Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

If Degh falls on the Floor

If Degh falls on the Floor

someone · 15 Jun 2004

If degh falls on the floor or if someone else drops a chunk of degh on the floor, what should be done with it? Do you eat it, or throw it away? I ask because I was distributing degh and some lady dropped a chunk of it. I found it later and I didn't know what do with it so I ate it. Was this correct? Is that considered joot? GurFateh [%sig%]

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

Kulbir Singh · 15 Jun 2004

I can tell you about myself and about the Singhs I know. If degh falls from your hands or from the distributor of degh, then we should pick it up and eat it. Degh found otherwise should be disposed off in flowing water and should not be thrown in garbage. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

. · 15 Jun 2004

kulbir, why?

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

Singh · 15 Jun 2004

Although it is up to the individual Singh to decide whether they wish to eat this degh or not, I know that in India, most Singhs do not eat the degh that has fallen on the ground. They pick it up and put it somewhere where it can later be disposed of respectfully.

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

no one · 15 Jun 2004

But there are always little pieces of degh fallen on the ground, I always see this at Gurdwaras after degh is served. You can't really go to each and every little piece and eat it, right? Some have been there for a long time, and people have stepped on the degh and stuff. Also, some of us are so into bibeki and not having jhoot and not eating from "moneh" or "manmukhs" - but what if we find degh on the floor that dropped from the hands of a "monah" or "manmukh" - then wouldn't some of you veers and bhans not want to eat from those hands? Also some people unknowingly step on small pieces of degh that were dropped on the ground. Would you still eat it if it was stepped on by "moneh" or "manmukhs" ? If so, then doesn't it contradict not eating from the hands of these people but eating the stuff they walk on? That's confusing.. I think it's very different if you drop the degh yourSELF.

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

kaur · 15 Jun 2004

i don't think that we should think so negatively . If we find degh on the floor that dropped from the hands of a "monah" or "manmukh" as you have mention. I think this is all the matter of "sharda". I would think that those who came to the gurdwara are all sangat roop...and if the degh found drop on the floor i would eat it....thinking that it is degh and not jhoot. Doesn't matter if it stepped too. We were suppose to be the tood(dust) of sangat. I am sure if we have this sharda in us ...guru sahiba will be very pleased with us. Let me share an experience . After an akhand paath , my relatives perfomed an aarti...and all the sangat was requested to throw the flowers on Guruji. As i was holding my share of flowers and i droped it on the floor . I was told that we are not suppose to carry the flowers that dropped on the floor cause we are going to put it on Guruji. I agree with that...but what i did was....i carried the flowers and i put the flowers on guruji's charan and ask Guruji to clean this moorakh , i am as dirty as this flowers and i am putting it on to your charan ,pls clean this flowers as i would think that YOU have help me and saved me from all kind of dirt. Now i don't know whether i did a right thing or not. But i think i had some sharda in me and i just thought of a way to communicate to Guruji. A lot of people started passing some remarks about me.....but i didn't bother. In fact i felt happy doing so..... what do you think? This is just my opinion...pls correct me if i am wrong. WJKK WJKF

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

Gaiani · 16 Jun 2004

Uh... this arti thingy of yours is bit wrong, why wud u throw flowers on guru sahib? I cant imagine ne1 doin it to Guru Gobind Singh Jee, I think this mite be ritual not a Sikh but a baman thing. Also one extra reason not to eat degh after its fallen on the ground and you dont know when or who dropped it, health, wat if the person had foot fungus or something?

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

no one · 16 Jun 2004

"gaiani" - bhanji did not follow the arti, her family did. she put the flowers at guru jee's CHARAN - she didn't throw the flowers on guru ji. didn't you read it ji?? but bhanji you said >> would think that those who came to the gurdwara are all sangat roop..<< well then why don't certain bibeki people eat in the same room as all the other people? isn't this a contradiction? "oh we can't eat in the same room as such people or we can't eat food cooked by their hands" but then why would you eat what they stepped on or dropped from their hands? what if their hands were "dirty" or "impure"? (according to some people)

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

Mkhalsa · 16 Jun 2004

>>> we can't eat in the same room <<< WHAT?! WHO DOES THAT? I absolutely HATE it when theres a seperate langar, and I think everyone needs to have one langar with maryada. I know if there is a seperate room, many times I will make it a point to sit with rest of sangat, instead of secluded etc, I know quite a few others who do this as well.

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

kaur · 16 Jun 2004

gaianiji , you seems to have a lot of "hangkar" No one ji..thank you for your comment and coming back to your question, "well then why don't certain bibeki people eat in the same room as all the other people? isn't this a contradiction? "oh we can't eat in the same room as such people or we can't eat food cooked by their hands" but then why would you eat what they stepped on or dropped from their hands? what if their hands were "dirty" or "impure"? (according to some people)" this is a very difficult thing to explain...maybe because i am not a bibeki yet but i do really respect bibeki's a lot ......but then there is one thing that we must think .... would you think that Guru Gobind Singh Ji will do the same to a sangat and will keep away from them just because they are not bibeki's.? i agree we are not suppose to take jhoot from a non amritdhari but if a person is aready an amritdhari and he made langar with naam bani and even Guru Sahiba will eat that langar. I am sorry...i shouldn't be arguing about this....this is just my point of view and i am sure most of you will not be agreable to this. I think at the end of the day...we just have to live they way we are suppose to be lived by HIS Hukam.....everyone is destined with thier own different way...all because of HIS HUKAM. WJKK WJKF

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I for one cant comprehend this "arti thingy" as well..... The SHABADS sung in AARTI are the ones CLEARLY CONDEMNING the "actions" of those doing the aartee. GURU JI is telling us that all this "flower throwing" ( offering at Guru Ji's Charan ??? excuse me there is such a RUSH that people just throw them at GURU JI ), INCENSE BURNING, etc are ALL a FRAUD because WAHEGURU and HIS OWN AARTII is just too big...this "small time" arti thingy is just a drama. GURU JI visited the HINDU MANDIRS where they were doing this AARTII and wrote the SHABADS to SHOW how WRONG they were......some SINGHS went ahead and IMPORTED the AARTII wholesale for GURU JI and started singing HIS GURBANI that SAYS" STOP THIS DRAMA" This is nothing but a brahmin COPY CAT action clearly and unequvically condemned in GURBANI as WRONG and Demeaning to WAHEGURU and HIS GREATNESS.....our handful of flowers to the One who CONTROLS the UNIVERSE !!! a few DHOOPS to the One WHO PERFUMES the UNIVERSE !!! The raggis like it becasue more money for them..... others like it becasue something for them to "do" becasue they dont understand any Gurbani Paath or such serious stuff... Dass Jarnail Singh

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

. · 30 Jul 2006

the first answer was the simplest if you drop it or sum1 drops it infront of u pick it up n eat it if its bin trodden on, put it into a flowing river

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

. · 31 Jul 2006

is a sink acceptable as "flowing water"?

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

Baljit Singh · 31 Jul 2006

I can't understand if someone happen to give a passing comment about the aarti...why did others have to jump at the chance to start criticising??? If sangat wants to throw flowers towards Guru Sahib, I'm sure its out of love...is that so wrong? Going back to the topic...I'v come accross this dheg problem so many times, it'd be nice to know if there was something that the Guru's said about it, instead of just basing it on our opinions.

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

gupt singhnee! · 31 Jul 2006

i think if degh does fall onto the floor then yes it shud b eaten..it has been dun bhog on at the end of the day...but..if a person does not decide 2 eat it then atleast put it in a respectable place like sum ppl hv sed a flowing river or something..and yes as "." asked..is a sink acceptable as "flowing water"?

Re: If Degh falls on the Floor

Singh · 31 Jul 2006

Can u give it to your dog if it falls on the floor or give it to the birds? My Dog loved degh, this is guru jee's blesssing.