Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

Kulbir Singh · 17 Aug 2004

Excellent stand by World Sikh Council. Daas, Kulbir Singh World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation Tribune News Service Chandigarh, August 16 The World Sikh Council — American region — invited to White House on August 18 to commemorate the 400th anniversary of the installation of Guru Granth Sahib has declined to attend the ceremonies over the issue of wearing of ''kirpan'' by the participants. The secretary-general, Dr Tarunjit Singh, in a fax message to The Tribune today has said that the council ''appreciates'' the sentiments of the White House executive branch to recognise such a historic event in the Sikh faith but would rather not attend the function as it involved ''compromising'' the principles of the very faith that the Sikhs professed. The message states that in a conversation over the telephone, a White House staffer had said that due to ''security risk'' no Sikh wearing the ''kirpan'' would be allowed entry and he has to remove the same. The council, on its part, explained to the staffer the significance of the ''kirpan'' and that asking a Sikh to remove it was not only ''offensive'' but was to deny him ''legitimate right'' to practice his faith. ''Kirpan'' is one of the five symbols, articles of faith, required to be worn by all formally ''initiated Sikhs''. The fax message also said that the White House staffer was duly concerned and explained that Dr Rajwant Singh, as organiser of the event, would be calling the invited guests—the Sikhs—that they wear a ''medallion'' with a small ''kirpan'' image in it instead of their usual ''kirpan''. The council, however, reiterated its objection to the staffer and asked if there was any other option, to which she said it was not possible due to the short time-frame. However, she suggested that the issue be discussed and resolved to avoid such a situation in future. The World Sikh Council is a representative body of 28 gurdwaras and eight Sikh institutions across the nation there.

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 17 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The latest I heard is that the NATIONAL COUNCIL OF CHURCHES has ENDORSED the Strong Stand taken by the WSC and Kuldeep Singh on this Issue. At least someone UNDERSTANDS the significance of the 5 kakaars especially Kirpaan to a SIKH. So called defeatists "sikhs" who are actually PATITS ( calling themsleves sehajdharees ) have been raving and ranting on about the "useless" stand of WSC. Some decried what Simranjit Singh mann attained by refusing to attend Indian parliament over this same issue. Others tried to say if the Chief Minister of Punjab and other top sikhs in India Punjab DONT carry the Kirpaan..... why is the WSC and Kuldeep Singh making such a FUSS. What a load of utter rubbish. Since when does a SIKH look at what "others" do..."Haun bhagtee na chhodon bhavenh log hasseihn..." is GURBANI. We PLEASE only OUR GURU... the PATITS and SEHAJDHAREES are welcome to their own beleifs and can go where they please BUT DONT QUESTION an AMRITDHAREES" committment to His GURU. With the National Council of Churches coming out so strongly on the side of the WSC and Kuldep Singh... I am sure the White House will reconsider its stand and let S. Kuldeep Singh Ji and other Amrtidharee Singhs attend this invite in full Khalsa uniform. OF what use is an invite to some "defeatist sikhs" who are NOT FOLLOWING their GURU's ORDERS. Let the world know that an AMRITDHAREE SINGH is NOT a "fundamentalist", "terrorist", "militant" etc etc BUT just a SIMPLE FOLLOWER of HIS GURU ji's COMMANDS and whatever GURBANI in the Guru Granth sahib jee COMMANDS a SIKH....nothing more and nothing less. Dass jarnail Singh

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

:| · 17 Aug 2004

I heard about this from another organizer who is completely against the idea of kirpan-logo medallions. Apparently, many "Sikhs" are willing and also encouraging others to exchange their kirpans for this silly medallion with a small kirpan design on it. Such absurdity! This compromise is not worth it as down the road, it'll set a precedent that THESE Sikhs took off their kirpans thus ALL Sikhs should be willing to. How can an event commemorating Sikhi require Sikhs to compromise on their beliefs?? These organizers had better look at the consequences of their actions and how it will effect the entire panth.

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

noone2 · 17 Aug 2004

an e-mail from rajwant singh : We are disappointed that Kuldeep Singh has chosen not to accept the invitation of the White House. However in their Press Release of WSC-AR are a few misrepresentations that need to be clarified: 1) It is misleading to imply that "Dr. Rajwant Singh, as organizer of the event, will be calling the invited guests and request that they wear a medallion with a small Kirpaan image in it instead of their usual Kirpaan." No one is being called to wear a medallion. That has not happened, will not happen, and is categorically denied. We would have appreciated if Kuldeep Singh had clarrified this with me or our organization before making press statements. His name as an individual was given by me for his work in the community. 2) It is not true that the White House was not aware of the Kirpan issue. The White House is aware of the Kirpan issue and it was discussed at length with the White House officials. I am calling the guests to inform them regarding this issue and other logistics. I fully understand the sentiments attached to Kirpaan. However, we also strongly believe that all issues can be amicably resolved with proper communication but not by unilateral sensational press releases. We are accepting this invitation to go to the White House in the spirit in which it was given. We greatly appreciate their initiative to celebrate the 400th anniversary of Guru Granth Sahib. It is a joyous occasion for our entire community nationwide. This is a great honor for the Sikhs. The Government of the USA is reaching out to the community with a hand of friendship. We look upon this as an opportunity to increase awareness about the Sikhs and our traditions and to build upon this relationship. Dr. Rajwant Singh National Chairman, Sikh Council on Religion and Education

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

Friendly Neighbourhood Singh · 17 Aug 2004

Excellent News... Good to see people standing by Sikhi principles. It is becoming a rare occurance in our times. My greatest fear is for the future generations who will seemingly have to inherit a "watered down" version of Sikhi if more of us do not take such stands.

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

annoyed · 17 Aug 2004

JARNAIL SINGH JEE PLEASE STOP USING CAPSLOCK AS YOU CAN SEE IT LOOKS LIKE YOU ARE SHOUTING AND THAT IS NOT NICE PLEASE STOP IT IMMEDIATELY RIGHT NOW RIGHT AWAY IT'S A BAD HABIT PLEASE STOP IT thanks :)

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

UkSingh · 17 Aug 2004

This news is very worrying if we as Sikhs start making exeptions by agreeing to take of our siri Sahibs to attend "functions" etc where will it end. once we slack on key principles, then the path becomes more tricky Rajwant Singh needs to clarify whether it has been agreed to remove siri sahibs to enter this function. and if siri sahibs have to be removed then no one should attend don't care if it is the white house, the green house or the pink house we have to keep the Khalsa house strong

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

Lakhvir Singh · 18 Aug 2004

GuruFatehJi. The honour of our Gurus is far more important than the so-called 'honour' of the White House, who despite being the world's top power and include some of the most educated individuals, can even attempt to not try and understand what the Sikh faith is all about. I stand by the decision of the World Sikh Council because they stand for my Guru. Whether the world (including some of our own Sikhs) supports them or not, I believe that the Khalsa will never compromise with a world that is insensitive to the beliefs and principles of a faith that has over the centuries written countless pages of history of valour, sacrifice, love and tolerance - all with the Kirpan across their shoulders. What the WSC has done is refused to allow the world to tell them how Sikhs should be, but rather stuck to the ideals of Guru Khalsa Panth, which is, by far, the highest hukam for a Sikh of the Guru. 'Nichay kar apni jeet karo.' GuruFatehJi. Lakhvir Singh Kenya

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

gaalee rab keeaa · 18 Aug 2004

>>> Jarnail Singh jee said: "Haun bhagtee na chhodon bhavenh log hasseihn..." is GURBANI. Actually no it's not. The shabad is "Thayree bhagat na chhodon bhavenh log hasseihn" bhul chuk maaf and arshi jee please relax on the capitals -- humble benti in your gurmukh pyare's beautiful charan

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Aug 2004

annoyed ji, why are you shouting...and at the top of your voice too ( all capitals all over the place ) avvar updeseh aap na kareh ??? or did someone give you a special licecense to shout...and you are exempted from following your own advice ?? do you think two wrongs can make one right. your shouting "match "message had nothing of substance...except shouting only. my capitals are only placed at strategic places to emphasise..i dont need to shout to make my point clear as i take care to do some research and write sensibily. thank you for your most valuable suggestions. take care and stay in chardikalla....and cool. too much annoyance makes for high blood pressure....you get my drift ?? Bhul Chuk Maaf Ji Dassan Dass jarnail singh

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

Mkhalsa · 18 Aug 2004

>>>>some of the most educated individuals<<<< uhhh... bush is the president right now, in case you didnt hear...............................

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

Singh · 19 Aug 2004

Also, why do people have a problem with Jarnail Singh Arshi using capitals? Let the man express himself in which ever way he wants to. I find that his emails are clearer to read when he uses capitals. Its pretty obvious that hes not yelling.

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

T · 20 Aug 2004

Gurfateh! Jarnail Singh, caps or no caps, you still got the bani tuk wrong - please make sure in future you have it correct, especially since you go on to emphasise that it is Gurbani. Khima de Jaachak.

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 20 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khlasa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. What is this I heard that Jathedar Prof Darshan Singh Raagi khalsa who can be seen in TORONTO gurdwaras every weekend carrying a FULL THREE FOOT SRI SAHIB JI ( to show that he is jathedar Akal Takhat/ Sikh kaum)... also attended this invite WITHOUT this SRI SAHIB/KIRPAN. Are we becoming more and more HYPOCRITES or what ? I have first hand reports from Canada that Professor Ji preaches every weekend that SIKHS should not compromise their principles...he has a Guru Nanak Academy there to do parchaar..... but are these principles only for preaching ??? or what ?? can someone confirm that he left his sri sahib outside the White House ??The pictures that are published sure show this...but i may be wrong. Further reports tell about how the people who attended "got themselves invited"..like they say Saddi an bulaii maein lareh dee taiyee... was how the 90 odd persons ended up on the lawn of the White House WAVING at Bush leaving in his helicopter for Minnesota !!! Dass jarnail Singh

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

manjit kaur · 21 Aug 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. In all the pictures posted on web sites the "sikhs" shown are NOT WEARING KIRPAANS/GATRAS...but some medallions around their necks. What can we say/? The Jathedar Akal takhat on a visit to malaysia also gave his sri sahib to a muslim security guard just to visit a tower in Kuala Lumpur.... he showed no hesitation in handing over the shastar/sri sahib/kirpaan to a muslim guard....but otherwise these same people will preach: DONT touch a SHASTAAR with your bare hands...wash them first..SUCH chaeheyaeh..you know sri sahib is BHAGAUTEE, Guru GobindSingh worshipped this bhagautee, sword..blah blah blah..." ALL DOUBLE STANDARDS ... and HYPOCRYSEE... manjit kaur

Prof Darshan Singh ji

member · 11 Sep 2004

Prof Darshan Singh ji attended this function, Yes he did not carry his Sri Sahib. Yes , he carries Sri Sahib in functions where he can carry it as a respect for an institution he held 14 years back . Veerji , he is the only Sikh who respectfully quit that position twice, when he could not convince miltants to carry the fight logically and second time when SGPC leaders fought in presence of Guru Granth Sahib at annual elections throwing each others turban off. Has any other leader worth of anme shown this sacrifice. About not carrying full keerpan to some functions has to be seen in other context. HE did not go there for any personnel needs, went there on invitaion of Sikh organisations. We sikhs working in corporate America with our turbans feel that there is more need to educate American people about our religion, we have to get permission to practise our religion it is very neccessary that we open dialouge with Media and press. Prof Darshan Singh ji has spend last 40 years of his life doing parchar through out the world. If he start making fuss about carrying keerpan into aeroplane or into assembly halls like Maan would he be able to do that. Which airline will care for him. There are so many sikhs around the world who die to get his programmes. Please read Sikh Rehat maryada carefully, there is no mention on the length of sword. Also look at the defination of patit Or kurahits cutting Kesh is one but if you have other kakars removed due to some reasons beyond your control, it is not kurrat. Panth made that decision because four kakars are outside symbols which can be removed during surgery, illness or or other situations beyond your control but Kesh is your body part. Even if you try to talk to any American it is lot easier to convince him about keeping Kesh because it is body part then convincing about 3 feet keerpan. That does not mean that we should remove all other four Kakars, Best efforts should be made to remain in Kakars. Also boycott by one group was not made on any prinicples but of jeaulsoy for other group. It is shame that we indulge in groupism and then give it colour of panthic values for justifications

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

khalistani · 11 Sep 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! he cud have dont parchaar anytime too take ure kirpan off for that is just stupid ure kirpan is ure ang it aint some toy u can take off anytime u want wud u cut off ure finger or head as easily?? bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: World Sikh Council says no to White House invitation

uk singh · 12 Sep 2004

I don't agree with taking of a Kirpan in order to bow down to White House Security - esp since an option was open. Although, some do remove Kirpans when training in sports such as Kung Fu, Boxing and Shashtar Vidya to prevent injuries to themselves..