Raagmala Crisis
Kulbir Singh · 19 Jun 2004
Looks like there will be a Raagmala debate in Panth again. Following the great book by Giani Gurdit Singh jee on the reality of Raagmala, the pro-Raagmala sections of Panth are not going to take it easy.
Regarding Raagmala, our stand should not be what people we revere think. Panth should resolve this based on facts and not on sentiments.
May Guru Sahib do kirpa on Panth.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Takht Patna Sahib summons Vedanti
Seeks clarification on book ‘Mundavani’
Varinder walia
Tribune News Service
Amritsar, June 19
In an unprecedented move in Sikh history, the Jathedar of Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, Giani Gurdit Singh, member of the SGPC’s Dharm Parchar Committee, and another Sikh scholar Mohan Singh Guard have been summoned at Takht Patna Sahib on July 20. They have been asked to personally clarify their position regarding the recent book “Mundawni”, authored by Giani Gurdit Singh .
It is for the first time that the Jathedar of Akal Takht has been summoned by the Sikh clergy of another Takht . Though Jathedar Vedanti has taken a serious note of the step taken by ‘Panj Piyaras’ (five beloved ones) of Takht Patna Sahib and which could plunge the Panth into a deep crisis , he said he could personally visit Patna Sahib to give clarification on the book. Jathedar Vedanti said he had visited Takht Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib along with Giani Gurdit Singh, who studied the manuscripts of the holy Guru Granth Sahib in his presence.
Talking to TNS, Jathedar Vedanti said he was shocked to learn about the move to summon him at Takht Patna Sahib, which had no precedent in Sikh history . He said Giani Gurdit Singh had simply documented the facts about “Raag Mala” and had not given any personal opinion on this issue. Similar views had already been given by the SGPC a long time ago. He said the Sikh clergy of Patna had no locus standi to take up such issues as it was the prerogative of Akal Takht only. The jurisdiction of Akal Takht and other Takhts had already been decided at the meeting of Sikh high priests, which was attended by Jathedar Iqbal Singh and Giani Rattan Singh , Jathedar and Deputy Jathedar of Takht Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib, respectively. While Akal Takht was declared supreme by all five jathedars, the other four Takhts were allowed to handle local issues
Giani Iqbal Singh, Jathedar Patna Sahib, in a written directive, said the above decision was taken by the Sikh clergy at an emergency meeting held at Patna Sahib today.
Meanwhile, Giani Gurdit Singh said the photographs in question are those taken by a local photographer from Patna Sahib in the presence of the author and others, including Granthi Iqbal Singh of Takht Sri Patna Sahib. “Itihaas Sri Guru Granth Sahib: Mundavani” is based on more than 50 years of research, and is the second in the series. The first, Itihaas Sri Guru Granth Sahib: Bhagat Bani Bhag was published in 1990 and is running in the second edition now. Both are research books and have been reportedly well received by scholars.
Mundavani is profusely documented which photographs of manuscripts of Guru Granth Sahib that conclude at Mundavani. Bhai Mani Singh in his book, “Sikhan de Bhagat Maala,” has said that Mundavani is the seal that signifies conclusion. The book discusses Mundavani and examines various issues related to it. It is meant to increase the understanding of the Sikhs, and not cause and divisions, it was mentioned.
Re: Raagmala Crisis
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 20 Jun 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Yes the situation does seem like what khalistanee veer says.
The Guru Khalsa Panth has two opposing sides....On one side are the SANT/Mahapurash/Derawallahs ( IMMOVABLE PILLAR ...i.e. a PILLAR that NO FORCE can Bring down)...and on the other side we have the Academics, and Gianis,Jathebandies like AKJ ( the UNSTOPPABLE CANNON... i.e. a Cannonball so powerful that NOTHING can stand in its way..)
So here we have the IMMOVABLE PILLAR that NOI force can bring down...standing before the UNSTOPPABLE CANNON that nothing can Stand up to it..??? Only GURU JI knows the answer to this riddle.
Anyone can write as many books as they like and pass any hukmnamas they like...the other side is not going to move one mm. That has been the situation for so many decades already....now the only thing that has changed is that the Takhats OUTSIDE PUNJAB have begun flexing their muscles..and the only winners in this melee will be the Anti-Panth forces that want us all to knock off each other's dastaar....
Dass Jarnail Singh
Re: Raagmala Crisis
Rashminder Singh OZ · 20 Jun 2004
raag maalaa is a bani or not, lets leave it on panth.............. there are very strong proofs of declaring raagmaalaa not a baani of guru ji.
what answers do all dera's and sampardaas have to the photographs in this book?
obviously we want strong proof rather than saying
" all the raags and raaginees we singing the praises of guru arjan dev ji at his door, he was about to seal the guru granth sahib ji, they ordered a sikh to open the door and saw all raags and raaginees singing his praises. guru ji became happy with them and gave them space in guru granth sahib ji"
i am sick of listening this stanza from taksaali singhs and from different kathakaars of these sampardaas.
i am not against any sampardaas or jathebandhi, only thing is i am interested in authenicity of raagmaalaa, if akj does try to prove that its not a baani, regardless of thier proofs most of the people say "they are not sikhs"
bhul chul maaf
Rashminder Singh OZ
Re: Raagmala Crisis
Harpartap Singh · 21 Jun 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
The original Aad Graqnth Sahib is still extant at Kartarpur and no one disputes its authenticity. Rasshminder Singh - you can get plenty of photograophs which show that the original saroop has Raag Maala.
BUT this is not about how many photographs each side can present - it goes much deeper than that. All saroops were made from the original - logically the debate should centre around the original saroop - whether copyists OMITTED bani or added additional verses is a separate issue.
Thanks to Kulbir Singh for raking this up again ;o)
PS this has been said many times but is worth restating, if members of the Sangat are using 'Hukamnama's issued by the Akaal Takhat in support of their position, it is only logical that they follow them in all regards i.e. its stand on the Panj Kakkaars, vegetarianism etc etc. Akaal Takhat has already stated that Raag Maala HAS to be within a saroop of Guru Granth Sahib ji - reading it is optional so all Anti Guru ji's Raag Maala people should accept this Hukam as well. There is no need for further Hukamnaama's.
Re: Raagmala Crisis
Harpartap Singh · 22 Jun 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
Daas bhaji made a very good post :o) Vaheguru, Vaheguru, Vaheguru...
Re: Raagmala Crisis
Raagmala PIC · 22 Jun 2004
http://sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/files/rag_mala_in_delhi_museum.jpg
A Bir from Maharaj Ranjit Singhs own scribes, is in the National Museum Delhi, it also has Raag Mala in it.
Re: Raagmala Crisis
Harpartap Singh · 22 Jun 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
'Mr. Singh' - the translation is available but this thread is not supposedly about Raag Maala itself. I doubt if many posts would be allowed if that were the case.
I have the translation as pictures in a MS Word document but don't know how this could be put here - or even if it should? I think that is up to Admin
Re: Raagmala Crisis
Harpartap Singh · 22 Jun 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
Going back to the topic - apparently Gurdit Singh has given photographs of manuscripts of some 'Beerhs' of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. According to him, 'Bhog' of the 'Beerhs' is on 'Mundaavani'. On the other hand, there are 34 old 'saroop' of Guru Granth Sahib in Takht Sri Harmandir Sahib, Patna Sahib. All the 'Beerhs' have the Raagmala.
Gurdit Singh was accompanied by Giani Joginder Singh Vedaanti when he had 'Darshan' of those 'Beerhs'. He claimed that some of these Beerhs, in which 'Bhog' is on 'Mundaavani', are there in Takht Patna Sahib.
Now, The 'Panj Piyare' of Takht Sri Harmandir Sahib, Patna Sahib has asked the author to tell which 'Beerhs' have the 'Bhog' on Mundaavani.
So based on this Gurdit Singh and Giani Joginder Singh should go to Patna Sahib, and tell the 'Panth' where are those 'Beerhs'.
The fact is that all the 34 'Beerhs' kept in Takht Sri Harmandir Sahib, Patna Sahib have the Ragmala according to the authorities of that Takhat. If Gurdit Singh has lied, he should be given hard punishment.
Giani Joginder Singh has not been summoned as 'Jathedar' of Sri Akal Takht Sahib. His photographs have been given in Gurdit Singh's book. Giani Joginder Singh should appear before the Takht Patna Sahib as a Sikh, not as a Jathedar of Sri Akal Takht Sahib. He was not the Jathedar of Sri Akal Takht Sahib, when those photographs were taken.