Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Jul 2004

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. An example of how clear GURBANI actually is if we care to read carefully. On the WORD "RAAM" Bhagat kabir explains... Sri Guru granth sahib Jee AAng 1374. "Kabir..RAAM kehan meh bhed hai..taan mehan ek BICHAAR. Soi RAAM sabhe kehe..soi kautakhaar Kabir Rameh RAAM ko...kahebeh mahin bibek EK anekeh MILL gayah...ek samaneh ek !!! “After thinking over the meaning of ‘Ram’, Kabir says that there are differences in the usage of this word. While everyone uses ‘Ram’ for God, the actors use it for Ram Chandar, the son of Dasrath. Kabir dwells on ‘Ram’ Who is God. The one Ram (God) is present in all whereas the other (Ram Chandar) was only himself.” AGGS, Kabir, p 1374. After such clarity, if someone still claims that GURBANI is "hindu based" or "hindu gods like Ram krishan etc " are mentioned as SUCH and NOT as AKAL PURAKH/WAHEGURU ..."RAAM ANEKEH MIL GAYAH"" as compared to a RAAM who is just ek ( one person )...what to say..... Lets have a discussion on this topic. Learned Gursikhs please input your valuable replies...and lets learn.. dass jarnail Singh

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

Kulbir Singh · 03 Jul 2004

Very good post Arshee jee. It is a widely accepted fact that the most of the times in Gurbani, word "Raam" or other such names mean One God - Vaheguru. Surya-Vanshee Kshatriya - King Raam Chander, the son of Dashrath and Kaushaliya was a great king of his time as he conquered the world by doing Ashav-medh Yagya but was not God as many Hindus believe. If you read Ramayana written by Rishi Balmeek and then read Tulsi Daas's Raam Charit Maanas, you will notice that the status of Raam got elevated in Raam-Charit-Maanas by Tulsi Daas. Raam that Gursikhs believe in is the omni-present Vaheguru and not King Raam Chander of Ayodhya. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

P Singh · 03 Jul 2004

I thought this was very obvious. On this thread, there are some people that lean towards hindu stuff: http://sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=4153&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 05 Jul 2004

Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dear P Singh Ji. The misconception is very common and it is not so obvious. This is the argument used by the Hindu leaning ones...they just look at the "superficial" word like for example RAAM..... and say Aha... see, GURBANI also beleives in our Gods and that is why they are mentioned. Probabaly KABIR JEE was already AWARE of this fallacious argument even in His Day.... that is why Bhagat Ji is going to such lengths to EXPLAIN EXACTLY what his use of RAAM means. The same goes for Krishan, Gopi, Hari, Govinda, Shiv, Narayan....etc etc..IN GURBANI these ALL refer to WAHEGURU. I have been to that Forum you refer to above and other forums. I think due to Waheguru Ji's KIRPA ( and Admin's hard work ) the Tapoban Forum is one of the best and balanced ones i have seen so far. Total emphasis of all the posters is mostly on Gurmatt and LEARNING.....very few troublemakers and jealous/irritating writers who know nothing better than make personal attacks when they lose an argument. May Guru Ji bless All. Dass jarnail Singh.

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

singh · 06 Jul 2004

Please explain the following Bhattan Savaye: You are blessed with the Nectar of the Lord's Name, O Guru Nanak; You have mastered Raja Yoga, and enjoy sovereignty over both worlds. ||6|| In the Golden Age of Sat Yuga, You were pleased to deceive Baal the king, in the form of a dwarf. In the Silver Age of Traytaa Yuga, You were called Raam of the Raghu dynasty. In the Brass Age of Dwaapur Yuga, You were Krishna; You killed Mur the demon and saved Kans. You blessed Ugrasain with a kingdom, and You blessed Your humble devotees with fearlessness. In the Iron Age, the Dark Age of Kali Yuga, You are known and accepted as Guru Nanak, Guru Angad and Guru Amar Das. The sovereign rule of the Great Guru is unchanging and permanent, according the Command of the Primal Lord God. ||7||

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 06 Jul 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Off hand I cant remeber but I read a shabad of Guru nanak sahib jee that essentially goes like this: Referring to Raam Krishan etc.. and talking about Akal Purakh, Guru Ji asks...DOES the RAAM (etarnal ) inside the raam ( chander son of Dasarth) become any bigger or braver because raam killed raavana or if KRISHAN (eternal) inside the krishan ( bindraban mahabaharat ) killed kans ?? Tu sultann kahon haun meean teri kavan wadaii .... says the same thing in naother shabad....that is the AKAL PURAKH neither becomes bigger with our praise...and neither is he any smaller due to our nindia.... The Bhatt sawiyeh are written in praise of Guru Sahibaans...but the underlying message is that the Guru sahibaans are the VISIBLE MANIFESTATION of the Almighty Akal Purakh who Has MANIFESTED HIMSELF countless times before as raam, krishan.. in earlier times. The HINDU gods are used as reference because this is Indian based composition and familiar names in Hindu literature and religion are used as everyone knows these..... IT is AKAL PURAKH that is the CENTRAL manifestation....in every Yugg.....and in Kalyug Akal purakh has manifested Himself through GURU NANAK JYOT. This is my understanding. I think Veer Ji Kulbir Singh Ji will also give us an interesting insight into this shabad. Dass jarnail Singh

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

Kulbir Singh · 06 Jul 2004

---------- You are blessed with the Nectar of the Lord's Name, O Guru Nanak; You have mastered Raja Yoga, and enjoy sovereignty over both worlds. ||6|| In the Golden Age of Sat Yuga, You were pleased to deceive Baal the king, in the form of a dwarf. In the Silver Age of Traytaa Yuga, You were called Raam of the Raghu dynasty. In the Brass Age of Dwaapur Yuga, You were Krishna; You killed Mur the demon and saved Kans. You blessed Ugrasain with a kingdom, and You blessed Your humble devotees with fearlessness. In the Iron Age, the Dark Age of Kali Yuga, You are known and accepted as Guru Nanak, Guru Angad and Guru Amar Das. The sovereign rule of the Great Guru is unchanging and permanent, according the Command of the Primal Lord God. ------------- This shabad has been taken from Saviyye Mahallay Pehlay ke. The baani verses are as follows: SATJUG TAIN MAANIYO, CHALIYO BAL BAAVAN BHAAIYO|| TRETAY TAIN MAANIYO, RAAM RAGHUVANSH KAHAAYIO || DUAPAR KRISHAN MURAAR, KANS KIRTAARATH KIYO|| UGGAR SAIN KO RAAJ, ABHAI BHAGTAIN JAN DIYO|| KALJUG PARMAAN NANAK GUR ANGAD AMAR KAHAAIYO|| SIRI GURU RAAJ, ABICHAL ATTAL, AAD PURAK FURMAAIYO|| In previous ages, whenever the avtaars of previous juggs did anything great, it was all shakti or power of Siri Guru jee working in them. When Baavan Avtaar deceived the demon king - Bal by measuring the whole world in 2.5 steps, it was actually Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee working inside the Baavan Avtaar. Bal was deceived but after this deception from Siri Guru jee, Bal bound Siri Guru jee in an eternal pledge as written by Gurbani - "Ajhoo Bal ke duaar khara". Till this day Siri Guru jee - Guru Nanak Dev jee - Vaheguru jee is standing guard outside the door of King Bal. Then in Treta Jug, when Raam belonging to the Surya Vanshi Raghu Vansh killed demons and the head of demons - Raavan, it was Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee at that time who was doing all the great work. What power did Raam Chander have on his own? Nothing! It was Siri Guru jee who was working inside him and helping the bhagats of that age. In Duaapar Jugg, all the greatness of Krishna was due to Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee working inside him. When he killed the evil king - Kans, it was Siri Guru jee who actually did that act. The world thought it was Krishna but in fact it was Siri Guru jee who worked inside Krishna and used his body to kill Kans. Then Siri Guru jee through the body of Krishna, gave Uggar Sain, Krishna's grandfather his kingdom back. In Kaljug however, Siri Guru jee decided to take his own avtaar rather than working through inferior avtaars. He took avtaar and called himself Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee, Siri Guru Angad Dev jee and Siri Guru Amardaas jee. The last line of this pauri is amazing and a gursikh can't help saying vaah vaah, hearing it. The translation is as follows: "Aad Purakh i.e. Vaheguru declared that the kingdom of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee is eternal (abichal Attal)". Don't we, the Sikhs of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee, get immense relief and satisfaction hearing that our father is the king of this world and will stay the king forever. Because it is our father's kingdom, so we too will enjoy this kingdom along with our father Siri Guru Nanak Dashmesh jee. Singho, drop all your worries. We are children of Siri Guru jee whose kingdom will never go away. Why should we worry. Our Pita jee is the king of this world. O Gursikho, let us all rejoice. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

Singh · 07 Jul 2004

SATJUG TAIN MAANIYO, CHALIYO BAL BAAVAN BHAAIYO|| TRETAY TAIN MAANIYO, RAAM RAGHUVANSH KAHAAYIO || DUAPAR KRISHAN MURAAR, KANS KIRTAARATH KIYO|| UGGAR SAIN KO RAAJ, ABHAI BHAGTAIN JAN DIYO|| KALJUG PARMAAN NANAK GUR ANGAD AMAR KAHAAIYO|| SIRI GURU RAAJ, ABICHAL ATTAL, AAD PURAK FURMAAIYO|| Thanks for the translation, however I believe that the Gurbani is not talking about Guru Nanak through the jugs as Kulbir Singh stated but Akal Purkh himself. The Bani is referring not to Guru Namak deceiving Bal but Akal Purkh who was working inside Bavan Avtaar and so on. I think the bani is basically saying how the world called different ‘avtars’ Akal Purkh in different ages. i.e. Bhavan in Satjug, Raam Chander in Tretay, Krishan in Duaper, and in Kaljug people call the Guru’s Akal Purkh. The Bani does not say anywhere that Akal Purkh himself is or was any of the above just simply that they were regarded as him. I think the translation “In the Brass Age of Dwaapur Yuga, You were Krishna; You killed Mur the demon and saved Kans.” is misleading, as it should not be ‘You were Krishna’ but actually follows on in the same way as the lines above and below it i.e. regarded as rather than you were as the Gurbani does not say ‘you were’ but is following on from the lines above. What do you think reading the Gurbani and not the translation, please note the use of maaniyo, kahaayo. Concerning the killing of Kans that’s clearly Akal Purkh to whom Guru Ji is referring to who is the real doer and not Krishna. Also Kulbir Singh please post the ang ref.

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

chee chee · 07 Jul 2004

>>> The last line of this pauri is amazing and a gursikh can't help saying >>> vaah vaah, hearing it. The translation is as follows: >>> "Aad Purakh i.e. Vaheguru declared that the kingdom of Siri Guru >>> Nanak Dev jee is eternal (abichal Attal)". hold on. the whole composition is written by guru nanak. why would he say this about HIMSELF ? according to your sikhi "nanak sahree gareebi hoonj ke lege si" ? are you saying he didn't have ANY gareebi. waiting for your reply.

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

Kulbir Singh · 07 Jul 2004

--------- hold on. the whole composition is written by guru nanak. why would he say this about HIMSELF ? according to your sikhi "nanak sahree gareebi hoonj ke lege si" ? are you saying he didn't have ANY gareebi. waiting for your reply. ------------ This baani is not written by Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee but by Bhatt Kal Sahaar and the name of this baani is Saviye Mahallay Pehlay key. This baani is on ang 1389 or 1390 or around that. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

chee chee · 07 Jul 2004

i am confused. i need clarification. how can the bani be 'headed' SAVIYE MAHALLAY PEHLAY KEY but be written by someone else?

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

Kulbir Singh · 07 Jul 2004

---------- i am confused. i need clarification. how can the bani be 'headed' SAVIYE MAHALLAY PEHLAY KEY but be written by someone else? ---------- Saviye Mahallay Pehlay ke means that these saviye talk about Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. There are 4 more saviye i.e. Saviye Mahalay doojay ke, teejay ke, chauthay ke and panjaway ke. These saviye collectively are called Bhattaan de Saviye and have been written by 11 great Bhatts like Kal Sahaar, Mathura, etc. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

Kulbir Singh · 07 Jul 2004

---------- Thanks for the translation, however I believe that the Gurbani is not talking about Guru Nanak through the jugs as Kulbir Singh stated but Akal Purkh himself. The Bani is referring not to Guru Namak deceiving Bal but Akal Purkh who was working inside Bavan Avtaar and so on. ---------- Baani in fact is talking about Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and not Akal Purak because in this baani (Saviye Mahallay Pehlay ke), Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee is the focus of praise. As the matter of fact these verses are addressed to Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

Singh · 08 Jul 2004

Having now read the whole shabad I would agree that the bani is in fact talking aboutGuru Nanak and not Akal Purkh.

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

J Singh · 08 Jul 2004

Kulbir Singh Ji, To me, this shabad from Saviye Mahallay Pehlay key really means that it was Guru Nanak Dev Ji who was called Bal Baavan Avtaar in SATJUG, Raam Raghuvansh in TRETAY, and Krishan Muraar in DUAPAR. It doen't say that Guruji worked thru these avtaars just for those particular moments. Why would guruji do that? These avtaars weren't bhagats of Guruji. Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

Kulbir Singh · 08 Jul 2004

----- To me, this shabad from Saviye Mahallay Pehlay key really means that it was Guru Nanak Dev Ji who was called Bal Baavan Avtaar in SATJUG, Raam Raghuvansh in TRETAY, and Krishan Muraar in DUAPAR. It doen't say that Guruji worked thru these avtaars just for those particular moments. ------ If it was Guru Nanak who was called Baavan Avtaar or Raam Avtaar, then what does the second last pankiti of this shabad mean: KALJUG PARMAAN NANAK GUR ANGAD AMAR KAHAAIYO|| ? The word parmaan here clearly means that "Hey Guru Nanak, in Kaljug you came out in open and called yourself Guru Nanak, Guru Angad and Guru Amardaas". Common sense says that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee was not Krishna or Rama. If Guru Nanak was Raam Chander, why would he say: Rovai Raam nikaala bhaiya|| Seeta Lakhman BichhuR gaiya|| ? (Raam cried when he was banished from Ayodhya. He again cried when Seeta was taken away by Raavan and when Lakhman was paralyzed and killed by Meghdoot or Kumbh-Karan) Was our Guru Nanak Sahib, Raam Chander in his previous life? No way. Yes, Siri Guru jee did overtake their (avtaars') bodies when they did great deeds. They could not have done anything on their own. It was Siri Guru jee's power that was working in them. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

P Singh · 08 Jul 2004

Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji was Waheguru's divine light in human form. So I feel its better to say Waheguru's divine light was working through the bhagats instead of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji. Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

J Singh · 08 Jul 2004

Second last pankiti means, as you explained, "You opened called(KAHAAIYO) yourself Guru Nanak Gur Angad and Gur Amar." But that doesn't change the meaning of any of the previous pankities. We are not talking about what Common sense says, we are simply discussing the meanings of this specific shabad. This shabad doesn't say anything about overtaking any bodies to do great deeds. Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: BHAGAT KABIR ON RAAM-

J Singh · 09 Jul 2004

Kulbir Singh, sorry about the typo in my post above. I wrote it in a rush. what I really meant to say was that the second last pankiti in the shabad means, as you explained, "You (Vaheguru Jot, or Guru Nanak Dev Ji - the name given to Guruji in Kaljug) came out in open in Kaljug and was called (KAHAAIYO) Guru Nanak Gur Angad and Gur Amar." This pankiti does not change the meaning of any of the previous pankities. I know what the words MAANIYO and PARMAAN mean. I can't fathom your interpretation about Guruji possessing bodies of avtaars for few minutes to do great deeds then leaving them behind to suffer their fate. The shabad doesn't say anything about that. Anyway, nothing happens without Vaheguru's will. vgjkk, wgjkf