Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Oh My God!!!!!!

Oh My God!!!!!!

nitn3m · 29 May 2007

I read this from a blog. 'Forgotten Science.' "The past year I have heard numerous variations of Simran and Kirtan. Though I enjoy them all, there is nothing like Raag. Our Guru's were experts in the science of Naad Yoga. They composed the Shabads of the Guru Granth Sahib in such a way that the melody of the Raag alone will uplift you and carry you across the world ocean. The ancient Science of Naad Yoga is a ancient Science that uses sound and chanting as a way of spiritual development, healing and progression. The very first kirtan I ever heard was by Snatam Kaur. Her angelic voice mixed with beautiful backing sounds soothed me and brought me to the feet of the Guru. From this starting point I started listening to more Raag. When I started attending the Gurdwara regularly and learning vaja, I got caught up so much in what everyone else was learning and I began to forget about the importance of Naad. Kundalini Yoga even teaches the importance of Naad, through various mantras and chants, but even my knowledge of that still escaped me. In the UK, the focus within the youth at the moment is the fast Simran .. For the past few months, this is the type of Simran I have been surrounded by and I have noticed a major shift in my character, it is only today, with Guru's Grace that I have realised what was causing it. The first time I heard this fast VAHEGURU VAHEGURU chanting I admit i was absorbed almost instantly. The atmosphere was electrifying. I experienced a range of sensations and emotions and had various experiences in this atmosphere, but, the experience was always short lived. I blamed myself for not being able to do the Simran right. On my recent visit to England I was reconnected with the first spark that brought me to Sikhi. I was reconnected to the Naad and to the Shabad and Guru helped me understand why for the past few months I have been feeling vulnerable and lost. This electrifying fast Simran raises energy so fast that it brings about spiritual and emotional changes in the body. From the base of your spine to the top of your head the vibration of Naam surges up and down, but there is no release point. And with no release point the energy manifests into energy, some are not ready to handle. The youth that do this type of Simran are full of anger, judgement and like power. Im not judging them, Im stating what I've witnessed and to be honest, it scares me. This type of fast Simran, In my own opinion should be done very carefully and by those only who are already at a certain stage in Sikhi. Im not sure where the style grew from and i would be interested if anyone has any informaion on it so that I may understand it better. From my own practice of this fast Simran I can say that it made me feel very emotionally vulnerable, angry at times and very confused. It is almost hypnotizing and everyone that does this type of simran appears to have similar beliefs in terms of thier Sikhi. Concluding this blog entry I would like to say, listen to a piece of hardcore rave music and listen to a piece of fast simran, they are almost identical in sound, rhythm and pattern, which is frightening! Are we doing this sort of simran to enjoy it or to benefit from it. I would be very interested to hear what people have expereinced from fast simran and the type of emotions people have from this. But from now on, I'm sticking to the traditional style, the way our wonderful Guru's intented it." Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Singhstah · 29 May 2007

seems just like an attack on akj rainsabais by sum raag fanatic, the comparison to rave music and simran was especially offensive. [%sig%]

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harjas Kaur · 29 May 2007

[quote]The very first kirtan I ever heard was by Snatam Kaur. Her angelic voice mixed with beautiful backing sounds soothed me and brought me to the feet of the Guru. From this starting point I started listening to more Raag... Concluding this blog entry I would like to say, listen to a piece of hardcore rave music and listen to a piece of fast simran, they are almost identical in sound, rhythm and pattern, which is frightening![/quote] Lol. Snatam Kaur sings raag? And fast simran is like rave music? Let her be, these are silly opinions, no need to post them on public forum like this. She's not talking bad about anyone, it's just something she doesn't understand. From her amrit name Guru Dev Kaur I assume she's 3HO, as they are the only people who use guru in their names. (no comment) Naturally she will be partial to Snatam kaur and yoga. She is not harming anyone, but I doubt she has a clue about naam drirh. She has a very nice picture and seems sincere. Guruji bless her to grow in Gursikhi! She is new to Sikhism, people should give her a friendly welcome. And if you have something educational to share with her about raag (haha) help her out! It's very beautiful to see her wearing keski! [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LrmYC8MMuNg[/url] Sanatam Kaur and Guru Ganesha Singh doing raag (Well not really :) [%sig%]

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Khalsaspirit · 29 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Let's see what Guru Sahib have to say ********************************************************** [gurbani]"hir ky log rwm jn nIky BwghIx n suKwie ] ijau ijau rwm khih jn aUcy nr inMdk fMsu lgwie ]3]2]"[/gurbani] Panna 881 ********************************************************** [gurbani] BwghIxW nUM hir jn au`cI nwm jpdy hI nhI suKwauNdy, ijauN ijaN hir jn au`cI au`cI hir js krdy hn, gurbwxI au`cI au`cI gWaudy hn jW au`cI Awlwp nwl hir-jp AlwauNdy hn, iqnHW nUM ahnW dw ies ibiD au`cI hir jsu gwauxw qy jwpu Alwauxw fMg lgy vWgUM cuBdw hY[ ieh auhnw dI mihz BwghIxqw hY Aqy mhW inMdkpuxw hY[ gurmuiK hir jnW nUM Aijhy hoCy inMdkw dI prvwh nhI krnI cwhIdI[ AwpxI AnMd lYA ivc jwp AlweI jwxw hir js gweI jwxw cwhIdw hY[ auh lokW dI .Kwqr QoVy gwaudyN AlwaNudy hn, siqgurU dw hukm kmwauNdy hn[[/gurbani] Viakhiya by Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee From above gurbani and viakhiya it is very clear unblissed one's have hate for naam ucharan and they should be ignored. And we guess this is nothing to do with certain jatha or the way but they have hate for Waheguru ucharan itself. Do not care about them keep on doing... Waheguru, Waheguru, Wahguru, Waheguru, Wahegurooooooooooooooooo Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

neech ajaan · 30 May 2007

partly...i had the same question in ma mind...like...why izit that we suddenly experience such a force while simran?...altho i jus know of experiencing it thrice or so.... does it mean ...that a person like me who is so black from the inside is not capable of reciting this pure name? hmmmm m confused... anywayz... about the original post....i guess the person jus expressed their views...and did not really mean to attack any particular group or jathebandi...coz it seems that s/he did not know that the keertan by snatam kaur ji was raag or not.... so how can that be an attack? and as s/he said I would be very interested to hear what people have expereinced from fast simran and the type of emotions people have from this." anyone regarding this?

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

jassmannn · 30 May 2007

I think it is very nice and sincere what she has shared with everyone on this forum. I myself am not too keen on very fast Simran, where the word Waheguru is distorted and becomes and sounds like something totally different. Speed has nothing to do with Simran, it is about making a connection, and Simran can be done slowly at length with Clarity and correct pronunciation for a real nice effect. I don't know why people have a problem with Raag, it is after all what the Bani is written in.

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harjas Kaur · 30 May 2007

[quote]I myself am not too keen on very fast Simran, where the word Waheguru is distorted and becomes and sounds like something totally different. Speed has nothing to do with Simran, it is about making a connection, and Simran can be done slowly at length with Clarity and correct pronunciation for a real nice effect. I don't know why people have a problem with Raag, it is after all what the Bani is written in.[/quote] No one has a problem with Raag. Raag is the purataan way the shabads are supposed to be sung. All I said was Snatam Kaur does NOT play raag. It's a foolish mistake if anyone thinks her style of kirtan is raag. It cannot be denied that the person whose blog is saying fast style simran creates anger and negativity and fanatical belief systems is biased. But these views are out there. It's kalyug. If we try to educate people and answer their concerns it will go far to diffusing some of the misguided attacks. [img]http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Atrium/1617/SIKHPICS/Kirtania/rancani.jpg[/img] Was Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji filled with krodh? Was Bhai Fauja Singh Ji filled with krodh? Was Bhai Sukhdev Singh Babbar Ji filled with krodh? Was Bhai Rama Singh Ji filled with krodh? Is Bhai Jeevan Singh Ji filled with krodh? No. These are all examples of Jathabandies filled with bir raas and Gursikhi jeevan. So it's not possible that a Jatha with practice of Naam drirh can produce so many spiritual lights and be doing simran in a way that creates anger and fanaticism. Sometimes people forget that we are supposed to be sipahis as well as sants. We have jaikara and battle spirit and sometimes our simran reflects that holy warrior nature. What Gurbani says is different from all these distorted opinions. And I believe Gurbani. [quote]so swDU bYrwgI soeI ihrdY nwmu vswey ] (29-14, isrIrwgu, mÚ 3) so saaDhoo bairaagee so-ee hirdai naam vasaa-ay. That person is a Holy Saadhu, and a renouncer of the world, whose heart is filled with the Naam. AMqir lwig n qwmsu mUly ivchu Awpu gvwey ] (29-15, isrIrwgu, mÚ 3) antar laag na taamas moolay vichahu aap gavaa-ay. His inner being is not touched by anger or dark energies at all; he has lost his selfishness and conceit.[/quote] Vahiguru/Waheguru is a word. If we all sit down and recite the name, Waheguru Waheguru, that is ordinary speech. How we precisely pronounce may be an issue. We respect the God who the word defines. But saying the word Waheguru will not effect any change in you. The word alone is not Naam. [quote]guru nwmu idRVwey rMg isau hau siqgur kY bil jwau ] (40-15, isrIrwgu, mÚ 4) gur naam drirh-aa-ay rang si-o ha-o satgur kai bal jaa-o. The Guru has lovingly implanted the Naam, the Name of the Lord, within me; I am a sacrifice to the True Guru.[/quote] Waheguru Gurmantara is a presence, not mere word or symbolic sound communicated by language. Naam Drirh is a gupt technique which can only be imparted to a Sikh by Panj Piare. It has nothing to do with clarity and correct pronunciation of the word Waheguru, but is a living power, a force, a sound current intimately interconnected with our breathing. Which is why in vaaran of Bhai Gurdas Ji he says that Vahiguru/Waheguru is Word-Guru. So Gurmantar is Shabad. It has nothing to do with "nice effect." It's not a musical artifice to manipulate a sensation in the listeners. The whole purpose of doing Naam simran with kirtan is because thats what Gurbani says. [quote]gurmuiK sbdu pCwxIAY hir AMimRq nwim smwie ] (29-5, isrIrwgu, mÚ 3) gurmukh sabad pachhaanee-ai har amrit naam samaa-ay. The Gurmukhs realize the Word of the Shabad; they are immersed in the Ambrosial Nectar of the Lord's Name.[/quote] No one anywhere said Simran has to do with speed. But neither can the energy of Simran be harnessed. It is a force of it's own. It flows. Sometimes it will flow fast, sometimes slow. Sometimes it is steady and rhythmic, sometimes forceful. What the Naam is doing in the individual Gursikh has to do on an energy level. There are times when japping Naam the mind is distracted a person has no feeling of connection. And other times when the mind is uplifted tears are flowing. How can anyone simplify a concept of spiritual energy to say fast is not good, only slow is good? Is your heartbeat always slow? It never gets fast? And your breath is always steady and never changes speed? The breath and heartbeat change to reflect states of your being, as does the simran. Bhai Manpreet Singh Ji doing Kirtan [url]http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6212265904869920687&q=akj[/url] Bhai Ravinder Singh Ji doing Kirtan [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nu9OAGkooA4[/url] Amazing and beautiful Keertan & Simran by a Child [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YJ9qW5fCqwg[/url] ~bhul chuk maaf karni ji [%sig%]

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

w/ever · 03 Jun 2007

^^^ i wish you would not take Tuks from Gurbani to try and "support" your arguement without doing vichaar/or relating your point to the WHOLE shabad

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

jassmannn · 04 Jun 2007

Because it looks like people are in a trance when they do it, and the simran is supposed to be remembering God not whatever it is you are talking about. Waheguru is the word, and pronounciation is very important, as anyone who has learnt bani will tell you. You can do as you please and what you think is right, but it just does not feel right to me. Saying vaheguru once properly will give you immeasurable benefit, so there is no rush in saying it over and over so that it sounds like something else.

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harinder Singh · 04 Jun 2007

The pronounciation of Gurmantar is VERY VERY VERY IMPORTANT. Infact the gurmantar is Gur Moorat and we have no right to alter the Moorat of Guru Sahib. The speed at which Gurmantar shud be spoken depents on the state of mind of individual. Its not the speed that matters, its all about listening. Infact same goes for gurbani as well. Whether we do kirtan or paath, we shud do it at a pace that our ears are able listen to it clearly. Fast simran is ok if it doesnt hamper the pronounciation. From my personal experience, I fing many singhs while doing fast simran ignore or cut short the Wahe part of Gurmantar which is a HUGE mistake. Satguru jee likes Wahe Wahe and we shud not be missing it.

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harjas Kaur · 04 Jun 2007

Well we could recite the entire Akhand Paath, and this would be entire truth. But for purposes of a discussion, to bring up points in a short space, I do not see another way to do it. Perhaps you could demonstrate. I used the tuk which mentions Naam drirh because of the mention of Naam drirh, not the entire philosophical discussion of the Gurbani, which of course is absolutely instructive but is not specific to this discussion.

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harjas Kaur · 04 Jun 2007

[quote]You can do as you please and what you think is right, but it just does not feel right to me. Saying vaheguru once properly will give you immeasurable benefit, so there is no rush in saying it over and over so that it sounds like something else.[/quote] I am not doing what I please. I am reciting according to the way the Panj Piare have instructed me. I cannot explain to you the gupt method of Naam abiyaas. But I can tell you it is a part of the breathing, and as such it is not specific pronunciation, because people are not saying a specific word. People are breathing a word, and thus the pronunciation isn't exactly speech. And it is this saas giras simran which is more of a vibration, or a force which becomes your breath. I am trying to be as informative as I can. Perhaps I'm not the person to explain it. I recommend you ask some of the older chardhikala Singhs who are Naam Abiyasi's to explain it before you completely criticize what you are not understanding.

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harjas Kaur · 04 Jun 2007

[quote]The pronounciation of Gurmantar is VERY VERY VERY IMPORTANT. Infact the gurmantar is Gur Moorat and we have no right to alter the Moorat of Guru Sahib. The speed at which Gurmantar shud be spoken depents on the state of mind of individual. Its not the speed that matters, its all about listening.[/quote] Veerji, when you are doing Naam abhiyaas, you are not speaking. You are breathing. So how can you make your mouth to exactly pronounce what is essentially an energy pranayaam? You are japping with every breath. The Panj Piare give you Naam Drirh. They infuse it into you. So you aren't altering anything. Guru Sahib is giving you a technique through the sargun roop of His Panj Piare. You can't just read Gurbani, find the word for Gurmantar and have the gupt method for recitation of the Naam. And that's all I can say on the subject. Accept or don't accept. I'm not saying pronunciation is not important. I'm saying when you do Naam drirh, you aren't speaking, and thus aren't pronouncing. You are breathing it. And you aren't even listening to it, you are becoming one with the Gurmantar of the breath and it is flowing through you. [url]http://naamvairaag.blogspot.com/2006/08/how-do-we-do-simran.html[/url] [%sig%]

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harinder Singh · 05 Jun 2007

<> We are breathing and with the power of this breathing, our tongue is moving in a way that helps us to speak Waheguru.Without this tongue moving with our breath, naam rass will be greatly affected. <> Satguru jee, through Punj Pyaras ACTIVITATES NAAM in our body but after this, its upto to the Punj pyaras and their knowledge of Naam abhiyaas to explain the way of japping Naam and thats where alteration can come. In AKJ, currently there are different versions of naam drirh going around. There are some people who give all importance to "guru" and almost ignore "wahe" part. Then there are others who only use their breath to produce the sound of "wahe"(and hence are unable to properly produce the sound of "v") while others use breath + tongue to speak wahe.All these alterations are bound to have an affect on the pronuciation of Naam. Recently to my surprise I met an AKJ singh who while inhaling speaks guru and while exhaling wahe and this is what his Punj taught him. Then there are differences with respect to the movement of stomach while japping Naam in the jatha. I feel that if someone is serious about meeting Waheguru and has bhola-pan, Guru Sahib would directly or indirectly get his naam abhiyaas right, so its better to leave everything on Guru Sahib on this matter.

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

jassmannn · 05 Jun 2007

When I took Amrit, there was no 'gupt naam'? I was told the same as everyone else taking at the same time that Veheguru is the guru mantar. There is no such thing as gupt, or secretive. We have nothing to hids and have the bani of the guru ji, where the panj piyare get their instruction from, as do we. What is the gupt thing all about?

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harinder Singh · 05 Jun 2007

<> Breathing shud not be affecting the pronunciation of Gurmantar and if it does, there is something wrong in the naam abhiyaas technique. Speaking a word in routine speech or speaking the same word while singing shud not be alterating the pronunication,though it will affect other characteistics of the sound signal. Same is true for breathing. I just recalled that there is one more version of naam drirh going around these days,lol. There are people in the jatha who speak Wahe-gurooooo while others speak Wahe-gurrrrrrrru and this will surely have an affect on the pronunciation. These differences might seem minimal to some but they can have huge affect on our spirtual growth.

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harjas Kaur · 05 Jun 2007

Thank you ji. This is a good explanation. Although it is concerning that different groups may be doing different things. I do understand about bandhas from yoga and pulling in the stomach and straightening the spine, but these are not specifically taught. I wasn't sure how much about it we could discuss. Especially there seems to be a lot of resistance to concepts of yoga by a lot of people. Although there is a difference between forcing yoga onto Sikhi, like Kundalini yoga which is something totally separate, and finding yoga principles discussed in Gurbani. Maybe I'm wrong on this, but that's how I see it. But the part about not being able to pronounce the Vahi and the energetic gurrrrru not being phonetically exact with breathing is what I was referring to. I have tried to strictly pronounce and it is very ackward and doesn't have the same flow or even sound right. But when I put my mind on Vahiguru and simply breathe, it is flowing very energetically. However when japping Naam, thought of Vahiguru is fixed in the mind. And while there are many spellings of Waheguru, we know from Vaaran of Bhai Gurdas Ji that the proper pronunciation is Vahiguru. V for Vishnu, H for Har, G for Gobind, and R for Ram. But when you breathe in, it sounds like Wahe. [%sig%]

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Khalsaspirit · 05 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, "I met an AKJ singh who while inhaling speaks guru and while exhaling wahe and this is what his Punj taught him." Seems very impractical. Anyway we think please you guys should use sanjam on this topic now. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harinder Singh · 05 Jun 2007

Dear Bhain Sahib, The pronunciation of Waheguru affects the impact on dasam duar and the kanval in our navel. The movement of the stomach also affects the impact on the kanval in our navel. Wrong pronunciation or wrong movement of stomach leads to wrong or weak impact, which can hinder or even stop ones spiritual progress. If we have any doubt over naam abhiyaas jugti, we shud not be taking it lightly. We shud be doing ardaasan day and night before Satguru Jee to give us Punj who know the complete jugti. Amrit is Naam and without complete naam abhiyaas jugti, amrit sanchar is incomplete. Ang 515 vwhu vwhu ihrdY aucrw muKhu BI vwhu vwhu kryau ] vaahu vaahu hiradhai oucharaa mukhahu bhee vaahu vaahu karaeo || according to my understanding, Guru Sahib says "speak Waheguru from ur hirdaa and also ur mouth. If we speak Waheguru from hirdaa, we realize the importance of pronunciation.

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Khalsaspirit · 06 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Harinder Singh jio, Fully agree with you but these details not needed to be discuss here that is why we asked for sanjam. Guru Sahib will keep his kirpa to have his panj Singh always available to decipher that situation. We hope you will understand what we are trying to say. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harjas Kaur · 07 Jun 2007

Okay ji. I am respecting Khalsaspirit's wise admonition. This discussion is over for me. Thank you Harinder Singh for taking time to explain. I will ponder what you have said here and do Ardas to Guruji for best understanding of technique. Also I will take time to speak to a Gurmat Singh who has done Panj Piare seva many years to clear up some matters. Thanks again. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! [%sig%]

Re: Oh My God!!!!!!

Harinder Singh · 08 Jun 2007

<> Theek-aa pyare veer, jivain tussin kaho.lol.