Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban
Khalsaspirit · 25 Jul 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
This world has always trouble with what Dasam Patshah given to the Sikhs from Kakkars (Keski, Kanga, Kirpan, Kara, Kachehra) and now to the last names. Well! may be many Sikhs went bipran ki reet that's why this is happenning?
"Jab Lag khalsa Rahay Niyara Tab Lag Tej Diuon Mein Sara
Jab Aah Gahay BIPRAN KI REET Mein Na karroo In Ki Parteet."
France for Dastar (Keski) and kirpan, Canada for Last Names and Kirpan, U.K/U.S for Kirpan and partially Dastaar (Keski). So, Khalsa jio keep up your Niyara pan by accepting the importance of Five Kakkars then definatly Guru Sahib will do kirpa and overcome these hurdles.
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban
Kulbir Singh · 25 Jul 2007
From what I know, "Singh" and "Kaur" are never part of a Gursikh's last name. These names are part of the first name.
Traditionally, Gursikhs have used the name of their villages or towns as last name e.g. Bhai Randhir Singh Narangwal, Sant Sunder Singh Bhindranwale etc.
Even politicians with the exception of Simranjit Singh Maan have used their villages or towns as their last names e.g. Parkash Singh Badal, Gurcharan Singh Tohra, Jagdev Singh Talwandi, Manjit Singh Calcutta etc.
Historically too Sikhs have used their villages as their last names e.g. Bhai Sukha Singh Maari-Kambho, Mehtab Singh Mirakoti, Bhai Tara Singh Vaan etc.
"Singh" and "Kaur" should never be used as last name but should be unremovable part of the first name.
[%sig%]
Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban
Khalsaspirit · 25 Jul 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Bhai Kulbir Singh jio,
Have to agree and disagree on some points. The Last names of the Gursikhs mentioned above are merely used for the references by fellows Singhs because of their popularity (In old days it was also known as Takhalus). We do not think when they were born or initiated in khalsa panth their last name was given by parents or Panj as mentioned.
Even for politicians and others goes same logic. If we look to their matriculation certificate if they have (the document used to verify name in India) there will be no badal, tohra and etc it will be SINGH or some parents use their castes or sub caste to distinguish from other names but that caste name will be eliminated when they join the khalsa panth. However, some one for public recognition move it to middle and add some thing else but SINGH or KAUR are the only last names given to a Gursikh.
Now consider this Bhai Kulbir Singh Toronto and we can bet there will be many Kulbir Singhs in Toronto and not every one will be referred as Bhai Kulbir Singh Toronto but because of bhai sahib jio your popularity adding "Bhai" before the name and "Toronto" in last it very easy to pin point you.
Just our thoughts.
Guru Mehar karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban
Jagjit Singh · 26 Jul 2007
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa, Vaheguru ji kefateh
Pyare jio, from an purely administration point of view, I can understand why the government would wish people not to use a name which is so common that it becomes hard to ID people effectively.
However in UK, names such as Singh, Kaur, Patel, Smith, Jones & Mohammed are very common. UK has a larger population than canada, and has cities with a more dense population.
I am aware in UK, government does not use surnames for ID, these use other vital information. In most cases this is the date of birth. But it can be National insurance number, NHS number, PAYE, or many other things.
I thought I would point this out. It would be far more helpful if sikhs not only wrote to canadian govt protesting at not being able to use Singh or kaur. But also gave examples on how in other countries, they have overcome these sitaution with practical examples.
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa, Vaheguru ji kefateh
P.s. interesting point by veer Kulbir Singh about singh and kaur being in the first name.
[%sig%]
Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban
Khalsaspirit · 26 Jul 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
Quote "You are not losing your faith because you make the Government's job a little easier"
Well! We wish that quote won’t apply in France.
Guru Mehar karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban
Khalsaspirit · 27 Jul 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
Quote "Turban ban, or other ban is not the same as using your last name. Don't put everything in the same bracket."
We have to keep in mind that small leak in a ceiling or wall leads to big hole if not patched at proper time and holes leads to a collapse. Now it’s our choice what to do to have a patch work ASAP or to wait for a collapse.
Guru Mehar karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban
Khalsaspirit · 27 Jul 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
We think instead of deciding here the new rules of last name of Sikhs as some thinks should be somthing else other than SINGH or Kaur the time is to take immediate action by Sikh community of Canada. As the media (like CBC) acknowledged this problem and we do not know how strong and influenced this(CBC) channel which only Canadians Sikhs can tell but regardless Sikhs should take this matter to civil rights unions and at the same time contact to your MPs, aware about this issue to every Gurudwara management and have petitions signed if necessary. Sikhs should also make sure what ever they are going to start about this matter should end up with a strong decision not a half way movement of no decision. We guess this case should already be in hands of any civil rights organization but if not then Sikhs should really take up action.
Having this thinking that it really helping government to have other last names other than Singh or Kaur, again for those thinkers this is our request that Sir this is plain discrimination. India, a poor and developing country can handle about 20 million SINGH or KAUR names then in contrast Canada, the developed country with advance technology which has merely half a million Singh and Kaur names can not handle ID system?. Come on guys what a Joke. If the immigration department has really a big trouble handling SINGH or KAUR last names then let them develop new technology to sort out the names but do not ask a particular community to change your names after all this is Canada not a third world country. This completely shows their lack of immigration handling. Why do not they hire a Singh Officer he/she will fix this up if they can not handle it. We guess that is not the case, this is some one behind the scene who has trouble with Sikhs and do not want to see the chardikala of SINGHs and KAURs. Again this is a plain case of discrimination and rationalism and entire Canadian community should stand against it.
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]