Re: "keertan" sohila
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 29 Jul 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
Mkhalsa is right. This Gurbani as written in the Guru Granth sahib Jee is SOHILA.
Someone arbitrarily added the word "kirtan" to it and this has stuck. This is WRONG as we are trying to "improve" on Guru ji...and btw this Gurbani is READ as part of our nitnem...who does "kirtan" of it ??
Similarly the word"dakhni" in Ramkali Dakhni Oankar...the actual name of the Gurbani is ONKAR and not "dakhni onkar" as normally used.
About "facing" your pillow ??? first time i heard it. seems a "superstition" cultivated by you know who....Derawallahs !! This presupposes that "GURU JI" is sitting on your pillow.....because in Indian Social culture etc a RESPECTED Person sits on the pillow side and the LOWER person sits at the PAIND ( opposite to pillow) side of the bed.... GURU JI is EVERYWHERE !!! at least this much we learnt from Guru nanak Sahib jee's visit to MECCA ( or have we learnt anything??)...
And by the way dont fall for that other superstition either which FORBIDS setting foot on the ground again AFTER reading sohila....If you need to go to the bathroom or get up to check on a "burglar" or something....DO IT unhesitatingly...your sohila is NOT going to be "broken" !!!!
Dass Jarnail singh
Re: "keertan" sohila
Kulbir Singh · 29 Jul 2004
I personally agree with Arshee jee that doing Sohila Sahib facing any direction (including the pillow) seems to be superstition. I have not heard any puratan Singhs doing so. Same way, if one has to go to washroom after Sohila Sahib, it is not broken in any way.
A long time ago, I heard that if one does mool mantra after Sohila Sahib, one's Sohila protection is broken. I think this too is a superstition. One wonders that what happens after Sohila protection is violated by doing Mool Mantra recitation. I would say that one gets Mool Mantra protection then. That would be good enough for me. In any case, I don't think doing mool mantra or Gurmantra after Sohila Sahib would break any protection.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "keertan" sohila
Dass Sevadar · 29 Jul 2004
The word Kirtan was added to Sohila in the last century or so, because sangat in gurdwara's use to do Kirtan before reading the Sohila in the evening before Sukhasan of Sri Guru Granth Sahib, and the name Kirtan Sohila was created.
Still the name of the Bani Should be called as Guru Sahib has written it.
[%sig%]
Re: "keertan" sohila
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 29 Jul 2004
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
Yes if sleep doesnt come immediately after sohila sahib has been read....i think it would be a great idea to do mool mantar or gurmantar jaap. This action shouldnt "break" or violate sohila sahib in any way....i do that most of the time if sleeping or dozing off takes some time. Just lying on your bed and staring into space might get "ideas" floating in your head..and stray your ever ready mann to fly off.... better do mool mantar or just waheguru waheguru...till you go to sleep.
i read on another site that the word "kirtan" was added by Bhai gurdass as he uses this in one of his vaars.
dass jarnail singh
Re: "keertan" sohila
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 31 Jul 2004
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
If i have to choose between my beloved Guru Granth sahib Jee...and any human even Bhai gurdass Ji, or sant baba Gurbachan singh ji or anyone else...I choose GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE.
Guru Granth sahib Jee ...this Bani is "SOHILA".
We add Sahib, Jee, and other words of respect AFTER the bani and these are verbal.....not meant to be "written down". NO Additions or Subtractions should be allowed for GURBANI...as these mean we are trying to be smarter than Guru Ji and "improving" on the Divine Message.
Its true we refer to "Jap"...as JAP JI SAHIB...BUT would anyone...DARE to PRINT a SAROOP of GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE with these EXTRA WORDS ADDED IN..... or change the title of SOHILA.. to "KEERTAN SOHILA".. I dont think so. SO why not just FOLLOW GURU JI.
Dass jarnail Singh.
Re: "keertan" sohila
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 01 Aug 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Veer Jss ji,
"kirtan with waja and tabla" is also performed for Chaupai Benti, Jaap Sahib, Japji sahib..... so should all these be called....KIRTAN CHAUPAII BENTI, KIRTAN JAPJI, Kirtan Jaap...???
In facr any bani can be sung with instruments kirtan style...but we dont go about adding kirtan to the title of each bani. Why added to SOHILA ??
Sohila is part of the Panj bania of our daily Nitnem.... NONE of the others have this word in its title...although all can be sung kirtan style and are sung in gurdwaras....
Stick with the GURBANI title given by Guru Ji Himself.
Dass jarnail singh
Re: "keertan" sohila
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 03 Aug 2004
Waheguru jI ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Bhai Gurdass Ji "scribed" ( wrote ) the entire GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE in front of Guru Arjun sahib Jee..... wouldnt he have "added" "kirtan" in front of SOHILA ??? Didnt he ask Guru Ji if he could do this ???
The Irreversible FACT is GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE has ONLY "SOHILA".... full stop. NO BODY can change this FACT...not eve Bhai gurdass Ji who scribed the ORIGINAL TITLE of this GURBANI in the Guru Granth.....and wrote a different "title" in his own bani.
Guur Ji DID NOT include any of Bhai Gurdass Ji's "bani" in GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE. How can we over-ride Guru Ji and choose Bhai gurdass Ji OVER GURU GRANTH JI ??? I am baffled...with the Guru Granth in front of us we keep on referring to Bhai gurdass ji....bhai gurdass ji...???? Why ???
And YES why am I not "surprised" as "confuzzled" above that there is also a Taksali Kirtan Sohila just like many other Taksali banis...there is no need to be CONFUZZLED.....thats just the way it is...taksalis are taksalis. ( Privately I also read the so called "rakhee waleh shabad" whenever I feel down or upset.. and I also encourage my children and students to put them to memeory and read them all the time.......BUT they are NOT PART of SOHILA simply because GURU JI said SO and the Proof is in the GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE.
Bhul Chuk Maaf Ji
Dass jarnail Singh
Re: "keertan" sohila
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 03 Aug 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
"Singh" Ji: Far from "implying" or "disrespecting" anyone.
What I am trying to say is that GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE says: "SOHILA" is "XXX" shabads.....BUT others who follow TAKSALI MARYADA say NO. To us SOHILA is ( ****+XXX+***) shabads.....and this is because some one said so.
Read the post of Khalistani veer who got Confuzzled veer ji confused: Khalistani veer says " "the entire keertan sohila starts with Gur Ka shabad Rakhvareh...raakhee waleh shabad...etc etc..."
THAT is NOT what GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE SAY UNDER TITLE OF "SOHILA" ?
So who is "disrespecting" who ?? and WHY ??
IF GURU JI gives WRITTEN PROOF that this bani is SOHILA and only SOHILA...why do we disrespect GURU JI and call it "KEERTAN SOHILA" ??...and then go on to ADD some more shabads from other gurbani and call that New Compilation "keertan Sohila" according to "Taksali maryada".
And of course before I forget...I never said Taksalis are NOT GURSIKHS. Who am I to judge anyone ? especially when i dont even know so many of you and live on the other side of the world. I only discuss SUBJECT MATTER and NOT Individuals./maryadas/taksal/groups/jathas etc
Bhul Chuk Maaf.
Dass jarnail Singh
Re: "keertan" sohila
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 04 Aug 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
You are right :-) Ji,
But then again this nerw style is the "invention" of our modern bollywood tunes crazy waja-tabla threesomes roaming the world...
We used to have Tapes of the Nitnem Banis READ....then some people came along and "read" them in different styles to be "different"...
then along came the "ragis" and we have NITNEM Banis in "waja tabla or instrumental styles...
All this is to SELL and MARKET their different cd's.....Just "plain reading" as GURU JI intended is just plain BORING for some people !!!
You see the waja-tabla-threesome sitting on stage or called to someone's house for doing Paath of Nitnem, Chaupai shib, Sukhmani Sahib etc feel" somewhat silly" just reading and not fiddling with their instruments....so out come the waja tabla...and voila we have JAPJI SAHIB KIRTAN...JAAP SAHIB KIRTAN...SOHILA SAHIB IN KIRTAN...and now we even have "awesome RAAGMALA in KIRTAN "...Wah wah...
Thats all to it. nothing more nothing less. When you have aspre waja tabla - jaap sahib kirtan just comes naturally i think.... I just hope the DHOLL wallahs at Bhangra parties dont get the same idea after they have donewith bhangra etc... to do some Sohila Sahib "kirtan" with their DHOLL bhangra style ???? its going to happen sooner than later !!!!
Creeps ???
Dass jarnail Singh
Re: "keertan" sohila
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 05 Aug 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
A Singh has made a valid ppoint. In the GURU GRANTH ji the Sodar rahras doesnt contain Chaupai which is dasam guru Ji's bani.
Chaupai was included later and even here there are serious differences as to where to STOP the addition....some like SGPC Panth parvanit maryada stop at **** and the others continue until ***%%...others may continue further ??
So following this example of Rehrass...then we start the same proces with Sohila....there will be so many versions.
Does one wrong make another wrong RIGHT ?? Is it a wrong in the first place ??
On the other hand we are the GURU Khalsa Panth and we have the RIGHT to make any changes ( except to GURBANI in the Guru Granth sahib jee) as to what maryada, what banis we want read, etc etc....BUT the SHARAT is that it MUST be Done By Sarbat Khalsa acceptable to all.
The POINT is that the Guru Khalsa Panth MUST have a UNIFIED MARYADA in order to be UNITED and STRONG. many maryadas make us weak. I am NOT saying this maryada is right or that is wrong...I want to see a UNIFIED SINGLE MARYADA...whether AKJ,Taksali,SGPC or whatever.....and once this is achieved ALL MUST follow it and I surely will follow as well.
dass jarnail singh
Re: "keertan" sohila
Harmeet Singh · 03 Jan 2007
Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh|
So Jarnail Singh Arshi Jee Gyani,
I am totally with you on reading what is in Guru Granth Sahib Jee and calling it Sohila like is written in Guru Jee. But this leads to another question, do we do Rehras Sahib paath the way it is written in Guru Granth Sahib Jee (right after Jap/Japji Sahib) or do we read mundhavani mahala punjva and everything added on? And also how about the short Anand Sahib, why do we shorten it? We don't have a right to shorten Anand Sahib and call it Anand Sahib, so why do we have it shortened and recite the shortened form before bhogs instead of the long version, and because the original version takes longer is certainly no excuse. Vahiguru :)
Side Note to the Cyber Sangat: I am really sorry for not posting for the past i don't know how long, feels like a year. I've been reading the phorum on a daily or everyother day basis, but I just don't know why I didn't post anything. But from now on hopefully, I can continue the 'inspirational posts' thread that I started a while back and put up a few stories every week and maybe start new threads on other topics and issues. Bhul Chuk Maph Karnee Jee
Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh|
Re: "keertan" sohila
Rashminder Singh Oz · 04 Jan 2007
I agree with Bhai Jarnail Singh Ji Arshi
Vaheguroooooooooo
[%sig%]
Re: "keertan" sohila
Premabhagti · 06 Jan 2007
Gyani Jarnail Singh Arshi wrote, "If i have to choose between my beloved Guru Granth sahib Jee...and any human even Bhai gurdass Ji, or sant baba Gurbachan singh ji or anyone else...I choose GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE."
Are you then ready to believe in the Raagmala as being Bani since it is in the SGGSji?
Gyaniji wrote "Similarly the word"dakhni" in Ramkali Dakhni Oankar...the actual name of the Gurbani is ONKAR and not "dakhni onkar" as normally used."
You argue that there is no "Kirtan" before "Sohela" in SGGSji. But then if you go to "Dakhni Ongkar", the heading is clearly "Ramkali M:1 Dakhni Ongkar". Then why shouldn't we call it Dakhni Ongkar since the heading is "Dakhni Ongkar"?
Bhul Chuk Muaaf
[%sig%]
Re: "keertan" sohila
Premabhagti · 10 Jan 2007
I totally agree with "dust" ji. It is the message of the bani that we are after, the title can be anything. I feel stupid having contributed to this argument. My apologies.
Bhul Chuk Muaaf
[%sig%]