Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

washing fruit?

washing fruit?

me. · 11 Jun 2004

I was just wondering, when bibeki's eat fruits like oranges or bananas, do these fruits ALWAYS need to be washed before consuming them? I know a few people who won't even eat the fruit unless the peel has been washed first, but doesn't one throw the peel away anyways? It's understandable that one must wash fruits such as apples, peaches, or pears, since they have no peel to begin with, but does it really matter if one eats a peeled fruit without washing the peel first??

Re: washing fruit?

Singh · 11 Jun 2004

if you eat a fruit, and don't wash the peel, then how will you put that fruit into your mouth? You have touched the dirty peel, but then will you use the same hands to put it in your mouth then? It is a tradition amongst Singhs to wash the peel and then eat it. Only in extreme circumstances do I think we can skip it and then too only if we are sure we won't touch the fruit itself.

Re: washing fruit?

whatWhat? · 11 Jun 2004

i don't get it

Re: washing fruit?

jus wonderin...... · 13 Jun 2004

wjkk wjkf. ok so you say that you have to wash the fruit peel so that if you touch the edible fruit it will be unclean or something. but then can't the same be siad about ohter foods that come wrapped e.g a packet of crisps?? you don't know where it has been, you open the pasket and hen eat the crisps with the same hands. ????? explain the difference????? bhul chuk marf. wjkk wjkf.

Re: washing fruit?

Kaur · 13 Jun 2004

I don't think a bibeki would be eating foods such as "crisps" in the first place since they are already made into a final form and prepackaged. Everything a bibeki consumes is made from scratch. So if someone really wanted to have crisps, the bibeki would make them him/herself. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> e.g a packet of crisps?? you don't know where it has been, you open the pasket and hen eat the crisps with the same hands. ????? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> All the more reason to keep bibek!!! :)

Re: washing fruit?

Mkhalsa · 13 Jun 2004

bibekis dont eat packaged foods like crisps.

Re: washing fruit?

balbir · 14 Jun 2004

"It is a tradition amongst Singhs to wash the peel and then eat it. " Since when has it been a tradition amoungst Singh's, since 1699 or just around the Singh's you hang around with.

Re: washing fruit?

Singh · 14 Jun 2004

Ok balbir. Don't wash your fruits. Every Western person, from child to senior citizen knows to wash fruits and vegetables before eating them. Singhs have been doing this from earliest times. But if this for some reason offends your sensibilities, then you may do as you wish and not wash them.

Re: washing fruit?

Mkhalsa · 14 Jun 2004

ECOLI ZINDABAD!

Re: washing fruit?

balbir · 15 Jun 2004

I was just wondering where "It is a tradition amongst Singhs to wash the peel and then eat it. " comes from. Everyone knows to wash fruit like apples, but I never heard of a sikhi tradition of washing bananas, nuts in shells or other naturally covered foods. Most people simply peel a banana and eat it. Just wondering where this sikhi tradition came from, and where it begun, please enlighten us.

Re: washing fruit?

Kulbir Singh · 15 Jun 2004

A Singh narrated me this incident from Sant Bhindranwaalay's life. Once Jatha Bhindraan was travelling somewhere in it's bus and they stopped somewhere to eat. They bought fruit and some singhs started eating bananas without washing them from outside. Sant jee saw the Singhs doing that and called them over. He had them hold their ears for this mistake and thus chided them for not washing the fruits. There is nothing wrong in keeping this tradition of washing fruits alive. By the same token, if we pluck fruit directly from the tree and there is no water around, there is nothing wrong in eating that fruit just like that. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: washing fruit?

kaur · 15 Jun 2004

This is just a fact related to unwashed fruits: vitamin B12 is very rarely taken in by vegetarians today as it is more commonly found in animals. in the past, vitamin B12 was obtained from unwashed fruits because the fruits would be coated by remnants of animal waste products (ie birds)....gross. So you can decide if you do or don't want to wash your fruits. even if you are eating a banana which is a tropical bright coloured fruit to which more animals will be attracted to, you might touch the skin and then the inside by accident without thinking. also who knows who else has been handling the fruit. there is no harm in washing the fruits. I guess for those who directly eat fruit without washing are getting some nice animal waste source of vitamin B12 - yummy. also regarding nuts, the peanut which is a ground nut, grows in the soil so you can imagine what environment the shell you're touching when you crack open your nice peanuts has been in (insects, various bacteria, and Guru Sahib knows what else). [%sig%]

Re: washing fruit?

jalebis at work uh oh · 15 Jun 2004

There is a Sikh tradition to keep your mind clean, your soul clean, and your body clean. It is common sense but Sikhi has reinforced this. A rehitnama from Bhai Daya Singh jee says a Sikh who does not wash his hands after going to the washroom is a thankhaaeeaa. Clean, proper, good hygeine and good behaviour is expected from a Sikh as they have the highest role to fulfill - they are the ***fauj*** of Akaal Purakh. I beg for the dust of the feet of such Sikhs. May I even live near their shadow.

Re: washing fruit?

Mkhalsa · 15 Jun 2004

That Sikh who urinates and doesn't wash his hands, HE IS A THANKHAAHEEAA -Thankhanama Bhai Chaupa Singh

Re: washing fruit?

balbir · 16 Jun 2004

If we wash for instance the skin of a banana or shell of a nut which we don't eat anyway but throw in the garbage, shouldn’t we also wash the fruit bit inside which we actually eat i.e. the peeled banana or nut out of its shell. After all that's the bit we eat, and not the skin which has been washed only to be thrown away?

Re: washing fruit?

Singh · 16 Jun 2004

balbir, Ok, let's go over this one final time: We wash the outside of nuts and bananas etc. not for some ritual reason. We wash it because the same hands which would peel the unwashed banana would then be used to eat the banana inside or eat the nut inside the shell. So, if the outside of the banana was dirty, we would use the same hand that touched the dirty outside to touch the part we are eating. We dont' need to wash the inside of the banana if we washed the outside because no one has touched the inside. This isn't such a complicated concept balbir.

Re: washing fruit?

balbir · 17 Jun 2004

Thank you for explaining the concept although you still have not revealed where the tradition among Singh's begun, (which Guru Sahib started it again?) Most people usually peel a banana and eat it without using their hands. Will they still need to wash to peel if they don't use their hands, likewise if they use a juicer to squeeze oranges so there is no contact with hands. Do these situations form part of the "extreme situations" where a banana can be eaten like a normal person.

Re: washing fruit?

Singh · 17 Jun 2004

Talk about focussing on minutiae.

Re: washing fruit?

khalistani · 17 Jun 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! theres a reightnama that says to always wash ure food before u eat it bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: washing fruit?

:S · 17 Jun 2004

>Do these situations form part of the "extreme situations" >where a banana can be eaten like a normal person. I didn't know the Khalsa behaved like mere "normal persons". If "normal" includes eating dirty unwashed fruit rather than being like most hygiene-conscious individuals who wash it for safety in case you DO touch it and consume a dirty part as a result...then abnormality rules.

Re: washing fruit?

Friendly Neighbourhood Singh · 17 Jun 2004

>>>>> Thank you for explaining the concept although you still have not revealed where the tradition among Singh's begun, (which Guru Sahib started it again?) Most people usually peel a banana and eat it without using their hands. Will they still need to wash to peel if they don't use their hands, likewise if they use a juicer to squeeze oranges so there is no contact with hands. Do these situations form part of the "extreme situations" where a banana can be eaten like a normal person. >>>>> Well veer jee most of the traditions among Singhs were started by Singhs and passed down to Singhs. If you want the exact date and time when the first singh decided to wash bananas and eat them well i don't think anyone has that information. But if you are looking for a time where Singhs were strict about jooth then their are numerous historical examples. A lot of Sikhi rehit is passed down word of mouth. If you feel certain things to be unnecessary then by all means don't do them. I personally didn't use to wash bananas before I ate them but I think I will start as other Singhs seem to be doing this. A lot of people will say you are just copying people... well that's true I am ... but I can't think of anyone better to copy then guru sahib's Singhs. A lot of the rehit that i've been blessed with comes from simply copying Singhs. I've don't have any epiphanies to share or insinghts that will enlighten anyone concerning guru sahib rehit but that doesn't mean other Singhs don't have experiences they can share. I simply look at it as me trying my best to keep guru sahib happy and holding on to the things that keep Kahlsa unique. A heartfelt submission to Guru sahib's will never lead one astray. Many of us are simply ground out between the millstones of two opposing schools of thought. On one had we are always talking about how we should think for ourselves and on the other hand we are told to be submissive to hukmans and rehits of guru/Sangat/Singhs. Well i believe this is the reason we ask for " .. bibek daan" during ardass. We are asking for the ability to know the difference between what is gurmat and what is manmaat. We are asking for the ability to know how to make choices. let me know what you think.

Re: washing fruit?

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I think some are just splitting hairs to score points.... You can bring a horse to water but you cannot make it drink.... If someone doesnt want to bathe, wear clean clothes, wash his hands, brush his teeth, wash his fruits, plates or spoon before eating then what can we do ????? He can just drop his banana in the dirt a couple of times and just eat it without peeling even... for all i care. After all apes and chimps eat their baanas like that and they are all perfectly healthy as well...so whats the point of arguing???? So in my humble opinion lets close this discussion. Its just a waste of bandwidth. Enough has been said. Dass Jarnail Singh