Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
singheee laad · 16 Jun 2004
Vaheguru ji ka khasa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh!!!
We had a very unfortunate incident hear in the Uk this weekend.
Bhai satnam singh damdami taksal wale was doing katha at guru ghar in Birmingham. Whilst doing katha bhai satnam singh "Sant Jarnail singh jee is in chardi kala wherever he is"
At this point a member of the sangat challenged Bhai Satnam singh he said
"Bhai sahib jee please do not lie in Guru jee's durbar, Sant jee is shaheed the akal takhat has declared he is shaheed, i offer £100,000 to whoever can prove he is alive"
At this point Bhai satnam singh replied "if iam lying let my head be cut off, if you are lying i will cut off your head.
There was commotion in the sangat, at which point the stage secratary stopped the katha. At the end of the diwan the Singh that had challenged Bhai satnaam singh in the durbar went to speak to the committee. The comittee were supportive but requested that He should not have said anything in the durbar.
Then 3 young amritdhaaree Singhs came into the room and beat Bhai sahib up, they siad he done byaadbee of mahraaj by intterupting the katha, and how dare he say sant jee is shaheed. The singh had to spend the night in Hospital.
Now, coming to my point, this action has been welcomed by many the Taksaali singhs here in the uk. Many of them saying that maybe now people will accept that Baba jee is not shaheed, and that the bhai sahib got what he deserved.
My question is not about whether Sant jee is shaheed or not that is another debate. My question
Was that Bhai Shaib right to question the Katha kaar in the durbar?
Does this mean that everyone will be forced to accept that Baba jee is not shaheed? ( already posters, Tshirts that are printed never say Shaheed Sant jarnail singh Jee)
Please do not turn this into a Shaheed or not shaeed debate!!!
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh!!!
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
what_is_going_on · 17 Jun 2004
What Sikhi are we promoting when we carry out acts like this? Ok the Singh should have just raised his hand to ask/put his question across in sangat i don't think there is anything wrong with that regardless of whether kutha is going on.
If we went back into Guru-Ji's times i think these sorts of things occured where sangat asked Guru-Ji questions whilst Guru-Ji were giving there sermons.
But then for the Singhs to beat the Sikh up? I am disgusted and ashamed that i am a brother of these fellow Sikhs. I have recently been reading the autobiographies of the first 5 Guru's and the Guru's in my opinion would have served out very serve punishment to these 'so called' Sikhs for hurting this fellow Sikh. Where has the forgiveness and understanding gone?
Sat Sangat Ji until we don't reform our ways and listen to bani and what it is trying to tell us Guru Ji will not do kirpa on the panth and we will all suffer.
The current youth of today especially in (UK) is more interested in having nice drawings/computer wall paper/big kara/listening to (but not understanding) stories from our illustrious past and portray a hollow sense of bravery and pride. Please try and think clearly and act humbly in Guru Ghar, you will not attain respect for beating up individuals. If those Sikhs who beat the Sikh up ever read this post meditate on Guru Arjan Dev Sahib Ji and let Guru Sahib tell you personally if what you did was right or wrong.
Apologies for any offence caused.
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
lakhvir singh · 17 Jun 2004
GuruFatehJi.
Where has all the pyaar gone? To seat down those who are mistaken and facts explained to them? You think the Guru is happy with this kind of squabbling? If we are so immature about handling Panthic issues as minor as there, then we certainly do not deserve our own country (Khalistan).
In the hazoori of Guruji, Sikhs made a scene of themselves. What impact did that have on the kids and young minds? How can Amritdharis, who are taught that raising of might is the last resort, do such a deplorable act as to beat up a fellow Sikh just for difference in belief and opinion?
How will we present ourselves to our Guru when our day of calling comes? Our heads will hang in shame and Sikhi will not be granted in our next life. Imagine that as a punishment - let alone union with Waheguru in the next world, we will have lost even the blessing of being a Sikh in the next life, if the Lord's Mercy is upon us to merit another human body.
Someone should now also seat the Amritdhari Sikhs involved in this and ask them if what they did was approved of by the Guru. Someone should speak them into meeting up with the fellow Sikh they beat up and reconsile them so that they can progress in meaningful debate, not engage in acts of that shame the Sikh Panth and our Guru.
Hum murakh, Baba bakhshleh . . .
GuruFatehJi.
L*
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
tarunjeet singh · 17 Jun 2004
vaheguru ji ka Khalsa
vaheguru ji ki fathe
I don't see anything wrong with Singh interupting the Katha, if the Akhal Takhat has declared Jarnail SIngh as Shaheed then Singh was right to question why the Katha was not accurate. Also who the hell do the yoputh think they are by beating up this guy ? Just becasue he follows Akhal Takhats stance on Jarnail Singh he got beat up, does anyone know who the youth where ? what are there names. ???
vaheguru ji ka Khalsa
vaheguru ji ki fathe
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
what_is_going_on · 17 Jun 2004
the panth has survived thus far, no greater tragedy could have befallen us when Guru Arjan Dev Ji and Guru Teghbhadur Ji were tortured and killed by the Moghuls but both Guru Ji's said accept Waheguru's will, and look we are here today still surviving.
Certain Sikhs must get out of this mind set that Sant Ji is going to emerge again one day and save us, nobody can save us except Waheguru.
And i wonder exactly what Waheguru and Guru Nanak Dev Ji are thinking now?! These Sikhs may say they punished the Sikh for speaking in Guru Ji's Darbar, but exactly who gave them the right to do so? They have committed the worst crime here of bring violence into Guru Amar Das's house! They have not been able to respect Guru Ji in the first place!
I think it is a known fact that Sant Ji and the Babbar Khalsa did not get along on certain topics but they never started shooting or killing each other. They had wisdom, intellect and understanding of bani. Something we youth of today are sadly lacking in spades. Apart of me wants to find out who these Sikhs are and extract my own revenge on them but my Guru forbids it, he calls for compassion and humility.
Let us love each other and be real Sikhs not imposters. No honour was received in this act of violence except shame and dishonour on the house of Nanak.
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 17 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Emotions going awry...Respect for Guru/Sikhi/Gurmat/Amrit going through the window ???...just because the other guy doesnt agree with you.
During the time of Guru Arjun Sahib Jee there used to be a very loving and devoted Nimana Sikh who used to sit right at the Back....."high and mighty devoted sikhs " used to sit Right in FRONT....But GURU JI knew the HEARTS...and so one day GURU JI called upon this Nimana Sikh to come sit right next to GURU JI. This action set those high and mighty devoted sikhs on FIRE with JEALOUSY..... they waylaid the nImana Sikh on his way home and WHACKED him Good and proper. The next few days the nimana Sikh was not around and the high and mighty devoted sikhs sat in front of Guru Ji with Chaurian chhatian ramrod staright backs...imagining Guru Ji thinking about how devoted and holy they were.... After a few days Guru Ji inquired about Nimana Sikh and some people told him that he was at home in bed due to injuries.... When GURU JI went ot his home, nursed him and asked him who beat him up ?? The Nimana Sikh said You ! GURU JI You beat me up and now you ask me who beat me up. Please forgive me for I must have deserved this beating otherwise You wouldnt beat me up ??
I have a feeling GURU JI is visiting this SINGH right now in his Hospital bed.
One man offered 100,000 Pounds.... the other offered his HEAD. One is LYING ? Sant Jarnail Singh Ji offered his HEAD and GAVE IT...many others also offered theirs and got away with false promises/broken fasts unto death etc etc. A SINGH of GURU GOBIND SINGH Ji NEVER LIES..... one or the other MUST be PROVED to be lying.....beating around the BUSH wont help resolve anything. We may have to beat up 100,000 to hide the truth but it will still come out. How about the Akal Takhat Hukmnama ??
The Kaum is in serious trouble and we MUST all UNITE to Fight the Enemy and not ourselves. Sit down and resolve - Gurmatta is the best way. Sant Jarnail Singh is one of the Greatest Singhs of the 20th Century ...He deserves our UTMOST RESPECT and DEVOTION.
Dass Jarnail Singh
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
Harmeet Singh · 17 Jun 2004
http://www.tribuneindia.com/2003/20030607/main3.htm
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
waheguru pyara · 18 Jun 2004
shame on gursikhs who beat bhai sahib
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
seva simran sacrifice · 18 Jun 2004
VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh.
S Singh ji, you are very correct.
>> I think we should respect Khalistanis right to his beleifs, while some of us may not agree with whether Sant Jee is Shaheed or alive. <<<
MKhlasa ji, you hit the nail on the head with your "few things to say".
Singh ji, re-read what Mkhlasa has quoted...a little respect for each other would be so nice...
what the three Singhs did was wrong!
VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh.
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
Niranjan Singh · 19 Jun 2004
Baba Ji's son's and wife annualy do Bhog of Sehaj Paaths on his Shaheedee Divas. They have already done his Antim Bhog many many years ago and believe IS SHAHEED.
They will not openly debate or talk to anybody about this due to DDT pressure.
This was openly stated by the Tut brothers of Cali. who performed seva of Sri Darbar Sahib Karseva and very close to his family.
Baba Ji belongs to the Panth now and the Panth had declared that he is SHAHEED. Now one should question that not even DDT or Baba Takhtur Singh.
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
Kaal is eating me alive....... · 19 Jun 2004
Taksaals stance on Sant Jarnail Singh s here: http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/video/index.php
I've asked Baba Takhur Singh ji if he meant that Sant Ji was in chardi kalaa (as in his body being shaheed) or if he meant that Sant Ji was alive and well. Baba Ji told me that Sant Ji is alive and well in his own body.
I've also read that Sant Ji's father has the same position as Taksaal.
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
Manjit Singh · 20 Jun 2004
This kind of ****admin cut**** will keep happening until we as sikhs stop being more obedients to some organizations or persons rather than Guru Sahib. Most of us are proud to be taksali or nanaksaria or missionary or this or that sikh and not Khalsa. It not bad to form organizations as long as they used for Panthic cause. Every organization or deras related to sikh tries to prove that only they are best. This HAUME is main reason behind such incidents. Guru tellus "Haume navain naal virodh hai doai na .......". We are polluted with his Haume and still we think we are the best sikhs.
Bhul Chuk maaf jee.
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
$ÍÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ · 20 Jun 2004
i myself used to believe that sant jee was alive until my cousin came over and showed me a picture of sant jee's body before cremation. it is still recognizable; u can easily tell that it is sant jee himself. the place where the body was cremated has a record of all the people that have been cremated and sant jee's name is written in the record CRYSTAL CLEAR. if someone tells me how to post a picture i'll try to do it
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 21 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
No matter what photos or even videos you post/documents/photocopies or originals...whatever.....WILL HAVE ABSOLUTELY NO EFFECT.
ALL these are ZILCH...compared to the TAPE of Sant Ji that SAYS: LISTEN to and FOLLOW Jathedar THAKUR SINGH JI....and whatever Baba ji says is 100%++++++++Nano Power TRUE to his followers.
So why waste your time and breath. Just accept the fact that not everyone is as convinced by the Photos, Cremation Records, AKAL TAKHAT HUKMNAMA etc....
To a NANAKSARIA.... whatever the Nanaksaria SANT/MAHAPURASH says is 100% TRUTH
To a Taksali....Whatever Baba Ji Thakur Singh says is 100%%%% TRUTH
To the rest of SANT/DERA/MAHAPURSH followers: Whatever their sant dera mahapurash says is 100%%%%%% TRUTH
To the rest of us simpletons out there these photos, cremation records and AKAL TAKHAT HUKM may mean something...but that is all.
Both sides will NOT change their positions so why not close this discussion and let matters be as they are.
Dass
jarnail Singh
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
Harpartap Singh · 21 Jun 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
Gyani, then you will know that short of reaching that stage of kamai where Vaheguru ji's blesses us with knowledge of the whole Universe, we have to rely on what our Guru given matt allows us to judge.
All evidence has to be substantiated and its authenticity depends to a great degree on the source of the evidence. Evidence can be given first or second hand.
All the documentary records you mention are sourced from the Indian Government departments at the time of the Ghallughara. How reliable a guide are they? At best they are secondary evidence and not proof in themselves that Sant Jarnail Singh ji was shaheed.
As to eye witnesses, Sant ji's brother was asked to ID the body. He has said that the body he was shown was very mutilated and it was not possible to confirm that it was his brother. So what does that leave us with? So-called eye witnesses, virtually all Indian government employees who purport to know better than Sant Jarnail Singh ji's brother.
As regards the holding of an Akhand Paath in honour of the Shaheedi of Sant Jarnail Singh ji - that does not in any way prove that he was Shaheed.
What it boils down to on the EVIDENCE is that the story is mixed and contradictory. There is not conclusive proof that Sant ji is Shaheed.
Finally, all the above leaves to one side the bachan of Sant ji himself and Baba Thakur Singh. Nothing to do with Sant folowers blah blah blah
H
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
Jugraj Singh · 22 Jun 2004
This whole argument that Khalistani veer ji uses is rather convenient.
If you belive that baba Jarnail Singh is shaheed that means you are calling baba Thakur Singh ji a liar.
The argument is cyclic.
**********Here is a mock debate to illustrate my point.
My question: ONly another brahmgiani would know if baba thakur singh is a brahmgiani or not, is that correct?
Most likely answer: true ... their is a recorded speech by baba jarnail singh where he says listen to baba thakur singh jee.
My question: so you are assuming baba jarnail singh was a brahmgiani... how do u know bab jarnail singh was a brahmgiani?
Most likely answer: He was a panthic shaheed and by not saying he was a brahmgiani you are disrespecting his life.
My question: How?
Most likely answer: because he was a brahmgiani and you won't admit it.
My question: how do you know he was?
Most likely answer: baba gurbachan singh said so.
My question: How do u know baba gurbachan singh jee was a brahmgiani?
Most likely answer: what? you belive all that propaganda put forth by the government.
My question: No i don't but what is the basis for your belief?
Most likely answer: Taksal comes from baba deep singh jee? Do you think he wasn't a brahmgiani either?
My question: What proof do you have that Taksal comes from baba deep singh jee?
Most likely answer: everyone knows this.
My question: well that doesn't make it true does it?
Most likely answer: their is a list of names, which shows all the jathedars after baba deep singh.
My question: i know of the list and did you know that many names on that list also are claimed by many other jathebandis? Many of the people are clamied to have been sants of quite a few deras...anyways who came up with the list? Do you have any historical documents which refer to Taksal say from anytime before 1940.
Most likely answer: I don't know but it doesn't matter... baba thakur singh is a brahmgiani and he just knows and we don't need to have any sort of historical proff or evidence.
*********end of mock debate.
Was it my intention to make chardi kala Singhs like bab gurbachan singh and baba jarnail singh and bhai sahib thakur singh jee look bad?
no ... i fear guru sahib.
I am just trying to illustrate the mentality that many of the youngesters seem to have developed. They lack indepth information and an ability to analyze facts for themselves.
Many of us make outrageous claims by giving the title of SANT to people.
Think about the companions of Guru nanak and think about all the chardi kala puratan sikhs of the past... none of them were called sants.
Baba Buddha jee.
Bhai Mardana
Bhai Gurdas jee
Baba Deep Singh jeee
Bhai Mani Singh jee
Even the sahibzaday
Baba Ajit Singh jee
We do not have the authority as individuals to give the title of Sant to anyone. So let's not do that. We can't make people brahmgiani's by constatly claiming that they are.
Daas,
Jugraj Singh
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
tarunjeet singh · 23 Jun 2004
vahegruu ji ka khalsa
vaheguru ji ki fathe
Does it really matter if Baba Jarnail singh is Shaheed or not?? The way I see it Akhal Takhat has told us that he is shaheed and we as Sikhs must follow what Akhal Takhats hukum is. What diffrence shoudl it make if he's dead or alive, Sikhi is a personal spiritual experience you should conecentrate on your own Jeevans and inspire to be the next " Shaheed Baba Jarnail SIngh " rather than waiting for him to ocme and lead the panth, lead it yourself.
vahegruu ji ka khalsa
vaheguru ji ki fathe
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
Harpartap Singh · 23 Jun 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
This is not a debate on the use of titles within the Panth.
This is not a debate on the history of Damdami Taksal.
I posted about the facts being unclear - Jugraj Singh simply attacked the history of Damdami Taksal. If you have something positive to contribute to the debate, then do so.
The use of an imaginary conversation is childish and is not the way to debate. A debate is where you actually debate with ANOTHER person NOT yourself.
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 23 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Reading about Jugraj Singh's mock debate...brings to mind the "arguments...nay SOLID PROOF" my Christian School master used to bring up in class. He used to say: What is the PROOF that the Bible is the WORD of GOD ?? Answer: Because Jesus is Son Of God and He says the Bible is the Word of God. Who says Jesus is Son of God ? Amswer: The Bible of course.
Khlistanne veer says" Show Me WAHEGURU ? Answer: Look in SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE...SANT, SADH, GURU are all NAMES of WAHEGURU and WAHEGURU ALONE. Waheguru is the "Sant" "Sadh" the "Guru" And HE LIVES in the DEEP HEART of each of US...that is the Sant/Sadh/Guru we all have to Search for and MEET in order to ATTAIN WAHEGURU.
This is the MAIN REASON there are NO SANTS, SADHS, in the Entire SIKH HISTORY from GURU NANAK SAHIB JEE and after GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE beginning 1708 till MODERN TIMES around 1940's. Each GURSIKH of the HIGHEST STANDARD is JUST a BHAI...
It is also a fact that due to the notoriety surounding the word "sant/Sadh" in the Sikh World, some famous so called sants have decided to DROP the word from their self styled title and become "bhai".
This is not to say that the GOI did not fabricate/falisfy evidence/plant evidence etc about the Ghallughara 1978-2004. There is loads of fabrication/falsification and sheer propoganda to DENY us our Shaheeds and Sacrifices made by so many ( many thousands are STILL SACRIFICING at the time I write this... and will go on sacrificing until we get Justice)..but nthing will come out of it if we try and force feed our viewpoints to others by dropping names, baba ji, mahapurash, sant sadh etc said this or that. To the unbeleiver this name dropping means nothing...to the believer it means Everything.
Dass's Plea to all: Keep our Goal in mind - UNITY before Everything else.
Dass jarnail Singh.
Re: Shaheed Baba jarnail singh jee???
to harpratap · 23 Jun 2004
but Jugrajs arguments are true.
Just for reference, harpratap, do you honestly believe the boys who beat the Singh up, did the right thing?