Why don't we...???
Singh · 28 Aug 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh 1) Why is it that when we read from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, we always say "Rahao"...but when we do Kirtan, we just skip it?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Singh · 28 Aug 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh 1) Why is it that when we read from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, we always say "Rahao"...but when we do Kirtan, we just skip it?Mkhalsa · 28 Aug 2004
Because it is a musical instruction meaning pause.yea · 28 Aug 2004
rahao is there for a pause so in bani we can think about it. rahau is also there for the main line/msg were supposed to be thinking about in kirtan we mostly sing that rahau line as our asthaee..Jarnail singh arshi gyani · 29 Aug 2004
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Also Guru Ji has been very very careful in the preparation of Guru Granth Ji. There are ample instructions as to HOW TO PRONOUNCE...numbers for instance. Mahalla (1) for instance will be written in numbewrs as well as WORDS (PEHLA)...so as not to be pronounced as EK. Same goes for DOOJA, TEEJA etc and we are not to say mahalla do, mahalla tin etc. Secondly at certain places there are other instructions...like it says: Eh Shalok AAd AANt pahna. meaning : read this shalok at the Beginning and END. This is becasue the SAME Shlok is given at beginning and end and some wise guy may argue that since it is the "SAME" shlok why read it TWICE ??? SO Guru Ji isntructs: Read this shlok TWICE. Now when doing Paath we DONT HAVE TO "READ" the INSTRUCTION.... IT is NOT GURBANI.....but a lot of people do. ( these people may also be "reading the Aangs.....like AAng pehla, aang dooja, aang ek hazar ate teeh...etc etc for all i know.....but we really DONT have to do that as well.) There are also many other appendages at the ends of banis put in by guru Arjun sahib jee....like "Total of shaloks = 34"...etc etc. these are also not gurbani and need not be read in a paath. Another thing i noticed is some taksali paathis insist on reading in an extra line in Ramkali Ki Vaar. This line appears Once...and completes a couplet...BUT the Rest of the Couplets are Left "incomplete" and they "look" COMPLETE if this First line is Read..Bt my question is IF Guru Ji wanted us to REad this last line in every couplet...then Guru Ji woyld have written this line repeatedly...or given an instruction to read it at end of every couplet..BUt Guru Ji didnt and we use our own manamtt. Bhul Chuk maaf Dass Jarnail singhAnotherSingh · 30 Aug 2004
Interesting thing about that particular salok ``Eh Shalok AAd AANt pahna```, If we recite at before and after our nitnem, or an akhand paath, or a sehaj paath, we are benefitted extra. This is from Se Kineheya, the jeeban of baba Harnam Singh ji of Rampur-Khela. He received this information straight from Guru Ji himself when he did ardass for answers as to the meaning of that line.simran_sewa_sacrifice · 30 Aug 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!! I am not a kirtanee so I have one question. I have heard some kirtanees (especially when singing Asa Di Vaar) they will say for example "sat kartar...salok mahala pehla". So my questions is why is sat kartar said? Are they just trying to be respectful? What is the actual reason? Thanks in advance, waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!!Jaipreet · 31 Aug 2004
Bhai Balbir Singh, the ex-Hazuri Raggi sings 'Rahau' in his Shabads which are done in Ragg. Is he incorrect in doing this?Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 31 Aug 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. dear simran sewa sacrifice Ji, I am no kirtaniya either BUT that is Pure MANMATT. Others add complete lines of their own kavitas ( kachi bani) to GURBANI, yet others add Waheguru here and there. Why they have to do this...to complete matras they say ?? Matras ?? the reason is they dont sing in the Raag Gurbani is written.....their own self composed "raags" that are basically Bollywood filmi tunes dont measure up..and so they add ++ to make up.... The Sants/derawallahs are even worse...they SING kachi kavita COUPLETS ( two liners) and pass that along as KIRTAN of GURBANI. This is becasue they only know these two liners and "kam saro" with them. Learning and memeorising GURBANI is difficult so they leave that aside and just entertain the crowds with their two liners which they encourage the sangat to sing along.....and people say wah weah what a wonderful experience....the snagat is singing along ( BUT singing along WHAT???? what is the use of that type of singing along.....the sangat can be singing along a Bollywood SONG very enthusiastically ...is that also OK - i see no differnce between a kachi kavita tewo liner and a bollywod song - BOTH are NOT GURBANI which should be sung at KIRTAN. ) Gurbani should be sung as it is.....IT is DHUR KI BANI.....Jaisee maeh aweh and should be sung as it is. NO additions no subtractions. IT is a COMPLETE Product. dass jarnail Singh*anon* · 31 Aug 2004
Jarnail Singh, The keertan that you are slandering is they type of keertan that Guru Gobind Singh told Sant Attar Singh Mastuana to sing. Comparing it to bollywood songs is an insult to the guru.hey · 01 Sep 2004
*anon* have u heard some of these bollywood influenced shabads the tunes are lifted straight from bollywood songs so what u on about?jasvir kaur Thind · 01 Sep 2004
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. anon: Guru Gobind Singh Ji asked sant attar singh to sing: AA giya baabaa vaid Rogian da...... hath jor ke singh bethe ji guraan de charni.....guraan de charni.... and such....??? Are you SERIOUS ?? Then WHY for heaven's sake did GURU JI SPEND over Nine MONTHS sitting at Damdama sahib RE-WRITING the GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE...and to RRAGS and in KAVITA so as to be SUNG as KIRTAN. Please quote any Janamsakhi or authentic Historical RECORD from the Lives of Our GURUS that they used to Sing...AAA Giya Babaa vaid Rogiaan daa...etc . Guru nanak Ji used to do KIRTAN.....anywhere it is stated that He told Mardana....bhai Mardaniah...Chher Rabab.....KACHI KAVITA AYEE EH....and proceed to singh AAA Giya Baba Vaaid Rogian Daa.... GURU JI's WRITTEN RECORD states: Bhai mardania Chher rabab Bani Iyee eh.... jaise me aweh Khasam Ki bani......" BUT then GURU GOBIND SINGH must be "slandered" by putting words in his mouth to say we must sing..AAA Giya Vaid rogian Daa...and NOT GURBANI DHUR KI BANI AYEE JIN SAGLEE CHINT MITAYEE by GURU NANAK. What i absolutely cannot understand is we have the GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE in Black and WHITE written PROOF right before our very EYES to VERIFY what GURU JI wants us to do...GURBANI NIRBAAN KIRTAN should be done says Baba SUNDER JI in GURU GRANTH JI...BUT we choose to beleive in some "XXX XXX XXXX XXXX" about someone being TOLD by GURU GOBIND SINGH JI ( no less because GURU JI HIMSELF has to do this JOB !!) that we MUST IGNORE GURBANI/RAAGS/ etc and SING "KACHI KAVITA" meaningless tunes !!! and pass that off as GURBANI KIRTAN ??? senseless. SIKHS can SLANDER our GURU JI's...but when we point out the truth about these sants.....it is called slandering?? what poetic justice ? GURU JI spends over 250 years BRINGING US GURBANI from SACH KHAND.....and then "comes back from Sach khand to tell a human being that we should all sing AAA Giya Baba Vaid Rogiaan Daa...and forget about Kirtan of Nirbaan bani. And this is NOT SLANDER of Guru Ji.?? then what is ?? Let me say that i have nothing against Sant Ji Attar singh. He did a great job of propogating Sikhi. BUT I do take objection to this serious slandering of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI that Guru Ji went around "encouraging" kachi bani couplets...going under the name of Kirtan. jasvir Kaur*anon* · 01 Sep 2004
Dharna keertan is needed so that everyone can understand gurbani. The main objective is to join people with Guru Granth Sahib. There is nothing wrong with joining people with Guru Granth Sahib. If there was something wrong with it, then why would such great gursikhs like Sant Isher Singh, Sant Attar Singh use dharnas for parchar? I do not know what you are thinking, but Guru Gobind Singh compiled gurbani and gurbani is our guru. There is nothing wrong with using gurbani to sing dharnas. Guru Gobind Singh told Sant Attar Singh to use dharnas for gurbani parchar. har jan ootham ootham baanee mukh bolehi paroupakaarae || The humble servants of the Lord are exalted, and exalted is their speech. With their mouths, they speak for the benefit of others. jo jan sunai saradhhaa bhagath saethee kar kirapaa har nisathaarae ||1|| Those who listen to them with faith and devotion, are blessed by the Lord; showering His Mercy, He saves them. ||1|| raam mo ko har jan mael piaarae || Lord, please, let me meet the beloved servants of the Lord.Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 01 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. Guru Ji WROTE "GURBANI" and Nothing lese but GURBANI. There are SPECIFIED RAAGS, Chhands, Chaupaiis, chants, ashtpadis, do padeh caupadeh, VAARS set to DHUNS ...... There is NO MENTION anywhere that KACHI BANI-DHARNA should be sung as "KIRTAN" . Is there any evidence whatsoever that GURU NANAK SAHIB JEE or any other GURU SAHIBAANS sang "DHAARNA" and NOT GURBANI. Was the Gurbani kirtan at Guru Ji's DARBAR just "Dharnas" or GURBANI set to its Raags ?? Why does Baba Sunder Ji in his Ramkali Sadd Bani say that Guru Amardass Ji specifically instructed His Sikhs to " DO NIRBAAN GURBANI KIRTAN ONLY. Weighed against all this Heavy weight evidence that GURBANI is the ONLY thing that is worthy of KIRTAN/KATHA in GURU Ji's DARBAR...I find the suggestion that GURU GOBIND SINGH JI would go around telling his sikhs to do OTHERWISE....a ludicrous and ridiculous suggestion . GURU GOBIND SINGH JI would NEVER go against the other NINE GURUS. GURBANI is SIMPLE and UNDERSTANDABLE for the Common man....that is WHY GURU JI wrote it that way. So there is no merit whatsoever in the suggestion that GURBANI is "DIFFICULT" and so Dharna kachi kavita has to be sung to enable people to "understand" Gurbani ?? WHY dont spend some time to TEACH the people GURBANI and SING it as it should be done. Give some examples of Dharnas and how these enable people to "understand" gurbani ?? IMHO these dharnaas are an attempt to take people away from gurbani and towards "entertainment" of a simplistic nature where everybody can just join in whenever and wherever knowing fully well it is not Gurbani and so no harm is done if wrongly pronouced or read. The SANTS like it that way as it frees them from really LEARNING kirtan RAAGS or memorising GURBANI.... I have yet to come across a SANT/SADH well trained in GURBANI KIRTAN as per RAAGS or able to Play any stringed instruments. Mostly all of them just know a few tunes on the Waja and use them over and over again. There is nothing wrong with dharnas, kavitas, dhadhi varaan, etc etc BUT these are sung as they are...NOT in place of GURBANI KIRTAN and certainly NOt to REPLACE GURBANI KIRTAN. Dhadhis singh dhadhi varaan.....thats perfectly ok becasue they dont call their varaan GURBANI KIRTAN and neither do they Claim that GURU GOBIND SINGH JI told them to SING Dhadhi varaan ONLY. Dass Jarnail Singh.SIKH · 02 Sep 2004
its people who are blind like *anon* ji who are making the correct practice of following sikhi as set down by our gurus hard for the wider panth we have people blindly making statements and adjustments to gurbani based on there own manmatt but oh of course its is backed up by what maybe a certain sant may have said AND no i m not say anything bad against Isher Ji or Attar Ji this is a general statement one only needs to look at the blind following of ragi jathas, on the whole if you quized the sangat who followed and heard the shabads as sung by these ragis, i bet they would have little knowldegse and understanding of the bani being sung why is this, in my opinion Guru-Ji is not happy and is not doing kirpa on sangat because we are not doing the kirtan as per the orders of Guru-Ji, how on earth can you make stuipd statements that Guru-Ji wants the kirtan now done with bollywood filmi tunes, why did they give so much time compiling the kirtan in various rags? maybe they didnt have much to do at the time?Rashminder Singh Oz · 03 Sep 2004
I agree..................... kachi baaaani is kachi...................... (@) IF BAGAT, SANT, BRAHMGYANI, BLA BLA BLA... CAN SING ANY TUKS WHICH TALKS ABOUT VAHEGURU THE SUPREME GOD AND CALL IT KIRTAN OF GURBANI.................. THEN................................. WHY NOT SING KURAN SHAREEF, GEETA, PURAAN, VED, SHAASTAAR ETC ETC WHICH BELONGS TO OTHER RELIGIONS "BUT" TALKS ABOUT THE SUPREME GOD??????????????????? CAN WE CALL IT GURBAANI KIRTAN?????????????????? CAN WE SING IT IN GURU DARBAAR?????????????????? bHUL cHUK mAAF jI VaHeGuRu............................YAY!! · 03 Sep 2004
Directed at Another Singh.. another singh its "eh salok aad ant parna" and that comes at the end of the salok, the salok starts off from gurdev mata, gurdev pita, gurdev suami parmesara... and baba harnaam singh was great.. he got instructions from Guru Gobind Singh ji that sikhs should read this salok after and before nintem so this way they will get laha.. and guru ji also wants us to hear the bani.. sunia mania man keeta bhao wjkkwjkfJagjit Singh · 03 Sep 2004
waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, no Dharna keertan is needed at all. This is completely false and damaging sikhi. These sants are propogating illiteracy of Gurbani under the guise of being false mahapurshes. The best explainer of Gurbani in Keertan in todays age is Bhai Jasvir Singh ji Khanne wale. He never uses kacche bani. More sangat listen to him, than any sant. The reality is most of these so called sants do not wish to put the effort in learning Gurbani and sikh history properly. They makes endless mistakes in their saakhis and keertan. This is always hidden because so called mahapurshes always know better. Please understand this very carefully.... The very first part of the spiritual journey is realising your path and mentor which is sahib Siri Guru Granth sahib jee. From that point Gurbani becomes the center of your life. So much so that listening to non-gurmat music, such as songs, becomes so hard, beacuse your soul always pines for Gurbani keertan. This is basic level sikhi, which I am sure most young Gursikhs on this forum can relate to. So when Gurbani is so sacred, how can any spiritual sikh ever even consider kacchi bani, especially one who is so-called mahapursh. No mahapursh could ever turn his back on his Guru, the Guru who has illuminated his jeevan, and the light that is all prevading in him. Instead he will just fall and submit all in front of this light. Not turn his back and say my thinking is better because people will understand it more. Today white clothes and kacchi bani is the biggest sign of a showman, profiteer in the name of religion, and general person lacking in knowledge of sikh history and Gurbani. They may wish to compare themselves to Baba Attar singh, but none are even close, and never understood baba ji at all. I personally have alot of time for baba Attar singh, and do not believe stories of him doing kacche bani, as I do not belive 3/4 of the stories told about baba Nand Singh. Ultimately Guru ji cannot be clearer about kachhie bani - Kehde kachhe, Sundai kacchae, kacche Aik vekhane. If sant folloowers still do not understand. Then just ask your sant, if every sant in the Panth, did proper vaikakhia like Bhai jasvir Singh Khanne wale, would not the Panth be a better place. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fatehsatnaam waheguru · 03 Sep 2004
Can you call Dasam Granth kacha? Looking at how gurbani reveals how God resides on the tongue of a true devotee, how can you call what a sant says kacha? Sadh Bachan Atlaadha||non-bhramgyani · 04 Sep 2004
its amazing how many brahmgyanis we got so many to make comments on how right some sant is how wrong some sant is how can u call someone is a sant brahmgyani when Guru ARjan Dev ji says 'Brahmgyani ki gat Bhramgyani jane ? nonbhramgyani..simran_sewa_sacrifice · 04 Sep 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!! ################################################ Looking at how gurbani reveals how God resides on the tongue of a true devotee, how can you call what a sant says kacha? ################################################ That is assuming the person in question IS IN FACT a "sant" in the first place! Its funny how people will say so and so sant said for me to do this and this ect. The instructions are already there (from panj pyare and SGGSJ). How about we try to build our own jeevans and do our own bhagti so that we too may get SatGuru Ji's blessing and know what is right and wrong. kaache bani is kaache bani [%sig%]satnaam waheguru · 04 Sep 2004
kachee bani is not what a sant says. that is your own manmat saying that. gurbani clearly says "Bani Uchrei Sadh Jun" "Bhagata Da Boleiaa Parvaan Hai" We are supposed to avoid kachee bani- which is nindia, chuglee, and all the other junk on tv, radio. Sant Attar Singh Mastuanai Vale did dharna keertan to preach gurbani. That clearly shows that there is nothing wrong with using dharnas to join people with gurbani. Critisizing dharna keertan is critisizing a method that Guru themself created.Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 04 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. NON Brahmgiani Ji has HIT the NAIL right on its HEAD - Square and Centre. ONly a "brahmgianI" CAN "know" another Brahmgiani. Only Guru Arjun Sahib Jee for example could "know" a Sain Mian Meer... Every other SIKH saw a MUSLIM...BUT Guru Ji SAW something else all together and asked Mian Mir to lay the Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib Jee. ANY SUCH EXAMPLE in the SIKH World TODAY ??? Has any Sikh gurdwara naywhere in the WORLD has had its Foundation Stone laid by a MUSLIM, HINDU, CHRISTIAN???whatever ??? There are TOO MANY "brahmgianais" in the Sikh World TODAY...ALL CHIEFS and NO INDIANS..eh ?? And even MORE "brahmgianais" who are even WILLING to BREAK YOUR HEAD if You dare to "question" their Pet "brahmgiani" Ji Maharaj ??? baba Ji, Sant Ji ???? Just quoting SukhmanI sahib Ashtpadi on Sant is not enough for these HOTBLOODS...they want to SMASH your FACE, KNOCK off your DASTAAR in the Gurdwara...and send you to Hospital ??? These are NO BRAHMGIANIS.. they area as KABEER says in Gurbani...Rahio SANT me Toll... THUGGH bhutereh DITHHEY..... I am "looking" for a SANT..BUT I saw MANY many THHUGGS cheaters Frauds.... IF a BRAHMGIANI like Bhagat KABEER whose GURBANI is in our GURU GRANTH JI CANNOT fidn a SANT but can see hundreds of FRAUD SADHS...who are we common "youngsters" able to see so many brahmginais, sants, babajis, maharaj jis ??? IS our "eyesight" that much better than kabeer Ji;s. Jarnail Singh__ · 04 Sep 2004
Where does it say in gurbani you have to be a brahm giani to recognize a brahm giani? Sukhmani Sahib gives a definition of a brahm giani and shines a light on what brahm gian is.manjeet Kaur gyani · 05 Sep 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Gurbani says: Bani uchreh sadh jun...: and a reader supposes that EVERYTHING a "SADH/SANT/BABA JI/MAHAR JI?whatever " Uchehs is GURBANI ?? Wah E Wah by this LOGIC...the "GURBANI" will be a thousand times MORE than the 1430 AAngs we have ...and an ever growing Khazaanh..something akin to a Kauri Weil. IF this is correct then Guru Arjun Sahib jee and Guru Hobind Singh Ji committed a Grave MISTAKE by compiling the Granth Ji and Mundawni Bhog..... they should ahve LEFT it OPEN for the later coming Sant Babas to Uchreh sadh jun types to continue ADDING "gurbani" Ha Ha ha Fat hope. NO veer Ji...gurbani uchreh sadh jun.. is NOT about some SANT/BABA shooting his mouth off with kachi banni..IT is about the SADH-JUN ( SANGAT) Uchreh - SINGING the AASLEE GURBANI in the Guru Granth Sahib Jee. My last name seems to disturb some people...nickname ?/etc etc..?? WHY for heavens sake has anybody's NAME got to do with anything ??? Shallow minds attack people based on "name" Manjeet Kaur