Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Singh & Kaur Name Ban

Singh & Kaur Name Ban

* · 24 Jul 2007

Common Sikh names banned under Canada's immigration policy Last Updated: Monday, July 23, 2007 | 5:15 PM MT CBC News A Calgary woman waiting for her husband to arrive in Canada is upset by a long-standing immigration policy that forces people with the surname Singh or Kaur to change their last names. Tarvinder Kaur, who is pregnant, said her husband Jaspal Singh's application to become a permanent resident has been delayed for well over a month because of his last name. He has no choice but to legally change his name in India so he can get to Calgary before she gives birth next month, she said. CBC News has obtained a copy of a letter sent from the Canadian High Commission in New Delhi to Singh's family stating that "the names Kaur and Singh do not qualify for the purpose of immigration to Canada." "Why are we needing to make a different last name?" said Kaur. "You choose what your last name is going to be and if it's always been a certain way, then why should you have to change it?" Traditional Sikh names Singh and Kaur are common names in the Sikh community. In a tradition that began more than 300 years ago, the name Singh is given to every baptized male and Kaur to every baptized female Sikh. The names are used differently by different people. Some use Singh or Kaur as middle names, while others use them as their last names. Karen Shadd-Evelyn, a spokeswoman with Citizenship and Immigration Canada, said the policy preventing people from immigrating to Canada with those last names has been in place for the last 10 years. "I believe the thinking behind it in this case is because it is so common. [With] the sheer numbers of applicants that have those as their surnames, it's just a matter for numbers and for processing in that visa office." Citizenship and Immigration Canada says there is no such policy against other common last names. Kaur, who was born in Canada, says that's unacceptable. "If it's going to be a standard policy it should be standard with all common last names. Why is it that it's only Singh or Kaur that's being attacked by this?" http://www.cbc.ca/canada/calgary/story/2007/07/23/names-immigration.html

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

Khalsaspirit · 25 Jul 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, This world has always trouble with what Dasam Patshah given to the Sikhs from Kakkars (Keski, Kanga, Kirpan, Kara, Kachehra) and now to the last names. Well! may be many Sikhs went bipran ki reet that's why this is happenning? "Jab Lag khalsa Rahay Niyara Tab Lag Tej Diuon Mein Sara Jab Aah Gahay BIPRAN KI REET Mein Na karroo In Ki Parteet." France for Dastar (Keski) and kirpan, Canada for Last Names and Kirpan, U.K/U.S for Kirpan and partially Dastaar (Keski). So, Khalsa jio keep up your Niyara pan by accepting the importance of Five Kakkars then definatly Guru Sahib will do kirpa and overcome these hurdles. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

Kulbir Singh · 25 Jul 2007

From what I know, "Singh" and "Kaur" are never part of a Gursikh's last name. These names are part of the first name. Traditionally, Gursikhs have used the name of their villages or towns as last name e.g. Bhai Randhir Singh Narangwal, Sant Sunder Singh Bhindranwale etc. Even politicians with the exception of Simranjit Singh Maan have used their villages or towns as their last names e.g. Parkash Singh Badal, Gurcharan Singh Tohra, Jagdev Singh Talwandi, Manjit Singh Calcutta etc. Historically too Sikhs have used their villages as their last names e.g. Bhai Sukha Singh Maari-Kambho, Mehtab Singh Mirakoti, Bhai Tara Singh Vaan etc. "Singh" and "Kaur" should never be used as last name but should be unremovable part of the first name. [%sig%]

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

Khalsaspirit · 25 Jul 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Bhai Kulbir Singh jio, Have to agree and disagree on some points. The Last names of the Gursikhs mentioned above are merely used for the references by fellows Singhs because of their popularity (In old days it was also known as Takhalus). We do not think when they were born or initiated in khalsa panth their last name was given by parents or Panj as mentioned. Even for politicians and others goes same logic. If we look to their matriculation certificate if they have (the document used to verify name in India) there will be no badal, tohra and etc it will be SINGH or some parents use their castes or sub caste to distinguish from other names but that caste name will be eliminated when they join the khalsa panth. However, some one for public recognition move it to middle and add some thing else but SINGH or KAUR are the only last names given to a Gursikh. Now consider this Bhai Kulbir Singh Toronto and we can bet there will be many Kulbir Singhs in Toronto and not every one will be referred as Bhai Kulbir Singh Toronto but because of bhai sahib jio your popularity adding "Bhai" before the name and "Toronto" in last it very easy to pin point you. Just our thoughts. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

CSJ · 25 Jul 2007

Some body ask me that we do need lastnames (surnames) for marriage only to make sure that the person you are marring does not have your closest 2 or 5 last names that is mothers fathers etc. for medical reason (geans childrens have problems if it is in same family). Otherwise we dont need last names just for the sake of cast or area. To people use last names in gurudawars in ardass and lecture is completly wrong. I have seen in gurudawaras some time they use only last names. People are even dividing our purataan shaheeds by last names just so they can feel proud that they belong to certain cast even thoug they didnt belived n it. Some body like goverment to tell us that we need t use last name iscompletly wrong Because khalsa dont need any last name only singh and kaur. To me even adding word "khalsa" in the name is wrong too because do we qualify for this degree, according to Guru sahaibs defination of khalsa. Most of us are on the path to become one. [%sig%]

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

jassmannn · 26 Jul 2007

Well, I see no problem with having your last name on a document. There are soo many Singhs and Kaurs that for legal and documentation purposes, I see no problem at all. You are not losing your faith because you make the Government's job a little easier since every sikh person coming into the country has the same name, so how do they avoid problems? It's just an ID thing. people don't need to get soo up in arms about it.

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

Jagjit Singh · 26 Jul 2007

Vaheguru ji ka khalsa, Vaheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, from an purely administration point of view, I can understand why the government would wish people not to use a name which is so common that it becomes hard to ID people effectively. However in UK, names such as Singh, Kaur, Patel, Smith, Jones & Mohammed are very common. UK has a larger population than canada, and has cities with a more dense population. I am aware in UK, government does not use surnames for ID, these use other vital information. In most cases this is the date of birth. But it can be National insurance number, NHS number, PAYE, or many other things. I thought I would point this out. It would be far more helpful if sikhs not only wrote to canadian govt protesting at not being able to use Singh or kaur. But also gave examples on how in other countries, they have overcome these sitaution with practical examples. Vaheguru ji ka khalsa, Vaheguru ji kefateh P.s. interesting point by veer Kulbir Singh about singh and kaur being in the first name. [%sig%]

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

Khalsaspirit · 26 Jul 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Quote "You are not losing your faith because you make the Government's job a little easier" Well! We wish that quote won’t apply in France. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

CSJ · 26 Jul 2007

start compromising one thing at a time and later will be left with nothing. useing last names will increase more cast system in sikhs. [%sig%]

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

jassmannn · 27 Jul 2007

Khalsa Spirit, CSJ. Turban ban, or other ban is not the same as using your last name. Don't put everything in the same bracket. And also, if you want to live in a foreign country then we all have to live by the rules, else protest. I just don't see what the problem is. People have always had family names, Singh is just the name given to us by the Guru which is part of our Sikh identity. A lot of people already use Surnames and caste system is already rife. It's about changing attitudes not names.

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

Khalsaspirit · 27 Jul 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Quote "Turban ban, or other ban is not the same as using your last name. Don't put everything in the same bracket." We have to keep in mind that small leak in a ceiling or wall leads to big hole if not patched at proper time and holes leads to a collapse. Now it’s our choice what to do to have a patch work ASAP or to wait for a collapse. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

Khalsaspirit · 27 Jul 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, We think instead of deciding here the new rules of last name of Sikhs as some thinks should be somthing else other than SINGH or Kaur the time is to take immediate action by Sikh community of Canada. As the media (like CBC) acknowledged this problem and we do not know how strong and influenced this(CBC) channel which only Canadians Sikhs can tell but regardless Sikhs should take this matter to civil rights unions and at the same time contact to your MPs, aware about this issue to every Gurudwara management and have petitions signed if necessary. Sikhs should also make sure what ever they are going to start about this matter should end up with a strong decision not a half way movement of no decision. We guess this case should already be in hands of any civil rights organization but if not then Sikhs should really take up action. Having this thinking that it really helping government to have other last names other than Singh or Kaur, again for those thinkers this is our request that Sir this is plain discrimination. India, a poor and developing country can handle about 20 million SINGH or KAUR names then in contrast Canada, the developed country with advance technology which has merely half a million Singh and Kaur names can not handle ID system?. Come on guys what a Joke. If the immigration department has really a big trouble handling SINGH or KAUR last names then let them develop new technology to sort out the names but do not ask a particular community to change your names after all this is Canada not a third world country. This completely shows their lack of immigration handling. Why do not they hire a Singh Officer he/she will fix this up if they can not handle it. We guess that is not the case, this is some one behind the scene who has trouble with Sikhs and do not want to see the chardikala of SINGHs and KAURs. Again this is a plain case of discrimination and rationalism and entire Canadian community should stand against it. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

jassmannn · 27 Jul 2007

Yes, but you're looking at it from what you want, not what is beign asked of us. In essence you are insuating that they have some issue with Sikh people, which I don't think is the case. I just think they want to make the process easier for themselves. Why would they let some many sikhs in if that was the case and just reject all those visas and people trying to come into the Country. Sikhs do make a contribution and that's my poin..

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

CSJ · 27 Jul 2007

I agree with Khalsaspirit this time. Anything is possible. What about other names why point to sikhs. What about muslim names or even english names mostly every 5th person is peter, steve, mike or john. (ok if last name is diffrent than first name is same). if those names have no problem then over is same we do have diffrent fist name. or date of birth, or in india address etc. like any body else. When in canada we have S.I.N. number. [%sig%]

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

talikhaak · 29 Jul 2007

Kulbir Singh veerji, if you think no-one should use it as their last name, you might wanna change yours to Kulbir Singh ( ... ) Personally I feel we need to stick to Singh/Kaur or Khalsa as last name it identifies you as a kaum, a community, race, religion. It identifies you, the last name makes you in the world, why did they use to call people in the old days by their last name, like hunter, or woodcutter, etc. because thats what they did, and thats why they were called that, we are khaalse and need to identify ourselves as that. Bhul chuk muaaf karnee.

Re: Singh & Kaur Name Ban

CSJ · 30 Jul 2007

THE GAZETTE, MONTREAL, FRIDAY, JULY 21, 2001 OTTAWA - The federal government hasn't forced potential Sikh immigrants to change their last names, Citizenship and Immigration Minister Diane Finley said yesterday. blaming the recent controversy on ambiguous documents circulated by the Canadian high commission in New Delhi. "I can assure you I have directed the department to ensure that this type of erroneous letter is not sent out again," she said. "No application for permanent residence will be rejected if the application chooses not to provide an additional surname." The World Sikh Organization expressed anger this week over claims the federal government was urging people with the surnames Singh and Kaur to add an additional name to distinguish themselves. The confusing 10-year-old policy earned international attention when Jaspal Singh, hoping to join his wife in Calgary, received a letter in May from the New Delhi high commission saying his surname was delaying his application. "The name Kaur and Singh do not qualify for the purpose of immigration to Canada," said the letter, dated May 17. Singh and Kaur - meaning lion and princess - are given to baptized men and women respectively after their birth names, to signify the Sikhs' emancipation from the Indian caste system in the 17th century. Many now consider them their official surnames. Peter Wong. a Calgary immigration lawyer, often tells clients to expect problems with the name Singh or Kaur "For a name like Baljit Kaur, you could easily have 50 of them in the system," he said, "But some people have used a family name other than Singh or Kaur for more than three generations." Wong said dates of birth and addresses should be suffice to distinguish similar names. World Sikh Organization spokesperson Jasbeer Singh said from Edmonton, "There are probably more Lees in China than the entire population of Canada. Are you going to tell them to change their names just because it's a common name?" [%sig%]