The threat from within
Khalsaspirit · 03 Aug 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
Some of the points made by writer are quite interesting and seems very close to truth and needs our attention.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
The threat from within
by Dipankar Gupta
Sikhs may be just 2 per cent of the population but in their self- image and deportment, it is as if they constitute 200 per cent of India’s one billion. As the saying goes: “Ek Sikh barabar sava lakh.” Even during the worst days of the Partition, Sikhs never felt insecure about their religion as their Hindu counterparts did, and continue to do.
Why then does a small, insignificant sect like the Dera Sacha Sauda, that does not even claim to be Sikh, get mainstream Akalis and a large number of everyday Sikhs so hot and bothered? This Baba is no medieval tyrant and martyrdom of any kind would be thoroughly wasted on him. He is a minor figure whose demonising by the Akalis raised his stature and downgraded their gurus who gave up their lives in far more glorious battlefields.
The question then is: How did the Sikhs suddenly turn so insecure? When did it happen and where were we all looking? Or did the lights suddenly go off in the changing room?
The original Panthic Party, which later morphed into the Akali Dal after 1947, never evinced such worries either, and those were very difficult times. They regularly participated with the Congress before Independence. The party even supplied the Congress with a stable of leaders from Pratap Singh Kairon to Swaran Singh. On election campaigns in undivided Punjab, the Panthic Party frequently displayed the Congress symbol along with its own. On no occasion did any of this to-and-fro movement from Panthic Party and back threaten Sikhism. Nor did the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee declare Kairon or Swaran Singh, or any of the others who took their political blood lines to the Congress, apostates or ‘tankhaiyas’. Sikhism had that much confidence.
In 1899, when Sardar Kahn Singh Nabha wrote “Hum Hindu Nahin (We are not Hindus),” he did not castigate any other religion but just said the plain truth. The Sikhs were not Hindus and let the record state the facts. It was not as if he was prompted to write this tract because of the perceived fear that Hinduism was eating up Sikhism. In this sense he was not the mirror opposite of Swami Dayanand who took every other religion, including Sikhism, as a threat to the Hindu faith.
Nabha’s interjection was to remind his readers of the symbolic energies at the heart of his faith without deriding non-Sikhs, nor, even for a moment, hoping to proselytise other religions to his own. Even the Singh Sabhas and Chief Khalsa Diwan of that period were intent on crafting a separate Sikh identity and not in impressing their own thought prints on their immediate religious neighbours.
Interestingly, in the 60 years after Independence, the Akali Dal has never used the Partition to evoke partisanship the way Hindu parties, and sadly, the Congress even, have done from time to time. This is indeed quite remarkable. Sikhs too had suffered along with Hindus in their migration to east Punjab and beyond. And yet, unlike Hindus, the Partition is history for Sikhs, and not a source of political energies.
When I was working with re-settled rural Sikh refugees in Punjab and Haryana, what struck me the most was that they found my questions, which recalled the Partition, quite stupid. So many of these Sikhs told me to move on and not keep looking over my shoulder for monsters and chimeras of the past.
That was such a relief. Hindu refugees, in general, were still agonising over the Partition and related stirring tales of their experiences during those times. Most of this recall was highly adorned as my Hindu respondents in the early 1990s were either babies or playing in the mud in knickers when 1947 happened. Some post-Partition Hindu families even held prayer meetings to solemnly remember the day they were ousted from their homes. I found none of this among Sikh refugees. It is no surprise then that even a sectarian party like the Akali Dal has no use for the Partition as a leavening political agent.
Later, during the bad days of Khalistan, a large number of Sikhs felt that they were humiliated by the Indian state, but on no account did they believe that their religion was under threat. Khalistanis were, of course, baying to the contrary from the margins, but an overwhelming majority of Sikhs did not politically side with these secessionists though they were widely admired for giving the hated agents of the government a tough time. This is not an ‘a-ha’ moment for, in spite of the trauma post-Bluestar, Sikhs were willing to look ahead the moment Prime Minister V.P. Singh visited Punjab with a healing balm.
The Khalistani years, if one may call them that, however demonstrated that in times of crisis, it was not as if there were Sikhs and Sikhs. Regardless of caste and origin, all Sikhs came together. This is where the difference lies when we come to the Sikh over-reaction to Dera Sacha Sauda. There are now Sikhs and Sikhs and the lines are drawn along the grooves of caste.
Most of the animus against Baba Ram Rahim came from the Malwa region of Punjab where Jat Sikhs are politically dominant. It does not matter really if Jats vote Congress today and Akali tomorrow, it would always be a fight between ‘lions’. Dera Sacha Sauda trampled on this territory by bringing in non-Jats to kick up dust and spoil the Jat versus Jat slugfest.
This is why Baba Ram Rahim was so profoundly despised in Jat-dominated Akali circles. It was not because he was undermining Sikhism so much as using his “low caste” followers to defeat Jats in their own lair that made Baba Ram Rahim such a hated poster-boy for the Akalis. If the Congress had won without his support, that would still have been acceptable.
It is not true, as the Akalis allege, that in the advertisement put out by Baba Ram Rahim he dressed like Guru Gobind. His turban did not have a ‘kalgi (or plume)’, he was stirring Rooh Afza (or something pink) with a ladle and not with a sword (which is Khalsa tradition), and further, he was wearing pink and not blue, not even white. No icon of Guru Gobind can ever be depicted in that colour. Chhatrapati Shivaji’s popular imagery looks closer to Guru Gobind than this pink spectacle.
And yet many Sikhs blindly believed the Akalis when they said that Baba Ram Rahim was imitating Guru Gobind and thus mocking Sikhism. The majority of such Sikhs did not bother to verify the facts as they were primed to believe anything against him. It was their Jatness, not their Sikhness, that Baba Ram Rahim deeply hurt. In the 1980s, Hindus too eagerly believed the tale that the Anandpur Sahib Resolution was secessionist. The drive to hate always numbs the better senses.
At the end of the day what is most depressing is that Sikhs are becoming caste-ridden, and more and more like Hindus. If this trend continues then Sikhism will probably find its greatest threat from within and not from figures clad in baby pink.
Dipankar Gupta is professor, social sciences, at Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi
http://www.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?id=a2baa6ea-d1f3-449c-bc65-3ce6bb4f1a9a
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: The threat from within
Harjas Kaur · 03 Aug 2007
[quote]Why then does a small, insignificant sect like the Dera Sacha Sauda, that does not even claim to be Sikh, get mainstream Akalis and a large number of everyday Sikhs so hot and bothered? This Baba is no medieval tyrant and martyrdom of any kind would be thoroughly wasted on him. [/quote]
Because he is sponsored by Congress as an infiltration into the Sikh community to corrupt Sikh religious teaching. He now has so many thousands of followers (former Sikhs) they constitute their own vote bloc and have power to manipulate public officials, police, and influence Punjab politics. This is proof the GOI's corruption into Sikhi has spread far and wide, enticed by big money. He is a cancer worse than a missionary. And because he is a vile pervert whose premis are murdering Gursikhs, slandering Guruji, raping young girls and now we are hearing about forced castrations.
In a word, his existence is "intolerable." God will wipe him out.
[%sig%]
Re: The threat from within
Harjas Kaur · 08 Aug 2007
[quote]It is not true, as the Akalis allege, that in the advertisement put out by Baba Ram Rahim he dressed like Guru Gobind. His turban did not have a ‘kalgi (or plume)’, he was stirring Rooh Afza (or something pink) with a ladle and not with a sword (which is Khalsa tradition), and further, he was wearing pink and not blue, not even white. No icon of Guru Gobind can ever be depicted in that colour. Chhatrapati Shivaji’s popular imagery looks closer to Guru Gobind than this pink spectacle.
And yet many Sikhs blindly believed the Akalis when they said that Baba Ram Rahim was imitating Guru Gobind Singh and thus mocking Sikhism. The majority of such Sikhs did not bother to verify the facts as they were primed to believe anything against him. [/quote]
He was not directly imitating Guru Gobind Singh Ji. He was making a [i]parody[/i] of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. The pink stuff he was stirring with a serving spoon and calling Jam-e-Insa, the "drink of humanity." And after receiving (what is described by Sirsa dera as) "amrit" members were requested to change their surnames from "Singh" to "Insa." The implication being, pakhandi Ram Rahim was creating a new form of Khalsa, one similar to the games played by GOI sponsored Nirankaris...a Sat Sitare instead of a Panj Piare. Ram Rahim made a mockery, a deliberate parody of the Khalsa. If he is not imitating Sikh Guruji, why is he creating his own amrit? And when faced with protests and opposition, the dera premis attacked and tried to kill Gursikhs.
[img]http://news.restoringthepride.com/image/2007/05-27-07/3288_jameinsa.jpg[/img][img]http://www.cbc.ca/gfx/images/news/photos/2007/05/18/070518-ram-rahim.jpg[/img]
He needs a kalgi?
[url]http://www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/3288/2007-05-16.html[/url]
[quote]The majority of such Sikhs did not bother to verify the facts as they were primed to believe anything against him.[/quote]
And you did not see the video broadcasts of the sadhvi's who testified against him alleging charges of murder and rape?
Or have you also forgotten scenes like this
[IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v728/Harjas/Bathinda_loneSingh.jpg[/IMG]
[url]http://www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/3289/2007-05-16.html[/url]
Why listen to agents of the GOI who want to divide and blame Sikhs and things like "Jattness" and "Akalis" and "Khalistanis" and the "Pakistani ISI" and not the dera system which they directly finance to turn Sikhs away from Sikhi to be used as tools for political agendas. This is a government issue about dividing and destroying Sikh identity.
Stop listening to lies.
[%sig%]
Re: The threat from within
Khalsaspirit · 08 Aug 2007
Khalsa jio,
Well! We have to keep in mind that
ਪਾਪੀ ਕੇ ਮਾਰਨੇ ਕੋ ਪਾਪ ਮਹਾਂਬਲੀ ਹੈਂ
And every premature action leads to mistakes.
Consider the case of nirankarees. As soon as the Gurbachna had his paaps filled fully he came to Amritsar sitting above the Guru Sahib and other holy Granths. Then Guru Sahib took the sewa from Naam Rasiyay Singhs under the lead of Bhai Fauja Singh jee and we all know how these Singhs left the legacy and Gurbachna and nirankarees were wiped out from Panjab.
Today the outcome of last three months is ਘਰ ਦੇ ਬਾਹਰ ਦੀ ਲੜਾਈ ਆਪਣੇ ਘਰ ਵਿਚ ਲੈ ਆਂਦੀ ਹੈ
now Sikhs are threatening their own people (life threat letter sent to Jathedar Akal Takhat and others). Which clearly shows are our lack of Sikhi, Naam Kamai and foresight. If this continued then forget we can achieve any single progress in the Sirsa case but at the same time have given so much advertisement to the PINK BABY.
Guru Mehar Karay.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: The threat from within
Harjas Kaur · 09 Aug 2007
[quote]now Sikhs are threatening their own people (life threat letter sent to Jathedar Akal Takhat and others). Which clearly shows are our lack of Sikhi, Naam Kamai and foresight.[/quote]
Vedanti is a puppet of SAD-Badal-RSS coalition. Either he is responsive to Gurmat Gursikhi and the Khalsa Panth, or he is removed by the Khalsa Panth. He is not a law unto himself to corrupt the Sikh Quam.
Bhai Joginder Singh Vedanti has undermined the authority of Akal Takht by accepting the position rightfully belonging to Singh Sahib Jathedar Bhai Ranjit Singh Ji who was removed to make way for pliable puppets. And then Bhai Puran Singh excommunicated Bibi Jagir Kaur and got removed. And all this Badal influenced political drama where Bhai Joginder Singh Vedanti reversed a hukamnama against Jagir Kaur. And this is why the Panth is now having all these problems. The highest Sikh authority has become a plaything in the interests of SAD-Badal-RSS. When he represents Panthic Interests, he is accorded highest respect. But when he diminishes that office, he himself will be diminished.
[quote]Several Panthic activists in California declared, Vedanti has damaged the Panth severely. By taking a worthless role in the case against the ‘Sacha Sauda’ Baba, Vedanti has embarassed the Panth.
When Vedanti previously visited Fremont Gurdwara Sahib, he was questioned about his dubious deeds. He was questioned as to why Saadh Dhanwant was forgiven after paying 80 thousands rupees; why the controversial movie- ‘Bole So Nihaal’ - was given the ‘ok’ after money was exchanged; why RSS Agent, Rulda Sinh was honoured with a Siropaa; why the actions of Ashutosh and Bhaniaaraevala were not investigated; why the issue of Mann Pehova’s several rape allegations was ignored after taking money from him, among other things.
Protests planned for Vedanti's trip to USA
[url]http://www.panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/3374/2007-06-20.html[/url][/quote]
[quote]Stated one Sangat member, "This instance only provided more evidence to fuel growing resentment in Panthic circles concerning the activities of the Jathedars and the SGPC officials' abroad. We fully support the actions taken against Kala-Afghana, and the Spokesman editor, but why be silent on other issues such as Badal, derawadis and those who violate the Hukamanamas?"
Jathedars and SGPC reps avoid Sangat, attend anti Akal Takhat establishments
[url]http://www.panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/2410/2006-04-23.html[/url][/quote]
[quote]Talking to the press here in the town, S. Simranjit Singh Mann leveled heavy accusations on Gyani Joginder Singh Vedanti for working under the guidance of the Shiromani Akali Dal President Parkash Badal. S. Simranjit Singh Mann indirectly charged Gyani Joginder Singh Vedanti for having taken the decision of calling for a social boycott of the Sarna brothers under influence of Parkash Badal.
S. Mann stated that the recent decision of Gyani Joginder Singh Vedanti was clearly "wrong and dictatorial". For Gyani Joginder Singh to pass directives while siding with others was against the standards of the Sikh religion. The SAD Amritsar President also charged the Jathedar for taking vital Panthic decisions without involving other Takhat Jathedars.
Vedanti Should Work In Panth's Interest
[url]http://www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/2239/2006-02-12.html[/url][/quote]
The threat is from within all right. The Panth will not sit idly by and be destroyed by dirty politics of the SAD-Badal-RSS faction.
[%sig%]