"Sant" Maan Singh Exposed!
:o!! · 09 Sep 2004
[url]http://www.sanjhsavera.com/news.html[/url] The newspaper SanjhSavera of TO has done an article on this "baba" and his exploits. Everyone should take a look!
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
:o!! · 09 Sep 2004
[url]http://www.sanjhsavera.com/news.html[/url] The newspaper SanjhSavera of TO has done an article on this "baba" and his exploits. Everyone should take a look!jagroop singh · 09 Sep 2004
Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh! It is my humble request that soemone translates this article into English for those of us who are unable to read Punjabi. i am not in the business of rubbishing or encouraging nindiya of 'Sants' but if this article is for the public good of the Panth then it should be accessible to all. Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki Fateh!please translate · 09 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji, please somebody translate the article.summary · 09 Sep 2004
A summary of the report is that the Baba's old garvai or personal assistant along with 14-15 other sevadars have left him and are hiding all around Punjab and even outside states, fearing retribution from the Baba for exposing his misdeeds. The Baba has links with major politicians and the police. The garvai, in an emotional voice said that he had spent 18 years with the baba but he now knows he is not a shiromani sant but a shiromani badmaash. A girl had approached the Singhs at the dera to say what had happened to her. She was not able to explain everything but her husbandalso came forward and explained how she had been raped. A 22-23 year old girl from a poor household had been kept at teh Ropar dera as a sex slave whom he abused whenever he visited. Her parents were too poor to do anything. When she began to have heavy bleeding, she was sent to a hospital from where she ran but was then returned by her parents. Even in North America there are women who have been the victims of this baba. He indirectly tries to hint that he is Guru Gobind Singh. He slowly brings women close to him and then all of a sudden begins to grab them. If they protest he claims that it was all a test and she has passed. If she does not react, he satisfies his lust with her. _____________ This is actually the same methodology used by a lot of perverts who use Sikhi to manipulate people and make them victims of sexual abuse. I don't know for certain whether this report is absolutely accurate, but another former chela has also made accussations in the past in the same light. If they are true, he should certainly be made an example of.sikh · 10 Sep 2004
there is so much out about him something is surely wrong maybe its time he was asked properly by some of guru jis real babbar 'gursikhs'!Rashminder Singh Oz · 10 Sep 2004
I have heard a lot about this idiot.................. i never wanted to use such language for any gursikh but he is not worth of calling gursikh, i would call him paakhandi I remember in 2001 australia's samagam few gursikh singnees from uk told us how he did misparchaar against keski's that most of the ladies removed keski's under this paakhandi's instructions. BEWARE BEWARE BEWARE of this cult Pakhandi Baba Maan Singh VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh Vaheguru Vaheguru VaheguruSad Very Sad · 10 Sep 2004
This was really sad news to me.... I started crying, honestly because I guess you can't believe anything anymore... :(Manjeet Kaur gyani · 10 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The trouble with sikhs is that they are so "GULLIBLE" that inspite of such reports....some will still insist thst all this is false propoganda.....and then LIST out names like Sant Baba Gurbachan Singh ji, Isher Singh, Jarnail Singh...and "inform" you to READ the SUKHMANI SAHIB ASHTpadi on SANTS... A famous THUGGH named Sant Amar SinghNanaksar/Burundi wala has even been BANNED from malaysia by the GOVT due to such misdeeds...BUT he VISITS MALAYSIA YEARLY on Private Visas issued by his chelas !!! A sant Gurbachan Singh KAMBLIWALA was forcibly put on an outgoing aircraft by Malasyain Singhs for molestation. ( After Chhittar parade)....but He is still attracting crowds of Chelas in germany england etc and his adverts appear in des predes newspaper... A sant going under name of JATHEDAR Bhai mani Singh Shaheed taksaal sacked for cheating etc.. from a Charity Foundation many years ago .is still going strong on his chelas strength..and visitng vccountries doing katha.... WE SIKHS nEVER learn ??? Manjeet kaur?????????????????????? · 10 Sep 2004
HOw do we know this is real, like people all Ways say thing about people. If we have 100% proof we should do what is needed. How can we do this ?S Singh · 10 Sep 2004
The truth is coming out now. Lets hope is money making tours to the west now finally end. The newspaper also mentions his commercial activities he apparently has 340 acres of farmland.S Singh · 10 Sep 2004
There are two different sources. There have been accusatiosn made in the west and independent accusations by his chela in India. hat have the former chela got to gain by making such accusations ? Absolutly nothing, Mahan Su is friends with politicians and with the police in India so these chela have been very brave to have come out with the truth. We should take action against him by making more people aware of the allegations.sad state of affairs... · 10 Sep 2004
don't like to say that i told you so......... this is true.....i have spoken to two of his victims personally myself. believe me that this exposure is only the beginning.....other actions must be taken also..... i apologise before writing the following, but all sants should be stopped, wether taksal, rara sahib...all of them...how long will the bleeding go on for....? there's atalk show on bassi's radio program today (fri. sept 10th 2004) about him... Yes these people will take advantage of this situation. gurfatehnothing new · 10 Sep 2004
Similar reports about him have come out before. During the late 90`s, there a rape accusation against him in Punjab. Human rights organisations produced a report which was put before the Akal Tahkt. However some southall chelas put pressure on Tohra who was head of SGPC. Tohra made the reports disappear, and families quiet. The Akal Thakt Jathedar never summoned him. He has money. In Punjab, people with money can do anything. Look at Badal.yes · 10 Sep 2004
the pardan of singh sabha southall (havelock rd) is one of his biggest chelas money is powerful but nothing is more pwerful than the might of the sangat maybe now is time to show him this mightyes · 10 Sep 2004
and to clear something up few months ago a post was put on this forum about a particular sant who had committed rape, due to evidence etc. the admin guys didn't let his name come through but it was this dog baba mann singh, i really hope guruji teaches this and other sant wale a good lesson and shows to the wolrd how bad they areS Singh · 10 Sep 2004
Translated story now at following site : [url]http://news.waheguroo.com/?633Q6-17274-69636-P6526-49443-Q3134-3530[/url]? · 10 Sep 2004
This shouldn't be a big shock to people. There were stories about this guy for years. I know for a fact that some of the comittee people in certain gurdvaras in Canada had recieved similar reports about him. However, they didn't do anything about it and kept bringing him over, with the justification that they didn't want to break the spirit of those sikhs who he had inspired to chuk amrit. The reality of course is that he brought in large crowds and the gurdvaras made money. Mahants helping each other out basically. I think most people also heard the stories linking him to the GOI and his links with ex cops who'd killed singhs. It was published in various papers. I could never understand why certain 'panthic' groups continued associating with him and even promoting him.saskar · 10 Sep 2004
where is the hysteria from everybody against this rapist and sexual abuser who is killling our sisters and daughters and dirtying our gurus image we act like lions when some muslims say something yet are quiet against the real enemies of the path how would you feel if one of his victims was ur sister or mother etc? why dont the various jathas get together and sort him outFatso · 10 Sep 2004
Looks like he is giving out a different kinda parshaad!!!!Harbhajan Singh · 10 Sep 2004
Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!! Sangat Jee, I went to see this pervert several times. He was used by Sant-Samaj and other so called panthic bodies to attack AKJ so many times. He would degrade Keski, Sarabloh Rehat and particularlly use vulgar language infront of Guru Jee against Gursikhs who didn't read Raag Mallaa. There were numerous stories about him and young girls and boys, but their was a big coverup by SGPC to protect him. I congratulate the paper in making a brave stance against this pervert and hope he gets punishment here and at the court of Dharam Raj. ? worte 'I could never understand why certain 'panthic' groups continued associating with him and even promoting him.' they probably are not as panthic as you think they are and are out to make money and sheep followers as the rest of santdom is trying to do. Hopefully he will be banned and governments informed all over that he is a Rapist and Pervert so he gets barred from the western countries. unfortunenatly he will probably be left alone in India as he has so many contacts. Harbhajan Singh Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Whaeguru Jee Kee Fateh!!!S Singh · 10 Sep 2004
Wait till the fat bufoon comes to england or any other western country again. He is lucky he left england before these allegations surfaced. No doubt he will be back soon collecting more money to fund his dirty sexual habbits. Next time he is over lets confront him and make the sangat aware of this dirty pervert for what he really is.seeker · 10 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh here is a quote from an above post: ------------ but all sants should be stopped, wether taksal, rara sahib...all of them...how long will the bleeding go on for....? ------------ I see the point that you are trying to make, but please realize, Damdami Taksal cannot be compared to these "Babay." The Jathedars of the Damdami Taksal only preached GURMAT and made people followers of GURU SAHIB. An example comes to mind...I was listening to Katha by Sant Kartar Singh Ji Bhindranwale and he says that he got a letter from another Jatha requesting him to come and attend a Smagum and to bring his "chelay." Sant Ji repeated the word...."CHELAY ???" Sant Ji got quiet then said, when i read that word, i thought to myself, do i have CHELAY??? WAHEGURU. Sant Ji said, i have been blessed with this seva to do Parchar of GURMAT where I try to show Sangat the greatness of GURU SAHIB, hoping they can become GURU WALE. Then Sant Ji said....i have no chelay...i am NO HIGHER than a keera. Sant Ji got very emotional saying "we are all chelay of Dhan SatGuru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj." Then Sant Ji spoke for about 10 mins explaining how ANYBODY who says they have chelay is WRONG and is a paapi. Then Sant Ji explained how it is a big paap to matha tek to anybody other than GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI....we cant even do it accidently. This is the same Sant Kartar Singh Ji who used to finish his Katha by saying "Please do not get up and see me off as my seva is complete, it is disrespectful to the KING, GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI MAHARAJ to stand up for a low human in GURU JI's DARBAR" Waheguru Ji, my point is.....this was a small example of the mentality of Sant Giani Kartar Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale....there is no "BABA PARCHAR" going on in Taksal. I have respect for all Jathebandia and i think we should be careful in the future when speaking of another Jatha. bhul chuk maaf karo Jisingh · 10 Sep 2004
s singh name the time and place i'll be there*anon* · 10 Sep 2004
If someone is going to do something like this they will use all means at their disposal. It is not appropriate to blame all Sants in this instance. At while back there was a bus driver involved deeply with the AKJ, and he inappropriately touched one of the female passengers. Now does that mean all AKJ are perverts. Did anyone even attack the AKJ because of that one man's actions. There have been many incidents like this with granthis as well. Does that mean we have to get rid of all the granthis. When things like this happen you have to go after the individual because regardless of what position they were in, they would have done that action even if they were involved with a different group. The Sikh kaum has been blessed with many great sants who continue to do great seva even if there are those that try to darken their image. The true saints are satisfied by the true naam and are in no need for worldy pleasures as shown by sri gurbani. pourree || Pauree: aapanaa aap pashhaaniaa naam nidhhaan paaeiaa || One who realizes his own self, is blessed with the treasure of the Naam, the Name of the Lord. kirapaa kar kai aapanee gur sabadh milaaeiaa || Granting His Mercy, the Guru merges him in the Word of His Shabad. gur kee baanee niramalee har ras peeaaeiaa || The Word of the Guru's Bani is immaculate and pure; through it, one drinks in the sublime essence of the Lord. har ras jinee chaakhiaa an ras t(h)aak rehaaeiaa || Those who taste the sublime essence of the Lord, forsake other flavors. har ras pee sadhaa thripath bheae fir thrisanaa bhukh gavaaeiaa ||5|| Drinking in the sublime essence of the Lord, they remain satisfied forever; their hunger and thirst are quenched. ||5||Perbinder Kaur · 10 Sep 2004
WJKK WJKF If these accusations are in any way substantiated, then shame on anyone who believes this man to be a Gursikh. He of course is answerable not only to those of this world but also to those of the next. WJKK WJKFYeah · 10 Sep 2004
It is not only a shame, but a scandal what a pakhandisingh1984 · 10 Sep 2004
Great post anon Ji. Dhan Dhan Sant baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaj Dhan Dhan Sant Raj yogi baba Attar Singh Mastaunewaley/Reru Sahib Waley. Dhan Dhan Sant baba Gurbachan Singh JI Bhindranwale Dhan Dhan Sant baba Kartar Singh Ji Bhindranwale Dhan Dhan Sant baba Isher Singh Ji Rara Sahib/Nanaksar Waley Dhan Dhan Sant baba Jarnail Singh Bhindranwaley DHAN DHAN SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI.tigerstyle · 11 Sep 2004
BHANN BHANN BABA MAAN SINGH notice i said "BHANN", meaning thrash...HAHAHAHAHHAYAY!! · 11 Sep 2004
hahaha thats funny tiger anyways DHAN DHAN SANT BABA HARNAAM SINGH JIAnotherSingh · 11 Sep 2004
just so everyone knows.... it's really bad to do nindia of a sant. these allegations have not been substantiated so it would be best for you all not to engage in idle/pointless nindia of him. by the way, i'm not his chela or anything, i just think that a reminder of the extreme danger of nindia is necessary right now. let's try to keep a reign on our emotions for the time being and calmly evaluate the evidence to try to find the truth.lol · 11 Sep 2004
thats a funny post anothersingh though i respect your stance on nindia how can u say we are doing nindia of a sant who called him that? he is a dog i think it is disrespectful to call somebody by their incoorect title so it dog/kutha maan scum of the earth thing he don't deserve the title singh evenns · 11 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Wahegur Ji ke Fateh!! Another Singh you mention " it's really bad to do nindia of a sant", if we were to followyour example, then we are mahan nindaks of this world. Surely when someone is exposed as such then it rightful everyone should know, and making people aware of mal practices of others in no way nindia in my books. Allegations not ben substantiated....takes two to tango my friend.... Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Wahegur Ji ke Fateh!!Jasvir Kaur Thind · 11 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Guru Amardass Ji started the MASAND SYSTEM.....for Parchaar purposes...this carried on until the time of GURU GOBIND SINGH by which time so many EVIL things had crept in and 99.9% of the Masands were CORRUPT EVIL men.....GURU JI "DID NOT" look at the 1% GOOD Masands...and said: DO NOT DO NINDIA of my MASANDS...Please PROVE any allegations you have etc etc... GURU JI got all the corrupted masands together and finished them off and CLOSED DOWN the entire MASAND SYSTEM. This is exactly the State of the SANT SYSTEM in Sikhi today..... the times of the likes of the "GOOD SANTS" are gone...or they are a mere 1% or even 00.01% ONLY...the REST of the 99.99% of SANTS are evil men of ill repute, amassing huge DERAS and have illegal delaings with politicians etc to ROB and ENSLAVE the common GURSIKH. Any "respect" for Guru granth and Panj kakaars gurmatt etc is just a SHAM and Crocodile tears to trick gullible sangat that they are doing parchaar....after all who in his right mind will go see a "sant" who says I will take your money, rape your daughter and wife.... HE has to wear long chola, wear the large kirpan, etc and mutter waheguru, waheguru, perform kirtan of DHAARNAAS ( kachi bani ) and tell people to amrti chhak etc etc....this is all a SHOW...who knows what happens behind the scenes.. If you dont beleive the above I have come across mails and posters of this same Baba mann Singh Bheve waleh and they DESCRIBE GOD ON EARTH !!! No one could be more holy, more atmik, more this and more than this fraud. Thousands of "gursiksh" SWORE by this HOLY baba !!! In fact if you said anything agianst his honour they will break your head and put you in hospital...Sant Ki ninda..... SIKHS dont need such SANTS just as we never needed the MASANDS. The Stark TRUTH is now our GURDWARAS are in the Hands of modern day MASANDS (SGPC/BADAL) and the OUTSIDE we have these MARAUDING BANDS of WOLVES in long cholas and huge kirpans and Huge DERAS...so Gursiklhs get looted outside and inside. I agreee with many Singhs like anon who write strongly in defence of Damdami Taksaal...what they write is 100% TRUE about the Parchaar of Sant Gurbachan Singh,sant Kartar singh, Sant Jarnail Singh Sant Thakur Singh...BUT where the followers of the Taksaal FAIL is when they REFUSE to CONDEMN the "SANTS and SANT SAMAJ' that tried to HIJACK the elections in Punjab and take over the Gurdwaras...they prefer to CLOSE ONE or BOTH Eyes. IF the AKJ and the DT were to DIRECTLY CLOSE ranks on this one subject, we would be on the way to gettign rid of the sants and the sant samaj which is a society of FRAUDS - there is not a single sant among them. As long as the DT singhs close their eyes to the SANTS and Sant sanmaj FRAUDSTERS...then I hold the DT guilty of complicity with these frauds. MAYBE DT needs the support of these fraudsters..... Jasvir Kaur Thindguru da dass · 11 Sep 2004
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh When I saw him at my local Gurdwara I called Fateh and had the darshan of the 'roop' of my Guru. With this respect I then went home. I am not aware of all these allegations till now. All I can say is that everyone is accountable for their actions good and bad. Please Guru peearey, resist the temptation of blaming a whole group of people for the actions of one. If he has done these things he will get the results of it soon enough. Those who were closest to him, having witnessed what they had, and are disillusioned will have learned the futility of devoting so much attention to a human being and hopefully will shift their trust more towards SGGSjee. It is good to respect Gursikhs but never be so close to them as you are to SGGSjee. Human beings are fallible. Gurujee is eternal Truth. :)AnotherSingh · 11 Sep 2004
"making people aware of mal practices of others in no way nindia in my books" Agreed. It is not nindia in my books either. I'm talking about the other disses put up that trash him but have don't contribute any info to the discussion.Respect for \guru ji · 11 Sep 2004
Why do sant chelays always put Guru ji at the bottom of the list. It should be at the top not the bottom. No sant can ever compare to Guru JI! Shame on sant chelays! singh1984 wrote: > Great post anon Ji. > > Dhan Dhan Sant baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaj > Dhan Dhan Sant Raj yogi baba Attar Singh Mastaunewaley/Reru > Sahib Waley. > Dhan Dhan Sant baba Gurbachan Singh JI Bhindranwale > Dhan Dhan Sant baba Kartar Singh Ji Bhindranwale > Dhan Dhan Sant baba Isher Singh Ji Rara Sahib/Nanaksar Waley > Dhan Dhan Sant baba Jarnail Singh Bhindranwaley > > DHAN DHAN SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI.khalistani · 11 Sep 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! how the hell does taksal have anything to do with this??? y was it even brought into the topic?? not one taksal sant has ever been bad all brahm gianis go read the taksal mukhi book this baba is not taksal da mukhi or something if u go to baba thakur singh je, he aint like maan singh so some people need to think twice before talking baba thakur singh je is a prefect example of a sant bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!Lol · 11 Sep 2004
You lot are all mad, especially this Manjeet Kaur, go do as much sewa of parchaar and Sikhi as some of the mahapurush you mentioned then come and slander them.Taz-SikhLionz.com · 12 Sep 2004
Sri Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Sri Waheguru Ji Ki Fatheh jasvir penji please don't take this as an opportunity to have a go at taksal especially when they have nothing to do with any of this- as khalistani paji explained they have an impeccable record. Before anyone kicks off i believe both akj & dt are beautiful people and i love the whole panth and mankind an one love peace i'm not one of mann su's greatest fans but lets leave any judgments until after the panth as a whole properly debates this innocent until proven guilty and all that anyone in the public eye that calls themself sikh will always be scrutinised by their every move. If there is evidence then let it be proven in a court of law or let the panth handle the matter internally otherwise it is hearsay- taking one word over another if he is guilty then i will be the first and foremost to deliver some serious shithur again dont take this as me defending him as i'm not one of his greatest fans or anything but i just think in this day and age... this reminds me of a court case going on where another slightly kooky guy that goes on stage is in court on similar charges... jacko! anyways be careful in your choice of words before accusing him outright due to possible legal action. i would hate it if this issue got suppressed, i dont think it could be... how could he continue with this lingering over his reputation anyways i never been a big fan ! ... lets not mix up our rating of him as a "baba" with this issue. personally i prefer gursikhs that can relate saakhia to the here and now- you know what i mean? the point of listenin to katha or saakhis is you learn practically about how to bring this into YOUR life or issues that affect the panth TODAY personally i prefer mahapursh that are willing to take that extra step and relate it to today fearlessly of consequence few and far between anyways thats my opinion -------------------- Taz_SikhLionz http://www.SIKHLIONZ.com May Waheguru Bless You Eternal Happiness Sri Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Sri Waheguru Ji Ki FathehYAY!! · 12 Sep 2004
haha yeah manjeet kaur i dont know what ur saying BUT ALL THE JATHEDARS FROM TAKSAAL WERE BRAHMGIANIS AND SANTS+1 · 12 Sep 2004
this is all propaganda. daas has personally had some spiritual experiences during diwans of Sant Mann Singh Ji. There would not be shaheed singhs guarding a terrible paapi like the accusations here.uk singh · 12 Sep 2004
Is it right to use the word "Sri" when repeating Waheguru? I read somewhere we should just say Waheguru on it's own when saying Fateh and during naam jap...but cannot recall what evidence they presented.singh-2 · 12 Sep 2004
sangat jeeo this report was published by sanj savera; they exposed grewal baba i believe so have a track record and must be taken seriously. there have been other allegations before regarding mann singh's goi allegiances and security connections. at the same time however, let us all wait and see what happens now. there are many thousands who were inspired to take amrit bacause of mann singh and he served in the panj whilst they took amrit. have some regard for their feelings too. there is no point in just posting abuse next to his name until this issue is resolved.kaur · 12 Sep 2004
this 'baba' stayed @ our house for while and we didn't know anything about him....from the second he stepped into our house we all had a strange feeling about him...it's hard to describe.....but i can tell you the way him and his sevaks talked you would be shocked....they use such dirty language-they never had any meaningful sikhi discusions and they did such weird rituals...it got to a point where none of us even wanted to be in our own house.........i could describe everything said and done from the second he stepped into our house but i won't -it will upset everyone reading this....the main point i'm trying to make is BE CAREFUL.......you do not want to be freinds with people like this or enemies......WAHEGURUGKD · 12 Sep 2004
yes we agree that mann "singh' is a fag and a half. but plz dont go diss other real Brahmgianis whoo Mann "singh" liked 2 relate him self to.g · 12 Sep 2004
I find it funny that any of you believe in these sants... someone who calls the self a sant is certainly not a sant... someone who lets others call them a sant is certainly not a sant... only real sants are the ones you wont know are santssants are..... · 12 Sep 2004
this is another example of why we shouldnt promote all the sants and have programs based on all these pakhandis, alot of the parchar that these ppl do is totally useless, one of the reasons being that they rely on the sangats money in which case wouldnt dare do anything that would risk not getting $$$ i.e. telling the sangat something they may not wish to hear. all these sants with all their websites, names and faces, fanism, all crap the lots of it. recent example being the atam raas programs, i do hope they dont become a collective fan club of these fake sants. i mean these guys had to be paid to sit on the same stage together initially. when all these punjabis r all making them even bigger and bigger theres nothing stopping them from turning to the dark side as they then abuse their positions. and the sangat is scared to speak out as it was them who blew these guys heads up so big in the first place.singh1984 · 13 Sep 2004
"Respect for \guru ji " You failed to notice SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI was in caps letter in my previous post. Gurfateh.Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 13 Sep 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. singh1984 ji, ALL CAPITALS IS "SHOUTING" AND RUDE !! A lot of singhs 84 and 94 / 04 give me a lot of flak for using CAPITALS. Seriously GURU JI COMES LAST...capitals or not. That means GURU JI is BELOW...all his sants and brahmginais... NOTICE how GURU Ji only has one plain word "GURU"...all the SANTS have TITLES....strings of titles...SRI, 108, brahmgiani, sant sant-giani...etc etc. PLEASE put GURU JI ABOVE all HUMANS....sants or otherwise. Why not BEGIN each mail with GURU JI......and END with GURU JI...then no one can complain. Thank You. Bhul Chuk Maaf Ji. Dass jarnail Singhsinghni · 13 Sep 2004
Author: uk singh wrote "Is it right to use the word "Sri" when repeating Waheguru? I read somewhere we should just say Waheguru on it's own when saying Fateh and during naam jap...but cannot recall what evidence they presented." It's good you mention this. Your right, Guru Gobind Singh Ji asked us to repeat "vaheguroo ji ka khalsa vaheguroo ji ki fatheh". I know someone who repeated 'sri' before it and the panj piaray asked her to repeat after them again before she was given amrith. Regarding 'Baba' Mann 'singh' - he came to my house a couple of weeks ago. I read the messages about him on this forum the day before he was to come over. I couldn't believe i was finding out a day before. I silently thanked the sangath, this forum and maharaj and thought that maharaj will show me the next day and i will make my own opinion The first thing he did was pressed/pushed/shoke his hand on my head so hard that it moved my dasthar back (which really annoyed me), he then sat down on the sofa and all his sevadars did a dandorth to his feet!! i was shocked - 'what the hell?'. They treated him like he was their guru, he didnt move his feet and just let everyone metha tak. I knew he was false because it was 'his' sevadars who were acting in the most anti-gurmat way (blind guru = blind followers). My mate asked him a question about raag kirtan (re: the moods of shabads) and he responded saying that coz japji sahib ji was not in raag so raag was not significant to him. he was rude to her, told her that she should just be quiet and take his answer etc etc. He and his chelay even laughed at her, just because she asked a question. Author: +1 wrote: "this is all propaganda. daas has personally had some spiritual experiences during diwans of Sant Mann Singh Ji. There would not be shaheed singhs guarding a terrible paapi like the accusations here." Bharji/bhenji, i totally understand that you have had spiritual experiences at the divans but those experiences have nothing to do with 'babaji'. You had those experinces because you were in the charan of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji (and there are always shaheed singhs around maharaj), and you were obviously concentrating on the shabad, so maharaj did kirpa on you. I was 15 when i went to listen to the katha/kirtan by 'babaji', he introduced me to guru granth sahib ji, i listened to amazing katha about guru gobind singh ji and totally fell in love with sikhi. I am grateful to him for that. ......But we cant be foolish. Too many people are coming forward with complaints. Baba ji may be known for getting thousands of people to take amrith...but quantity means nothing!! Does anyone know how many of those people commit one of the bujjer kurehats and take off guruji's kakkar's afterwards? At 15 i was told by babaji sevadars that i didnt need to do the 7 bani's if i didnt know them and that i didnt need to wear my kirpan to school etc etc Guru Gobind singh ji maharaj does not care about how many random people 'take' amrith. He cares about the quality of his gursikhs...one khalsa is better than 10,000 slack 'gursikhs' Finally, i totally agree with the posts above suggesting that we should'nt get carried away with verbally abusing 'babaji'. : Author: AnotherSingh wrote: "Agreed. It is not nindia in my books either. I'm talking about the other disses put up that trash him but don't contribute any info to the discussion." let us try and behave/speak like khalsa when dealing with this i'm sorry for the vaad gaat written above vahegurooji ka khalsa vahegurooji ki fathehnext step? · 13 Sep 2004
Sangat gee oh... Whats should be our next step? its slowly coming out in the newspapers in north america, but England seems to be slow in wanting to release his story (because of his influence) so khalsa's of England, please begin to due your duties, please. The radio stations are having talk shows (apparently a new baba in brampton, has been exposed...listen out for further info...) I have been informed that two of the young singhni's that he raped are willing to come forward and take a stand afer they heard about the news in Canada (there location geographically cannot be exposed, due to baba's chelle's looking for them and the dozen or so singhs that left his dhera...) THIS IS A BEANTI..THOSE OF YOU WHO MAY HAVE SOME SHREAD OF EVIDENCE THAT WOULD HELP WORK AGAINST HIM, SHOULD GIVE AN E-MAIL ADDRESS THAT CONTACT CAN BE MADE WITH YOU....IF SOMETHING IS TO BE DONE, THEN A COLLECTION OF EVIDENCE MUST BE BROUGHT FORWARD...PLEASE ASSIST THE PANTH One of the Punjabi T.V shows may get an exclusive interview with one of our sisters this BASTARD raped...when i'm inofrmed i will lt all know.... Lets keep the pressure on..sikh · 13 Sep 2004
to the veer who had darshan of shaeed singhs veer they were probably there hoping someone would get up and kick this dog in the teeth and serve him the punishment he deserves but alas nothing as we are to weak to bhain ji i am sorry to hear your friend was laughed at by the dog and his friends i hope some real chardi kala GurSikhs confront this dog and teach him the lesson he deserves and to veer talking about uk sangat veer alot of uk sangat indirectly think of him as guru gonna take awhile beofre they open there eyes, but finally the truth is flooding forward and i hope this makes other fake babs and sants take notice and they stop their bad ways because no matter how long it takes sangat will always with Guru Ji's kirpa take action!Taz-SikhLionz.com · 13 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fatheh singhni penji the word "sri" is just a term that you can add when you want to add a level of respect, eg: Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji for Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Is this important? If there's a hukkham from akal takhat saying not to use this word or the panth as a whole wishes me not to then i will obey. either way note i've not used sri above to please all concerned lets not take semantics too far- otherwise the panth will end up bickering over the teeniest tinyest things and no sikh will be able to do or say anything to please another, bhull chukk maaf karni please agree on the point on 'baba' maan su's grip- i was attending my local Gurdwara as usual and he was leaving the hall and grabbed my gooti like a jcb. I was not even looking in his direction and Waheguru forgive me for what thoughts came into my mind. At the end of the day it wol be best to petition akal takhat to deal with this matter and let them look at the evidence. everyone stay in Chaardhi Kalaaa until the matter is dealt with info on this issue has been passed on in the uk peace bhull chukk maaf karni -------------------- Taz_SikhLionz http://www.SIKHLIONZ.com May Waheguru Bless You Eternal Happiness Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fathehsingh1984 · 13 Sep 2004
"ALL CAPITALS IS "SHOUTING" AND RUDE !!" not in my dictionary... dude spent some lookin under your own manji before net-picking faults in others. Gurfateh.Kulbir Singh · 13 Sep 2004
I first heard Maan’s (Maan Singh) diwaan in mid nineties when he came to Toronto for the first time. There was a massive advertisement campaign to promote this fake sant. They were saying that he has some magic and is getting record number of people to take amrit. I went to listen to him at Malton Gurdwara Sahib and I noticed that the hall was packed. Somehow, I managed to find a seat about 10 feet from Maan. This was the first time that I heard dhaarna singing. He was singing the following dhaarna: KAAVAAN KUTIYAAN KHOTIYAAN DEE JONI PAINGAY, JINAA NAY GURU NAHIYO DHAARIYA|| (All those who have not adopted a Guru will be reincarnated as crows, dogs and donkeys) He was emphasizing a lot on the word “kuttay” (dogs). All monnay people bowed their heads in shame when they heard him call them dogs. He spoke with a lot of force but one thing I could not help noticing was that while his words were very good but his face seemed very evil to me. It looked like a raakash (demon). Then he started badmouthing Akhand Kirtani Jatha and all those people who promote Keski and oppose Raagmala. He spitted out so much venom at that time that I felt like slapping this bastard right there and then. I somehow controlled myself and walked out in disgust. I never went back to listen to his diwaan. Outside in the hallway of the Gurdwara Sahib, I met one of the old members of AKJ. He told me that he had finally found a Mahapurakh in Maana. I told him right there that this person Maana is a fake sant but he got upset with me. I am now looking for this akj member to talk to him but have been unable to find him yet. Last year I wrote something against this molester Maana and got threatening emails from some gursikhs. One gursikh threatened me with dire consequences. Others were a little polite than this but they too were very upset at me for criticizing Maana. I told them to do what they had to do and that I would not relinquish my criticism of this fake sant Maana. Anyway, I received an email from one of the gursikhs who first opposed my criticism of Maana and requested me to call him at a number as soon as possible. I called him and he told me how he had always considered this person as Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee himself and how this person Maan had deceived them so badly. Apparently, he acted inappropriately at their house and at their friend's house. This gursikh veer, whom I really sympathize with and whom I have found to be a very good person, suffered immensely in the hands of this faker. Maana tried to molest his wife and his friend's wife. Obviously he was shattered for not one reason but for two reasons. One because he tried to molest his wife and secondly because his religious beliefs or his palace of Dharam came down like a house of cards. I know that this gursikh is reading this post of mine and I request this veer to not let his gursikh get affected by the actions of this imposter. Veer jeeo, this person has spoiled lives of so many girls as per your account and believe me that Guru Sahib will surely punish this person. Don't let yourself get affected by this person's paaps. Gursikhi is much bigger than one person. Gursikhi is great. This person is an insect of human excretion and will surely go to hell, where he belongs. You stay in chardi kala. Anyway, let us learn from this incident and let us not run after white-clothed fake sants. A real sant will not advertise himself as a sant. He will not let anyone call him a sant. If a person is doing all this drama of being a Mahapurakh, know that this person is fake. The real sants are gursikhs who stay humble and forever stay as dust of feet of all gursikhs. They keep full rehit and do swaas swaas simran. They don’t distribute sons to couples as these fake sants do. They never let anyone come near their feet, let alone touching them. They are always panthik i.e. stand with Panth all the time. They never accept any prizes or awards from the worldly governments. They forever stay merged in the divine colours of Naam. This person Maana on the other hand came across as a very egoist person who openly used to ridicule monnay people from stage and allowed amritdhari persons to touch his feet. What a fake sant he was. Daas, Kulbir SinghRespect for Guru Ji · 13 Sep 2004
Nevertheless, it was still at the bottom of the list. Not nit picking, but just suggesting who always write Guru ji at the top, not bottom. singh1984 wrote: > "Respect for \guru ji " > > You failed to notice SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI was in caps > letter in my previous post. > > Gurfateh.antam saskar · 13 Sep 2004
somebody needs to read kirtan sohila for him!Jagjit singh · 13 Sep 2004
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, when I first came across Sant Maan singh, I was with Bhai Rama Singh ji walking to the gurdwara in southall. Youth in UK were hyping up Maan singh alot. I just looked at Bhai sahib, who just smiled back at me. I knew that meant, we were wasting our time in this idle chatter and carry on doing mool manter. We carried on walking. Then there was the incidents in southall and slough. I was involved in some of this. I have no regrets and never have. I was always extremely wary of him. At sikhi camps in UK, alot of youth idolised Maan Singh. I never understood this. I always believed anyone who reads kacchie bani can never be a mahapursh, because he has never even reached the first stage of sikhi. This is recognising your Guru - Shabad Guru. So many youth got disillusioned with him over the years. Over the years the very youth, who were prepared to fight us in slough and southall for being anti-him, came up to us and said we were right all along. It is so sad when peoples faith is shattered. This is why as Gursikhs, our faith should be in Sahib Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji only. These reports whether they will be actioned by the Panth or not, only time will tell. But I remember that first day during the night youth ranisbhai, with Bhai Rama Singh ji, sitting on stage with children. Then Sant Maan singh bursting in the hall with his chelays, mattha tekking, sitting staring at Bhai Rama Singh in an intimidating way, knowing he was jathedar of AKJ UK. Then getting up and walking out. I looked at that scene, and Bhai Rama singhs shining face, with his enigmatic smile. Who was the real sant? Who was the real Bhramagiani? Bhai Sahib smile said it all to me. Just like Bhai Jeevan singhs does. It is so easy to spot a real Gursikh, I do not know why so many people fall for the fakes. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fatehSheru · 14 Sep 2004
I aggreeSheru · 14 Sep 2004
I aggree with all these people, this ******* is a rapist, i personally know the victoms and have gone to his diwans in, NY, CALI, VANCOUVER, TORONTO, ENGLAND, and INDIA, and he is one of the biggest con-artist in today's day and age, this is from first hand experience, everything in the Sanjh Savera, Charde Kala, Akal Guardian is 100% true!*anon* · 14 Sep 2004
I will wait for some hard facts before I make a decision on this matter. And once a decision is made, something will have to be done either way - to take out a terrorist or to protect the innocence of a gursikh. Right now it is only the newspaper sanjh savera, that doesn't like sants and are just eager to publish stories like this. In response to all the people dissing dharna keertan, there are real sants that do dharna keertan just like Sant Attar Singh did dharna keertan.singhni · 14 Sep 2004
Author: Taz-SikhLionz.com wrote: 'singhni penji the word "sri" is just a term that you can add when you want to add a level of respect, eg: Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji for Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Is this important? If there's a hukkham from akal takhat saying not to use this word or the panth as a whole wishes me not to then i will obey.' Taz bhenji you are right. Ofcourse we can use Sri for respect. I only meant when you are saying gurfatheh. It's 'Vaheguroo ji ka khalsa vaheguroo ji ki fatheh', panj piaray asked my friend to repeat it exactly in those words when taking amrith (&greeting other gursikhs) since that is the hukam of maharaj sri Guru Gobind Singh ji. Sorry for the confusing, To those who do not know it is the Joti Jot of Guru Amar das ji and Guru Ram Das ji, and Gur-gadi day of Gur Ram das ji and Guru Arjan dev ji on Thursday 16th Sept. Also Angad Dev ji's Guru Gadi day on Saturday 18th and Joti-jot of Guru Nanak dev ji on the 22nd Sept..... phew....dhan dhan dhan guru maharaj (sorry that this post is not related to the subject)Manajeett Kaur Sidhu · 14 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Sants and Brahmgianis..... a dime a dozen now a days.....Just show mw HOW MANY during Guru Nanak- Guur Gobind Singh Ji's time ??? NOT even ONE. ALL are BHAI and Gurmukh.... beginning with BHAI LEHNA JI.... NOT a SINGLE ONE during the times of Baba Banda Singh Bahadur, baab deep Singh Shaheed, Bhai mani Singh Shaheed, Bhai Taru singh Shaheed... Fast Forward to the POST Second World war period.....and SANTS, Brahmgianis, Sri 108's started mushrooming...... like KHUMBBAAN after a Rain... and as time passed...their NUMBERS Increased like GROWING CANCER CELLS......MUltiplying so fast that the PATIENT will soon die. GURSIKHI of GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE is the Patient....dont be MISLED by the numbers of "amritdharies" these FAKES create.... these vast numbers are SANT CHELAS and have FAITH MORE in their Own PET SANT BABA JI and NOT in Guru Granth sahib Jee.... The GURU KHALSA PANTH MUST take ACTION to STOP this CANCER of SANTWAAD/DERAWAAD spreading rapidly. NO ONE who calls himslef a sant/Brahmginai/Sri 108/Maharaj/baba Ji/ etc is a SANT. NO One who ALLOWS or ENCOURAGES his Chelas to call him such names titles is a SANT. ALL those "genuine" ones MUST ISSUE a HUKM immediately that they are NOT SANTS/Brahmgianis/Sri 108s. Baba Ji's...and NO HUMAN BEING should be Adressed as Such under any circumstances...or referred to as such by anyone as long he has Faith in GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE. We cannot have FAITH in TWO - duality - sant as well as shabad guru. Two swords NEVER sit in a single Scabbard. All true Gursikhs MUST choose - SANT JI or GURU JI. MANY such FRAUDS have been exposed and many more will be exposed....but then the DISASTER has already happened to many.....the DAMAGE has been done...the Faith of many have been shattered. The ONLY REMEDY is to DO AWAY with all sants just as GURU GOBIND SINGH JI did away with the Corrpt MASANDS. GOOD MASANDS like Bhai Feru Ji were honoured by guru Ji with title like Sachi Dharee because on hearing of the fate of the Masands, he appeared before Guru Ji HOLDING HIS DHAREE in his folded hands...BUT inspite of having good masands alike Bhai Feru Ji...GURU JI ABOLISHED the Masand system becasue 99.99% of it was bad and CORRUPT. Similarly "Good " sants are only a mere 000.0001%....the REST are COORRUPT and EVIL....what lesson have we learnt from GURU JI and the Masands ??? or havent we learnt anything ??? Manajeet akurss · 14 Sep 2004
One of the first protests against this fake sant was held in southall england during one his programmes. Onkar singh, now general secretary of AKJ UK and a few other singhs from Slough were merely handing out a photocopy of an article from Sikh Phulphari magazine which exposed the mann singh and his corrupt ways. This was way back i think in 1999? Anyway, the article was by some sikhs from dubai. mann singh went to dubai and got a glass of amrit after the pahul ceremony and threw it into a well. he then said who ever wants amrit drink from the well. other such occurences were mentioned. We were leafleting all the cars of the sangat with this article when suddenly a group of mann singh chelas saw what we were doing.they chased up to us and we were manhandled. the situation got very ugly and mann singh chelay got their kirpans out and threatened to kill onkar singh on the spot. they said they wanted him to apologise to mann singh personally and took him to the gurudwara. just as things were getting very heated, the ardas started and we all called for everyone to at least listen to ardas. they obeyed this and calmed down. things then blew over. is it not interesting how people continue to worship him even though he has already been exposed? what will it take for this charlatan to stop his anti gurmat parchar? oh har kay sant na akheyae, benaras kay tughthere payed off.... · 14 Sep 2004
Those devout chele's of his are payed off. When we found out about his on-goings, we backed off, even though we were close to him, something said that this kind of stuff, isn't just made up...there is most definitely truth to it... We expected all those we told to do the same.....but no, why because they are payed off by him, i believe that they must have un-covered his wrong doings sometime in the past (approx. 4 years ago), approached him, and guess what, his main chele's in england suddenly had busineses that were doing real well...all of a sudden, why because mann the rapist, paid them off. he is celebrating sant baba isher singh ji's barsi tomorrow in pehowa(15th sept 2004), as he does every year..........but things are not going to plan this year.......??? maybe we should call him? 011-91-1741-20697 (pehowa #) (first five digits are canadian dial code)i have tried calling · 14 Sep 2004
actually the number is...... 011-91-1741-220697what? · 14 Sep 2004
i wish i was there with bhai onkar singh, then we would have seen who was ready to die, the punj pyar of the jatha in uk are all gursikhs with excellent jeevans this man is a nothing his time is now coming i cant wait for him to come back to uk and its about time somebody told the idiot pardaan of singh sabha havelock rd himmat singh to take down the stuipd plagues in the gurdwara of poeple who have donated (excess of £50k) to guru ghar this peice of **** has his name on there as well maybe somebody should scrawl rapist on the plague, umm must remember to take my marker next time i go to the gurdwara its funny times like this the heart pines for a real sant like bhai jarnail singh you dont have to think very hard what bhai sahib would have done!Jasvir Kaur · 15 Sep 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. PAID OFF CHELAS is definitely Right. Although there are a lot of fools who are ready to "die" for free, the real high ups are very handsomely PAID. And the Jathedars and Brahmgianis of other deras etc are also PAID and in LEAGUE with each other...you scratch my back and i will scratch your ***** !! NO wonder NONE of them speaks even a single word !!! SILENT as NIGHT OWLS.... Sant Sipahi, Des predes, Sanjh savera has been exposing them for decades...the really seriously exposed ones disappear....those not so seriously damaged..lie low for a while and reappear.....like the so called jathedar of Bhai mani Singh taksaal who went overseas for KATHA recently was SACKED by a Charity organisation he had cheated of its money. The REPORT came out in the Sant Sipahi in 1997/98...obviously small time crooks get forgotten easily.....confirmed rapists / CHEATERS.FRAUDS/ like sant amar singh burundi NANAKSAR is still free to go and come as he likes... jasvir kaurchelay? who me?? · 15 Sep 2004
some people never learn http://forums.waheguroo.com/index.php?act=ST&f=8&t=6912&hl=&s=7c9af3a7e7448f50fc96ad601e5a9dca UK chelays still backing himSingh · 15 Sep 2004
I am no supporter of any sant or modern day jathas. But it should be noted that we have no real proof yet, just allegations. i'm not saying that he didn't do these things, but what real proof do we have. During the 80s and 90s the Babbars and people from the Jatha were in much the same way accused of doing such things to woman by the media. I know these were probably false, but all we have now is the same style newspaper report. In India you can get someone to make false allegations with a few rupees, just look at the woman who came forward claiming they were raped by the singh's at darbar sahib. So what's the difference here, with no real 100% proof. I know the Jatha have always hated maan singh, and it seems that this is the chance they always wanted to say he's bad. Like i said he may have done these things, but without solid proof rather but only alegations how can anyone be sure, just like we wouldn't beleive people claiming and media reports that the Babbars used to rape girls.S Singh · 15 Sep 2004
>>I know the Jatha have always hated maan singh, and it seems that this is the chance they always wanted to say he's bad. Like i said he may have done these things, but without solid proof rather but only alegations how can anyone be sure, just like we wouldn't beleive people claiming and media reports that the Babbars used to rape girls. Its actually the other way round maan su has hated the jatha and this hatred is well documented on the web. Ha ha you make me laugh with your defence of this sex pervert. Maan su can easily take the paper to court for libel in canada. Lets see if he has the guts to do so or would rather not risk being further exposed. OK in India you can buy people but people in the west have also accused him of doing these dirty acts. I suppose it is a big time conspiracy hatched by MOSSAD and the ISI backed with money from secretive banker who lives in Andorra (LOL). Wake up and start facing reality !Manajeet Kaur · 15 Sep 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. singh ji, what you are saying above is GOI propoganda.....and also there were GOI Agents disguised as babbars and such who raped and pillaged to destroy the real babbar movement.... Every Singh knows for a fact that GOI agents stpped buses and killed hindus to defame Sikhs who NEVER do such even in their dreams. This report on kutta maana is NOT GOI propoganda by a long shot. It is a report based on secret information given by defencelss girls who are hiding for their lives from this rabid dog. That is why their names are changed...CAN YOU GUARANTEE their SAFETY if they come out with 100% PROOF that YOU need ??? What powers do you have on this account ?? I KNOW for a FACT that a certain SANT took nealry a YEAR of Preparation to Gradually bring under his control a amritdharee girl who beleived in him...through his chelas.... going through the motions of REBUKING his head chela who one night got a bit KAHLA and manhandled the girl....the SANT fired this man and sent him off....but then his other chelas started saying he was such a good man, doing so much sewa etc and the girl felt guilty and asked the Baba to forgive him...the next time she didnt have the opportunity to escape.... the BABA caught her in a room and the so called disgraced sewak was hiding under the bed. they BOTH RAPED her the whole night....told her to keep quiet....and keep them informed as to her monthly period.....when she told them no period this month.... the BABA JI proudly announced to the SANGAT that the YEAR LONG AKHAND AATH had suceeded, ardass has been heard and the Amritdharee bibi is PREGNANT. Then ONLY did this girl get the courage to EXPOSE the fraud baba Ji and he was arrested by the POLICE in jalandhar District - 1999 June. Luckily the girl wass brave enough...not everybody is such....and so the babas escape to another poor girl the next day....and then next day...until such time they get caught. Dassree Manajeet kaurlegall document has been signe · 15 Sep 2004
Gur fateh sadh sanghat jee oh... It's offical.....one of the girls that he raped has signed all legall documents telling the story of what mann the rapist did. We hope another sisiter will be signing a document this week, with another to follow...... (one of the girls has clinic documents from the abortion clinic...she was sent to , twice...they do not have his DNA or genetic info, or any blood group info. but the time/dates can confirm that the girl was staying at his dhera...) please all pray that she comes forward too. the girls are in hiding, as mann the rapist has alot of power in india.... fatehSingh · 15 Sep 2004
If we have evidence which can be proven than great. But if all we have as it seems at this stage is accusations than can we really act as judges, and executioners based on allegations. Like I said he may be guilty and I have never been a fan of him or the jatha. But the fact is that if we are to believe the media and allegations made by people with no facts in presented in criminal proceedings, where evidence is presented than we also need to accept the same for the Babbars and members of the Jatha accused in the same way. Saying maan singh is guilty based on what we presently have, is like saying the Babbars were also guilty of rape (agents or not), and hence the same words presented here should be used for people I wouldn’t dare to mention in the Babbar organisation. I don’t believe anything ie that Babbar leaders etc did these things, or anyone is guilty without real evidence. I’m not giving maan singh the benefit of the doubt or saying he’s innocent in any way, only that evidence and facts are the key, not allegations. Sorry if this sounds uncommon to you guys, but most people with common sense would agree. Would you start saying these types of things about a leader of the jatha if a paper and people from India started saying they raped etc, I doubt itS Singh · 15 Sep 2004
To Singh maan su can easily start legal proceedings against the publication for libel if he considers the accusations are false. Just puzzled as to why he or his chele have not started this. If he is so innocent then he should start a libel action. the only reason a person would step back from such a step would be if they were scared of being further exposed.Singh · 15 Sep 2004
When someone prominent is accused of such things in the community, almost immediately two camps will set up: the "lynch the sob" camp and the "it's a conspiracy!!" camp. Issues like this are hard to resolve. The women that have been mistreated usually don't want to come forward. That's not unreasonable due to the way our community is and even taking into account the fact that women in Western courts aren't identified when they make such accusations. As for "evidence", usually these things aren't caught on videotape and aren't done in a group of people. So how do you know if it's true? Look at how many people are coming forward. If the accuassations are piling up and coming from people who have no vested interest in the issue, it's probably true. If there have been long-standing rumours, then it's also a good indication that the accusations are true. In the case of Mann Singh, it's pretty clear that these charges are probably true. But always be careful not to jump to immediate conclusions. One accusation without asking the perpetrator is not enough to condemn. At the same time, demanding "evidence" in the face of scores of accusations is also stupid.Taz-SikhLionz · 15 Sep 2004
WJKK WJKF this goes out to all those that think uk sikhs are chup-chaap on this issue first off i'm changing my position on from sitting on the fence and looking at the evidence to joining my canadian brothers and sisters in denouncing the stuff that mann su appears to have done i'm officially a signed up member of the "baba"-bashing-brigade let's get these nakali babas out of the Panth NOW we need REAL Gursikhs inspiring the next generation of Sikh Youth; Gursikhs that we can trust our children with... trust our future with also, Awaze Qaum; another leading weekly sikh magasine will be releasing an article on this nakali "baba" in their next issue. so who says uk sikhs are chup-chaap now? WJKK WJKFuk. finally wakes up.... · 15 Sep 2004
it must be the time delay my Taz... Punjab times in the uk. will also be publishing an article.....panjab radio will be having a talk show sometime today or tomorrow (15th/16th) on mann the rapist... New york Punjab express will also release an article.... lets see how many baba's come to his defence or or condemn him...? what a farce...the sant samaj.....who are they meant to be guiding.....?Gurmat · 15 Sep 2004
All, correct me if i'm wrong, but aren't all those who are joining in the 'bashing' of this guy also guility of blindly jumping on the band wagon, albeit a different one?? IF this 'sant' is guilty, then there are always going to be people who will not see past the smoke and mirrors... accept that. People should be able to make up their own minds without having to sift through this rubbish. If our belief in god is strong, then leave it to the almighty to judge and punish... our role should be to make people aware that there are two sides to every story, and NOT to convince everyone that OUR side is the correct one... otherwise we are no better than them. my two centsG · 15 Sep 2004
All, correct me if i'm wrong, but aren't all those who are joining in the 'bashing' of this guy also guility of blindly jumping on the band wagon, albeit a different one?? IF this 'sant' is guilty, then there are always going to be people who will not see past the smoke and mirrors... accept that. People should be able to make up their own minds without having to sift through this rubbish. If our belief in god is strong, then leave it to the almighty to judge and punish... our role should be to make people aware that there are two sides to every story, and NOT to convince everyone that OUR side is the correct one... otherwise we are no better than them. my two centsLol · 15 Sep 2004
Vaheguru, may He give all of the Nindaks here some Summat and SHANTI (especially Jasvir and Manjeet), it's clear to see how much u have progressed in your sikhi by your venomous remarks about everyone and anyone, without knowledge and valid proofs. It would be too much to expect the ADMN to lock or moderate this topic, because it seems when it is an anti-sant topic, everything goes. As a Bhai Sahib said before, let's not comment on anyone without proof, and if this guy has sinned, then Vaheguru will dispence justice.YAY!! · 16 Sep 2004
seeker excellent points and statementsimran_sewa_sacrifice · 16 Sep 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!! I would like to say that whether or not he is guilty right now (i think he is) he should not be allowed to ANY kirtan, katha, sikhi parchaar from ANY PANTHIC stage WHATSOEVER! Any person who allows him to do so (Gurdwara comitte member or other) while he is being being evaluated guilty or innocent should be awarded a severe thankah. Secondly Maan is indeed guilty of other gross violations such as giving amrit in bottles and traveling with a DSP who upon being reckognized by a youth who had been torured by him, Maan was asked who is this man and he is being accused of torture ect. Maan replied HE IS MY CHELA (hmm interesting how men can have OTHER MEN as their chelas esp if the chelas are being accused of torture). This can be confirmed by plenty of people. On the basis of this and other allegations (lets predend he was innocent of raping anyone) he shouldnt be allowed to even CLEAN a panthic stage much less adress sangat from one! Its funny how if Maan was just some ordnary Joe Blow Singh no one would have any problem CRUCIFYING him/her for a much lesser crime. But since most people have a habit of putting some person a pedestal,and equally having a heck of a time taking him off when they know he was totally wrong. One other thought...how come those close to him only chose to expose him after so many years... If only there was an easy way to properly investigate this matter and get to the truth. =( AT THE VERY LEAST DO NOT ALLOW MAAN TO DO ANYTHING FROM ANY STAGE ECT UNTIL HIS NAME IS CLEARED/EXPOSED THUROUGLY..this is the LEAST we can do. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!!GKD · 16 Sep 2004
he should be given tankah as well as be prosecuted 2 the FULL EXTENT OF THE LAW in each country he has commited his crimes!Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 16 Sep 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. LOL has a wonderful viewpoint......let WAHEGURU deal with such... Luckily Guru Hargobind Ji...Guuru Gobind Singh ji, Baba banda Singh Ji, and Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Bhinderawaleh.....and many others DIDNT THINK THIS WAY...otherwise there would be NO SIKH HISTORY...or any SIKHS for that matter IF Beant Singh and Satwant Singh had said this...Indira would be PM today...IF Dilawar Singh ahd said the same thing..Beanta would still be Punjab CM... ALL SINGHS should wear CHOORIAN...and let WAHEGURU deal with such dogs....while they rape our daughters and sisters....wah wah lol ji. WHY are we here in the First Place IF Waheguru is going to do all the work ?? Why didnt lol ji keep his fingers away from his keyboard.....and let WAHEGURU deal with everything??? Wah Wah ji. Dhan Dhan lol Ji types of Sikhs. This is a rare topic that has slipped past 82 posts and still counting... shows how important this subject is for everyone... Taking pot shots at ADMIN and deriding it as 'all systems go because this is anti SANT Topic...is hitting under the belt...WHY should any sane person be "Anti Sant" just for the fun of it....no body "made" manna do all those horrible things.....and now whay should we keep it under wraps ??? I say EXPOSE ALL SUCH MAHAAN PAAPIS and DUSHTS before they cause more dmaage to the PANTH. I also congratulate my sisters Manjeet and Jasvir for being brave enough to call a spade a spade !!! Hiding under the big cholas and rounder than round turbans is not going to save these dushts...everyhting they said I would have said myself...they beat me to it. Dass jarnail Singh MALAYSIA.seeeen · 16 Sep 2004
FATEH!!!!!!!!-? HEY "LOL"......ALL I GOTTA DO IS LAUGH AT YA-OUT LOUD.... EVEYONES A SANT THESE DAYS.....LETS WAIT AND LET "GOD" PUNISH HIM, LIKE MANY PPL HAVE BEEN DOIN FOR THE PAST 18 YEARS...AND WAIT FOR THE NEXT GENERATION OF SINGHS/SINGHNIS TO SAY THE SAME THING YOU'RE SAYING...... AND "BHAI SAHIB" YOU SAY??? OF COURSE "BHAI SAHIB" IS GONNA SAY THAT...YOU KNOW WHY DUDE?...CUZ THEY ALL THE SAME..... PEACE!AnotherSingh · 16 Sep 2004
I still feel that it is importent to refrain from nindia. Information is one thing, derogatory remarks that contribute nothing are nindia. I happen to know the person who put the article condemning him in the paper, and he is not a trustworthy or honourable individual. There is apparently a case registered against the writer of that article. I think it is importent for those who are letting thier emotions carry them away in the heat of the moment to remember that these are unsubstantiated allegations, that a person is innocent until proven guilty. It is unfortunate that some of the punjabi press does not abide by the same standards of journalistic integrity that much of the western press does. So how about a hunt for truth instead of a witchhunt, eh? Generally speaking, even if a person does things that are anti-Gurmat, it doesn't mean that they are capable of rape.AnotherSingh · 16 Sep 2004
I just wanted to add, I apologise if I have offended anyone.Singh · 16 Sep 2004
S Singh, what evidence do we have to be 100% sure at this stage. Like I’ve said over and over again it’s the same situation the Babbars found themselves in, i.e. media and personal accusations of rape and crime with no evidence. If they were innocent why didn’t they hold legal proceedings for libel and slander? The point is that facts is what counts, and without facts its remarkable how people can say he’s defiantly guilty (unless they hated him before and now have just found an excuse). He may or may not be guilty, all the woman accusing especially in the West should report this to the police and let criminal proceedings take place where evidence can be presented. Just believing in media reports and personal accusations isn’t sufficient in any ones case, and people should not let there personal hate or pindu mentality wreck their judgement. This is not a passive stance as actions should certainly always be taken, but only when we have solid proof and not accusations and claims. What if tomorrow someone claims the same things about the Jathedar of the Jetha, and media reports back this. Will you all say the same things, I think not. In the meantime maan singh should not be allowed to perform any kirtan etc, and criminal proceedings should begin. Once he has been found guilty than we can surely say these things. What I find very interesting is that Panjab radio has been mentioned here. This is a great station in my opnion as it is 100% panthic, but only a few months ago on this very site people were saying the jatha should boycott it and that the presented in question was bad. Strange how now the jatha is advertising on the station, and how its being mentioned with respect by people in this discussion.Manas Singh · 16 Sep 2004
WJKK WJKF In these sorts of topics some people lost their sense of perspective. If I came on this board and said Sant so and so did such and such anti-Gurmat thing chances are most of the people will believe it and start to deride that Sant. We are willing to believe almost anything derogratory about anyone as long as we place Sant in front of his name. If I came on here and said my neighbour Joe Bloggs did this and that you will want proof! This is not to say that all the things said about Mann Singh may not turn out to be true in the end. But until there is definate proof referring to him as Maan Su seems to just display anger and displaying such anger just hurts your argument. Unless you have a extreme hatred of all Sants then you will find most of the views posted by some people difficult to read. Having a sense of decorum doesn't hurt anyone and make it easy to read your argument. Debates such as these just hurt Sikhi. NONE of us here knows 100% whether we are RIGHT or WRONG. But most of the posts read like he's already been proven guilty or found totally innocent. By using derogatory names for him will make the people who have faith in him defend him or view your argument as being biased. These people would ordinarily be willing to understand your viewpoint and make a judgement based on the facts. Referring to him as a Rapist without any proof isn't the Sikh way. To those who take everything written in the newspaper as if it is fact, please be aware that as with all places, Deras of Sants do have personality clashes as well as politics. These people making the allegations seem to have been fine with what he was doing for a number of years and then suddenly they get a conscience and make their statements. Lets see both sides of the story before we condemn anyone. Most of the people here will have their say and deride this person and that will be the end of the matter. If you really care about Sikhi then the Sangat should -; Gather the evidence and then approaching the Akal takht as well as helping the victims to institute court cases against Mann Singh. Or if that cannot be done due to Mann Singh's undue political influence in India Then gather a group of well known five Gursikhs in UK, USA and Canada and then let them look at the evidence and if possible interview the people making the allegations. These Gursikhs should be ones who are above reproach and against whom no allegations of bias can be made. Then Maan Singh should also asked to give his side of the story. If he doesn't do this then it should be assumed that he has something to hide since the Panj Pyare will only make a decison based on the evidence. If he does not come then the Panj Pyare should ask all Sangat both in India and abroad to socially boycott him until he attends. If he still does not attend then the Panj Pyare should make a decision and a suitable punishment be given. An investigation into the facts should be easy given the Sangat in India who can verify the facts such as the happenings at his dera. Some people are saying that Mann Singh should go to Canada and take the newspaper to court to show that he is innocent. It is easy for Mann Singh to say that he is a religious figure and he doesn't care about 'nandaks' publishing things about him. Many people will believe him in this. What is needed is for the Sangat to take action as detailed above. It would be difficult for Mann Singh to give the same answer if he is confronted by the Sangat asking for his side of the story. Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani I don't think that lol was saying that we should just sit idly by. What he/she was saying was that Waheguru will cause people to take action. But action should be based on the facts and only when he has been found guilty by the Akal Takht or by Panj Pyare as detailed above. Waheguru will help the Akal Takht or the Panj Pyare to come to the right decision.only the panth.. · 16 Sep 2004
AnotherSingh... On which grounds do you write that the writer of the article has had a case registered against him....? Sorry to say but you to sem to suffer from the same 'influenza' tht the rest of us do... mann the rapist has not made any moves at all, we are watching him daily and are getting up-dates daily from his dhera's... he has been covering up a past which stems from the early 1980's, but his down fall was messing with an educated sister, a sister who knew that actions can be taken against him. sanjh savera will release a follow up story today (16th sept)S Singh · 16 Sep 2004
Manas Singh >>Gather the evidence and then approaching the Akal takht as well as helping the victims to institute court cases against Mann Singh. This has been done before and he used his contacts to stop any action. Taking the paper to court is a very easy solution. Why has he not done it ? If someone made fasle accusations against you like those against maan su would you not take action (especially considering he does not lack the financial resources to pursue such an action). He has done enough to deserve the maan su tag and for that I do not apologise. Leaving joota langar as a holy prashad for his followers, links with policemen who tortured Sikh youths. If any one else had done such things they would also be referred to as a su, it is only because people think he is some sort of baba that they remonstrate when anyone calls him maan su. As for the Panj Piare idea, great idea on paper but in reality it will not work. Only a few years ago Jagir Kaur (head of SGPC) had an edict pronounced against her by the then head of the Akal Takht (Giani Puran Singh) and four other Singh. Rather than obey the decisison of the Panj Piare they sacked the Akal Takht Jathedar. Do you think maan su will actually respect the decision of the Panj Piare ?Gupt · 16 Sep 2004
Fake Baba is currently on tour to Hemkunt Sahib. He along his chelyah are currently there. I heard yesterday, may be false information but the source is a very close pro ''baba jee''another sikh girl · 16 Sep 2004
The few girls in the west are educated girls, have families are well settled, please people tell me what they have to gain out of all of this by saying he is a rapist, abviously something happened......they sure don't need this kind of publicity and put their families reputation on the line....the main reason, so then can save another girl from getting raped!! "To those who take everything written in the newspaper as if it is fact, please be aware that as with all places, Deras of Sants do have personality clashes as well as politics. These people making the allegations seem to have been fine with what he was doing for a number of years and then suddenly they get a conscience and make their statements. Lets see both sides of the story before we condemn anyone." To the above statement, the person that made the allegations came to the dhera when he was 6 or 7, and grew up there, he had no personality clashes with NO ONE...when he was approached by a girl and was told what had happened to her, he investigated the situation and found out that there were many other girls in the east and in the west. These are not FALSE accusations, this is the TRUTH, only time will tell, that these are the facts....mann with no mann... · 16 Sep 2004
hemkunt sahib yatra will normally start in a few days....the big barsi only finished this morning... His london chella's have managed to silence Des Pardes newspaper, they have not released an article in the uk......TAZ wake up son....get you boyz going.....lets ask questions....another sikh girl · 16 Sep 2004
I'm sure I be would able to silence any newspaper, if i had that kind of money backing me up!Taz-SikhLionz.com · 16 Sep 2004
The jyot of Waheguru is supposedly meant to be alive within us and we are supposed to fight to uphold the truth. In this case any and all sikhs have the right to demand the accusations and evidence be presented to akal takhat, and other bodies. Sikhs can say that parchaar should cease until this matter is dealt with... The problem with this entire confusing situation is the evidence is nebulous and so people can take from it whatever views they wish. Due to the nature of this type of problem it is 1 word against another often. No matter what decision is made by Akal Takhat, or courts, etc. the other parties involved will not accept the decision- on the one hand we have very loyal chelae who serve him and followers & on the other we have those who disagree with his views, the victims, etc. This issue may never be sorted out Guilty or not guilty one thing's for certain- he cant afford to be involved in a situation of this sort again... this is a messy situation May Waheguru shine a light on this situation to dispel the darkness awaysikh · 16 Sep 2004
why dont everyone who has posted on this topic do ardas to Guru Sahib to reslove this matter for the panth........... and Guru Sahib take the action... at present we don't seem to be getting anywhere and lets pray for the people he has abusedSingh · 16 Sep 2004
S Singh Once again why didn't the Babbars or supporters of people like Suckdev Singh Babbar go to court when they were defamed by the media. Just by not taking allegers to court does not mean these alligations are true. If you are waiting for maan singh to take people to court and that is what you base your proof of his guilt on than you should also hold guilty the singhs in the jatha and babbars accused by the media and numerous people from good families of rape, murder and terrorism. Why use double standards. "These are not FALSE accusations, this is the TRUTH, only time will tell, that these are the facts...." Where's the proof at this stage?? Let these girls give evidence and take him to cought and jail where he belongs if found guilty. But without any proof but just allegations you are being totally blind, and I am convinced that the reasion is past hate for most people. What kind of justice system are you following where an allegation convicts someone of rape, where is the common logical sence. Its like someone claiming a memeber of the panj pyarai in the Jatha committs rape, so it must be true. Anyone accused of any crime should be tried and evidence presented, only than can we say this is TRUTH, that's if you beleive in common sence, if not form a lynch mob and burn everyone who has been accused wrongly or rightly, including members of the Jatha. I hope this goes to court, and the evidence is presented. If found guilty maan singh should go to jail and be accordingly punished, the key is a criminal trial in the west. After all we are always complaining about the thousands of singhs in India's jails who have been imprisoned and tortured without there basic human right of having a trial and chance to show theire innocents, or do we have another standard for people who we have never got along with.?? · 16 Sep 2004
Singh said, "Like I’ve said over and over again it’s the same situation the Babbars found themselves in, i.e. media and personal accusations of rape and crime with no evidence. If they were innocent why didn’t they hold legal proceedings for libel and slander?" You obviously don't have a complete grasp on reality. The babbars should have gone to court? Who's court? Your court? The babbars were fighting a war and the enemy was spreading propoganda. How do you compare that to the Maan situation? The babbars going to court is the stupidest comment I've read on this thread so far. And why do you keep bringing up 'the jatha' in this discussion? They didn't bring out these accusations. They have nothing to do with this issue.what happened TAZ.? · 16 Sep 2004
what happened TAZ, wind being taken out of your sails...? I do agree about the split in views, but let me tell you something, i was a chela of this man for many a year, and never got wind of anything. only when two victims opened up did i question him, and not once did i think that these two sisters of mine could be lying, for tell me one thing, just one thing they have to gain from this coming out into the public area, and there names being brought forward, there families going through this ordeal.....just one advantage please. The fact remains that there is no advantage for them, only that another sister may be saved. long after this all dies down, the legal procedures will continue, who will be there to support our sisters, when the circus has left town???? When they come forward in public, and they will, think about what i have just wrote..... STOP THE WHOLE SANT THING NOW....FOR LETS NOT LET ANOTHER INNOCENT SISTER HAVE TO SUFFER BECAUSE OF HER FAITH. BABA TAKHUR SINGH BOWED TO THIS MONSTER TWICE. ONCE IN TORONTO, AND ONCE IN VANCOUVER.....WHY??? (did he not know about this mans past my taksali brothers/sisters?) And for those of you who may be asking, that bastard first tells you that SGGS is everything and that SGGS should be the focus, then slowely turns that faith to himself, over a course of a few years.... BE READY TO SUPPORT OUR SISTERS THAT WILL BE GOING PUBLIC, NOT FOR A DAY OR SO, BUT UNTIL THE WHOLE SITUATION IS CONCLUDED, BEANTI... Fatehanother sikh girl · 16 Sep 2004
Singh, maybe there is proof, and believe me you will get it, like i said time will tell!S Singh · 16 Sep 2004
>>S Singh Once again why didn't the Babbars or supporters of people like Suckdev Singh Babbar go to court when they were defamed by the media. Just by not taking allegers to court does not mean these alligations are true. If you are waiting for maan singh to take people to court and that is what you base your proof of his guilt on than you should also hold guilty the singhs in the jatha and babbars accused by the media and numerous people from good families of rape, murder and terrorism. Why use double standards. If it is lies he should have no qualms about taking them to the cleaners for libel. I am not using double standards by all means if Babbars were guilty they should also be bought to book. But as another veer ji has mentioned the practicality of militants taking someone to court for libel would be absurd as they were involved in an underground struggle. maan su is not involved in such a struggle, quite the opposite he is known to be friends with policemen who tortured Sikh youths. No past hate on my part, just fed up of him taking advantage of our sisters. What past hate do his ex chele have, who have gone underground ? Appears to me that some people have been brainwashed by maan su so much they will do anything to defend his dirty actions.Lol · 16 Sep 2004
Oh sorry 'seeeen', clearly your authority is higher than God's it seems, maybe I should rephrase and say, let 'seeen' dispence justice. To label every Mahapurush under the same category as this guy is Nindya, whether you like it or not, someone's appearance does not make him a Sant or a Sikh, similarly white clothes do not automatically make some people rapists, use intellectual arguments and references for claims and people will take you seriously.The Facts · 17 Sep 2004
sick and tired of silly posts by mann singh chelas! How dare you bring babbars and jatha into this? You mentioned allegations against them, - name one??? Who, when, where??? Stop twisting & Back it up with facts! Lets stick to FACTS in this case:- 1) Allegations are made against Maan singh only, and they are made by his chelays? 2) These are published in an independant Toronto paper- Sanjh Seveara. 3) They are now been made by Punjab radio aswell. 4) Mann singh chelas always say they will sue, but never do. This is just proganda, that he is a victim. How sick is THAT! The rapist the victim! 5) When dubai sangat wrote about his giving Amrit is glasses stunt. He said he would sue. But never did. Why? 6) When Sikh Phulwari magazine of Sikh missionary society, published the allegations, he said he would sue but never did. Why? 7) When Onkar singh UK distributed these articles, he said he would sue, but never did. Why? 8) When Ex- Jathedar Professor Darshan singh confirmed on Punjab radio, about his stunts in Dubai. He said he would sue, he did not. Why? 9) When Gurdeep Singh Jagbir said on Punjab radio that he gave Amrit in glasses In Dubai in return for a new Mercedes. He said he would sue, he did not. Why? 10) When allegations of rape were made against him in India in late 90`s. The SGPC registered a case agianst him, but the Tohra & Southall Gurdwara elders got involved. The girl disappeared, and the case was dropped. this was confirmed by senior SGPC members. 11) He was slapped on stage at Ludhiana by an elder bibi. He said he would seek redress, he did not. Why? 12) A few years later, he was pulled off stage at Ludhiana again by students for speaking against Panthik Rehat marayada. He said he would seek redress. he did not. why? 13) A European website exposed him in pictures, where his chelas were proved to be Punjab police officers identified as sikh youth torturers and murderers. He said he would sue, he did not. Why? 14) Over the years numerous allegations of rape has been registered against Sant Samaj members, most of which have been proved true. He never condemned them. Why? He is main spokesperson for Sant samaj. 15) Where all the rape victims of these Sants - "Sant ke Nindaks" - or where they helpless girls, victims of a molester and rapists. 16) Now allegations have been made against him by his own chelas. We hear the same story, that he will sue again. There is no Tohra to protect him now. Badal has little influence in Canada. Maybe now his time has come. His only hope is his chelas, will still think of him as Guru Gobind Singh, and blindly cover him up. All of his chelas, in their posts, have also said, it is probably true. So they back him, but have also doubt his character aswell. Look at above, nothing like this ever happened to Baba Attar Singh Mastuanawale, Baba Isher Singh. Then why is it happening to him. At some point all chelas are going to have to realise, he is not right???Singh · 17 Sep 2004
The babbars going to court is the stupidest comment I've read on this thread so far. And why do you keep bringing up 'the jatha' in this discussion? They didn't bring out these accusations. They have nothing to do with this issue.†A typically narrow minded response and obviously not in touch with reality. The babbars were banned in the uk as a terrorist organisation, surely in the uk their supporters could have taken the uk gov, and the media which a few years back printed reports on them being banned to court. If they are not terrorists why don’t they do so? If we use your argument that maan singh based on not taking anyone to court than the babbars rapists and terrorists as they haven’t taken the uk gov or the newspapers who reported them as terrorists to court. If you disagree you cannot use the same argument for maan singh not taking the newspaper in question to court. The babbars are also branded in numerous media reports outside India where they can take anyone to court for libel and slander as murderers and terrorists, so just because they haven’t taken anyone to court does not mean they are guilty, why doesn’t the same apply here? As to why I keep mentioning the jatha you need to re-read the above posts, where you will see a lot of comments have noting to do with this new scandal but are based on past hate. Numerous comments are here for you to see with your own eyes of how the Jatha years before this were at loggerheads with him, so although these new claims have nothing to do with the jatha its clear that people who hated him before are running with this, and are intent on calling him a rapist and guilty without any solid proof at this stage. "Appears to me that some people have been brainwashed by maan su so much they will do anything to defend his dirty actions." I can tell you that I have never supported any Sant or any modern day Jatha. Why don't you have a re-read of my past posts and you will see how on numerouse times I have stated that I have never supported him, nor liked him. My argument here is not for him, but for common sence and the need for proof. I believe any individual so called sant or jatha which hypocritically talks of the Panth and at the same time produces their own Maryada and have their own rules separate and in conflict from the Sikh Rehat Maryada by the Guru Panth issued from Akal Takt should not be considered as part of the Panth.to the author of THE FACTS... · 17 Sep 2004
To the author of the facts....WOW..... very detailed and precise. Could you please put up an e-mail address (temporary if needed) so that i may touch base with you. I am one of those who helped to break this story and am continuing to until the legal system, both in indai as well as north america, serves out there punishment for mann the rapist....all this info. that you have can only help our cause.... FatehSingh · 17 Sep 2004
“If we use your argument that maan singh based on not taking anyone to court than the babbars rapists and terrorists as they haven’t taken the uk gov or the newspapers who reported them as terrorists to court. “ sorry extremely bad English. My point is that by maan singh not taking the newspaper to court does not make him guilty just based on that, in the same way the babbars and their supporters by not taking outside governments and newspapers to court for claiming they were rapists and terrorists does not mean that they are guilty.CONSIDER this with open mind. · 17 Sep 2004
Here are the real facts, read them and then ask urself the question that if someone who is himself not of good character, should we believe him?? 1) In the Sanjh Savera article it was mentioned that he just wants to earn dollars. Answer my question, if he was like that, y would he spend millions of rupees in Gujrat (Earthquake), Orissa(Hurricane), Punjab border( force deployment), he did it. Ypui guys wouldnt know coz u were not there, ask me I was there. 2)The article mentions about Babaji's property, Do u even know who has the property been named to. It is either Shri Guru Nanak Dev ji or Guru Granth Sahib ji. He does not have it undeer his name, he doesnt even own it. 3) Article states abt the student fee, Just tell me one think y doent the article mention abt the teacher's pay and other expenditure which has to be incured. It is a non profitable academy. 4) People who have leveled these charges are those who were kicked out coz of their evil deeds. Now tell me a person who has been kicked out of dera coz of his deeds, will obviously say such things. Some news paper say that babaji has been in jail for the past few days, I cannot stop laughing , coz they are making themselves look like jokers, as Babaji just held the Barsi function, I attended it. And guess what there wasnt a place to stand there. At this point just think should we believe that some handfull people are true or lakhs.. Ball is in ur court.kaur......... · 17 Sep 2004
vaheguroo ji ka khalsa vaheguroo ji ki fatheh Singhji, although i know that mann su is a fraud (from personal experience) -and i hope you get ur proof too.....i totally totally respect your last paragraph..... "I believe any individual so called sant or jatha which hypocritically talks of the Panth and at the same time produces their own Maryada and have their own rules separate and in conflict from the Sikh Rehat Maryada by the Guru Panth issued from Akal Takt should not be considered as part of the Panth" vaheguroo....sikh · 17 Sep 2004
CONSIDER this with open mind ji people like u will never see the light u are his chela and u see him as guru - ur as lost as him - all people who believe in sants and regard them as more than guru sahib are a waste and a burden on sikhi the truth is coming!Maan Singh & The Facts · 17 Sep 2004
answering some of your questions......... CONSIDER this with open mind. wrote: > 1) In the Sanjh Savera article it was mentioned that he just > wants to earn dollars. Answer my question, if he was like that, > y would he spend millions of rupees in Gujrat (Earthquake), > Orissa(Hurricane), Punjab border( force deployment), he did it. > Ypui guys wouldnt know coz u were not there, ask me I was > there. Actually if you look at the facts. he did not spend any money, the trip was funded between Punjab govt, and SGPC. Basically Badal sanctioned it. Go back to that date, and do your research. > > 2)The article mentions about Babaji's property, Do u even know > who has the property been named to. It is either Shri Guru > Nanak Dev ji or Guru Granth Sahib ji. He does not have it > undeer his name, he doesnt even own it. Some proof please...... or just hearsay, especially hearsay from babaji himself... > > Some news paper say that babaji has been in jail for the past > few days, I cannot stop laughing , coz they are making > themselves look like jokers, as Babaji just held the Barsi > function, I attended it. And guess what there wasnt a place to > stand there. At this point just think should we believe that > some handfull people are true or lakhs.. I have stuck to facts, not sure where you got this one from...... > > Ball is in ur court. No, in fact it is in yours. Because your defence has made no mention of this rape allegations, and the ones before.....Any response???? Or do so-called bhramagianis have the right to rape anyone they want??? In bani, it clearly says, white clothes are of no use. What is important is being white inside.Maan Singh & the Facts · 17 Sep 2004
To Singh -- For someone is writes alot, you have completely dodged the question. You said babbars and akj had allegations against them. I asked for facts, who, where , when???? Either give a specific answer or accept you are talking rubbish. I can name specifics of plenty of sants that have has rape allegations against them.S Singh · 17 Sep 2004
>>I believe any individual so called sant or jatha which hypocritically talks of the Panth and at the same time produces their own Maryada and have their own rules separate and in conflict from the Sikh Rehat Maryada by the Guru Panth issued from Akal Takt should not be considered as part of the Panth. Well maan su is known for flouting the maryada. He leaves joot for his followers to consume as holy parshad. Bottled amrit, what more examples you want ? As for the spending on earthquake victims. Yes he did all that but why was it publicised. You should do seva without advertising and publicising it. As he farms 340 acres of Guru Nanak Dev Ji then you should not even bother bringing up this issue as he was only using Guru Jis wealth to help the poor victims. As mentioned by another brother why has he never bothered to take anyone to court, is he scared of being exposed further ? As for the property, even the land/jagir at Nankana Sahib Janam Asthan is in Guru Nanak Dev Jis name but it is farmed by scion of Rai Bullar. So that really means nothing. Why does he need so much farmland ? All his chele can moan and groan all they like, they are not exactly impartial. They should start looking to Guru Granth Sahib for inspiration and guidance rather than this maan su.sikh · 17 Sep 2004
mann is not even worthy of being the dust underneath late Jathedar Bhai Sukhdev Singh Babbar *****Admin cut. Please don't threaten anyone from this forum*******open mind....we'll see. · 17 Sep 2004
well get ready for a an ace (tennis terminology..) in direct response: 1, Re. sanj savera article, it does say that he 'just wants to earn dollars' lets not take a comment out of context, you i both know how fond of money he is, and re. gujrat, orissa, and the border langars....govenment funded. All donations collected by him stayed with him, he even made a profit on the money that was given to him by the government, you may have been there, so what, you know all his in's and outs, don't think so.... 2, actually not all the property is in guru granth sahib ji's name, or guru nanaks name..please wake up or grow up.... most the land is in his name or this top sevaks...why, because the likes of mani singh, karam singh, bhagtu singh, kerpal singh, etc..they all know of his wrong doings, so baba has placed land on there names...oh, twana singh too.....they all have sexual relationships too, with so-called sisters.....this too will be coming out shortly my friend...HARD EVIDENCE... 3, non-profit academy....a trust in who's name...? who heads the trust....? hello... 4, no one was kicked out my friend....joga singh the langari left, vikram singh left, surmukh singh left, saab singh left, paddhi left, why...because all these chardi-kalla wale singhs found out about baba and his on-goings, and decided that they could not live in such a place...thats why..... baba is not in jail, he is planning his trip to hemkunt sahib (normally scheduled for the 19th departure....)..we know. Barsi was well attended, we know...but the stage was not full of the usual sants and dignatories..why because they have heard the allegations. The simple pindoo folk that normally attend have not yet heard.....OK. whoever you are....you too are in the dark my friend....when the truth comes out as a legal action, we'll see how many stay standing..... do you want to try serving againg my friend, i'm ready....... (tennis terminology again.)answering questions · 17 Sep 2004
for all the facts on what baba maan singh really did in gujerat and orissa, speak to the Khalsa aid boys. Ravinder singh did a complete write up on it. How baba maan singh made every on mattha tek to him, how only wealthy and middle class families where helped. How he practiced jaat-paat by helping mainly jaats, and singled out so-called low castes. By the way, ravinder was his chela during slough situation. After gujerat and Orissa, Ravinder Singh hates him.another sikh girl · 17 Sep 2004
open mind....we'll see. WOW, very well said!!! I couldn't have said it better!!!"I Heard" · 17 Sep 2004
Well, i heard that he has several children ( 2 or 3) wandering around, and perhaps one in california, this guy is really on the go!!!jagroop singh · 17 Sep 2004
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat jio, i was personally told by a Khalsa Aid Singh the following a long time ago: re: Gujuraat Earthquake - 'Sant Baba' Mann 'Singh' was having his feet touched continuously in a tent and not showing the slightest sign of annoyance at the people who were doing so. When the Singhs went up to him and said their GurFatehJi, he JUMPED up and said GurFatehJi. ignore all the stuff going on at the moment if you wish but compare this 'Sant' with Mahan GurSikhs like Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh who was even caught on video literally JUMPING AWAY from a bibi trying to touch his feet. another example is Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh who is known to have, on one occassion, JUMPED INTO SOME WATER to prevent a fellow Gursikh from touching his feet. so while 'Sant Baba' Mann 'Singh' JUMPS UP when he is caught by some Gurmat-oriented Singhs in the act of having his feet touched, these two GurSikhs actively JUMPED AWAY from having their feet touched by anyone... Sangat Jio, actions speak for themselves...and when they speak, they speak louder than words. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!Inderjit · 17 Sep 2004
Having spent time reading this thread, it is clear that the most sensible post has been written by Manas Singh. Why would we want to wash the sins of another by slandering them? Take note of the example of Bhai Rama Singh Ji - he just grinned. Did he curse? No! He did not have the need and neither should we. Ultimately he is answerable in the court of Dharam Raj; IF the allegations are true and IF he escapes any panthic/legal trial."I Heard" · 17 Sep 2004
oh yeah, that property issue, only ONE acre is in the Guru Granth's Sahib's name!k k k singh · 17 Sep 2004
why his duneaa sava funded ???? cuz of votes ...what ever baba said to the poor people they will listen ....why cuz in their eyes it was him who came in with his gangssters,along with the inicent ones To save the day.Admin · 17 Sep 2004
The admin has decided to close this thread. We had to disapprove a lot of messages as they were off-topic and had attacks on individuals for no reason. If there is anything new to tell about Mann Singh, please start a new thread. Baseless and childish messages will not be approved. Admin