Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

TOUGH

TOUGH

meee · 26 May 2004

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHGURU JI KI FATEH A friend of mine took Amrit, and the Rehat that was told was SGPC. My friend asked the Punj Piaray if it was okay to do Sampooran Rehras Sahib, and the Punj said "NO, you must do the short one (starting at Sodar, and not the Sampooran Choapay Sahib)...now the problem my friend is facing is that they want to start doing Sampooran Rehras, because their heart says it is right, but then they would be going against the Hukam from Punj Piarey. Should they Pesh infront of the Punj at a different Gurudwara in order to 'have permission' to do Samoppran Rehras, or should they just start doing it, and go against the specific Hukam of the Punj? [%sig%]

Re: TOUGH

A Kaur · 26 May 2004

Whatever is said by the Punj Pyare is FINAL. There's no if's, and's or but's when it comes to the hukam of the Punj. Your friend should happily accept whatever has been said and not try to find any loopholes around what he/she has been told.

Re: TOUGH

Singh · 26 May 2004

I never understood the concept of "sanmpooran rehraas". Does that mean the rehraas sahib most people in the Panth do is "adhooree rehraas" ie. incomplete? The core of Rehraas Sahib is found as the 2nd baaNee in Sree Guru Granth Sahib. It begins with Sodar. The so-called Sampooran Rehraas can begin at "Dukh Daaroo" or "Har jug jug..". I used to have a gutka sahib published by Baba Mohan Singh BhindarKalan Valay. The Rehraas Sahib in it begins at "Dukh Daaroo", while the Mehtha Gutkas begin at "Har jug jug...". Both are organizations which descend from Baba Gurbachan Singh, so the question is, who added or cut baaNee? I am certain that the puraatan Rehraas Sahib in the time of Guru Gobind Singh jee did not contain Har Jug Jug or Dukh Daaroo. Otherwise it would have been added in the Rehraas Sahib found in Sree Guru Granth Sahib. Please do not get too confused about this topic. Super Long chaupaiee sahib is also a fairly new phenomena. Puraatan Singhs did chaupaiee sahib to "kharag kayt may sharan tihaaree". The "panthic" rehraas saahib seems fine to me. Stick with it.

Re: TOUGH

answer · 26 May 2004

I don't think the punj would tell you that you cannot read extra bani. Therefore, in conclusion, you could say that you are reading extra bani.

Re: TOUGH

Mkhalsa · 26 May 2004

Read the two shabads before rehras "har jug jug" and "dukh daroo" begin your rehras, read shabads after ie "pauree" to "tis sahib kee tekh" then do long chaupai sahib afterwards. simple.....

Re: TOUGH

the singh next door · 26 May 2004

the rehiras that other people do is "adhooree" yes you're right. sampooran rehiras is "har jug jug" and "dukh daroo" and up to chaupai "pun rachas" then kabyo bach bayntee chaupai and then all the dohras and then savaiya onwards to the end. that's sampooran rehiras in the gurmat rehit maryada gurmat rehit maryada and sgpc rehit maryada are both accepted by the panth neither is fully accepted by akal takhat there is no akal takhat maryada there wont' be until there is a SARBAT KHALSA

Re: TOUGH

Singh · 26 May 2004

Right. Adhooree Rehraas. Of course. If "har jug jug" and "dukh daaroo" were part of rehras sahib, it would have been in that order in Sree Guru Granth Sahib. All this is added by various deras. I already said that Baba Gurbachan Singh started at Dukh Daaroo, but now it starts at Har Jug Jug. Why is that? Sikhs have been reading the standard Rehras for such a long time, why would it be changed now?

Re: TOUGH

g · 26 May 2004

I find it funny how one panj says one thing and another panj says another... oh yeh i forgot that why I dont go to the panj. :D

Re: TOUGH

Dass · 26 May 2004

MEIN MOORAKH KI KETAK BAT HAI, KOT PARADHI TARIA RE SATGUR NANAK JIN SUNIA PEKHIA SE JAN FIR GARBHAS NA BHARIA RE What is the meaning of "Kabio Vach Benty Chaupee" read it by yourself and think. Is it still Benty after "Kharag Ket Mein Sharan Tihari, Ap Hath De leo Ubhari, Sarab Thor Mo Ho Sahai Dusat Dokh Te leo Bachai". No it is not benty. Kirpa kari hum per jag mata....read the meanings, this will tell you it is not benty any more , it is thanks to GOD for completing the Granth...... so this stanaza is thanks not benty... I mean request. So it is very clear that Kabio Vach Benty Chaupee is only upto AP Hath DE LEO UBHARI. GURU FATEH! WAHIGURU JI KA KHALSA! WAHIGURU JI KI FATEH!

Re: TOUGH

hpluthera · 12 Nov 2005

"Apne Gur Ka sun updesh" " Hukum Pachhan" The faith with in is the ultimate guru who leads us to satguru. You as a sikh do not follow punj piyayras like blind faith in times of Guru Nanak followed the Brahmins. Bhakti path is not a ritual it is Shradha It si love with in the Sikh. If under the authority of SGPC some people (designated Punj Piayras) try to run it like that they are wrong. I am not a Amrit Dhari and did not take it is not known who is right who is wrong so I listen with in me the faith in my Guru Nanak" More over many Amritdhari has ego of being supeior sikhs and instead of getting out of Homein Rog they jump into by taking Amrit. Amrit is to connect you with Waheguru and who is to tell you how much Path PUja Simran you should or should not do. HP meee wrote: > WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHGURU JI KI FATEH > > A friend of mine took Amrit, and the Rehat that was told was > SGPC. My friend asked the Punj Piaray if it was okay to do > Sampooran Rehras Sahib, and the Punj said "NO, you must do the > short one (starting at Sodar, and not the Sampooran Choapay > Sahib)...now the problem my friend is facing is that they want > to start doing Sampooran Rehras, because their heart says it is > right, but then they would be going against the Hukam from Punj > Piarey. Should they Pesh infront of the Punj at a different > Gurudwara in order to 'have permission' to do Samoppran Rehras, > or should they just start doing it, and go against the specific > Hukam of the Punj? >

Re: TOUGH

???? · 13 Nov 2005

referring 2 'g', i think this is very wrong what u have jus said... what do u mean u dont go 2 the panj?? does this mean u think u higher than them so u dont need them?? this is a veryw rong attitude 2 have.... the panj piyare are in guru jis roop.... they are here 2 guide us and bless us with amrit... if u diss them... u r dissin guru ji and that is unacceptable!! i think u shud watch what u say be4 u say it and understand that the panj piyare are gursikhs that guide us other moorakhs onto the path of the guru.... it is a very big sin 2 condemn gursikhs as this is sayin that r better then them.... please watch what u say before u say it.... Bhull chuk maaf Wjkk Wjkf

Re: TOUGH

moorakh · 13 Nov 2005

If any of you gurmukh pyare have read Sri Dasam Granth Sahib, you will realize that Sampuran Chaupai Sahib is beyond the line "Kharag Kayth Mai Saran Thihari." It actually extends to "Kripa Karee Ham Par Jag Maathaa" and Chaupai Sahib is not finished until these lines. If you read only up to Kharag Kayth Mai Saran Thihari, it is like reading Anand Sahib upto the 38th Pauri and not reading the 39th and 40th pauris. If you all only believe in the version that is present in Guru Granth Sahib Ji, then why do you read Jaap Sahib, and Swaiye, which are not in Guru Sahib? The Sodar gurbani in Guru Granth Sahib Ji is a Gurbani, but it is not Rehiras Sahib gurbani that we have as part of our nitnem. The nitnem was given by Dasmesh Pita Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Ji in 1699, and that was the sampuran rehit. If you read Bhai Mani Singh Ji's puratan das granthi and panj granthi, you will see that the complete Rehiras Sahib, from "Har Jug Jug Bhagat Upaaeiaa" is there, and it includes the Sampuran Chaupai Sahib. For our own cases of manmat, we want to pad-chhed gurbani, we want to take Guru Sahib jee to party halls, we want to remove our kakars when bathing, we want to skip RaagMaalaa, we want to give up Sarbloh for Corningware, want to eat at restaurants, we want to read shortened versions of Rehiras, and we want to give up our keski. These are all our weaknesses. The rehit is one, it is panthic, and we all have a responsibility to maintain it. We are all missing out on something. We cannot call ourselves practitioners of tat gurmat if we sacrifice on some rehits. Moorakhs like me pick and choose rehits. Out of the list above there are some rehits which I do not keep, do to weakness. But Gurmukh pyare do not pick and choose. They live in hukam of Guru Maharaj. MKhalsa's advice is good. If your punj said do the shortened Rehiras, follow their hukam until there is a Sarbat Khalsa samelan. In the meantime read "Har Jug Jug Bhagat Upaaeiaa" and Sampuran Chaupai Sahib after doing the shortened rehiras.