauDrIAw ] [/gurbani] ham bhooleh thum sadhaa abhoolaa ham pathith thum pathith oudhhareeaa || We are mistaken; You are never mistaken. I am a sinner; You are the Saving Grace of sinners. (Ang 1213) If after reading this you believe that Maharaaj Jee's Lareevar Saroop must be preserved, please take it upon yourself to make a change. It won't be easy, because Gurmat never is...and was never supposed to be. [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

CSJ · 23 May 2007

How and when new saroops started [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Atma Singh · 24 May 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Veer/Bhain 'CSJ' Jee, Pls see the following paragraphs which were in the article above: "It was during the 1960’s, when the SGPC, despite their previous resolution, allowed certain printers to carry-out pad-ched. Pad-ched has never become Panth-Parvaan (accepted by Panth). Sangat Jeeo, the sad fact is that printing was done through the back-door, with the SGPC who published the original Gurmatta against pad-ched, literally co-ordinating the process, without any due consideration for anyone’s opinions or feelings, let alone the wider Panth’s. Sangat Jeeo, these are the disgusting facts behind pad-ched of Maharaaj Jee’s Saroop. The key question is: How did that which was harmful to the Panth in 1945/1950, according to these Gurmattas, become desirable and acceptable during the 1960’s? It is this question, originally posed by Jathedar Bhai Raam Singh Jee of the Akhand Keertanee Jatha, which remains un-answerable. Shame on those who carried-out this unfaithful and egotistical act. There was money to be made because there were very lax Gurdwara ‘Sevadaars’ and ‘Parchaaraks’ the world over and the ‘Sangat’ were williing to take the ‘easier road’ of reading from pad-ched the moment it was offered. Like all good monopolists, the SGPC knew they were placed to make lots of money; especially since they were the ‘installed custodians of the Panth’." Perhaps Gursikhs can share more info about the socio-political climate within and during which the Dhil of creating pad-ched Saroop took place. [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Khalsaspirit · 25 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Just to clarify further about year and half ago again Sri Akal Takhat Sahib enacted the hukamnama to do the parkash of only Larridar saroop in all historic Gurudwaras under the SGPC management. How strongly it is implemented only Guru Janay but Panth never accepted the Parkash of Pad-ched saroop. And seems like at this moment only Akhand kirtani Jatha seems carrying this voice agianst Parkash of Pad-ched and we guess also only Taksal Jatha Bhindra (different than Mehta and Sangravan Taksal) has same thought as of AKJ on this issue and none others including SANT CORP cares about it at this moment. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Atma Singh · 26 May 2007

VahegurooJeeKAKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Veer/Bhain 'Khalsaspirit' Jee, Sadly i have to point out that although many Jatha Singhs/Singhneean no doubt recognise the importance of Lareevaar Saroop, as an organisation, and as individuals, there are evidently many lapses going on... In the UK, as well as in India but perhaps to a lesser extent, programmes do occur where it is a pad-ched Saroop which is Parkaash. Many individuals have pad-ched Saroop at home. This is escpecially apparent in the UK. In the UK the situation is such that Jatha elders are not even in a position to promote Lareevaar Saroop because perhaps over 90% of Rainsbaees are held at Gurooghars where pad-ched Saroop is Parkaash. Also, many of them believe there is no difference between pad-ched and Lareevaar Saroop...ideologically, sadly there is no committed standpoint. However, to the UK Jatha's credit, a recent Smaagam did feature the Parkaash of Lareevaar Saroop for most of the duration. This was definitely a step in the right direction. Generally speaking, whereas once the Jatha could say it was a strong advocate, i personally feel this is really no longer the case. Realistically, you only have small bands of people, such as Singhs in Panjaab and Singhs in Toronto, who not only proactively promote Lareevaar Saroop but most importantly refuse to even consider using or promoting pad-ched Saroop. Until the Jatha worldwide takes this stand, then the Jatha is also not truly advocating Lareevaar Saroop. i guess 'unanimous stands' don't really exist, or at least aren't a focus, when you get to the organisational level... i heard not so long ago that at Mehta pad-ched Saroop has been Parkaash...it seems they have also succumbed to this Dhil. i know nothing of Bhindra...pls tell me, do they only do Parkaash of Lareevaar Saroop? Veer/Bhain Jee, pls tell me more about this Hukamnama which you say was issued not so long ago. How can i obtain a copy? [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Khalistan_zindabaad · 26 May 2007

as faar as i know at mehta they do parkash of larevaar saroop of guru granth sahib jee maharaj. . . and give santhia of larevaar

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Khalistan_zindabaad · 26 May 2007

and actually just to correct yourself, there are sant mahapurkhs who also do parkash of larevaar saroop. . . so you cant say SANT corp arnt. wateva that means.

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Atma Singh · 27 May 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Sangat Jee, i inadvertantly made a mistake. i placed the translations in the wrong order. It should have read: [gurbani] hmmskInKudweIbMdyqum rwjsuminBwvY ][/gurbani] ham masakeen khudhaaee ba(n)dhae thum raajas man bhaavai || I am a humble slave of Vahiguroo, (but) egoistic power (of administration) pleases you. (Bhai Veer Singh Jee; Prof. Sahib Singh Jee) [gurbani] hmmskInKudweIbMdyqumrw jsuminBwvY ] [/gurbani] ham masakeen khudhaaee ba(n)dhae thumraa jas man bhaavai || I am Your humble servant, Vahiguroo; Your Praises are pleasing to my mind. (Shabdarath; Teeka Faridkot) (Ang 480) [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Khalsaspirit · 27 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Bhai Atma Singh jio, We understand your concern within jatha even. It is just timely matter but at least at large in jatha not denial for larridar saroop parkash may be some at dhill is possible. Anyway at least there are some one who cares about this other wise today in panth most became Sikh either under greed, for fame or to come to foreign countries thru misuse Gurudwaras. For the recent Hukamnama we will try to get the copy or other specifics and as soon as we got it we will post on this forum. It may take a while. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

ummm · 29 May 2007

still don't understand why no one did any shaeedi of this matter, recent events show the fervour with Shaeed bhai kanwaljit singh... why is it there are many talkers on this issue but no record of sacrifice ???

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Atma Singh · 27 Jun 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Veer/Bhain ' Khalsaspirit' Jee, Did you find that Hukamnama? [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

ummm · 27 Jun 2007

Veer atma singh, since you seem to be a very keen larivar supporter can you answer my question on the reason why there have been no sacrifices ??? no morchas ??? not even demo's in front of the printers who print pad ched birs ???

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Khalsaspirit · 27 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Bhai Atma Singh jio, We are trying to get copy with Akal takhat Sahib seal. As we mentioned earlier it may take a while and as soon as we get it we will post it here. In the mean please try emailing to [address removed] for the this hukamnama and see what they say. We just got info that most Historical Gurudwaras (Under SGPC) in Punjab alreday started to do larridaar saroop parkash" Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Atma Singh · 27 Jun 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Veer Ranjit Singh, i can't tell you why Shaheedian didn't occur but i can speculate... During the mid-late 1960's, it seems like the major Jathebandiaan, including AKJ and Taksaal, ignored what was happening or simply didn't do enough to raise awareness. Perhaps they did too little too late...it's probably a mixtuire of all of the above. Another reason could be that the printing and distribution of pad-ched Saroops was done in a seemingly stealthy manner i.e. there were no major announcements or any fanfare. This is undoubtedly because the SGPC didn't want to advertise the fact that it was contradicting its own standpoint, blatantly ignoring a binding Gurmatta and was not consulting the Panth to boot. Therefore, it may have taken a while for anyone to realise what was happening... Over the last year or so, i've experienced first hand how complacent people are regarding this issue. Either they think the issue is insignificant or irrelevant, or they think it is 'too controversial' to talk about. Most people are not bothered about the current state of affairs and would rather accept the status quo. The worst is when people say 'there is no difference between pad-ched and Lareevaar Saroop'; and then look at you as though you are doubting the power of Gurbanee and disrespecting pad-ched Saroops. It just shows how ill-informed we are about this major issue...that those who stand-up and protest against the vandalisation of Maharaaj Jee's Saroop are treated as the 'faithless doubters'! Most people believe that the GurShabad is simply 'writing in a book' and so they find it easy to stand by and remain silent while all this goes on. Perhaps that would explain why they are not fussed by the 're-arrangements of words' as they perceive it. There are also those who are well-intentioned, even respected Gursikhs, however they have succumbed to this major Dhil (lapse) due to a lack of Bibek (discerning judgment) and/or a misplaced sense of faith. They think the best way to please Maharaaj Jee is to accept that both Saroops are equal, the same and Parvaan (acceptable to Maharaaj Jee). In complete contrast, those who accept Maharaaj Jee's Saroop as the Ever Present, Ever Watchful Satguroo Sahib Jee (Hazar Nazar) are pained by the act of pad-ched Saroop. i have faith though that across the world, slowly but surely, people will begin to wake-up and right this massive wrong. The Panth can never be in Chardee Kalaa until this most fundamental issue is addressed. To even talk about the Panth being in Chardee Kalaa while this continues to occur is flawed... >>> How can Maharaaj Jee bless that Panth with Chardee Kalaa which itself continues to vandalise His Deh (body)? <<< [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

ummm · 28 Jun 2007

the bit i still don't get is, do we accept printed larevar birs then ???? surely these are not legitamate according to what you have written, maharaaj never printed any birs, they were hand written, >>> How can Maharaaj Jee bless that Panth with Chardee Kalaa which itself continues to vandalise His Deh (body)? <<<

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

ekmusafir_ajnabi · 28 Jun 2007

Atma Singh ji Is it not bad enough that people fail to read correctly or understand SGGS in its simplified format that you now advocate to have it read in Lareevar Saroop. Lareevar was a traditional writing format of that era and its significance in SGGS was that no one can polute (alter or add) the orignal writing. Nowadays we are farmore aware of our literature and its contents and thus can safeguard it from mischief. The emphasis should be on the understanding of our Hollybook and correct pronounciation and not on trying to make life difficult for the future generation. There is absolutely no spiritual gain in reverting back to Lareevar text. If you feel there is an spiritual advantage then perhaps you would like to elaborate on your thoughts. This is my humble opinion. Ekmusafir_ajnabi

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Kulbir Singh · 28 Jun 2007

Musafir Ajnabi, -------------- Is it not bad enough that people fail to read correctly or understand SGGS in its simplified format that you now advocate to have it read in Lareevar Saroop. --------------- We don’t have any right to change / alter Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee for our convenience. Today you advocate doing padd-chhed of Gurbani for convenience of doing paath, tomorrow by the same token someone may promote changing the script to Roman script for ease of doing paath. Now would we accept a Romanized roop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee as Guru and install it on the throne of Guruship in Gurdwaras? Same way, altered form of Gurmukhi should not be installed on the throne of the true Guru. ------------- Lareevar was a traditional writing format of that era and its significance in SGGS was that no one can polute (alter or add) the orignal writing. Nowadays we are farmore aware of our literature and its contents and thus can safeguard it from mischief. ----------- If we for a second assume and accept that doing padd-chhed is okay, then the next impossible problem we face is the impossibility to do padd-chhed in a correct way. There are hundreds of big and small differences between different padd-chhed saroops. “Nanak Dar Sareeta” or “Nanak Daras Reeta”? Which one is correct? One of them is not correct and the saroop carrying the wrong padd-chhed is missing that much baani. How can such saroop be the Guru? -------------- The emphasis should be on the understanding of our Hollybook and correct pronounciation and not on trying to make life difficult for the future generation. There is absolutely no spiritual gain in reverting back to Lareevar text. If you feel there is an spiritual advantage then perhaps you would like to elaborate on your thoughts. ------------- As mentioned above, many padd-chhed birs don’t have full baani. Don’t you see any harm in not reading baani correctly? Don’t you see any harm in missing baani by reading wrong padd-chheds? You may argue about paathis who may do wrong paath from laridaar saroop. The answer to this objection is that in case where paathis do wrong paath from laridaar saroop, the mistake would be considered to be the paathi’s mistake and not Guru’s mistake (as it is in case, its written wrong in saroop). And above all doing ardaas in the end is for seeking apology for such unintentional mistakes. The basic logic is that we have no right to alter what our Guru Sahib did. Who gave anyone write to do padd-chhed when Guru Sahib did laridaar? Kulbir Singh [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Khalsaspirit · 28 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Comments like these ----------------------------------------------------------- "The emphasis should be on the understanding of our Hollybook and correct pronounciation and not on trying to make life difficult for the future generation." ----------------------------------------------------------- Whoever made and agrees with these comments thinks that they have better foresight for generations than Guru Sahib. They are directly challenging Guru Arjan Dev ji, Guru Gobind Singh ji and their scribers Bhai Sahib Gurdass ji and Bhai Sahib Mani Singh ji. Challenging Guru Sahib is a sin for a Sikh. Waheguru Waheguru see the sharda of these Sikhs they started to call Guru Sahib "Holly book". We think for them it is a holly book because by doing manmat of Pad shhed and adding kachi bani to it yes, it will be a holly book like others has in their respective religions but piyario it is a living Guru for a Gursikh as Dasam Patshah himself ordained In 1708 as "PARGAT GURAN KI DEH" which was from Ik Oankar to Nanak naam milay ta jeeva in larrivaar order. We do not know what to call either sickness or ignorance of these Sikhs which shows that they do not want to be children of Guru Sahib. Any way Guru Sahib already did his kirpa and parkash of Larrivaar saroop has begun already in all historical Gurudwaras in Panjab which is a big achievement by Gursikhs who carried and carries this voice. Now it’s up to us we need just holly book or Living Guru. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Atma Singh · 28 Jun 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Veer Ranjit Singh Jee, Personally i think that ideally all Beers should be handrwritten because that would be very respectful not to mention a beautiful Seva to do. i imagie that unless Gursikhs are involved during the whole printing process, beadbee must occur within a typical printing room. Gursikhs in the past placed a big emphasis on not only reciting Gurbanee but also writing it. i believe to this day Jews still write every copy of the Torah (their holy scriptures - the Old Testament) by hand. How wonderful would it be if we still did. However, to compare printing with the act of pad-ched is wrong. Writing with an ink pen or printing with a ink template/head is not the same kind of difference that exists between Lareevaar Saroop and pad-ched Saroop. Printing is about a change in technology and method. You can print and produce Lareevaar Saroops without introducing any kind of typographical mistakes, if Maharaaj Jee does Kirpa. However the act of pad-ched is in itself an act where people knowingly introduce their own understanding regarding Gurbanee into Maharaaj Jee's Perfect Saroop. In other words, they inject their Manmat (their limited intelligence) into Maharaaj Jee's Saroop, knowingly making mistakes and creating differences between Beers. This issue is beyond ink and paper; it is about Gurbanee which is expressed via that ink and paper. i hope you now see that there is a major difference. Veer Kulbir Singh Jee has already addressed 'Musafir Ajnabi's' views but i would just like to add one more thing: It is the role of Maharaaj Jee to issue Hukams. It is the job of a Gursikh to simply follow without any kind of questioning. It was this attitude on the part of Bhai Lehna Sahib Jee which meant He became Siree Guroo Angad Sahib Jee. It then logically followers that to question or change, of all things, the very form of Maharaaj's Saroop is, in my opinion, not only a debased and utterly ungrateful act, it is also an act of apostacy...because Satguroo Sahib Jee's Wisdom is being challenged and rejected. To create pad-ched Saroop is to believe that one can do things better than Maharaaj Jee; that one can 'improve' things. Gursikhs knows that that Satguroo Sahib Jee Who is Perfect can never be improved or changed: [gurbani]pUrykwkIAwsBikCupUrwGitviDikCunwhI ] [/gurbani] poorae kaa keeaa sabh kishh pooraa ghatt vadhh kishh naahee || All that the Perfect Lord does is perfect; there is not too little, or too much. [gurbani]nwnkgurmuiKAYswjwxYpUrymWihsmWhI ]33] [/gurbani] naanak guramukh aisaa jaanai poorae maa(n)hi samaa(n)hee ||33|| O Nanak, knowing this as Gurmukh, the mortal merges into the Perfect Lord God. ||33|| (Ang 1412) [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

ummm · 29 Jun 2007

but that's my point, the larevar birs i've seen that have been handwritten aren't in a template form whatsoever, they are not neat and tidy like the printed ones.. the tukea overlap to the next line, the letters don't finish they way they do in the printed bira, the flow is continous not so perfect. You say its a technological advancement ??? was guru ji not aware of such things ?? Sikhi to the max is a technological advancement, we all use it copy and paste to prove our points and arguments ?? no i don't think using the technological advancement satisfies the point. You yourself have admitted there are around 500 differences in the birs, but then there is probably more made according to the knowledge one has , you and i could prob come up with 2000 variations, when it come's to the mehngi baniya, the one thing that i haven't understood as of yet is that when we recite gurbani, it will definitely be done pad ched, if anyone can do it larivar it wouldn't make sense would it ??? Again I can't see how we can accept the printed bira, beadbi is beadbi ! big or small, we shouldn't condone one as it's not as big as another, I agree though the birs should be hand written with the love and devotion a guriskh should have. Why do you say on one hand in maharaj's foresight he would have written it pad ched if he wished so, but as he never, who are we to change it, maharaj was beant and if he wished so, he could have created printing machine there and then and printed the birs, but he never, it was handwritted by a gursikh who had the love of gurbani enshrined in his heart. It seems that we wish to ignore other bullea going on and only concentrate on the larivar v padched issue. For me at the moment there is much more beadbi going on with printing presses be it larivar or padched.

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

123 · 29 Jun 2007

As SIkhs today our job is not to forcibly place Lareevar Saroops into gurudwara, we have to have the patience and teach people the Grammatical rules which govern the reading of Lareevar Saroop. This is because the BIGGEST reason that commities/communities have for not instaliing lareevar saroop is that no-one can read it. THAT IS WHERE THE FLAW IS. SGPC will begin to use that as an excuse (probably already do) for their shady actions in the 1960's when pad-chhed was brought about. If we taught Lareevar on a GLOBAL basis this problem would solve itself. We have to bring Lareevar to the people because in today's condition, the people aren't going anywhere near Lareevar [%sig%]

Re: Lareevar Saroop: Some thoughts

Atma Singh · 29 Jun 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Dear Veer Ranjit Singh Jee, It's best if i try to address your counter-arguments point-by-point: "but that's my point, the larevar birs i've seen that have been handwritten aren't in a template form whatsoever, they are not neat and tidy like the printed ones.. the tukea overlap to the next line, the letters don't finish they way they do in the printed bira, the flow is continous not so perfect". > When i say template what i mean is the fact that pad-ched Saroops are printed in 'different formats' according to the decisions made as to how to carry out pad-ched; this is what i mean by template. i am not referring to the general layout. Incidentally, there is no such thing as a Praatan pad-ched Saroop. This is because our ancestors, unlike us, had much better Bibek-Budhee and didn't commit such acts. Never mind even this; to my knowledge there are not even any Praatan Gutkae Sahibaan featuring pad-ched. Hand-written Lareevaar Saroops are, needless to say, hand-written so they will never look as 'tidy' as the printed ones. You're right about the flow; the last letter on each line won't necessarily signal the end of a word in hand-written Saroops. You may have to begin the next line to view the tail-end. This is the case with many printed Lareevaar Saroops as well. For someone who makes an effort, this is not a problem. In fact, i think it's part of the overall charm and pleasure. "You say its a technological advancement ??? was guru ji not aware of such things ?? Sikhi to the max is a technological advancement, we all use it copy and paste to prove our points and arguments ?? no i don't think using the technological advancement satisfies the point". > i was simply trying to make the point that the contentious differences between Lareevaar saroop and pad-ched Saroop are not to do with the printing/writing methods. They are to do with the way Maharaaj Jee's Saroop is disrespected, mis-expressed and ultimately changed by those who have no right to do so. i actually agree with you. i don't think printing is an 'advancement'. Ideally all Saroops should be hand-written. Reading Gurbanee is an act of carrying out pad-ched via your limited mind and then expressing it via your mouth. Using SikhiToTheMax is the act of reading someone's limited opinion regarding pad-ched from a display technology (i think Professor Sahib Singh's in this case). It's when people mess with Maharaaj's Infinite/Unlimited Saroop, which is in The form of A Granth, that we have a distasteful situation. i have no problem with people writing/printing Gurbanee in pad-ched form - it does not mean they are disrespecting Maharaaj Jee’s Saroop; they are simply expressing their opinion regarding how they think it should be read and what they think it means. However, when people change and manipulate Maharaaj Jee's Saroop, surely you must realise this is not a good thing. "You yourself have admitted there are around 500 differences in the birs, but then there is probably more made according to the knowledge one has , you and i could prob come up with 2000 variations, when it come's to the mehngi baniya, the one thing that i haven't understood as of yet is that when we recite gurbani, it will definitely be done pad ched, if anyone can do it larivar it wouldn't make sense would it ???" > Veer Jee, may i humbly say that i think you are missing the central points of my argument, yet you have by coincidence proved my central point in this statement: When interacting with Gurbanee, we all do pad-ched according to OUR LIMITED MAT. It’s not the general concept of pad-ched that people like me have a problem with…to interact with Gurbanee is, by default, to carry out pad-ched. However Veer Jee, please understand the following: me or you can say with 100% faith that only That Gurbanee recited through The Holy Mouth of Maharaaj Jee, or written by His Holy Hands, can be called ‘correct pad-ched’. No pad-ched Saroop can ever be regarded as ‘correct’, neither can any human’s recitation be ‘correct’. However, by not manipulating Maharaaj Jee’s Lareevaar Saroop, we leave intact every possible approach when it comes to how Gurbanee can be recited. In other words, we leave un-affected That which is Unfathomable and Infinite. Lareevaar Saroop can never be limited to human-inspired mistakes. This is the central crux of the argument. "Again I can't see how we can accept the printed bira, beadbi is beadbi ! big or small, we shouldn't condone one as it's not as big as another, I agree though the birs should be hand written with the love and devotion a guriskh should have". > i agree with you 100%. Printing is not ideal and creates a situation where Beadbee can and most often does occur in your everyday printing-presses. "Why do you say on one hand in maharaj's foresight he would have written it pad ched if he wished so, but as he never, who are we to change it, maharaj was beant and if he wished so, he could have created printing machine there and then and printed the birs, but he never, it was handwritted by a gursikh who had the love of gurbani enshrined in his heart. It seems that we wish to ignore other bullea going on and only concentrate on the larivar v padched issue. For me at the moment there is much more beadbi going on with printing presses be it larivar or padched". > Veer Jee, i fully accept your point. It is something i, and no doubt many others, fully agree with. However, i fully agree that an even better solution would be only hand-written Lareevaar Beers are produced from now on. A second-best solution would be if a Gursikh actually owned a printing press which would exclusively print Saroops, Senchiyaaan, Potheean and Gutkae Saahibaan in conditions which maintain Satkaar. These could then be distributed via a centralised and licensed process… i probably don’t need to say that these would all be Lareevaar... :-) Veer/Bhain '123' Jee, i fully agree with your sentiments. It is about education. Poeple are asleep and need to wake-up. We've got to help them understand but ensure we never dilute The Truth of the argument...i am sad to say that i have met many Gursikhs who 'water down Truth' in the name of 'Humility' and 'Piyaar' when it comes to Gurmat-related issues such as Lareevaar Saroop and sarbloh Bibek. i think that is fake humility and fake piyaar. However, on a side-note, one does not have to be fully aware of Grammatical rules to do pad-ched while reading from Lareevaar Saroop; this can and will no doubt come later with many people. For instance, Gursikhs linked to Taksaal, which does not accept that Gurbanee features a unique Grammar System, read from Lareevaar Saroop and do pad-ched extremely proficiently. [%sig%]