Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

aanadh · 17 Aug 2004

In gurbani Dhanna is mentioned - worshipping the stone and attaining God Naam Dayv went to the mandir and it turned around to face him because of his Devotion Meeraa Baee accepted Krishna as her husband and God and eventually became one with the statue of Krishna So why are the former two "accepted" and "parvaan" while the third isn't ? ???????? CONFUSED !!!!!!!!!!!

Re: DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

? · 18 Aug 2004

maybe cause she was a woman and people didn't listen to women back then (not that they do now either, but back then things must have been much more oppressive) the other bhagatji who'se shabad was posted above was also praising God through Krishna, but was saying that Krishna's mother is great - because into her home "the lord" was born.. his writings are accepted though

Re: DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Aug 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki afteh, bhagat dhanna ji and the stone theory.....tall tale. guru arjun sahib jee in his gurbani tells clearly and unequivocally that bhagat dhanna ji realised waheguru through bhagtee jsut as all the other bhagats.....guru ji says wehn dhanna the jatt heard how the famous ravidass and other bhagts of "low castes" not worth a false penny became world famous due to bhagtee....he also got up and decidd to do bhagtee guur ji doesnt mention any stone that dhanna worshipped to get god.in fact many many shabads tell us in no uncertain terms that a stone which is stepped on and nirjeev cannot be a repository for god - the living god. gurbani tells us that those who hope to swim across the ocean with these stone idols will sink. 2. secondly i simply cant understand the fixation with krishna, ramchandar etc when we have our own 10 guru sahibaans... numerous shabads explain clearly that krishna raam chandar etc are just humans beings not akal purakh...the names dont mean anything important....these are part of our historical traditions but then we have our gurus to learn from. once we have graduated from university of guru gobind singh ji we can leave the tales of kindergarten snow white and the seven dwarfs behind us.....why go on agonising about whether the dwarfs existed ?? why were they so small, ugly , this and that...why was snow white so white ? was she real?/ for me guru gobind singh matters more than any krishna meer bai. no offense to anyone intended. 3. what about meera bai ?? are we questioning why her bani is not included in guru granth ji ? that guru arjun sahib jee somehow left it out and why ? i fail to see the relevance of the posting at the beginning of this thread ?? why is meera bai not parvaan accepted ??? why should meera bai be parvaan or accepted ?? or why wasnt she accepted parvaan by guru ji ?? dass Jarnail singh

Re: DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

Dogma · 18 Aug 2004

I agree with Jarnail Singh I believe that Bhagat Dhanna Jee got muktee not from a stone, but from his own bhagtee. Just like Jarnail Singh mentioned Bhagat Dhanna Jee heard of the exploits of Ravidaas, Kabeer, Naam Dayv and decided to do the same as them eih bidhh sun kai jaattaro out(h) bhagathee laagaa || Hearing this, Dhanna the Jaat applied himself to devotional worship milae prathakh gusaaeeaa dhha(n)naa vaddabhaagaa ||4||2|| The Lord of the Universe met him personally; Dhanna was so very blessed (Dhan Dhan Guru Granth Sahib Jee: Ang - 487) I encourage you to read the whole Shabad.... As far as what is accepted or isn't....ACCEPTED BY WHO? If your questioning why the latter was not accepted to be part of Guru Granth Sahib Jee then I think we better end the topic right here because that is the equivalent of questioning Guru Sahib. Our matt is infinitely low compared to our Guru Sahib's. In my humble opinion, I don't think we should be questioning what is accepted by Guru or what isn't. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

aanadh · 18 Aug 2004

well the question is it seems like naam dayv and dhanna both did "moortee poojaa" and so did meeraa baee - so why are the former two people accepted in gurbani and the latter is not ? (her bani was actually literally rejected)

Re: DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

Dogma · 18 Aug 2004

Why wasn't Bulle Shah included? Why wasn't the Buddha's words included? Those two did not do any type of "moortee pooja" and yet their words were not included in Guru Granth Sahib Jee. I don't know veerji, it just seems like a pointless question to me. I am sure there is a reason out there, but I'm not sure I really care. I have enough trouble grasping what is already said in Gurbani. I don't need to be questioning why OTHER people were included in Gurbani.

Re: DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

Singh · 18 Aug 2004

I'm of the belief that Namdev jee and Dhanna jee were Sikhs of Guru Nanak (as shown by G. Gurdit Singh in his work). It is for this reason that they were included. But in the end, who are we to judge who should or should not have been included or judge why someone was or wasn't?

Re: DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

Singh · 19 Aug 2004

The bhagats doing moorti puja is 100% nonsence, as is a result of people not having the basic ability to read and unserstand Gurbani. Shabads which show murti puja as futile are numerouse, and is condemed in sikhi. Guru Ji is not a hypocrit who reveals one formless God and than allows bhagats or people who worhip idols into Adi Granth. Please give true ang refs to back you view and we can cichare these, as it appears you are ignorant of basic gurmat.

Re: DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

singh_is_king · 19 Aug 2004

nam dev was from a lower caste. in the old times, people who did not have high castes were not accepted in mandirs. when bhagat nam dev ji entered the mandir, he was kicked out because his caste was not high. he outside of mandir facing the backwall. he was crying because his low caste and also doing bhagatee. what happened was the mandir turned the otherway where bhagat nam dev was sitting. bhagat nam dev was facing the entrance of the mandir.

Re: DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 20 Aug 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Singh Ji is absolutely right. There is no place for moortee pooja in Gurbani...Guru granth sahib jee records bani from the bhagats...and each bahgat shows that he beleives only in Akal Purakh. Guur Ji wouldnt be self contradictory....EACH single line in Gurbani says exactly the SAME thing...whether the writer is GURU Sahibaan or a Bhagat ji. That is the real beauty of Guru granth sahib Jee... so many diverse authors from all over who AGREE on Akal Purakh as the SOLE Provider, Sustainer SAVIOUR of all. In the beginning the bhagats may have been on a different path.... so what ?? In the beginning even Bahi lehna Ji and Bhai Amardass Ji were also DEVI BHAGATS, going on pilgrimages teeraths etc...BUT eventually they SAW the JYOT LIGHT and became GURU. Similarly the bhaagts also saw the DIVINE JYOT and merged with Akal purakh. That is why I beleive that Guru Ji Arjun sahib jee must have edited out "earlier" writings of some bhagats like Kabir Ji and others that drew wrong conclusions.....ONLY those writings that AGREE with GURMATT were allowed into the Guru granth ji. As such we MUST draw our conclusions only BASED on what Gurbani is written in the Guru garnth Ji because that is the FINAL position of the Bhagats Ji on subjects like Akal Purakh and moortis. If in his Final Position a Bhagat REJECTS Moorti Pooja ( even though he may have followed this earlier) then we MUST follow this logical conclusion...and that is Proof enough as this Final Position is VERIFIED by Bhagat bani in Guru Granth sahib Jee. If you are still doubtful..... then as Singh Ji has pointed out there are hundreds of Shabads in Gurbani written by the Bhagats, and Guru Ji that CONDEMN moortis and moorti pooja s strongly as anybody possibly can. So it is your personal pergrotive to either believe GURBANI or some half baked sakhi from somewhere that contradicts Gurbani. Always use the GURBANI BENCHMARK..... Kaswatti of Gurbani to check and double check anything doubtful. You will never make a mistake. dass jarnail singh.

Re: DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 20 Aug 2004

sorry i left out a line in my previous message. singh is king ji, let alone "olden times" even today mandirs DONT allow low castes. ask the dalits if you dont beleive me. and the sad thing is even some Gurdwaras are also doing the same treatment to dalits... a shame...because GURU JI LOVES..... all irrespective of caste. Do a good deed...find a dalit low caste...and take him to the gurdwara with you and treat him the same as Guru ji would want you to. That is the way to increase our numbers - with LOVE for ALL sarbatt da Bhalla. dass jarnail singh.

Re: DHANNA, NAAM DAYV, MEERAA BAEE - WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?

Tolaram Suthar · 16 Jun 2006

well efforts, it is a good way to preach of hinduism, i like to follow this, sincerely Tolaram Suthar