Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Respect During Kirtan

Respect During Kirtan

London Singh UK · 06 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I would like to express an important concern to people who while sitting near the kirtani, completely DISRESPECT our beloved GuruGranthSahibJi by turning and FACING the kirtani, exposing their 'Pitth' (Back) to GuruMaharaj. I was at a kirtan yesterday in Hounslow and saw this happening. The elders cannot even correct them. Its a sad and sorry state. Majority of these people are youth. I don't care what anybody says but if this doesn't stop then I will be forced to go up to them and tell them to correct their posture whether a 'big kirtani' is sitting next to them or not!!!!!! I hope everyone who reads this post thinks twice when sitting on the 'stage' or sitting near kirtani when they're performing to GIVE RESPECT TO GURUMAHARAJ ALWAYS. It's utterly rude to show your back towards GuruJi. The kirtani are not above Gurumaharaj. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh [%sig%]

Re: Respect During Kirtan

Masard GanDaa Singh · 06 Aug 2004

I have myself thought of this when I have attended AKJ programs. It seems to be common sense if you ask me. And that shows in there actions as above.You can pretty much pick out the pakhandi's!!

Re: Respect During Kirtan

M Singh · 06 Aug 2004

Exposing back is the totally wrong posture, rather they should try to face Sri Guru Sahib.

Re: Respect During Kirtan

foolio · 06 Aug 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh London Singh UK Ji, many of these youth have not even partaken khandai-de-pahul so why should they know about true gurmat values if they are not encouraged to do so! Its a shame that these days, there's fighting over different 'jathabandi's', and even petty competitions have been taken place to see 'who can bring in the best kirtani' or 'who can sit the most closest to the kirtani'. Sikhi isn't partime 'dakhaavaa' during kirtan progammes etc etc. if you think it is then you're fooling yourselves. You hafta EARN sikhi, build on your kamayi,be truthful in your ways. When you depart from this janam, no-ones going to ask you how popular you were. I wish there was more emphasis in Rehat in the Jatha. If the present youth show so much disrespect now then waheguru help the future generations. Guru Ji is our KING. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh [%sig%]

Re: Respect During Kirtan

Justin Singh · 06 Aug 2004

WJKK WJKF! Another important note is that I see the Singhs/Bibi's sitting altogether goda touching goda. In some circumstances flirting even. I believe that there should be a seperation even if kirtan is done on the floor. I'm sure this is in line with puratan times. You only have to look at the pictures and see that. WJKK WJKF!

Re: Respect During Kirtan

Rashpal Singh · 06 Aug 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh Yes, I have noticed this alot during any Keertan programmes, the youth try and face towards the Keertanee and take no notice of Guru Sahib. No matter how big the Keertanee is, we are all nothing in front of Guru Ji. The Gurmukhs are awake, contemplating spiritual wisdom and the Glory of God. sae jan jaagae jin naam piaar ||1|| Those humble beings who love the Naam, are awake and aware. ||1|| sehajae jaagai savai n koe || One who is awake to this intuitive wisdom does not fall asleep. poorae gur thae boojhai jan koe ||1|| rehaao || How rare are those humble beings who understand this through the Perfect Guru. ||1||Pause||

Re: Respect During Kirtan

yankee · 06 Aug 2004

and i have seen these people walking around in commando gear when they go play football no keski no dastar a cloth (patka) tied on their head and during samagams they wear kurtey pyjamas and siri saab on top and sit on the stage using their eyes to scan i dont know WHAT who are these people trying to fool??????? they only fool themselves....sikhi is not part time if any part timer sees these please either be full time or leave sikhi

Re: Respect During Kirtan

anon · 06 Aug 2004

i agree with the above but would just like to add: when one walks out of the darbar is it wrong to turn your back then?? i see some people walking backwards as not to put their back to Guru ji.

Re: Respect During Kirtan

yankee · 06 Aug 2004

when did this mixed sitting of bibian and sing start...its really bad... they just sit as if 2 singhs or 2 bibis sit....even grown ups with kids and they are not husband wife....what is the opinion of snagat on that

Re: Respect During Kirtan

Mkhalsa · 06 Aug 2004

London Singh, this is a Major problem with having keertan on stages. When it is on the floor it is much more respectful. >>>Sikhi isn't partime 'dakhaavaa' during kirtan progammes etc etc. if you think it is then you're fooling yourselves. You hafta EARN sikhi, build on your kamayi,be truthful in your ways.<<< I entirely Agree! When I learned this, I actually began to learn what Sikhi is really about. Unfortunately, a lot of our AKJ youth think this is what Sikhi and the Jatha are all about. Its not. If thats what you think, look deeper and it will change your life. >>>when did this mixed sitting of bibian and sing start...its really bad... they just sit as if 2 singhs or 2 bibis sit....even grown ups with kids and they are not husband wife....what is the opinion of snagat on that<<< As far as I know, this is how it has always been. I have never seen a problem with it. Here we do keertan as if we are a family. All Guru Jee's children. We all sit together doing keertan every week. Sometimes I cant help but look around at everyone in our jatha and smile. Its so awesome. When brothers and sisters are sitting together enjoying celestial bliss, what business of ours is it what they are doing? The game of love is a strange one.

Re: Respect During Kirtan

SKhalsa · 06 Aug 2004

MKhalsa, you are wrong, it has not ALWAYS been the case. In puraatan times, the Singhs and Bibian used to sit seperately. When a Singh does kirtan, the Singhs sit next to the Kirtani (or sometimes the wife of the kirtani? and when the bibian do kirtan, all the other bibian used to come up for back up. If the tabalchee was a Singh, then the singhs sit at a distance behind the Tabalchee. When the jatha used to travel around India for smagams in different cities (even husbands and wives) used to be seperate in Singhs and Bibi's camps respectively. You could actually see the distance between males and females. When Gurbani says that panj choar are inside us and we have to fight them, does it not help if distance can help us even if 0.001% although you may say it's the minds game to protect one from these panj choar. But, the first choar kaam happens through sparsh and sugandh...wouldnt the distance play a role there?

Re: Respect During Kirtan

Harpinder Singh · 06 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh, Dear anon, you should try your best not to turn your back when you walk out, but sometimes you hafta be careful, as you don't want to bump into anyone while walking backwards! It cannot be compared to sitting next to the kirtani or etc and facing the kirtani, disprespecting GuruJi. Your mind should be on GuruJi, not on the kirtani. The kirtani is just projecting Gurbani, but your thyaan should be on the Gurbani only. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Respect During Kirtan

* · 06 Aug 2004

I personally don't think it's such a good idea for singhs and bibiaan to be sitting goda to goda. We can all sit together to do keertan, yeah, but there's no need for anyone to be in physical contact with the opposite sex. Mkhalsa jee, we can still sit closely enough as a "family" without touching one another. The problem is that a lot of youth, ie. those who don't know Sikhi is more than just dekhaavaa, may not know that they're all one family and the bibiaan beside them are their sisters, so sitting goda to goda may not be such a bright idea.

Re: Respect During Kirtan

Mkhalsa · 06 Aug 2004

I agree. I have seen this problem elsewhere. I have also seen other jathas where the stage is split right down the middle singhnees on one side singhs on the other. But htere was like a hatred there that I just didnt understand. One time I innocently sat in the only free space in the middle and I was grabbed immediately by an older singh who physically removed me from teh stage. I dont know. This is an interesting issue. Whatever older gursikhs say, I will accept. But I know we have never had problems with this in our local Jatha and I hope to god we never do.

Re: Respect During Kirtan

maya men · 06 Aug 2004

The keertanis turns their back to the guru by doing KEERTAN FOR MONEY. That is an EVIL CRIME. One guy I came across had RATES set on his keertan. For an average keertan it was a low rate, for a good keertan it was a high rate, for a very good keertan it was a very high rate. THis person did KATHA at dasmesh darbar last week. The keertanis that do KEERTAN FOR MONEY are only ENTHUSIASTIC about the keertan when there is a lot of SANGAT, that has MONEY to offer. When there is little sangat, they have no enthusiasm. The only enthusiasm is for showing off. These kinds of keertanis only do keertan TO the sangat and not FOR the guru. The guru is watching EVERYTHING.

Re: Respect During Kirtan

.... · 06 Aug 2004

"THis person did KATHA at dasmesh darbar last week." name???

Re: Respect During Kirtan

g · 06 Aug 2004

Vaheguru is everywhere doesnt matter which way you face

Re: Respect During Kirtan

g · 07 Aug 2004

isnt there a story of Guru ji goin to mecca and pointing his feet at it... and then they would come and turn him around and mecca would still be at his feet... and he said something like God is everywhere so it doesnt matter where my feet face...

Re: Respect During Kirtan

London Singh UK · 07 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh 'g' would you feel it's appropriate to sit with your back to GuruMaharaajJi in the Gurdwara?. I think not. Yes i agree that Waheguru is everywhere, but if you've got the darshan of GuruMaharaaj's saroop, would you sit with your back towards GuruJi? There are certain ways we should conduct ourselves while in the Gurdwara, and having your back towards GuruJi is certainly NOT correct. And especially when you give preference to the kirtani. What i saw at the kirtan was disgraceful and I feel as a jatha, we should emphasise to these Youth who think that having the best kirtani around etc etc does NOT automatically give you preference of popularity. It's about time, the elders got more strict on Gurmat Values esp if you are using the name of a jatha. More time should be spent on ENCOURAGING gurmat values and not just making competition against other jathabandi's. I'm sure many people agree with this. There is NOWAY any form of 'beabdi' should be tolerated. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Respect During Kirtan

LostPrincess · 08 Aug 2004

yes i have noticed this millions of times...raagis would do wonderful keertan with great enthusiasm when there is so much sangat...usually for teh money i guess...or just to get the praise of more people... it's strange isnt it...that Gurbani can be used for such evil desires. It's really a shame...Gurbani should be done from the heart whether there are 2 people sitting in front of Guru Granth Sahib jee, or whether there are 45 people....what does it matter to show off ur keertan, you may be feel the praise coming from others about doing such good keertan, but if there is no pyaar or ras inside u when ur singing those gurbani lines,then what use is it? the sangat is NOT at the Gurudwara Sahib to praise you singing gurbani, but to praise Guru Sahib through this gurbani. I have actually come across an incident when my keertan teacher told me i would get to do keertan on stage that night, but when the time came he did keertan and didnt even call me to do keertan. Instead he did keertan. Thats really good , keertan is keertan whether i do it or a realy good raagi does it, but it really annoyed me when afterwards he said he didnt let me do keertan because there was a lot of sangat tonight so youngsters shouldnt do keertan. I just accepted what he said and said "its ok, no worries" but it realy hurt me to see this. keertan is keertan and should be done by anyONE, regardless of age, they get practice at it too, and doesnt matter how much sangat there is...its the ras and pyaar for Guru Sahib only. bhul chuk khima...Waheguru jee ka khalsa Waheguru jee ki fateh!

Re: Respect During Kirtan

Admin · 09 Aug 2004

Beautiful thoughts by "Lost Princess". Kirtan is done by Sangat for Guru Sahib and not for Sangat. Sangat is the performer not the audience. We agree with your thoughts Bhain jee. However, we are receiving posts that are making personal attacks and we have decided to end this thread right here. The purpose of this forum is to discuss Gursikhi in a healthy Gursikhi environment. Please refrain from making personal attacks. Admin.

Re: Respect During Kirtan

London Singh UK · 11 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!! The ones that are making personal attacks are probably the guilty ones and i believe that Admin should NOT approve their posts. However, I think that this issue in Gurmat should be addressed and it's important. There are so many smagams around the world, and if they use the name of the jatha then they should know how to behave. Yes, Singhs and Kaurs' SHOULD not be sitting together in kirtan. There should be some kinda seperation. No, NOBODY should ever sit with their back turning towards GuruSahib, and certainly NOT turned towards the kirtani. Broadcasting and microphone setters: THIS APPLIES TO YOU.....watch your every step, always going up to adjust the mic's interrupts the concentration of sangat....have some respect. What do you think they used to do in puraatan times?...if you're going to record/broadcast/take pictures, do NOT interrupt the sangat in anyway. I know this thread is closed, but we should NOT shy away from gurmat values. We call ourselves a jatha, put on a front during smagams etc, but forget the main value of sikhi. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!!!!!!!

Re: Respect During Kirtan

g · 11 Aug 2004

I dont believe what I wrote had any personal attacks... all it said was that we as a sikh community put on a show for each other and not Guru ji... but as for London UK singh... hes got alot of personal attacks in his post... so yeh I think the admin is a bit biest

Re: Respect During Kirtan

London Singh UK · 12 Aug 2004

g, sikhi isn't easy, remember that.......and i'm sorry that you think that the admins are a bit biased, but at the end of the day, i'm gonna stand up for whats right in gurmat........pleasing GuruSahibJi is more important than sitting there and allowing beabdi.......theres so such thing as being a part-time sikh.....ALL your actions are being accounted for....and if anybody reads my post, and the next time they go to the gurdwara sahib they think twice about how they sit/act/give respect to guruji, then it'll only benefit them if gaining more thyaan in gurusahib. I have nothing more to say......... Apart from just follow Gurmat in the best possible way ever..........

Re: Respect During Kirtan

g · 12 Aug 2004

my only question is... is how can you go to keertan and concentrate on keertan/bani when your worried about what everyone else is doing?

Re: Respect During Kirtan

'G' · 12 Aug 2004

the answer to 'g' is :how can you go to a keetan representing the jatha, when everything done is anti-jatha?.

Re: Respect During Kirtan

g · 12 Aug 2004

why not just go to keertan for keertan and keertan alone? why bring politics into it

Re: Respect During Kirtan

Admin · 12 Aug 2004

Unless someone has something new to add, this thred is closed.