Re: Panthic Unity
Nirvair Khalsa · 15 Jun 2007
It is definately nice to see better Panthic Unity now since a long time. Lets hope this does not decrease, but increase, and ultimately there is complete EKTHA in the Khalsa Panth...
[%sig%]
Re: Panthic Unity
Khalistan_zindabaad · 16 Jun 2007
we already have our heads together, but when they do come together they seem only to take a photo have a press release and then actually forget the matters why they were called. ekta with vaheguru is a must not with humans. but isuppose whatever satguru jee wants will happen.
Re: Panthic Unity
Harinder Singh · 16 Jun 2007
Unity in the panth ? we dont even have unity within jathas. There are groups within groups within groups .......
The ONLY solution to this is PUNJ. And these punj will be real punj of the level of 1699. And its not in our hands to choose these punj. Guru Gobind Singh, the king of the world, the only Mard to have ever existed, is going to choose them. He is going to keep His pyara lotus hand on 5 heads and thats it. Game on.
"Tahe kaha parvah kahu ke, JA KAI BASEES DHARIYO GUR HATH "
RAJ KAREGA KHALSA
Re: Panthic Unity
the paradigm shifter · 20 Jun 2007
On the issue of tolerance, perhaps we ought to understand that when we say we 'tolerate' someone we are saying in other words that we do not necessarily like what the others are doing however offensive it might be but we'll accept to keep our distance.
why do we say we tolerate something when we should be saying that it is not acceptable? would you tolerate inhuman treatment or sheer stupidity? why tolerate something when you can make a difference and change it?
we should stop tolerating things and start making a difference. it is almost insulting for anyone to say they tolerate you.
tolerate v.- allow the existence or occurrence of (something that one dislikes or disagrees with) without interference.
My understanding of our Guru's lives is that they never tolerated anything but always made a difference in those people they disagreed with.
[%sig%]
Re: Panthic Unity
the paradigm shifter · 21 Jun 2007
No Jassmannn, what i am saying is that when they start reading the ragmala infront of you and it begins to upset you just walk away or go do some sewa somewhere else.
my perception is that raag mala is not bani yet i have no qualms about anyone reading it or not. I do not propagate it since it holds no essence about sikhi. It teaches one nothing that they can apply in their jivan hence it is of little value.
you do not have to start any protest yet worse use any force.....on what grounds do you want to do that? That others are reading the raag malaa and it upsets you? so what if they think it is bani? If you know better teach them.
Panthic unity is not about tolerance, its about understanding better the differences that make us what we are. Panthic unity is not about numbers, its about following the way of the Guru, Gurmat.
I cannot understand why it upsets you so much that other people read the raag malaa. What are you doing there whenever they are reading it? The only way to make a change in others is to change oneself.
have a nice day jassmannn
[%sig%]
Re: Panthic Unity
the paradigm shifter · 21 Jun 2007
oops sorry jassmannn, i just read on another post that you are pro rag malaa. I guess that is why you are always present when it is being read.
I on the other hand feel there is nothing virtuous in the rag malaa yet cannot deny you your right to read it accepting it as bani.
my question now is, do you tolerate me because of something i don't do i.e don't read the rag malaa or do i accept you the way you are? How is it possible that you can tolerate me for something i do not even do?
[%sig%]
Re: Panthic Unity
the paradigm shifter · 22 Jun 2007
jassmannn you are certainly not bothered with what i believe but you go on and on in so many posts stating what you believe.....seems like you do not enjoy a dose of your own medicine.
but back to the point.......pray tell me how it offends you when other people walk out? what part of you aches in pain at seeing them go? can you not see the folly of your so called tolerance? you do tolerance when others do nothing and yet it offends you?
perhaps i ought to tolerate your next post....have a nice day jassmannn
[%sig%]
Re: Panthic Unity
Harjas Kaur · 22 Jun 2007
Tolerance and respect are needed. We have to pick our battles, or we will deteriorate fighting each other over every difference. Cohesiveness and Panthic unity are achieved when we can subordinate the differences and show respect for others views and unify against the larger abuses that are injuring the Panth. Just because someone has a different opinion about something isn't the same thing as doing beadbi. You don't have to ostracize 80% of the Panth because they do something different. This is where we need to get our priorities straight. Everything is in context. Are we debating meat-eating? Are we debating cut kes? Are we debating Raag Mala? Are we debating some amritdhari bibian don't wear keski?
Some things are personal choice and opinion or views which belong to another respected Jatha. Other things are just a deterioration and disregarding of rehitnamay. Some other things are absolutely contentious and disharmonious and border on beadbi, as we have seen current examples of.
1. People are not perfect. There's a difference between failing to live up to a standard, and attacking the validity of the standard. Hence someone may cut kes, but be a very respectful person who is trying in their life to do better. Or someone may be preaching to all our kids that no one needs to keep kes. There is a very different standard here in how these people would be approached.
2. Someone may actually believe eating meat is okay, because this is what the SGPC Maryada says. Is he deliberately doing paap? Should we say his amrit is no longer valid? To be honest, these more tricky situations call for a hukumnama and maybe even Sarbat Khalsa to be cleared up within the entire Panth. But for now, we would be splitting the Panth to reject outright someone elses amrit when Panthically it has been declared valid.
In this case, I recommend tolerance and respect because the individuals are actually obeying what the Panth has allowed. Despite our personal understanding of the wrongness of eating meat as an amritdhari, we have to reconcile the various beliefs of the Panth currently, not split ourselves off in a mini protest, which is what often happens, leaving AKJ to be called cultic by the mainstream. Then people just shut off from anything wise AKJ has to teach.
Unless we ourselves (well actually elders and wise Gursikhs) start to do real parchaar of Gursikhi, how can anyone say another is invalid? To segregate yourself on your own Gursikh island is not even reaching the Panth. If I dare say, it is worse than useless. We have to all do our part to love, respect, and build up the Panth, with our seva, with our kindness, with our information. To throw ourselves out of the Panth through self-imposed isolation because we can't accept differences which are primarily due to ignorance...I have to ask how much of the fault is ours as a Jatha for not publically teaching the more correct way.
To be honest SGPC has allowed meat-eating because we would probably be invalidating a lot of the Panth. And where would those people go if they became outcasted. Politically, it is to keep peace in the Panth. I'm not entirely sure the right approach, but to tolerate and respect everybody's amrit is important, and then do Gursikhi parchaar within the Panth so people know better and can become more in line with principles of purataan Gursikhi. This is probably the least destructive and most successful choice.
Tolerate means you don't get upset unnecessarily over something you disagree with. But you have to have respect for the person you disagree with as a Sikh as well. When we start treating each other as family, we will have Panthic Unity. Until then, we are no match for our enemies as a house divided. There are some real Panthic issues though, that can't be ignored or swept under the rug. Some things which are commonly accepted are violations of purataan rehitnamay. But instead of breaking the Panth over it, we just need to do better parchaar.
I'm not saying if somebody eats meat we allow him to do kirtan at an AKJ smagam. It is still wrong. I'm saying if someone really believes it's okay to eat meat we should still say fateh to him and show him acceptance and respect as a Sikh brother/sister. And if the question ever arises where we are respected enough by him, we have a relationship where we can teach why the Jatha does not believe it's acceptable to eat meat in a wise and loving way. And if he cannot accept this, we should be able to agree to disagree and still say fateh and show respect.
~bhul chuk maaf karni ji
[%sig%]