Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Share trading/analyst?

Share trading/analyst?

ns · 25 Jun 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ke fateh After reading the lottery debate which I believe Gursikhs shouldn't gamble in that sense , I want to ask this serious question to the sangat. Is it OK to be Technical Analyst in Stocks and commodoties, currencies? This is what I am , I have asked a number of Gursikhs in the past before I approached this career, I was told by a very well known katha vachek, Jaswant Singh Ji Jachek in fact to not to worry as this involves real work and a lot of thought process before making a decision. Sangat jee I've spent hours upon hours in this area as it is my chosen goal to be a trader ,and today I am with Guru Ji's Grace successfull. But a question keeps arising in my mind that is it right, that what i am doing ? is it a gambling profession or proper kirat kamai one? It took me years to get where I am , loads of hours of study of charts, stock, econmic indicators, technical indicators and I don't buy and sell just as a gambler would, it takes a lot of thought process other wise you'll be loosing money like there is no 2morrow.Could the cyber sanagt Ji please post your opinions on this. And I apolgize in advance if this topic has been discussed before, if so please post the links. I 'v also heard quotes from Gurbani about traders but my brain at this moment in time doesn't remeber them , I think it is referred in bhai Gurdas Ji's vars ,if someone knows please post so I can refresh my mind. Thanks in advance Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Share trading/analyst?

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 26 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. A lot of people have this misconception that "playing the shares market" makes you rich.....Yes it does happen and others become poorer too. But these PLAYERS are Gamblers..... they GAMBLE on which shares will go up and buy into them ands if their HUNCH proves right they make a killing...otherwise they jump off the enarest building when they cant repay their debts.....Worse off are those who BORROW money to gamble this way. BUT there is one big difference......and that is what veer Ji is doing above - Shares ANALYST and TRADING. This is as already more than obvious from veer Ji's letter VERY VERY HARD WORK and is NOT a GAMBLE/LUCK but based on seriously studying a Company's PROFILE, Management, Tactics, Techniques, Sales, marketability of its products, future prospects etc....and then making a CALCULTED JUDGEMENT to buy or sell its shares. This can still go wrong and make the person listening to the advise of the analyst poorer or if it is the right advise makes him RICHER. So this is HARD WORK and can be called KIRT KAMAII. As in any profession veer Ji must make sure GURUMATT is always ON TOP of things.....if there is any chance at being UNSCRUPLOUS, CHEATING, INSIDER TRADING etc which are all CRIMINAL ACTS then we must REFRAIN from them. In our judgement we cna go wrong...even a doctor can go wrong if he starts doing abortions for money when he should be saving lives ( especially those doctors scanning and killing FEMALE FOETUSES for get rich quick chances... are definitely NOt doing Guru Ji's WORK !!) To be on the SAFE side ALWAYS LISTEN to YOUR CONSCIENSCE ( GURMATT)...It will NEVER LIE to YOU and will always keep you on the Good Clean path of the GURU. So carry on your trading/analysing......and be a Damn GOOD ONE so that GURU JI will be proud of his Sikh. Dass jarnail Singh.

Re: Share trading/analyst?

~ · 26 Jun 2004

It's more like giving financial support to a company and profitting off the companies success.

Re: Share trading/analyst?

Jinder. · 26 Jun 2004

Veerji, Even Guru Nanak Sahib was a merchant, and that involved money. All I can say veerji is with stock analyst, you are not stealing/cheating for anyone, you are doing legitmate work that took years of study. I think some professions such as barber, beauty care products, drug dealer, prostitute/pimp, professional gambler, theif and lying polticians, or being a pakandi baba count for bad jobs. God Bless.

Re: Share trading/analyst?

bikramjit singh · 26 Jun 2004

WJKK WJKF I think that Jaswant Singh Kathavachak is correct Gambling is a game of chance based on ONE likely event. You either win or lose. Share dealing is totally different. It is not based around ONE event. You buy shares and you either make a profit or a loss depending on when you sell them. It is TRADING and not GAMBLING. It is similar to the way you would buy something and then hope that you would be able to sell that thing for a higher price thereby making a profit. GurFateh Bikramjit Singh

Re: Share trading/analyst?

A Singh · 28 Jun 2004

Gur Fateh! I would be inclined to agree with Bikramjit Singh and Jaswant Singh given that there is a difference between 'gambling' and 'investing' understand this and your question should be answered. BTW, Bikramjit Singh, I liked your explanation, do you work in a Financial Institution as well?

Re: Share trading/analyst?

bikramjit singh · 29 Jun 2004

A Singh I don't work in a financial institution, I just trade shares in my spare time

Re: Share trading/analyst?

/.. · 29 Jun 2004

you invest based on knowledge. i.e. study fundamentals of a company, invest based on those numbers there is less risk. gambling involves no knowledge. more risk becasue less knowledge.

Re: Share trading/analyst?

ns · 29 Jun 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ke fateh Many Thanks for everyone's reply on this point. Jarnail Singh Jee, you are perfectly right when you say even after loads of time and research spent things still can go wron and no doubt I 've experienced this many times and Guru Ji has saved me early. This has cleared the final clutter that was irritating me in my mind and i only pray Guru Ji keeps me motivated in Gurmat style and way of life, for the rest of my life on this planet no matter what i do. Thanks Again. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ke fateh