Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Nanaksar

Nanaksar

Veerji · 11 Jul 2004

Did anyone read this newspaper Asian Post, I got it from a place in Delta. It basically stated there is a feud going on between 2 babas, one Baba Mann Singh and one Baba Harnek Singh over control of gurdwaras belonging to the Nanaksar sect. What's your take on it?

Re: Nanaksar

jk · 12 Jul 2004

nanaksar is not a sect.

Re: Nanaksar

................. · 12 Jul 2004

These people give a Bad name to sikhi and great sikhs from Nanaksar like Baba Nand Singh and baba Ishar Singh. Its Sad, What can we do.

Re: Nanaksar

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 12 Jul 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The present "nanaksar" is not only a sect but a very divided sect at that with numerous babas and sants all over the place...all fighting over Golak and charava. There has been FIRING of guns at main nanaksara gurdwars...in Punjab. The present babas are consuming the kamaii of Ishar Singh and nand Singh and using their name to scam ordinary sangat. nanksdar doesnt beleive in KIRPAN, also it deosnt beleive in Jhoolte Rahen Nishan Panth maharaj ke - NO NISHAN SAHIBS at their THAATHS ( not gurdwaras) Dass jarnail Singh

Re: Nanaksar

Tony Singhprano · 12 Jul 2004

my family was very close to Baba Nand Singh Ji..... and it's heartbreaking to see how Nanaksar has spiraled and crashed into it's present state. i think the same thing could happen to the AKJ..... give it another 5-10 years......as the elders pass away, the young blood isn't strong enough to handle the internal conflict that will arise. As an outsider i can already see the divisions that have taken place.... The sub-divisions within AKJ are well know, but seldom talked about. have i hit the nail on the head or have i got the story totally wrong. Tony Singhprano.

Re: Nanaksar

.............. · 12 Jul 2004

did bhai isahr singh and bhai nand singh wear the 5 kakkars?

Re: Nanaksar

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 13 Jul 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. About the 5 kakkars I am not sure BUT what i am very sure about is that BOTH of them were NOT GRISTHI - breaking the very FIRST LAW of GURU NANAK which says a Person MUST be a HOUSEHOLDER...and NOT be recluse, staying in the jungles caves etc as sadhu/sant/rishi etc. ALL the GURU SAHIBAANS were MARRIED and lived as Householders ( except of course Guru harkrishan Ji who was only 8 years old at Gurgadhi) NOt a SINGLE GURU recommended the ascetic lifestyle to attain Waheguru. Other than that I am unable to comment on their kamaii/Gurbani Love etc but to me it is of utmost importance to BE LIKE YOUR GURU if YOU REALLY LOVE HIM..... and ALL our GURUS were MARRIED had WIVES, SONS and DAUGHTERS and partcipated in FAMILY LIFE to the FULLEST. Dass jarnail Singh

Re: Nanaksar

10 · 13 Jul 2004

First of all, Nanaksar is not a sect. The mukh sevadar at the Nanaksar in Punjab is Baba Kundan Singh, who have handled this seva after Baba Isher Singh. Nanaksar attracts a lot of sangat so there are currently some people that you can call greedy that want control of it after Baba Kundan Singh. The Nanaksar gurdhwaras in North America were started by Sant Meeha Singh, who have been around since Baba Nand Singh's time. Sant Meeha Singh were a blessed charhdi kala gursikh. They used to do over 120 JapJi Sahib paats daily. The problems at the Nanaksar gurdhwara mentioned have begun after Sant Meeha Singh left their body. The dispute is between the son of Sant Meeha Singh, and a sevadar that used to do a lot of seva Baba Harnam Singh. The sons are saying that as the property belonged to their father, and they should have all the control. The sangat want the control to go to Baba Harnam Singh, who also doesn't have the best track record as he has been caught DUI. And Baba Nand Singh and Baba Isher Singh followed gurmat rehit so they did keep 5 kakaars.

Re: Nanaksar

khalistani · 13 Jul 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! sant baba ishar singh je and sant baba nand singh je were some of the greatest sikhs ever did MAAAASIVE bhagti but there is sadly many fights at their dehras, even gun fights but the main nanaksar jathedar is baba gurdev singh, and there was this thing were all the jathedars got together and put there names or something and baba gurdev singh jes name came up the others just want the attention, power, and mooneey bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Nanaksar

P Singh · 13 Jul 2004

Sad Sad Sad, this stuff causes much confusion to the seeker.

Re: Nanaksar

Balwant singh · 13 Jul 2004

akj will never be what nanaksar is akj believes in langar akj believes in deg and the bhog ceremony akj believes in nishan sahib akj never preaches brahmchraya no matter how many divisions in akj it will always be panth oriented and never be an agent for the congress or any enemy of the panth akj can easily demonstrate its sincerity with ulimited names of shaeeds which nanaksar cant even dream

Re: Nanaksar

noone · 13 Jul 2004

>>GURU NANAK which says a Person MUST be a HOUSEHOLDER<< i don't think guru nanak ever said that you HAVE TO be married or have kids or whatever. several gursikhs did NOT feel the need to do all that. it doesn't mean they ran into a forest, but they just didn't feel the need to get married and live like that.

Re: Nanaksar

10 · 13 Jul 2004

It is not a requirement in gurmat to live a gristhi lifestyle. It is recommended to the average person, who would more likely to make a mistake later on in their life. One of the greatest gursikhs of the 20th century, Sant Attar Singh were not married.

Re: Nanaksar

khalistani · 13 Jul 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ka fateh!! thats A MAJOR INSULT TO NANAKSAR how wud u like it if i started saying taksal is better than akj?? u need to learn respect for mahapurshes like baba nand singh je seriously, i dont know wats happened to some of us we think sants as nothing we are filled with so much hankar have some respect sant baba nand singh je was one of the greatest sikhs ever to do the nidya of a sant is a one way ticket to narak i cant belive this no mpre respect for mahpurshes this is a saad time for the world when sants who come to help us are treated like nothing bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ka fateh!!

Re: Nanaksar

Anon · 13 Jul 2004

Enough about akj talk already Giani Arshi Ji, what is important in SIkhism is love, What is the point of saying what you are saying? Baba Nand Singh and Baba Ishar Singh were TWO, yes TWO of the GREATEST SANTS of all times..whatever you say cant change that

Re: Nanaksar

Daas · 13 Jul 2004

Please do not put nanaksar down like this. You may or may not know but the amount of bhakti that baba nand singh did, can not be compared to many gursikhs present today. bhul chuk maph!

Re: Nanaksar

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 13 Jul 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. YES... the GURSIKHI of GURU NANAK-GURU GOBIND SINGH -GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI = MIRI+PIRI = SANT + SIPAHI..... Massive BHAGTEE without any SIPAHINESS is only HALF the equation.... A SANT MUST SHED his BLOOD..... I dont think there are any such SANTS in any of these movements... Look at Massive Bhagtee SANTS like Baba Deep Singh Ji, Baba Mani Singh Ji....... each one was ever ready to shed his life blood for Sikhi. SADLY During the SINGH SABHA MOVEMENT, GURDWARA LIBERATION MOVEMENT, hundreds of Sikhs took SHAHEEDE at Nankana Sahib, Guru Ka Bag, Panja Sahib, Dehra sahib Lahore, Jaito....... very few of these sants were around to participate.. Even during the recent HOLOCAUST of 1978 - to PRESENT time none of these SANT/BABA movements contributed any shaheeds... I will stand corrected if any veer can NAME any prominent SANT/BABA of Nanaksar Movement, other SANT DERAS that took SHAHEEDEE in 1984. The AKJ and the Damdami Taksaal took the FULL BRUNT of this attack on Sikhi and fought alone... ( NANGEH DHHARR) ..NOT a SINGLE SANT DERA of the SANT SAMAAJ gave any support in any way - even support in the form of VERBAL SUPPORT !!! HOwever Many Prominent POLITICIANS CONGRESSIS, Indira Gandhi, Sonia gandhi, Rajiv gandhi were WELL RECEIVED at these DERAS by the SANT/BABAS and BLESSED !!! and this is still going on. Dass jarnail Singh

Re: Nanaksar

Wondering · 13 Jul 2004

I am sure Sant Nand Singh and Sant Isher Singh must have wore 5 Kakaars. They probably wore their kirpans under their cholas. We know of some hard core Amritdharis who are from the Nanaksar jatha.

Re: Nanaksar

Deep Singh · 13 Jul 2004

i don't think AKJ will end up like Nanaksar, because AKJ is organised in a different way. i think there is no 'one' head (jathedar or something) of that Jatha. After Bhai Randhir Singh, several people have been leaders. It is called: Panch-Pardhani [read at www.akji.org]. at least i haven't heard of a single Jathedar heading the Jatha.. secondly, there is no 'sampardae', like one jathedar giving the leadership to next jathedar after his death...that can create divisions, if the unity is not strong. these things happen also in Damdami Taksal (single jathedar and sampardaya), but the unity is stronger there and lots of Mahapursh, so there is not such great divisions and fightings there, as in Nanaksar. But ONE question: does Nanaksar have a lineage back to Guru Sahibs time, as Damdami Taksal claims? are Rarasahib, Mastuanawale and Nanaksar, are they the same thing...i mean like are they the same sampardae?

Re: Nanaksar

Admin · 13 Jul 2004

Topic now closed. Admin.