Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

singer "hard kaur"

singer "hard kaur"

sy · 17 Jun 2007

is this singer insulting sikhs, using the name hard kaur to represent she's a hardcore sikh girl yet in her songs she talks about drinking and wanting a gangster boyfriend, i think this women is an insult to all sikh women and to sikhi, the gurus gave the name kaur to sikh women this women isn't a sikh i think she is insulting every sikh women who gave her life for sikhi and the sikh women who stood up for sikhi in the 80's and are sitting in jail.

Re: singer "hard kaur"

Dalbiri · 18 Jun 2007

Why stop at her. There are thousands at it.

Re: singer "hard kaur"

abc2 · 18 Jun 2007

With this type of 'pop' music, if you drop out the pointless blaring vocals (which are meant for the very young listener) it will be obvious even to the lowest common denominator listener that the music is utter crap.

Re: singer "hard kaur"

Harinder Singh · 18 Jun 2007

This hard "kaur" is an insult to her very existence and is going to have a hard time at the hands of jamm doots. This is ghor kaliyug and there are kanjarrs everywhere and I dont think such kanjarr humans can insult daughters of Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee Maharaj. Just a kaur in the name does not make her a kaur. Its all on the face. A kanjarrs face looks like a kanjarr and daughters of Satguru jee look like angels.

Re: singer "hard kaur"

kulsin · 19 Jun 2007

You know what we have many pure leaders who behave immaculately, we have clergy who is so fine, honest and honourable, Our Gurdwars Managements behave with such dignity, that it boil my blood too that I feel like slandering “Hard Kaur”. Look around ourselves first then think of casting a stone at others. I am sorry if somebody feel hurt with these comments. We do fantastic job at looking at other people and giving them bad labels and bad names, rather then improving our own life or looking good in people. I think Guru Nanak will be well pleased with this kind of “Sikh” behaviour ! Just dear Chandra Singh Ji I think we should recommend to God to do the third party contract to collect Sikhs after death as we don’t want his Jamdoots” ! Imagining you hate Hindus all your life and then Jamdoots turn up. Bloody Hell !!!!!!!! ………. LOL

Re: singer "hard kaur"

jassmannn · 21 Jun 2007

Sorry to say this, but Chandra Singh, but why do you take every topic back to the gutter. If you haven't seen the difference between the Sikhs and the Hindus till date, then mate, you are looking in the wrong place. We can call whatever figure, whatever we like. And what I don't get is, when we don't want to be called Hindus for whatever reason, who do you insinuate that we are. There is no understanding of where Hinuism originated, its origins or otherwise, so maybe you should try and figure that out before you bring that topic, that you always do, about who we are and what we are trying to be.

Re: singer "hard kaur"

Harjas Kaur · 22 Jun 2007

[quote]"have a hard time at the hands of jamm doots"" Is she a Hindu?. Jamraaj is a Hindu God and his fellas Jamdoots too are Hindus and for Hindus, why would they go behind a Sikh?. I can smell appropriation here. I thought Sikhism is different from Hinduism. Don't you think Sikhism should have its own figures for life after death?. Why use a Hindu figure created by greedy, cheat Brahmins?"[/quote] Just because Hindu religion has eternal truths in what it teaches doesn't mean the religion has the right to appropriate eternal truths to itself alone. Those truths belong to the eternal God. Likewise all religions in the world have some truth to teach. Sikh religion does not disbelieve in the existence of Hindu gods. It simply proclaims a worship of the one supreme Waheguru to be the highest road to mukti in the Kalyug. All religions in the world have basic teachings which are part of the eternal truth: kindness, fairness, respect, sympathy, dignity, justice, love...because the One God has spoken to all human beings in every culture and every language. These truths are universal. They belong to the world. Even near death experiences are the same in every culture. Some things are simply truths of reality, and have nothing to do with exclusivity for a particular religion. If you die, it doesn't matter if you are a Muslim, a Christian, a Hindu, a Buddhist, a Sikh. the reality is still the reality, however human beings want to call it or describe it. If you strip away the cultural differences of any belief system, you will find the basic truth. When radicals of any religion promote divisions and prejudice and intolerance of others, and when Governments which have tremendous power fail in their obligation to be fair, entire groups of people get targeted for discrimination. You can blame and scapegoat Jews or Communists, Muslims, Khalistanis, or whoever. And all this does is create the seeds of social intolerance that leads to genocide. This is against the eternal truth. Intolerance of Sikh independence has nothing to do with the antics of Hard Kaur or this topic. Hasn't the world had enough intolerance, scapegoating and genocide? Why can't you just accept and respect a Sikh as being a Sikh? You would do far more to heal and improve relations by this approach than the constant taunting disrespect of the Sikh Freedom Movement and denial of any wrongdoing on part of Hindu India during the Sikh genocide and repression. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1tn0fdKsQWg[/url] Religion is supposed to be about removing the seeds which create hell on earth within all our hearts. Religion is not supposed to be a new kind of prejudice or elitism or demonization of "the other." Please let's stop this kind of talk. It disrespects the beauty in Hindu religion. If you think Brahmins created these "figures" then you don't even believe in the reality of religion. [%sig%]

Re: singer "hard kaur"

khalistani · 28 Jun 2007

it's not like she's a real kaur.

Re: singer "hard kaur"

sy · 28 Jun 2007

but not all religions can lead to god, since 5 of the 6 major religions in the world believe in a different god with a different definition. so reality is only one religion can lead to god and to me it really does sound like sikhism.

Re: singer "hard kaur"

Harjas Kaur · 29 Jun 2007

All human beings are one people. And there is only one God. It's just that people are at different stages of development and have different understanding and confusion about religious teaching. Even a Buddhist who says there is no soul and no God can be a marvelous and spiritual human being. A Christian who is a mixed up and annoying missionary can still be in love with people and give his life defending human rights with more commitment than we see in our own communities. How many have died trying to build hospitals in impoverished lands? If someone's grandmother who is Jewish is praying all the time for world peace. I think she is doing a lot to get closer and closer to the truth of true religion. Sikhism has all the truth, yet many "Sikhs" don't even bother to pray for other people. There is a true religion which doesn't even have a name and is beyond language. It speaks with deeds alone. You won't be judged by the God by what religion you were, you will be judged by how you lived your life, by your deeds. Our great fortune is to have a true Guru. We have an opportunity to go farther than other religions to reach jeevan mukti. But just being a Sikh doesn't mean we could still waste the opportunity. We could actually go spiritually backwards while all these others could go spiritually forwards. Karma is like that. It all depends on us. Sometimes people think religion is like a basketball team, and if they are tagged with the winning teams colors they will somehow get ahead. We all have to do our own work. there have been saints and holy people born in all religions. That's not because of the religion. It's because they did the work of lifting themselves up with the grace of God. Anyone who tries to be more spiritual will always have the grace of God. And eventually will be blessed with being born in Gursikh home. [%sig%]

Re: singer "hard kaur"

sy · 06 Jul 2007

look at the role model hardkaur is being to young sikh girls and using the name kaur to show she's sikh http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TlrVBN4Ptos are community needs real role models and leaders, and for khalistanis how in the world you guys see khalistan when more and more of the community doesnt care about sikhi

Re: singer "hard kaur"

Harjas Kaur · 08 Jul 2007

I agree with you, she is a disgrace and should change her name to stop offending Sikh sentiments, since she isn't even a religious Sikh. [%sig%]

Re: singer "hard kaur"

Bal Singh · 09 Jul 2007

Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsaaa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateeeh What the heck is that all about I ask ya. As SAS (Sikh Awareness Society) state that 85% of the problems are caused by us! No wonder the youth show such uncouth behavour - as they have role models like these beysharam "artists" to reflect upon. Whilst the parents are sitting downstairs watching their favourite Zee TV serials the children are upstairs practicing, listening and getting influenced to this kind of beysharam environment. Tho glassy thin glassy char glassy. [%sig%]

Re: singer "hard kaur"

sy · 09 Jul 2007

then you have jazzy b who has huge impact on youth in punjab. But hardkaur should change her name.

Re: singer "hard kaur"

sy · 09 Jul 2007

when i saw that video on youtube i was pretty disapointed.

Re: singer "hard kaur"

sy · 09 Jul 2007

chandra singh could you please try staying on topic, this thread is for a totally different topic.

Re: singer "hard kaur"

jassmannn · 10 Jul 2007

Chandra Singh, Jamdoot is the name given to the 'grim reeper' if you please. It's the occupation of the Jam Doot. Hindus don't have a monopoly on the truth. If we gave Jamdoot a different name, would that make it more legitamate. OK, I name Jamdoot, Peter!! Happy.

Re: singer "hard kaur"

kulsin · 11 Jul 2007

Dear Harjas Kaur ji after writing really nice comments you wrote. “she is a disgrace and should change her name to stop offending Sikh sentiments, since she isn't even a religious Sikh.” Dear Harjas Kaur Ji, there is a list as long as your phone book of Sikh leaders who have disgraced the Community, I have never seen a call to asking them to change their Name or calling them as non Sikhs. You may would like them to do the same but we should be careful in labelling others, what make us the better Sikh then anybody else? Are we qualify to be the Judge ? As Guru Sahib said, we are all full of short comings then if we are not perfect how can we ask other to be ? Large part of your comments are very very nice so in most humble way I have replied. I am merely pointing out What Guru Sahib is saying. A thief ( Bhomia) and a murder ( Sajjan Thug) can be forgiven and taken in huge while thief did not even given up thieving so please be careful. ################################################### And Dear Bal Singh Ji, Your comments / endorsement “85% of the problems are caused by us!” are very good, I agree with you on that. Then you write. “No wonder the youth show such uncouth behaviour - as they have role models like these beysharam "artists" to reflect upon.” Vir ji how come we are not role model for Children ? how come Gurdawar’s Granthi are not role model for Children ? How come Gurdaware’s leaders are not role model for children ? How come our love for each other don’t inspire our children? How come our history don’t inspire our children ( if they are made to understand)? Above all how come our Guru Sahib Ji ( if they are made to understand) are not role model for our children? It is far more easy to blame somebody who children see on the TV completely ignoring TV actually is in the Home not out of Home ? NOTE: TV is not only in the homes of Sikhs. Children ‘s life is not spent with Hard Kaur it is spent in the family and community. Talking people down will not make us rise, so please see my point. I hope my comments in relation to Harjas Kaur also have relevance to you point. As when we talk about beysharm I think our leaders ( political and religious ) have different league of Beysharmi which people like Hard Kaur cant even enter, let alone compete with them. ######################################### Dear Chandra Singh Ji, I have not read your details comments so I would not be engaging in them but as you have openly said “ "there have been saints and holy people born in all religions." Show me one in Christianity and Islam. “ I am providing you link and there are about 100+ Saints listed on Wikipedia if you want then have a look. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_saints List of Islamic Saint/ sufies ( taken from Wikipedia as its without my input) Nizamudin • Data Gunj • Gharib Nawaz • Khusro • Bakhtiar Kaki • Rabia • Baba Farid • Kabir • Alf Sani • Shah Waliullah • Bhittai • Ata Allah • Zarruq • Gajadwani • Hamdani • Yesevi • Kubra • Emre • Semnani • Haddad So my dear brother Chandra Ji I hope this help. ( now don’t think Everybody listed have my endorsement or I am against anybody, these people are regarded as Saints and Sufi pirs by their people.) I have not intended to cause hurt to anybody, if you feel hurt then please ignore my comments and accept my apologies. Thanks Kulsin. [%sig%]

Re: singer "hard kaur"

Harjas Kaur · 12 Jul 2007

[quote]“she is a disgrace and should change her name to stop offending Sikh sentiments, since she isn't even a religious Sikh.” Dear Harjas Kaur Ji, there is a list as long as your phone book of Sikh leaders who have disgraced the Community, I have never seen a call to asking them to change their Name or calling them as non Sikhs. You may would like them to do the same but we should be careful in labelling others, what make us the better Sikh then anybody else? Are we qualify to be the Judge ? As Guru Sahib said, we are all full of short comings then if we are not perfect how can we ask other to be ? Large part of your comments are very very nice so in most humble way I have replied. I am merely pointing out What Guru Sahib is saying. A thief ( Bhomia) and a murder ( Sajjan Thug) can be forgiven and taken in huge while thief did not even given up thieving so please be careful.[/quote] Veerji, Of course she can be forgiven. But she is not changing or repenting anything. She is only dragging down the public image of Sikhi with her public antics. A Sikh is not powerless to speak against something wrong. If we prevent ourselves from acknowledging wrong things, how can we ever safely navigate a maya world? To pretend not to notice someone is involved in public acts of indecency for fear of maligning them, is ridiculous. HardKaur is a public personality. Her antics are recorded and videotaped. When a public personality goes by the commercial name HardKaur, to imply that she is "Hardcore" as in drinking whiskey, sleeping with gangsters, smoking, and promoting a bad public image...she is insulting a gift from Guruji to dignify women. She makes DVD's and CD's and distributes them all over the world promoting this shameful behavior. Are we so fragile that we silence ourselves for fear of being perceived as offending her or judging her, while this besharam kudi is on radio stations? She has succeeded in labeling herself. I think we can safely say this image and behavior is a disgrace to the entire Khalsa Panth, and the commercial use of the Sikh name "Kaur" should be removed and not publically exploited to create negative image of Sikh community and Sikh religion. It is obvious the association between the religious name "Kaur" is being used to commercially represent something disgraceful. And if this "Kaur" wants to apologize to the Panj Piara, and to the Sikh sangat for such outrageous and atrocious example, no one is stopping her. Right now there is a huge problem of Sikh girls being perceived as "easy" and exploited by Muslim youth to force conversions and gain prostitutes. People like HardKaur who are public figures are part of creating this stereotype of Sikh girls. The repercussions of her videos are enormously hurtful to the image of the Sikh community, and especially harmful to Sikh girls and how they will be perceived and treated. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idAqhkmzGrU[/url] What kind of "Kaur" is this? [%sig%]

Re: singer "hard kaur"

kulsin · 12 Jul 2007

My Dear Sister Harjas Kaur Ji, I think It is my fault for not clearly stating thing, I don’t think for 1 min that we should not acknowledge when some thing is wrong, What I am saying is there are too many people in our community who openly say they are either leaders of Sikhs or Leaders of Gurdawars or something on these lines and they behave much –much worse then Hard Kaur. I have watched an interview with Hard Kaur, She is an intelligent girl, Even she acknowledged her self that she been writing songs and singing about social situations in the society and then her songs did not got popularity when she sang about Drink every body started buying her CD and so on. So she seems to be quite down to earth and intelligent, Her name Hard Kaur is given to her by her fellow industry people who though that they can put her down as she was young Asian Girl without father born in India and still manage to make her name in a very Male dominated industry , and being Asian female she still fought her betel and won the respect of her own industry . Now we can say the name is actually controversial but she is trillion times less harmful then Our leaders in politics and temples who bring shame on community day in day out. She has never claimed to be a model Sikhs but our leaders do. I don’t think for one min that any Girl watching her think that her act is a good role model. Everybody knows what is right and wrong. What I am pointing out is if we want to point fingerer at her then first of all we need to be clean, Have a look around you pick five temples at random in your area and tell me that you don’t feel ashamed the way their leader behave. Now tell me who is more of a threat Hard Kaur or Harden Leader who have stone hearts and keep on damaging our communities. Hard Kaur is a little girl who is making her leaving openly, She don’t claim to representing Sikhs Values or Sikh community. We need to sort our own houses out first then point finger at people who never claim to be representing us. If we portrait her as an evil of the society then some nuttier may go and get abusive to her. That is my fear, people get emotional and don’t use brain which God has give us. Let’s not pick on people who are far far low in the list of damaging the community. If we really want to make a stand then start with the people who are on the top, those who advice us wrong and sell the Khalsa penth for their own benefits. You are right that “. HardKaur is a public personality. Her antics are recorded and videotaped.” Let’s see if our eyes are wide shut to ignore the real threat to our community by the leaders or not. You have mentioned “When a public personality goes by the commercial name HardKaur, to imply that she is "Hardcore" as in drinking whiskey, sleeping with gangsters, smoking, and promoting a bad public image...she is insulting a gift from Guruji to dignify women.” She is putting a mirror in front of us and making us see the ugliness of our community, try to understand the message rather then shooting the messenger. Your comments “She makes DVD's and CD's and distributes them all over the world promoting this shameful behaviour. Are we so fragile that we silence ourselves for fear of being perceived as offending her or judging her, while this besharam kudi is on radio stations?” Let’s not be childish about this who is buying this she is not selling it as a religious item. Unlike many leader who shamelessly sell anti Sikh things by putting them under the penthick Name. Dear Harjas kaur ji you have written “I think we can safely say this image and behaviour is a disgrace to the entire Khalsa Panth, and the commercial use of the Sikh name "Kaur" should be removed and not public ally exploited to create negative image of Sikh community and Sikh religion.” She is at least 1 billion trillion time less effective in giving Sikhs bad name then our Penthik leaders. Dear Harjas kaur ji I understand your emotions when you say “Right now there is a huge problem of Sikh girls being perceived as "easy" and exploited by Muslim youth to force conversions and gain prostitutes. People like HardKaur who are public figures are part of creating this stereotype of Sikh girls. The repercussions of her videos are enormously hurtful to the image of the Sikh community, and especially harmful to Sikh girls and how they will be perceived and treated.” But these things were happing when Hard Kaur was not even born, As I said she is just putting a mirror to show us our ugly face and we want to break the mirror and shoot the messenger rather then deal with the real issue. If she change her name, apologies to Sikh Community you seriously think it is going to make .00000000001 % difference. Girls and people are far more intelligent to know that what Hard Kaur does is an act it is not to be taken as role model. And as above I have already said how come our good things don’t become the role model, short comings are in us it is absolute mistake to say she is making girls behave bad when clearly this is been going on from well before I think Hard Kaur was even born. If your Love, Gurdawara and community don’t inspire children then believe me Harjas Kaur ji, it does not matter if Harjas Kaur tomorrow leave the current occupation and become Amritdhari and start doing Kirtan it will not have effect. We as individual and as community have to be loving, accepting, forgiving only then we can inspire people. Guru Nanak dev ji did not go around blaming grass root people, He showed them love, compassion, kindness which was unconditional and in result they could not help themselves and fall in Love with him. And in process changed and became good people. We will not achieve anything at all by picking on people who clearly have nothing more in their mind then to make money, we should be focusing on people who intentionally, systematically, willingly and in organised way derail the development of Sikh Penth. Be broadminded, we have lot to gain by loving to even the worst of the worst ,but we will lose a lot by being witch hunters. I hope I have explained my point , my idea is not to diss your opinion I just want us to focus on real enemies rather then some media PR thing which is so easy to pin point, but it does not have no long term positive effects on the welfare of the community. If I have in any sense offended you then I am absolutely sorry. Please forgive this stupid brother of yours, who occasionally but unintentionaly go mad. Bul chuck maff. Thanks Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]