Skip to content
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Forum
soaps
soaps
believer · 09 Jun 2004
wjkk wjkf.
Sangat ji,
this is gunna sound silly, but as sikhs are told not to eat meat and by products of meat should they also not use soaps that contain animal fats???
What does bani say about this?? or can a gursikh answer this-cuz surely u shudn't rub soap made from animals on the temple body?!!!!!
bhul chuk marf karni.
wjkk wjkf.
Re: soaps
GSC · 09 Jun 2004
WJKK WJKF
you can find numerous sources of soaps and shampoos that do not contain animal fats (herbal essence shampoo/body wash, ivory soap i believe has no animal fats in it). I believe i once read on a rehat maryada ( I cant remember whose) that products that cantain animal products should not be used.
WJKK WJKF
Re: soaps
g · 09 Jun 2004
how about tabla they are made from cow hide... why is this accepted everywhere? you can say they only take them of animals that are allready dead... but you and I know the truth thats bs, and what would it matter your still touchin dead animals... I dont really care my self it just seems so hippacritical for people to say one thing... then accept something like this
Re: soaps
um · 09 Jun 2004
if you don't eat meat, egg, fish - that's great. that's bibek budhee. in this day and age it doesn't make sense.
but if we want to take it from bibek budhee to brahminvaad...
if you want to avoid products that touched meat or are made from meat or came out of an animal ,
avoid YOURSELF - you came out of your mother ... yes.
avoid tablas
avoid various types of gatka weapons
avoid dhols and various musical instruments
avoid
glue
soap
shampoo
shoes
wallets
purses
wood
cotton
sugar
all of these products come into contact with meat, are made because of animals, are made with the killing or the use of animals
Re: soaps
believer · 09 Jun 2004
thanks for the comments but please be serious bout what exactly should one avoid?????????
where do u draw the line with meat products???
cuz otherwise i will be obsessing over everything!!!!!!!!!!
Re: soaps
Kaur · 09 Jun 2004
Just think of it this way...if Guru Sahib used the products and said it's ok...then it's ok. The tabla was used in Guru Sahib's time. Therefore it's ok and there's nothing hypocritical about it. It's not like one is going to eat the tabla after playing it or shove one's hand in his/her mouth after touching the tabla. The tabla is used for Gurmat reasons. Not for eating and breaking one's bibek.
I personally think that things made of leather such as wallets and shoes should not be used/bought because materials such as these have no place in Gurmat and don't help one in his/her Sikhi. So therefore, just think: if Guru Sahib used "it", I can use it.
Re: soaps
Mkhalsa · 09 Jun 2004
toothpaste is pretty border line..
Re: soaps
um · 09 Jun 2004
Akali Phoola Singh had a leather gaatraa for his kirpaan
So did Kavi Santokh Singh