Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What if, in 1984.....? (Blue Star Scenarios)

What if, in 1984.....? (Blue Star Scenarios)

Singh · 17 Aug 2004

We were talking with a Singh and he mentioned that one of the most neglected pieces in the 1984 Attack is the role of Gen. Shabegh Singh. Gen Shabegh Singh masterminded the entire defence of Darbaar Sahib and was an expert in gurreila warfare. He knew that the Singhs would be fighting a retreating battle and he designed the defences so that the Singhs could fall back and leave traps and problems for the advancing soldiers. He was the one who taught the gurreilas in Bangladesh and he was essentially the one who won that country. He knew where to hit and how to hit and how to organize resistance. For example, if you see parachutist commando dropping from planes, what do you do? I know I'd shoot at the commando. Gen. Shabegh Singh taught the Singhs to shoot at the parachute and make the soldiers fall. On the ground they would be injured if not dead and could be shot much easier. He personally went to the front lines and ran from defence to defence. He was shot many times when running like this and he attained shaheedee due to multiple gunshot wounds. He was still clutching his walkie talkie. He would tell Singhs to move back and give up a position. He would also look at the approaching soldiers and see what type they were from the pins on their shoulders and tell the Singhs about their armour. For example the commandos that first raided Darbar Sahib, they were covered in armor but Gen. Shabegh Singh knew their legs were uncovered, so he ordered Singhs to go below the waist. When all the commandos fell, it was up to the next wave to clear them out and this of course killed thier confidence. Now for the "what if...?" We always go on about what if Sant Jarnail Singh lead the movement. I say, it would have been amazing if Gen Shabegh Singh escaped and lead the post-1984 movement. I think we might even have had Khalistan by now. He would have trained the fighters to go for key targets and not waste time on small revenge kilings etc. He would have been an amazing commander and everyone would've obeyed him. I think that if Gen Shabegh Singh had gotten out, we would have a very different picture today.

Re: What if, in 1984.....? (Blue Star Scenario)

^^^ · 17 Aug 2004

One of the big reasons Pakistan helped the movement was that they didnt' think it was possible to fight in the plains of Punjab. They had faced defeat in their attacks and were shocked that 50 Singhs could hold off the Indian army for 4/5 days. But yeah, Gen. ji would've made an excellent leader for the movement.

Re: What if, in 1984.....? (Blue Star Scenario)

another · 17 Aug 2004

WHAT IF... What If There Was No Operation Bluestar? Would Indira Gandhi not have been assassinated? Obviously there would have been no pogrom in 1984, but would India be very different today? MARK TULLY The most obvious assumption to make is that if the army had not mounted Operation Bluestar, Indira Gandhi would not have been assassinated by her Sikh bodyguards. But I’m not sure we can go on from that to assume that there would not have been other attempts on her life by Sikhs. So much would have depended on what she would have done to regain control of the Golden Temple from Bhindranwale if she hadn’t ordered the army action. I just don’t buy the theory that she didn’t give that order. The Indian army is far too disciplined to have undertaken such a major operation without clear orders from the highest authority. Indira Gandhi could have delayed action against Bhindranwale but she realised voters were beginning to think she lacked the will to act. What I do believe is that neither she nor indeed any of her generals thought the operation would cause such devastation. Nevertheless she knew the risks involved in any military operation in the Golden Temple, she realised the outrage there would be in the Sikh community, and so the fact that she ordered Bluestar suggests that she felt she had no alternative. But as we are in the business of suppositions, of hypothetical questions, let’s suppose Indira Gandhi had baulked at Bluestar, what then? Indira Gandhi could have delayed taking action against Bhindranwale yet again but she realised voters were beginning to believe she lacked the will to act. In her broadcast to the nation before the operation started, the prime minister said, "an impression has been assiduously created that Punjab is not being dealt with", and that was not an impression she wanted to give with a general election on the horizon. If she had still delayed, it would probably have meant having to take even more drastic action later. I suppose it was just possible that the Akali leaders might have listened to the appeal Indira Gandhi made in that broadcast and called off their morcha. But they would not have been able to pull her chestnuts out of the fire because they had lost all influence over Bhindranwale. Supposing Indira Gandhi had listened to those advisors who recommended laying siege to the Golden Temple to starve Bhindranwale and his men, would she then have avoided arousing the wrath of the more militant members of the Sikh community and putting her life in danger? Almost certainly not. In the supercharged atmosphere created by the Akali morcha, Sikhs would probably have marched on Amritsar, with consequences even graver than the snap military operation Indira Gandhi believed she was being offered. That was certainly the view of the intelligence services and that was why the army was told that Bluestar must be short and sharp. So even if there had been no Operation Bluestar, it’s difficult to see how Indira Gandhi could have avoided putting her life at risk. But putting her life at risk didn’t necessarily mean she would have been killed. If she had not ignored the advice to remove all Sikhs from her bodyguards or if her assassins’ plot had been foiled, Indira Gandhi would not have died on October 31, 1984. India’s immediate history would then have been very different. The massacre of Sikhs that followed her assassination would not have occurred. But what about the longer term? What about India now, would it be very different? I am not so sure. At the time many prophesied that Bluestar and those massacres would achieve Bhindranwale’s ambition of driving a permanent wedge between Sikhs and Hindus. They have not. There were plenty of Cassandras who prophesied that after Indira no one else would be able to hold India together. They too have proved false prophets. Many in the Congress party would like to think that they would still be the undisputed rulers of India if Indira Gandhi had not died. I don’t believe that to be true. The decline of the Congress party is Indira’s legacy. Her Emergency reminded voters how precious their rights were, and so they were no longer prepared to accept the inevitability of any party coming to power. At the same time, Indira Gandhi’s strategy of forming caste alliances had created the very politics which was to undermine it in its own northern bastions of Uttar Pradesh and Bihar. One Jagjivan Ram was not enough to convince Dalits that the Congress was their party, and anyhow Indira lost him after the Emergency. Her second term in office was dominated by the third factor which has undermined her party’s monopoly of power—regionalism. Indira’s belief that more not less centralisation was the answer to regionalism created disasters in Punjab and Kashmir, and the collapse of her party’s southern fortress, Andhra Pradesh. Instead of curbing regionalism, she set India on the path of general elections in which state rather than national issues matter and coalition governments are the outcome. I used to think that 1984 was the most momentous year of my long stay in India. Now I wonder whether India would be a very different place if Bluestar, the mutinies by Sikh soldiers, Indira Gandhi’s assassination, the Sikh massacres, the installation of a prime minister who had never held any ministerial office, and the Bhopal gas disaster had not taken place. Looking back on that year, my image of India is reinforced. I have always seen her as a mighty ocean liner. She is sometimes tossed about by winds, and rolls and pitches in seas which would sink a smaller, less stable vessel, but she weathers the storm, and sails on. If all those storms the liner sailed through in one short year have had no lasting impact on her, I am tempted to say that the answer to that question ‘what would have happened in India if?’ will always be a dull ‘what did happen anyhow’. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- (Sir Mark Tully, the legendary BBC correspondent, is the co-author with Satish Jacob of Amritsar: Mrs Gandhi’s Last Battle.)

Re: What if, in 1984.....? (Blue Star Scenarios)

singh · 17 Aug 2004

for your knowledge indira gandhi 's army built the replica of golden temple and conducted exercise or drill read the comments of retired gen sinha

Re: What if, in 1984.....? (Blue Star Scenarios)

huh · 18 Aug 2004

Tully is biased. Most people know that. There's no point in saying what if because it wasn't in Hukam to have Khalistan at this time anyways

Re: What if, in 1984.....? (Blue Star Scenarios)

Singh · 19 Aug 2004

Now is only the eye of the storm.

Re: What if, in 1984.....? (Blue Star Scenarios)

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 20 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The advisors that put indira to such mischief ares till alive and kicking today... these are the KAUMNASHAT like Harkrishen singh surjeet and company who bow 15 times daily towards moscow. Thsese ******** are still the "kingmakers" behid the manmohan govt...and you can see that hs surjeet sits on the Guru Granth sahib 400th Parkash Divas Committee even though he doesnt beleive in Akal Purakh/gurmatt/gurus/sikhi..it is like having a convicted murderer/thief/rapist/serial killer chair the committee to commemorate Law and Order Day or Police Day !! such is India. Since the early 1940's and after wards with full connivance of Nehry gandhi these kaumnashats started to infiltrate the Sikhs..these kaumnashat writers and academics professors etc took over posh jobs in our Universities,colleges, and started to pour oil into the roots of sikhism by producing literature and students who were anti gurmatt, they always supported the congress govt in its Anti-PUNJAB policies all the way even more than the Jan sanghis even now they run websites and newspapers in India as well on the world wide web always on the lookout to disgrace gurmatt/sikhi/gurus...in the guise of journalism they write lekhs after lekhs about how the akal takhat is bad, the jathedars are lousy, the sgpc is corrupt etc etc ( no doubt there is truth to these but the main aim of the kaumnashats is not to improve but to destroy through "constructive" looking criticism !!) the entire khalistan moivement was a govt agenda to manipulate sikhs into such a corner that the whole world would applaud when the killing started. the movement was heavily infiltrated by gvt agents and self serving goondas...the few genuine sewaks died fighting a losing battle Isnt it heavily surprising that almost every Govt agent IAS oficers, SDO, CMs newspapers etc have ONLY WORDS of DERISION for Sant Jarnail Singh Bhinderawaleh....BUT the present Damdami taksaal is not at all "bad" or anti india. I have not read a single word against the present DDT. Almost always in world History it is the ORGANISATION that is considered dangerous...not a SINGLE leader. Is it becasue the DDT as it is today is NO MORE DANGEROUS to the GOI...while the Govt media is SILENT about DDT, Sant Jarnail singh continue to be "hunted" down just as vigorously as terrorist, bad man, etc etc etc almost daily in the indian press. maybe this is yet another trick to divide and rule the sikhs.....praise one and decry the other... god knows. The world must understand that Khalistan will come...may be longer may be shorter term..but it will come because there is no way without it. That is my personal beleif and i work towards it my way. dass jarnail singh

Re: What if, in 1984.....? (Blue Star Scenarios)

springster · 21 Aug 2004

i recall reading that khalsa raj will follow on every place Guru Nanak stepped foot from india china to mecca. But we sikhs should be walking ambassaders of our dharm. fruther we should work for our panthic goals and khalistan is one of them.

Re: What if, in 1984.....? (Blue Star Scenarios)

Shabegh Singh Srai · 10 Jul 2005

What if operation Bluestar had never occured. The sikh population would have been massive and we also may be in control of india. Many non-sikhs saw indira gandhi's bodyguards as terrorists but i see them as freedom fighters. It wasnt just the attack on Amritsar but also 37 or 38 other sikh shrines. Others been raped, killed and arrested for no reson at all. The bodyguards helped free khalistan and took a stand for the sikh commuinity. By Shabegh singh Srai 15 years old